10 Things We Learned From The X-Files Revival Premiere My Struggle

The revival, or shortened tenth season, premiered Sunday - what did we learn?

After over a decade away from the small screen (with a brief stop in movie theatres for 2008's I Want To Believe), the iconic 90s sci-fi/paranormal juggernaut The X-Files finally returned to network television. One of the most recognizable television sci-fi franchises, the return of the show, in the form of a revival rather than reboot or remake, was huge news throughout 2015. The fact that it was "getting the band back together again" and had all the key players was promising - but X-Files fans (otherwise known as X-Philes) are a highly critical bunch at the best of times. The first episode of the show, written and directed by series creator Chris Carter and focusing on both bringing viewers up to speed on where main characters Fox Mulder and Dana Scully are now, where they've been since 2008, and the ongoing alien conspiracy central to the show, is entitled My Struggle. It premiered for a collection of lucky fans back in October, but the rest of us had to wait. So, what did we learn from the return of the X-Files? Was the revival worth the wait, or should Fox have gone the Next Generation route? Lets take a look at ten things we learned from the first episode of The X-Files revival (or season ten if your prefer), My Struggle.

10. Mulder Feels More At Home In Civilian Clothes At This Point

Yes, the suit is iconic. It was the uniform, so to speak, best highlighted by Michael J. Anderson's character Mr. Nutt in the season two episode Humbug, when he sarcastically pegs Mulder's profession to be an F.B.I. agent based on his uninspiring suit choice, only to find out he's spot on in his assessment. These days, however, it almost seems that Mulder is more natural - and more comfortable - in civilian clothes. Having been something of a rogue F.B.I. agent throughout his career, "Special Agent" Mulder seems more at home as a scruffy conspiracy theorist then as a government agent. Of course, My Struggle has Mulder brought back into the government fold, but he never actually puts on the suit. We know he eventually will, but this is one area that the show may wish to reconsider should it return for a season 11, or a movie. Both the last movie (I Want To Believe) and the revival have gone this route, but there's nothing wrong with letting Scully, or Skinner, be the link to the F.B.I., while keeping Mulder as a free agent so to speak. Without the stuffy suit. Just a thought.

9. The Show Has Reset The Sexual Tension

With apologies to the "shippers" out there (those who want Mulder and Scully together, romantically), the duo work better apart. Or, more accurately, the show works better when there is UST - unresolved sexual tension - between the two. One of the first things keen eyed fans will recognize about the show's revival is that the producers have opted to turn back the clock, or at least reset the tension between the two. It was spoiled early on that the pair would be apart when the new season started, but what we really learned following the premiere of My Struggle was that, on a character level, the shortened season would be about the journey to bring them back together. The tension between them is apparent pretty early on: Mulder and Scully are now akin to a divorced couple still in frequent contact, or trying to make a go of it as friends. Mulder is clearly the wounded party, though it wouldn't be fair to say Scully has moved on - she simply has other things in her life, including her continuing work at the Our Lady of Sorrows hospital (the same facility she worked at in 2008's I Want To Believe). That said, she obviously loves him, and he obviously hasn't let go.

8. Tad O'Malley Is A Bit Too Much Of A Caricature

He's a 9/11 truther mixed with Bill O'Reilly and every other over-the-top talk show icon the right has to offer. And in the end, it's somewhat puzzling why Mulder is so quick to latch on to what Joel McHale's Tad O'Malley is selling. Other than, perhaps for Mulder, it's nice to be sought out again. That said, the character is far too cartoonish to really be effective, and it's one area the show could really have tweaked a little. The idea of someone in the media being a conspiracy nut, and "true believer" when it comes to UFOs isn't a bad idea, and at first, it seems like the character might fit - until not only Mulder, but O'Malley himself begins making fantastic leaps in logic, switching from aliens to America's own government orchestrating a hostile takeover of its own people, and the planet. This isn't a fault of McHale, mind you - it's just what he has been given to work with.

7. Scully Is Open To Dating - But It Sure Feels Odd

Sure, this was done to increase the tension between Scully and Mulder, but Tad O'Malley's awkward overture to Scully - in her own hospital no less - was accepted. Which shows, at least, that Dana Scully is trying to move on in her personal life. The problem the show has, however, is that we all know that it's going nowhere. And though most of their one-on-one encounter took place off screen, the fact that she even accepted a drink from O'Malley in his private limo is startling. It's not really the Dana Scully we're used to, though she has shown flashes of it before (the fourth season episode Never Again, for example). Even so, this little outing feels weird, and it's doubtful much will come of it, even if O'Malley is back in the follow-up to this episode, which will be the final episode of the revival. By then, you can be money on Mulder and Scully having rekindled their romance.

6. You Can Never Be Too Paranoid

"We've never been in more danger" says Fox Mulder - how very true. This is one area that The X-Files can really capitalize on. In the post 9/11 world of terrorism, the Patriot Act, and N.S.A. surveillance, we're told we're in more danger than ever before. We also - many of us - are under watch by "Big Brother" types more than ever before. Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they're not after you. Both Kurt Cobain and the original X-Files series referenced this line by Catch-22 author Joseph Heller. It's a line that would fit perfectly with this new episode. If any one thing in My Struggle stood out, it's how suited The X-Files is to modern times. The news clips of George W. Bush, Edward Snowden and others sealed the deal.

5. The Pacing Was A Tad Off

My Struggle had a difficult task in acquainting new viewers with the franchise while still telling a story long-time fans would be interested in. For the most part, it managed to succeed, though not without issues. Interestingly enough, most of what worked were the scenes without Mulder and Scully. Flash backs to an alien crash (possibly Roswell, though that is later mentioned as a "smoke screen") were intriguing, and something that has always worked on the show, though in this case, the scene was particularly compelling, especially thanks to the fantastic set created for the crashed spaceship. Mulder being shown a fully working replica alien craft was also compelling, and an interesting twist - but elsewhere, the pacing dragged. Far too much cutting between characters, for starters, thanks to Mulder and Scully being apart. In fact, the sooner they're back together, the better, and that should help bring added focus. For My Struggle, however, it felt like a lot of scenes of Mulder just showing up places, without any explanation as to what he was doing when off-screen, or why he didn't just call ahead (outside of paranoia).

4. Sveta Was Far More Likable Than Expected

Of the characters introduced in My Struggle, one works much better than the rest. There are really only three: Mulder's nameless informant/ex-military doctor, conspiracy show host Tad O'Malley, and Sveta, a supposed alien abductee. It's Sveta who works best, and it's a tad surprising really. Coming into the episode, on paper, she seemed the weakest, just another poor soul on the wrong end of an alien encounter. However, the character, played by Annet Mahendru of The Americans, worked far better than it should have. Claiming to have been impregnated by aliens only to have her offspring taken by men from the government, Sveta especially shines during her exchanges with Dana Scully, when she demonstrates some low-level psychic ability, being able to uncover that her and Mulder have had a romantic history, among other little factoids. It gets even better, however, when she misses a key fact - that Scully herself has been an abductee. Her reactions are spot on perfect, and Mahendru holds her own against the talented Gillian Anderson. Later in the episode, she claims to have been paid by Tad O'Malley to make alien abduction claims, but it's clear that itself is a lie, and of course, Scully uncovers the truth: that Sveta does in fact have alien DNA. Yet while we learned that, we also learned that she may be the best alien abductee guest star since Scott Bellis' Max Fenig.

3. The Big Reveal At The End Was No Surprise

He had been in all the marketing material, and everyone knew he had signed on. So despite the show hiding his name until after the credits rolled, it was no surprise to see the Smoking Man (or the Cancer Man, if you prefer), played by William B. Davis, back at the end of My Struggle. What was a surprise was how the show brought him back. When the news was first announced, a flashback was suspected. After all, ol' Smokey basically had his face blown off in season nine's series finale, The Truth. A second option would have been to bring CSM (his initials) back as a clone or alien-human hybrid, something already covered in the mythology of the series. However, the producers went another direction, and simply brought him back - with significant facial damage. Other than that, he still has the tracheostomy, and he's still smoking through it. And he's still one of the most evil characters ever created.

2. The Groundwork Has Been Laid

Interestingly enough, critics who were given advance screenings of this new batch of X-Files episodes have indicated that the best it yet to come. Most have pointed to the second and third episodes of the season as far superior to My Struggle, and several have stated that the third, Mulder and Scully Meet the Were-Monster, is an instant classic. That said, My Struggle had a job to do, and not an easy one at that: bring fans up to speed on the world of The X-Files and its characters, while introducing potential new fans (who have hopefully been marathoning the show on Netflix, or who bought the recent Blu Ray releases) to the series. So you can forgive the expository dialog this time out. The show did succeed in setting the table for bigger and better things. Duchovny and Anderson performed admirably, and A.D. Skinner being back, with a beard, was perfect - Skinner is always welcome (fanboy moment: Mitch Pileggi's in the opening credits, as he was towards the end of the show. Awesome!). The groundwork is there, The X-Files have been re-opened, and fans will have high hopes for the next couple of episodes. The problem is, with only six outings (and five remaining), the show doesn't have long to find its stride.

1. Six Episodes Will Not Be Enough For The Mythology

Which brings us to the next thing we've learned, and it's something of an issue: six episodes will not be enough. For starters, rather than tighten things up and address the mythology head on, the show has added another wrinkle to it, by suggesting that the very government Mulder and Scully worked for are using alien technology to assist in world domination plans. It should be noted that the whole "aliens are a hoax" thing has been done by the show before, notably in season five's opener, Redux/Redux II, episodes which fans have been comparing My Struggle to quite a bit. However, while that storyline had Mulder being tricked into believing aliens were a hoax, My Struggle suggests that they are real, that the governments of the world have used - and hidden - their technology, but that the rest of what he has believed over the years is a lie to cover up more insidious plans from our own government. Mulder even has an informant leading him in that direction. The problem is, most of this is probably a smoke screen. It would be downright insulting if the show actually went this direction after showing fans so much in the later seasons, where even the skeptical Dana Scully became a believer. However, with four monster of the week episodes coming up next, and just one more mythology outing, The X-Files has precious little time to tie things up. Of course, Chris Carter has already spoken of another season, or a third movie - but first, the show will have to prove it can continue to entertain us. My Struggle was a solid start, but not a home run. The next few episodes will really seal the deal, one way or the other.

Contributor
Contributor

Primarily covering the sport of MMA from Ontario, Canada, Jay Anderson has been writing for various publications covering sports, technology, and pop culture since 2001. Jay holds an Honours Bachelor of Arts degree in English from the University of Guelph, and a Certificate in Leadership Skills from Humber College.