10 Things Everyone Gets Wrong About Game Of Thrones

Hodor's name is actually Walder. Now we've got your attention, here's more of the biggest mistakes you can make in Westeros.

HBO

The world and lore behind Game of Thrones is as vast as it is intricate. Considering the constraints and time restrictions of the television format, it's remarkable that creators David Benioff and D.B. Weiss have managed to condense so much information in an easy-to-digest manner. Despite this, there are still some details and scenes that have caused some confusion among show watchers. While most of these misconceptions may seem only minor, they can lead to an altered interpretation of what is happening in the bigger picture. This list takes a look at some of the most common misconceptions that have come about due to a misinterpretation of certain events or details. Most of these are down to the show not making these points quite clear enough, not being able to allocated enough time to some plot points, or just due to watchers making false assumptions. Note that if you aren't up to date with the television series (the end of Season 4 as of writing), then there will be spoilers ahead. Future events and details won't be discussed, but if you're hyper-sensitive to even minor spoilers and haven't read the books yet, then proceed with caution.


10. Jaime Raped Cersei

HBO

In one of the most controversial scenes so far, Jaime and Cersei participate in risky, incestuous lovemaking while leaning on a table that holds their son's corpse. That should be shocking enough in itself. However, many viewers interpreted the scene as Jaime explicitly raping Cersei. This is an easily understandable misconception, and the scene in question even left many book readers second guessing themselves. Due to the ambiguous scripting and unclear direction, it's easy to see why the scene has been widely viewed as a textbook example of rape. However, despite the show's scene suggesting otherwise, the book makes it very clear that the act is ultimately consensual on both sides. Although she intially resists, this is more to do with the location than the act itself. Here's part of the passage as it's written in the books:

€œHurry,€ she was whispering now, €œquickly, quickly, now, do it now, do me now. Jaime Jaime Jaime.€ Her hands helped guide him. €œYes,€ Cersei said as he thrust, €œmy brother, sweet brother, yes, like that, yes, I have you, you€™re home now, you€™re home now, you€™re home.€ She kissed his ear and stroked his short bristly hair. Jaime lost himself in her flesh. He could feel Cersei€™s heart beating in time with his own, and the wetness of blood and seed where they were joined.

A counter-point would be that the show has simply re-written the scene, and the showrunners were aiming to present it as rape from the start. However, Alex Graves has insisted that this is not the case, stating that it, "becomes consensual by the end." He also claims that, "The consensual part of it was that she wraps her legs around him, and she€™s holding on to the table, clearly not to escape but to get some grounding in what€™s going on." It's a tricky topic for discussion, and there's no doubt that the scene was handled poorly. Within the fictional canon of the show though, and for its relevance to future events, it's important to note that the act was not considered a rape.


9. Prince Rhaegar 'Kidnapping' Lyanna Stark Started Robert's Rebellion

HBO

If you'll recall the chats between Eddard Stark and King Robert in the first season, Rhaegar Targaryan allegedly kidnapped Lyanna Stark, Robert's betrothed and Eddard's sister. This occurred before Robert's Rebellion, the war that led to Robert Baratheon overthrowing the Targaryens and taking the throne. A common misinterpretation of these events by both show watchers and book readers is that it was Rhaegar's kidnapping of Lyanna that started Robert's Rebellion in the first place. Despite being an important catalyst, Robert didn't simply declare war on the Targaryens due to the kidnapping of his beloved. Following the news that Lyanna had been kidnapped, Brandon Stark (Eddard and Lyanna's older brother) rode into King's Landing, demanding Prince Rhaegar's blood. The 'Mad King' Aerys II arrested Brandon and his companions, which included the heir to the Eyrie, Elbert Arryn. After the capture, King Aerys II demanded the fathers of each prisoner to come to Kings Landing and answer their son's charges. When Rickard Stark arrived to fight as his son's champion in a trial by combat, the Mad King said his champion was fire and cooked the Lord Of Winterfell in his armour. At the same time, Brandon had a noose tied around his neck and a sword just placed out of reach, so he strangled himself trying to get the weapon to free himself and save his father. Still paranoid, the Mad King went on to demand that Jon Arryn (the dead guy from the very start of the series) hand over Robert Baratheon and Eddard Stark, who had been under his protection in the Eyrie. Instead, Jon Arryn chose to revolt against the King, thus beginning what was later known as Robert's Rebellion.


8. The Size Of Westeros

HBO

Scale can be a hard thing to convey in a television show, and Game of Thrones has been no exception. Despite the incredible opening credits sequence that swoops over the key locations, many fans are unaware of just how large the continent of Westeros is. A lot of people have compared Westeros to the United Kingdom, due to the accents, cold North and similar flora. However, if Westeros were to suddenly appear on Earth, the United Kingdom would fit inside its shores numerous times. This immense scale means that many of the characters' journeys in the show has taken a lot longer than most people realise. For example, the journey from Winterfell to King's Landing would have taken around 2 to 3 months, judging from the distances involved. Below is a map showing Westeros in rough proportion to the Americas, showing you just how long it would take to get to the capital.


7. The Targaryens Conquered All Seven Kingdoms

Jordi Gonzalez

One of the largest events that preludes the series is the Targaryens conquering Westeros. Called the War of Conquest, it occurred around 300 years prior to the events seen in Game of Thrones, and resulted in the Targaryens occupying the throne until Robert's Rebellion. It's a commonly held belief that the Targaryens were able to defeat all seven kingdoms of Westeros. However, there was just one that managed to successfully resist: Dorne, the home of Oberyn Martell. The leaders of Dorne observed that open battles with the Targaryens only resulted in defeat, due to the immense power of the dragons under their control. Instead, the nation engaged in guerilla warfare, swiftly striking Targaryen forces then disappearing before the dragons could show up. Eventually, the Targaryens just gave up, withdrew their armies, and allowed Dorne to remain as an independent nation. A century and a half later, King Daeron Targaryen once again attempted to take Dorne and succeeded, despite heavy losses. The ensuing Dornish rebellion proved too much though, and it quickly returned to being an independent nation. Dorne eventually joined the rest of the Seven Kingdoms via a peaceful alliance through marriage, on their own terms. This explains why Oberyn Martell can style himself 'Prince,' rather than 'Lord,' - it's a concession granted through that alliance.


6. Sansa Stark Is Stupid

HBO

Until perhaps episode eight of the fourth season, fans have continuously expressed their frustration at Sansa. Almost constantly appearing as the most helpless of the Stark children, Sansa has long been accused of being one of the most stupid of all the characters on the show. It's easy to see why people make this assumption. Sansa at the beginning of the series is childlike, naive and hopelessly optimistic. This innocence is quickly lost though, following the beheading of her father. Fans have expressed their frustration towards Sansa for being pathetic and passive, especially in comparison to the brash deeds of her siblings. However, it's exactly this pathetic persona that has kept her alive in the snakepit of King's Landing. Sansa, by the end of season four, has shown she has the potential to be a formidable player in the game of thrones. And there's no reason she shouldn't be, she's had some of the best teachers in the kingdom. Cersei Lannister taught her the confines of a woman's place in society, and how to overcome them. Lady Olenna showed Sansa how to see through deceit, and utilise this for her own means. Sandor Clegane taught her that heroes don't exist in this world and that nothing is black and white. Now, she's living under the guardianship of Petyr Baelish, possibly the greatest living player of the game, and revealed that she's more than just a scared little girl. Plus, despite the power Baelish may hold, she knows she's his one weakness, and how to play him. Frankly, that's a formidable card to hold.


5. The Kingsguard And Gold Cloaks Are The Same

HBO

This one has become a common misunderstanding, due to the very similar uniforms worn by the two organisations. In the books, the Kingsguard are dressed entirely in white and silver, down to their armour and belt buckles. In Game of Thrones though, only their cloaks and armour patterns are used to visually differentiate them from the Gold Cloaks. Particularly during fight scenes, it can be tricky to discern which is which. Despite their similar garments in the show, the Kingsguard and Gold Cloaks are on two entirely opposite ends of the spectrum. The Kingsguard is historically made up of the seven greatest knights in all of Westeros, sworn to protect whichever king is currently in power and their royal family. Each member is in it for life, and may not own land, father children or take a wife. Joining the Kingsguard is considered the highest of honours, and many legendary knights have been sworn in through history. 'Gold Cloaks' is actually just a nickname for the City Watch of King's Landing. Although gold and red are the Lannister colours, the Gold Cloaks are not under the allegiance of any house (corruption and bribery is rife though). Instead, the Gold Cloaks are just meant to be enforcers of the law, their only fealty to the Crown. While the Kingsguard contains only the greatest of warriors, the Gold Cloaks are generally undisciplined, unskilled fighters, with minimal training. If a Westerosi were to mistake any member of the Kingsguard for a Gold Cloak, it would be a grave insult to their honour.


4. Targaryens Are Immune To Fire

HBO

Despite the method by which everyone's favourite 'beggar king' was dispatched, many fans are still under the impression that Targaryens are immune to the effects of fire. This misconception came about due to Daenerys surviving the roaring bonfire that resulted in the hatching of her dragon eggs. However, Daenerys did not survive this simply due to being a Targaryen. The event was a totally unprecedented miracle, probably powered by blood magic. In fact, death from extreme heat or fire has been a common theme in Targaryen history. As well as Viserys' molten crown, major members of the Targaryen family have died by anything from house fires to drinking wildfire. While Targaryens may have a higher-than-average tolerance to heat, there is nothing to suggest that they are totally fireproof.


3. Wights And White Walkers Are The Same

HBO

This is something that has long caused confusion for many readers of the books, long before HBO's television series. In fact, the difference is possibly made clearer in the show, due to the creators being able to visually show what the two look like. The White Walkers (more commonly known as the Others in the books) are the strange, demonic necromancers that are spoken about only in hushed whispers and legends. Even in the books, very little is known about them so far, other than the fact they have the potential to be very dangerous. The Wights are the more commonly seen dead people (or animals) that have been brought back to life by the White Walkers. Essentially, they're just mindless zombies, controlled by the Walkers that raised them. While the Wights can be destroyed by fire, it's long been unknown how to dispatch a White Walker, which is why Sam managing to kill one was such a big deal. Sam unwittingly discovered that the White Walkers are susceptible to weaponry made from Obsidian (also called Dragonglass).


2. Stannis Is Under The Control Of Melisandre

HBO

The portrayal of Stannis in Game of Thrones has become one of the most contentious points for book readers in the series. Book Stannis is something of a fan favourite, and much like Ned stood for honour, Stannis is the epitome of duty and doing the 'right' thing. In Game of Thrones, Stannis is rarely seen without Melisandre talking into his ear, influencing his decisions. This, combined with Melisandre's penchant for magic, has led many to believe that Stannis is actually just a puppet under complete control of the red priestess. This is absolutely not the case. During season 2, Stannis shows open defiance of Melisandre, choosing not to bring her to the Battle of Blackwater. For a short time afterwards though, during the aftermath of defeat, Stannis is a broken man, locking himself away from the world. With Melisandre as his only comfort during this period, he naturally becomes more susceptible to her counsel and commits questionable acts in the process. Fortunately, Davos, upon his reemergence, is able to bring Stannis back to his former self. There's no question that Melisandre, for better or worse, has a huge influence on Stannis. As it stands though, Melisandre and Stannis are just two powerful figures that use each other to progress a shared agenda. To suggest that he's mentally weak enough to be under her control, or that she's using magic to make him her puppet is completely unfounded.


1. The Lannisters Are Still The Greatest Military Force In Westeros

HBO

Something that wasn't explored enough in the show is just how good a leader Robb Stark was. During the events of the first two seasons, Robb Stark outplayed the Lannister forces at every turn, winning every single battle. This, combined with the bloody Battle of the Blackwater resulted in the deaths or desertion of a very high percentage of Lannister soldiers. The Lannisters may currently appear to be in a fairly good position. However, the War of the Five Kings was catastrophic for them with regards to troop losses, and the house has only survived so far due to underhanded plots, shaky alliances and the unappreciated genius of a certain dwarf. House Lannister is almost totally reliant on their alliance with the Tyrells at this point, which is why Tywin is doing everything in his power to keep the houses together, despite their obvious distaste for each other. Because the Tyrell army has avoided all conflicts except the eradication of Stannis' forces at Blackwater, they are currently in command of one of the largest unified forces in Westeros. As such, the Lannisters simply cannot afford to lose them as allies. And, judging from a recent conspiracy plot involving the poisoning of everyone's favourite boy king, the Lannister-Tyrell alliance might not be as solid as Tywin hopes. And that's before he goes to the privy.


Contributor
Contributor

Tom Butler hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.