10 Things We Learned From Sunderland Til I Die Season 2
New season, same problems.
In a world ravaged by uncertainty and doubt, football whilst unpredictable, continues to boast some comforting absolutes. Lionel Messi is good, West Ham will forever disappoint and Sunderland will always take part in a gripping documentary that chronicles an inevitably disappointing season.
Netflix has returned with a second season of Sunderland Til’ I Die and given that the first season documented Sunderland’s relegation from the Championship (following relegation from the Premier League), this time round it’s Sunderland’s ultimately unsuccessful season in League One that is on display.
Despite the dismal tale of Sunderland’s on-pitch exploits, the series faithfully encapsulates what football means to the city of Sunderland and the club's largely working-class fanbase.
Whilst, all documentaries construct narratives and toy with reality, unlike the 6-part advertisement that is Manchester City’s All or Nothing series, Sunderland Til’ I Die is an honest, unvarnished and unfiltered glimpse into modern football.
However, the much-acclaimed series isn’t just for the avid football fan. Given the relatability of both the club and the city’s struggles, Sunderland Til’ I Die makes for utterly compelling viewing for anyone …who has a Netflix subscription.
Sunderland have faced a real lesson in how it can all go wrong so very quickly. But what have we learned?
10. Documentaries Are A Bad Omen For Sunderland
Fool me once,
shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. Fool me a third time?
Whilst, it isn’t shameful for Sunderland to allow documentary makers to film them over a season, it is perhaps worth raising the point that on the three times this has occurred Sunderland have been relegated twice and failed to get promotion and lost a cup final the other.
Football aficionados or simply those with too much time on their hands will be acutely aware that before Sunderland Til’ I Die, Premier Passions was the go-to viewing for a Sunderland season that incurred the fate of relegation. After gaining promotion from the Football League First Division as it was then known, Premier Passions followed the expletive laden season of Peter Reid’s Sunderland, which remains prime viewing for any diehard football fan.
Season two of Sunderland Til’ I Die, although not culminating in relegation, certainly documents a season that was far from desirable for fans, players or the board.
If a season three is to happen, Sunderland will hope to break both their Wembley hoodoo and end their documentary omen.
9. League One May Be The New Normal
On every mug, hat, scarf and Sunderland shirt in the Stadium of Light there is a crest. On this crest between two lions, adorning a red banner are the words Consectatio Excellentiae, meaning “in pursuit of excellence”.
Although, series two certainly captures an upturn from the dismal league season that preceded it, on the pitch it seems as though Sunderland are as far away from excellence as they have been for some time. Jack Ross has since left the club, but the club have yet to see any real sign that they may be about to really take off.
Sunderland Til’ I Die certainly conveys a sense that the fans are preparing for the long haul, with the Premier League increasingly becoming a distant memory, rather than a realistic short-term reality.
Sitting just outside of the Play-off places before the Coronavirus outbreak, it seems that another season of Lincoln away and Blackpool at home is on the cards for the Black Cats faithful.
8. The Importance Of A Club’s Culture
For too many years Sunderland have been more Crazy Gang than Culture Club. A succession of poor appointments both on and off the pitch have meant that the club from academy to boardroom is brimming with people happy to collect a pay cheque and further deplete club resources without truly contributing to the cause.
The shadow of administrations and squads gone by, looms large over the current incarnation of the club, with Stewart Donald, and Charlie Methven in particular, ruing the apathetic culture that allowed the club to sleepwalk through consecutive relegations. Methven cites the custom of, ‘sending a cheque at the end of each month to Florida’, symbolising the rampant lack of accountability at the club. Donald throughout expresses the need to pull in the same direction, improve the club’s spirit and build towards something etc.
However, aside from parting ways with one non-believing staff member, the challenge of shifting the culture of the club from lethargy to togetherness appears to be ongoing.
As Stewart Donald paid well over value for Will Grigg, Sunderland continue to pay the similarly hefty price for years of mismanagement.
7. Will Grigg Is Not On Fire
Wembley heartache aside, the Deadline
Day saga of signing striker Will Grigg from Wigan is arguably the series and
the season’s defining moment. From Gillingham to Portsmouth, it’s safe to say
not many defences in the 2018/2019 League One season were terrified.
Signed to replace the outgoing Josh Maja, Grigg was the subject of a Transfer Deadline Day ‘will they won’t they’, spearheaded by the overtly desperate, and at this moment hapless, Stewart Donald. Like your paralytic mate who can’t resist going back to throw one last punch on a frenzied night out, Donald simply can’t leave well enough alone. Sunderland’s owner falls into the trap of endless chairmen and executives, bidding way beyond Grigg’s value to the dismay of his supporting staff.
Given Grigg’s solid record at that level and Donald’s reasoning that he could offer that bit of experience later in the season, there seems to have been a slither of method in his madness. But £3 million and four league goals later, Donald in hindsight looks out of his depth and punch drunk.
Will Grigg was most certainly not on fire.
6. Loyal Strikers Are Hard To Come By
It seems that Sunderland fans more than most must suffer from severe Déjà vu. Not only has the club suffered consecutive relegations, but both seasons of Sunderland Til’ I Die start with an in-form striker giving the club hope, before leaving in January.
In season one it was Lewis Grabban, the on-loan Bournemouth forward who hit 12 goals in 19 League games, whilst often dragging his beleaguered side out of trouble single-handedly. However, Grabban, presented in the series as a mercenary, requests to return to his parent club before turning out for Championship rivals Aston Villa that very same season.
Sadly, for the Black Cats lightning does strike twice, with the latest series chronicling the rise of academy product Josh Maja. 15 goals in 24 League One games made Maja a fan favourite, however his form put him on the radar of bigger clubs, with the previous regime failing to tie him down to a long-term deal. Cue Maja’s agent forcing a January move to Bordeaux after months of failed negotiations.
Non-Sunderland fans will be thankful they didn’t stick around- their departures certainly add to the drama.
5. Caring Isn’t Enough When Running A Club
Almost inevitably given their
on-pitch failures Stewart Donald and Charlie Methven have been widely
criticised by fans and viewers alike. However, the documentary portrays two
people who seem to truly care about both the club and the city.
Football fans are increasingly becoming disenfranchised and disillusioned with the commercialisation of the modern game, and supporters are more than aware of the contempt billionaire owners hold them in. Therefore, it is certainly refreshing to see an owner and a director who really like football and care about the fans. Despite Methven’s red trouser wearing, Brentian tendencies, such as the scene where he picks a new song to be played at the start of games, he seems to be more than aware of what the club means to the city and is overawed by the support week in week out. Both he and Donald kick every ball, and appear genuinely devastated upon falling at the last hurdle in the Playoff Final.
However, a lack of finance and
ultimately a lack of nous mean that despite their best intentions Sunderland
come up short where it counts.
4. Positive Starts Can Be False Dawns
One swallow does not a summer make. Never has this been truer than for seasons one and two of Sunderland Til’ I Die. Both seasons start with an unwavering sense of positivity, with the club seemingly building sound foundations for the coming year. However, in each case these foundations are built on sand, with the goodwill procured over the summer months, dissipating as quickly as it accumulated.
Despite fan loyalty, as the results begin to worsen and more L’s than W’s appear in the club’s form guide, the mood around the club begins to sour, with those previously applauded decisions and transfers increasingly chastised by the supporters who certainly vocalise their displeasure. In season two Charlie Methven, states that the good will from fans is understood to be ‘on a short lease’. Therefore, despite boardroom manoeuvring and attempts to arrest the decline, the failure to smoothly navigate the challenges of League One mean that negativity begins to reverberate around the Stadium of Light.
For the second season in a row Sunderland Til’ I Die portrays that, despite every season offering fans new reasons to be hopeful, there is often the rapid realisation that what seemed like a dream in August has quickly become a nightmare by October.
3. The City Of Sunderland Is The Main Character
Whilst the first series perhaps lacked subtlety in its portrayal of the working-class people of Sunderland, both series faithfully represent the bond between the club and the city. The club needs the city and the city needs the club.
Familiar characters are on hand again to narrate the story with passion and despair in equal measure. The fans’ commitment to their club is unrelenting, with the series punctuated with born and bred supporters making it profoundly clear how much this all means to them. The club mirrors the city, so when the club suffers the city suffers.
A week can either be made or ruined by what happens at 3 o'clock on a Saturday, with fans even travelling down to London without tickets for the Play-Off final just to show their support.
The heart of the documentary truly comes from the insight given by the fans’ intimate interviews. As they say in Barcelona, this is Més que un club.
2. Fan Loyalty Can Withstand A Lot
It’s only natural for every group of fans to believe they their clubs’ following is more dedicated than any other clubs. As the chant goes, “We are the loyalest football supporters the world has ever had, we are the [insert club here]”. But it cannot be denied that Sunderland fans are a particularly committed and passionate group.
It seems a long time since Sunderland graced the likes of Old Trafford, The Emirates or Anfield. Since their last relegation from the Premier League the club has been on a downward trajectory that has given fans little to get excited about. And anything good that does come their way they see slip through their fingers (Lewis Grabban, Josh Maja etc.).
Regardless, part of Sunderland Til’ I Die’s second series follows Charlie Methven’s attempt to garner the third tier of English football’s largest ever crowd. Methven’s efforts represent his dedication to steering the club in the right direction, but also the sheer love Sunderland fans have for their team, turning out in their droves with a crowd of 46,039 eclipsing the 38,256 who were present for Leeds United vs Gillingham in 2008.
Through every relegation, dispiriting Wembley trip and Jack Rodwell saga the fans keep turning out. Because it’s what they do.
1. Football Is A Business
Part of the joy of football documentaries is the behind the scenes glimpse of clubs we know purely from what they do every Saturday at 3pm. Sunderland Til’ I Die gives viewers a detailed look at how the cogs of a football club turn and click into place, so that every weekend 11 players run onto the pitch in front of an ebullient crowd.
The main protagonists of season two are new owner Stewart Donald and director Charlie Methven, who have the unenviable task of saving the club from financial ruin. Throughout the series, viewers are privy to the pair discussing marketing, player contracts and transfers. Intermittent shots of training, defeats and fans proudly discussing their passion for the club are punctuated by Donald and Methven explaining the catastrophic state of the club’s finances and the poor business practices that facilitated the financial mess and persist at the club.
Balancing a gaping £35 million deficit alongside promotion is the key objective for the club’s new ownership, which is one they actually achieve. It is telling that Donald and Methven in the boardroom are more prominent than manager Jack Ross.
Sunderland Til’ I Die may be about football, but the owners, despite their laddish enthusiasm, won’t let you forget that this is a business.