10 Things We Learned From Twin Peaks: The Return Part 11

"Cherry piiieeeeeee!"

Twin Peaks The Return Part 11 Becky
Showtime

Twin Peaks: The Return is very much the 18 hour film it has been marketed as. Its 'Parts' often end - superficially at least - arbitrarily.

Characters reintroduced in the two part premiere remain elusive, even as we firewalk beyond the halfway point. James Hurley is still cool. He's also still there, awaiting some narrative purpose, in the background. We don't need to check in on him every week. This isn't an episodic television show in which its showrunners feel the need to check in on the inhabitants of the town as a means of reassurance. Except, increasingly, it is - not that it's a bad thing.

These last four parts have deviated from that jump cut to the Roadhouse, snip-the-reel-wherever format. Part 8 was a standalone surrealist masterpiece in its own right. Part 9 deliberated on procedural elements, its heavy (and heavy-handed) use of law enforcement coalescing the arresting standalone plot strands. Part 10, while disparate in its handling of the still-expansive plot, underscored the series' fascination with violence against women by connecting them with a singular sense of theme.

"It all comes out, now like a river" warned the Log Lady at the climax of Part 10. Her words were typically prophetic; in Part 11, police dispatcher Maggie Brown struggled to keep up with an endless spate of emergency calls. The narrative was equally turbulent.

This suspenseful hour of cinema/television/something totally new was crafted with the skill of an experienced thriller writer...

10. Miriam Lives!

11 Miriam
Showtime

We open Part 11 with three young brothers playing catch (terribly) near the woodland. As the ball goes astray, again, one of the boys notices a "someone" emerging from the weeds - Miriam, who has seemingly (damn the incessant need for the qualifier) survived the attempt on her life by Richard Horne.

It is a scene reminiscent, almost, of Blue Velvet - a reminder that the stain of modern humanity is always there, lurking beneath the surface of innocent Americana. As mentioned, much of Part 11 is akin to a thriller - but the genre conventions are transcended by the use of such poetic imagery, employed to disturbing effect here and elsewhere.

Richard Horne is many things for a supposedly one-note character. He is unspeakably and unmistakably horrifying. And yet, underneath the surface, like Miriam in the grass, there is an element - a particle - of pathos. His DNA left him with no chance - so much so that you can almost, almost sympathise with him. He is also fairly inept, having only inherited the worst of Mr. C's traits. Mr. C in the premiere poured scorn on the idea of humanity - "you follow it perfectly," he told Phyllis, for predictably succumbing to her sexual impulses. His supernatural terror was spawned with irreconcilable human weakness. Horne is a monstrosity, in the strictest sense of the word. Isn't that pitiable?

Part 10 was nihilistic. The image of Miriam crawling away from the woods, instils a fleeting sense of hope.


9. Everybody Loves Stephen

11 Steven Gersten
Showtime

An unseen witness tips off Becky with unheard information pertaining to her husband - sufficiently harrowing enough to order her mother to the New Fat Trout Trailer Park with a car in tow and to send her flying off the windshield in a manic sequence. Like Cooper, Shelly loses her shoes.

Becky arrives at an apartment complex with gun in hand, as Angelo Badalamenti's harshest, most piercing string arrangement yet piles on the tension. Amanda Seyfried is incredible here, conveying an unhinged vengeance threatening to spill over into something horrific at any point. Her gigantic eyes are soaked in blurred eyeliner, visually recounting a history of abuse and neglect. She aims her gun at the door, not caring who is inside, and shoots six holes through it - the same number accrued during Andy Brennan's target practise during the original series. Lynch's camera then bounds through the corridors and down the stairs, finally revealing Steven in a tryst with Gersten Hayward (Alicia Witt).

It's a sad descent for Gersten - from wholesome teen piano prodigy to the other woman of a monstrous, drug-addled abuser. She is yet another victim of The Return's ruthless passage of time.


8. A New Opening To The Otherworld

11 Vortex
Showtime

As we cut back to South Dakota - unlike in Part 10, these cuts are not as sudden, which allows for an insidious, lurching and brutally effective atmosphere of tension - Tammie Preston briefs William Hastings on his activities on "the site" to which he has returned.

"Think there's one in there Abert?" Cole asks. "One", it is revealed, is a swirling vortex. Cole approaches a run-down outhouse, gun in hand. Electricity cackles in the air. The camera cuts back to Hastings, terrified, ramping up the unease. We then receive an answer to possibly the first mystery The Return posed: who, in the first "In Production" teaser, appeared at the end of it, and in what context? It is Cole, looking skyward, hypnotised. A vortex pierces the sky, rotating black entities in its axis line. "There were so many people," recollected Hastings in Part 10. These possible multiples of woodsmen beckon Cole upward. A terrifying split second reveal sees three of these woodsmen appear on a stairwell.

Cole's physical form disappears and rematerialises in and out of view - an inverse image to the woodsmen creeping into "our" plane of existence. Albert snatches Cole backwards just as his image seems to fade entirely.

This is the second portal introduced to the supernatural mythology in Peaks lore. It is testament to Lynch's genius that it is equally unsettling as Glastonbury Grove.


7. David Lynch Is Brilliant

11 Hastings Dead
Showtime

In both his role as co-creator and his portrayal as Gordon Cole.

Cole in the original series was a hilarious but one-note punchline, one which worked precisely because it wasn't overdone. When Showtime President David Nevins let slip that Cole's presence in The Return was major, it raised slight suspicions of self-indulgence and broad comedy. Those have been blown away thus far in a blow-away performance by Lynch, whose Gordon Cole has evolved seamlessly into an integral part of the series' emotional core. That aforementioned sequence would not have been so unbearable, had it not threatened the existence of his character.

Even during a terrifying and mystifying sequence, the winning fluidity of tone essential to the series capped it off with a moment of hilarity - possibly the funniest moment in a series that is as priceless as it is spellbinding.

As Ruth Davenport's body is discovered - or planted - a woodsman creeps up on the car hosting Hastings. We cut to Cole and Rosenfield observing the scene. We hear the familiar, sickening crunch of bone as blood splatters all over Detective Dave Macklay's face. "Oh my God! Oh my God!" he screams, really putting the moment over the top. Until now, his stoic detective has only spoken in detached monotone.

Still, it's Cole who steals the scene. As the camera lingers on Hastings' halved head, brain remnants and all, Lynch answers a revolting question so obvious as to not even be rhetorical with a hilariously unnecessary "He's dead."


6. Bobby And Shelly Are No Longer Together

11 Shelly Red
Showtime

It's hardly surprising, really; Lynch and Frost have laughed while they f*cked with our cherished memories of the original series. Those who 'shipped for Dale Copper and Audrey Horne were punished with the very real threat of rape and subsequent demonic offspring. This brutal pillaging of the source material has both informed the plot and reinforced the grisly thematic weight of the series.

As Bobby - sat in the opposite side of the RR booth, our first indication - is ushered in to intervene in Becky's marital drama, we discover that their money is also kept separate from one another. As Shelly embraces Becky, Red, Twin Peak's new drug merchant, approaches the window. This triggers Shelly's inner teenager; she seems to have been illuminated. The passage of time, as we are reminded constantly, is as ruthless as Mark Frost warned us it would be. Bobby and Shelly's young love is dead. Bobby mourns it with uncharacteristic but welcome restraint.

It is a performance both winning and reassuring from Dana Ashbrook, who has previously only been asked to emote melodramatically at the memories of his dead teenage girlfriend and dead father. It's difficult to get a true gauge on Bobby's reaction because there is much to be read into his silent expression: regret; apprehension; even guilt.


5. The Evil Is (Literally) Spilling Out

11 Boy Sick
Showtime

Part 8 ended with a grotesque amphibian/insect hybrid harvesting itself into the mouth of an embodiment of innocence. "This is the water, and this is the well," instructed the Woodsman-as-siren, beckoning the creature to penetrate and pollute this girl and the age she represented.

There is a thematic callback to this narratively unconnected scene in Part 11. Bobby is removed from his sombre recollection of a live once lived by a bullet shattering a RR window. He instructs the patrons to get down and emerges onto the road. There is no crime to intercept, or even to report; a young boy, dressed identically to his careless, camouflaged father in a visual metaphor of the sense of fatalism coursing through the story, stole it from his unwitting parents. In a chaotic scene with intense sound design mirroring Fire Walk With Me, an unseen driver honks her horn ceaselessly.

It is revealed to be a rotund, hysterical woman screeching "Why is this happening?!" while practically headbanging into her steering wheel. From the passenger seat emerges a drastically sick young girl, vomiting green bile in a disturbing but somehow hilarious echo of The Exorcist.

If that beguiling climax to Part 8 represented the inception of evil, this blackly comedic aside might represent the birth of it - it is spewing forth into the town of Twin Peaks, as the person closest to her can only react with a series of short, mystified screams.


4. Hawk's Map Has A Message For You

11 Hawk S Map
Showtime

We visit the Sheriff Station briefly, after hours, as Frank Truman and Hawk carry out some reconnaissance work ahead of their trip to Jack Rabbit's Palace. This got Hawk "thinking" about a living, evolving map in his possession. The information given by the Major is going to take them there. These woods, as Hawk tells us, are formed by a dark path.

Truman attempts to parse it, to little success. What he mistakes as a campfire is in fact a "fire symbol" - a "type of fire more like modern day electricity," teasing a fusion of original series and Fire Walk With Me mythology. Its power is apparently dependent on its usage. This dialogue, ironically, is both threatening and comforting. The former, for reasons that should be obvious; the latter that, in a story in which the demarkation between worlds has been clearer than Lynch's post-TP solo efforts, lends it a human agency. Hastings was very much a spiritual successor to the Leland Palmer of episode 16 more so than Fire Walk With Me - an unwitting patsy more so than torn collaborator.

This teased expansion of the mythology may yet blur these lines to more pressing, philosophical effect.


3. How To Serve Up Nostalgia

11 Cherry Pie
Showtime

All across the world, Twin Peaks fans - a fervent cult enamoured with the iconography of the show, as much as the storylines, the characters, the visuals and that haunting, gorgeous soundtrack - settled into the premiere with cherry pie.

There were precisely zero scenes set in the RR diner. Instead, fans spent less than ten minutes in Twin Peaks itself, greeted by the disturbing sight of their hero's double rabbit punching women in the face and blowing their brains out in seedy motel double beds. Not great for the appetite.

Even as Dougie Jones, Dale Cooper has retained a love of coffee - hilariously, Lucky 7 colleague Phil Bisby has taken to using it as bait to navigate the man he has evidently taken pity on from one room to the next - but cherry pie, Cooper's very first love, has been absent from the revival thus far. Until now. The Mitchum brothers engineer a plan to assassinate Douglas Jones in the Nevada desert. Meanwhile, it emerges that the intuitive scribbles penned by Cooper have revealed Anthony Sinclair's plan to defraud the Mitchums. The tense desert showdown is interrupted by a certain gift Cooper brings to the meeting, prodded by Philip Gerard, a sort of peace offering by way of dream symbology.

It's funny; when Robert Knepper's Rodney Mitchum says the words, for the first time in The Return: "OK. What the f*ck. In that box there. Is that a cherry pie?" it almost feels like fan service - but this literal slice of nostalgia has been baked over the course of eleven hours, and is served here in a gloriously, ridiculously, damn different fresh context.


2. Jim Belushi Is Also Brilliant

11 Mitchum
Showtime

As we reacquaint ourselves with the brothers Mitchum, Jim Belushi's Bradley, almost endearingly pouring himself a bowl of children's cereal, recalls his dream of "killing that Douglas Jones f*ck" to Rodney. "I hate him so bad!" he whines in a fittingly childlike tone. He can barely last three more hours before killing him.

When we re-reacquaint ourselves with the brothers Mitchum, Bradley's juvenile bloodlust has subsided. His dream has stirred within him a sense of anxiety. He has seen this before - is it future, or is it past? - and in his dream, the cut on Rodney's face had healed. "I'll be damned," Rodney confirms. It has. When Cooper emerges from the limo, Bradley also confirms that the aforementioned box was part of the same dream. "Ah f*ck," the equally great Rodney says with an instantly, perfectly blunt despair.

It's when he discovers the $30M cheque made out to him and Rodney, screwing Duncan Todd's plan and saving Cooper's life, that his performance reaches the elusive 'Peaksian', erm, peak. He sort of makes an exaggerated, slowed down, about-to-feint gesture - an undefinable bit of physical comedy you will only see in a Lynch production.

His casting triggered concerns - Belushi is quietly good in a dramatic context, his reputation glowing following an acclaimed turn in Show Me A Hero - but the series' fondness for broad comedy did much to quell optimism. Lynch and Frost have subverted expectations by subverting the gangster trope.


1. "There's A Freshness To It, A Lightness To It..."

11 Cooper Pie II
Showtime

So said Kyle MacLachlan in one of the few teasers released ahead of the show. It would be odd if he wasn't referring to the beautiful, unapologetically saccharine final scene of Part 11.

Cooper and The Mitchum Brothers, now (anti)heroes of the piece, celebrate their shared luck in a plush restaurant, toasting with champagne. The pianist strikes a minor key, echoing Laura Palmer's Theme, stirring something within him. Then, the old lady from the casino, to whom Mr. Jackpots bequeathed some of his jackpots, embraces him. Cooper changed her life. She has a little dog! A house! Her life back! Such is the overwhelming, inherent goodness of Dale Cooper. Frost and Lynch have mythologised him as much as the fandom have. It seems the world needs him and his ability to alter the fortunes and mood of those around him as much as we do.

His reward is a slice of pie. In the closest we have come yet to the full restoration of Dale Cooper, he wolfs the thing down with his faculties fleetingly intact. It is the first thing he sees to which he blinks normally in response, as opposed to the backwards slurring blink seen in his interactions with the strangers surrounding him. Lynch has never been this sentimental. It fits him like a glove. You can't watch this scene without a smile as dumb as Robert Knepper's plastered on your face.

Earlier, there was a frightening scene cutting through the whimsy. As Bushnell Mullins prepared Coop for his meeting, he told him to "knock 'em dead!", Coop massaged his face, like Mr. C did with Jack, and parroted the word back to him.

Sentiments on the Dougie arc are divided. Still, I defy anybody to wish that fate upon him.

What did you think of Part 11? Share your thoughts down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!