10 Things The Arrowverse Wishes It Could've Done Differently
Major exits, miscalculated plots, and overused relationships ... the Arrowverse has it all.
Arrow has come a long way since the show debuted in 2012. It's spawned an entire universe - the Arrowverse - comprised of Arrow, The Flash, Legends of Tomorrow, Supergirl and now Batwoman.
Oliver Queen once said, "I came home with one goal - to save my city," but things have changed since then as the Arrowverse has extended beyond Star City and into the Multiverse.
With this year's long awaited crossover-event, 'Crisis on Infinite Earths' looming, the Arrowverse has well and truly grown to a size no one could have expected when it debuted seven years ago. But while it's provided us with some great superhero entertainment since then, that doesn't mean it's faultless.
Each show certainly has its weak link. The Flash keeps repeating storylines; Supergirl's characters are inconsistent; Legends lacks character development; Arrow has had a few major exits and continues to overuse certain relationships.
With Arrow heading into its eighth and final season, it seems apt to take a look at the things the Arrowverse probably wishes it could've done differently. We're unlikely to see any drastic changes in Arrow's final season but The Flash, Supergirl and Legends seem to all have some steam left in the engine, so maybe there's hope some of these changes can actually happen...
10. Emily Bett Rickards' Exit (Arrow)
There is no denying that Emily Bett Rickards' Felicity Smoak - also known as Overwatch - was a huge asset to Arrow. Initially featuring in a recurring role in Arrow's first season, Rickards was promoted to series regular after her performance impressed Arrow's writers - in addition to her undeniable chemistry with Stephen Amell.
Staying with a show for seven seasons is a big commitment for an actor but unfortunately for audiences, Rickards wasn't willing to make it eight. The season seven finale thus marked Rickards' exit where she was last seen leaving to an unknown destination with The Monitor in an attempt to be reunited with Oliver Queen. The Monitor tells her, "Where I'm taking you, there's no return," so it sounds like we've seen the last of Felicity Smoak.
There is no official confirmation on why Arrow has been cancelled. Therefore we don't know whether Rickards was aware season eight would be the show's last or whether her exit informed the decision. Either way, Felicity was certainly a huge fan-favourite and her absence in the final season will be noticed... we think.
It's hard to imagine Oliver without Felicity. Season eight is yet to unfold and so Rickards' exit can't be deemed as having a negative impact on Arrow with complete certainty. That being said, there's a reason her role was expanded all those years ago. Felicity is the heartbeat of the show.
9. Repeated Storylines (The Flash)
Somewhat surprisingly, The Flash beats Arrow to being The CW's most-watched Arrowverse show - although that doesn't mean The Flash is without its faults. Primarily, The Flash can't seem to stop repeating the same storylines with the same character archetypes and it's starting to feel tiresome.
Yes, Barry Allen is a speedster. Yes, it was fun to watch Barry face down an 'evil' speedster - but even that simple statement could refer to a whole host of characters. We've had Eobard Thawne, Savitar, Zoom, and in season five, Thawne again. There are only so many evil speedsters that can come and go before we crave some originality.
It doesn't help that the stakes seem to be set so low on The Flash. Iris' near-death at the hands of Savitar was about the closest the show got to putting one of its core characters in danger. It's the same thing over and over again: an evil speedster shows up, Team Flash defeats them - all is right in the world.
The Flash's repetitive nature doesn't stop there. Have you noticed how many sidekick speedsters we've had? Wally West, Jesse Quick, Nora West-Allen, and even Iris for a short while. Let's not even start on how many characters Tom Cavanagh has portrayed in the show. Sure, he's talented and a great addition to keep around, but season five's Sherloque Wells was maybe just a step too far into the absurd.
The Flash shows no signs of ending anytime soon. Thankfully, that means there's time for things to change.
8. Introducing Too Many Team Members (Arrow)
Most Arrow fans will tell you that the show's first two seasons were its best - the question is why? Oliver Queen's mission began as a solitary one but that most definitely contrasts the size of Team Arrow that we see today. As Oliver's mission evolved, it seemed clear that he would require some help in protecting Star City. The initiations of Felicity Smoak and John Diggle into Team Arrow were welcomed and expanded the scope of what the group was capable of.
Since then, Team Arrow has kept on growing and not always for the better - season seven even prepped us for the next generation. Team Arrow isn't The Avengers and there are more weak links than the show cares to admit.
Take Curtis Holt for example - also known as Mr Terrific. Whilst Felicity was managing just fine by herself in the technical department of Team Arrow, Holt proved an unnecessary but tolerable addition to the team. Recently however, Holt has been venturing out into the field and there is no need for him to do so. Yes, he's been training up, but he can't match the skill of Oliver, Diggle or even Rene Ramirez. It just makes the team feel clunky.
Does anyone even remember Ragman? This season five Team Arrow member was perhaps the most fleeting of the lot. On the other hand, there have been some valuable additions to the team. Laurel, Sara, Thea and Roy all felt like natural additions - yet they all had personal connections to the team and so their joining made sense.
Sorry but the Team Arrow we've seen in later seasons feels like a home for wayward, wannabe vigilantes.
7. Inconsistency (Supergirl)
Inconsistency isn't unique to Supergirl - it features across the Arrowverse. Arrow's first two seasons are far superior to the rest; The Flash needlessly includes 'funny' filler episodes that draw away from the main arc. However, Supergirl doesn't seem to fully understand its characters.
One of the earliest examples of this in the show is Kara's relationship with James Olsen which seems at odds with the show's message of female empowerment. That's not to say an empowered woman can't be in a relationship at all, but the show forces the two characters together and it adds nothing to the plot. Apparently, Melissa Benoist and Mehcad Brooks just didn't have the right chemistry and the storyline was abandoned. It did nothing for either character in the first place and just seemed like having a core relationship from the get-go was a network requirement.
Maggie Sawyer and Alex Danvers' break-up is another example. Yes, Floriana Lima wanted to leave the show but the break-up could've been handled better. Supergirl's writers decided that Alex wanted children and Maggie didn't - something that Alex had never mentioned before. That doesn't mean she hadn't privately thought about it, but in a TV show, you need to at least hint these things to an audience - otherwise it all feels out of the blue.
Supergirl is a good, entertaining show but it needs to start to understand its characters better. If the show is sending us mixed signals about what a character wants, how are we supposed to try and attempt to understand their actions and decisions?
6. Questionable Humour (The Flash)
Every Arrowverse show uses humour - some more than others - but it's The Flash that takes the title for being the most light-hearted Arrowverse show. The unique tone of the show is perhaps what makes it so popular. Despite this, sometimes the humour is taken a step too far and it ends up undermining any tension or urgency The Flash is trying to create.
Ralph Dibny seems to encapsulate this. It is near impossible to have a serious scene with Dibny in it because the writers are so focused on making him a constant joker. Whether he's expanding or shrinking, you can count on the so-called Elongated Man to bring the humour.
The problem is, the stakes are set pretty low in The Flash. The show doesn't often put its core characters in any serious peril. When it does, it's characters like Dibny that undermine the tone of the scene. Actor, Hartley Sawyer, actually does a great job with what he's given. What would be even better is if the writer's gave his character more of a purpose. Cisco is a funny character but it isn't his only personality trait.
This problem isn't limited to Dibny though. The Flash's issues with humour can be seen on a much larger scale. The show has a habit of including often absurd 'filler' episodes that draw away from the main arc in favour of humour. Hopefully, this is something The Flash will fix going forwards. Humour is a characteristic of the show - it wouldn't be the same without it - but there is a time and place.
5. Losing Its Simplicity (Arrow)
One of Arrow's greatest strengths in its earlier seasons was its simplicity. Arrow is a DC show and thus a superhero show but Arrow's early seasons felt gritty and grounded. It was refreshing and set Arrow apart from anything else.
No member of the original Team Arrow had any enhanced powers. Oliver Queen had his quiver; John Diggle had his strength and agility; Felicity had her technical capabilities. Even the bunker was basic. Oliver Queen has always been a billionaire but he didn't throw his money into the team straight away. The bunker was little more than a dingy basement with a couple of computers - plus that famous salmon ladder. It set Arrow's tone.
Flash forward to now, and Team Arrow is as high-tech as ever. Gone is the dingy basement in favour of an enhanced headquarters that can only be accessed by a secret elevator in City Hall. Things started to change when Arrow introduced Ray Palmer who became the superhero, Atom. It was one of the first times Arrow started to introduce super-powered characters.
Unfortunately, this hasn't been for the better as Arrow has rapidly lost the simplicity that so many of us loved in the first place. Arrow crosses over with The Flash, Supergirl and Legends of Tomorrow so naturally, more enhanced elements were inevitably going to end up in the show but it should be limited to crossovers.
Arrow has always shined when it draws back to its roots. It's doubtful we're going to see any drastic changes in Arrow's short final season but we can hope.
4. Too Many Characters (Legends Of Tomorrow)
Legends of Tomorrow is an ensemble show so the vast number of core characters shouldn't be a surprise, but that doesn't mean it always works. It was always going to be a risky move taking a group of B-List characters and giving them their own show. It could be a contributing factor as to why Legends is the Arrowverse's lowest-rated show - the group can feel a little soulless.
Season one established nine core characters: Atom, Rip Hunter, Firestorm (x2), White Canary, Hawkgirl, Hawkman, Heat Wave, and Captain Cold. In a show like Legends with no central protagonist, it's difficult for writers to split our time evenly amongst each character. There isn't enough time in a single weekly episode to develop a storyline for everyone in addition to advancing the central plot.
Each character gets to be the focus every now and then - but Legends is no Lost. It isn't THAT dedicated to developing each character. It can make Legends a hard show to connect with - although now going into its fifth season, it must be doing something right.
Half of the original Legends team is gone and has since been replaced with a whole new set of characters. Interchangeability seems to be in Legends of Tomorrow's DNA. If you want some light-hearted superhero fun, it's definitely the show to watch. However, you're unlikely to attach to the characters the same way you might invest yourself in the lives of Oliver Queen, Barry Allen, and Kara Zor-El.
3. Olicity (Arrow)
It was fairly early in Arrow's first season that #Olicity was born. The sparks between Oliver Queen and Felicity Smoak soon starting flying and it wasn't long until Arrow's writers gave fans what they were asking for. You can't deny that Stephen Amell and Emily Bett Rickards' have chemistry with each other - Olicity has made for some pretty memorable Arrow moments.
That being said, Olicity quickly became a main focus in the show and things started to go downhill from there - Arrow started to feel like a soap opera. We started spending too much time on the relationship and as a result, other areas of the show suffered. Damien Darhk had the potential to be a great Arrow villain in season 4 but he was sidelined in favour of the on-going Olicity saga.
Even the other core characters have been consumed by the relationship. If Diggle, Curtis, Rene or Dinah are in a scene, you can bet they're probably discussing Olicity. It's unfortunate that we don't spend time with Diggle the way we did in earlier seasons but on top of that, the newer characters feel underdeveloped.
Olicity shines when it isn't the main focus but instead a subtle moment between the chaos - Arrow has lost that. With Emily Bett Rickards' exit, we're not going to see any Oliver and Felicity scenes in Arrow's final season. Despite that, it's likely every episode will still at least mention the pair. They do say absence makes the heart grow fonder. Perhaps season 8 will remind us why we loved this relationship in the first place.
2. Team Flash's Lack Of Development (The Flash)
Team Flash is comprised of some great characters. The problem is - Barry Allen aside - they rarely go anywhere outside of work. Cisco Ramon and Caitlin Snow are the victims in this instance. They're not under-developed characters by any means but they're not developed to their full potential either. Both characters are loved by fans, so why can we count on one hand the number of times we've seen them outside of work?
Cisco has had a couple of fleeting relationships and Caitlin's family occasionally make the odd rare appearance but that is about the extent of it. Where do they live? Do they have friends outside of Team Flash? What do they do in their spare time?
OK, this wouldn't make for the most thrilling TV of all time but it wouldn't be difficult to throw in the odd scene or at least line that hints towards something. In stark contrast to Arrow, The Flash isolates some its core characters a little too much - refusing to give them a life. Iris and Joe don't suffer to the same extent but only due to their family ties to Barry.
It doesn't make sense. As popular characters, Cisco and Caitlin should be given the treatment they deserve. Now going into its fifth season, The Flash needs some fresh material. It's time to get rid of The Flash's characteristic filler episodes and replace them with some character development.
At least now that Cisco and Caitlin are Vibe and Killer Frost, respectively, the two get out of the office occasionally. The Flash is moving in the right direction but a lot more could be done.
1. Civil War (Arrow)
Season 6 of Arrow saw the team split in two in what was essentially a civil war. It was a mistake. Even Arrow's showrunner, Marc Guggenheim, will confess. In an interview with TV Line, he stated, "If I miscalculated anywhere, it's probably on the order of not taking into full consideration the fact that […] there's always going to be a love and affection for the original characters that the new characters don't get a chance to enjoy."
He's right. Viewers were never going to side with Rene, Curtis and Dinah over Oliver, Diggle and Felicity. We had spent six prior seasons with the original Team Arrow - they had our loyalty.
The issue is, the more time we spent on Team Arrow's civil war, the less time we spent with villain Cayden James. This was no Captain America: Civil War. With the majority of viewers on the side of the original Team Arrow, the civil war felt like a nuisance and distraction from the main story.
The newer Team Arrow never stood a chance and we knew that - so why spend the time on it? The storyline was misjudged - Rene, Curtis and Dinah were never in contention.
Rene, Curtis and Dinah weren't new characters by this point but we certainly didn't know them as well as we did the original members of Team Arrow. The civil war storyline made us want to dislike them. Time would have been better spent integrating them into Team Arrow. There could still be disagreements along the way but it would've saved us from seeing a whole lot of unneeded drama.
The Ultimate Arrowverse Quiz