10 Times BoJack Horseman Assaulted Our Feelings
Think animation's all unicorns and rainbows? Think again.
In the year 2014 people were lining up to pour freezing water over their loved ones with ice-filled buckets, Pharrell Williams snuck a baby elephant into an awards ceremony, for whatever reason…and yet somehow, an animated series about a half horse half man hybrid was the most poetically ambiguous, but unforgivably realistic thing to arise, seemingly out of nowhere, to proverbially rip out our hearts and take a big you know what on what we thought knew about animation as a medium.
Simultaneously, it redefined the social outlook on animation as a whole for generations to come. South Park, Family Guy & even The Simpsons had all broken the mould on just how far an animated series can take such heavy themes as politics, drug/alcohol abuse and the overexertion we place on profanities. BoJack Horseman stole the clay, experimented with it and created a new model entirely.
In a series that opens with our titular character seemingly falling into the same tropes and iniquities as those in the same medium before him, the show subsequently envelops itself into something much more original, relatable and at times, unbearably heart-wrenching - perpetuating the reason for its existence, despite our main character failing to see his own.
The series never failed to apply impact when getting its point across, even if this had to be done through the most heinous, hilarious or horrific storylines...
10. BoJack breaks Wanda’s heart
(“Yes And” – Season 2, Episode 10)
“You know, it’s funny, when you look at someone through rose-coloured glasses, all the red flags, just look like flags”.
These are the last words that we ever hear from Wanda in the series and what a powerful set of syllables to go out on.
Upon awakening 30 years into the future after being in a coma for the aforementioned amount of time, the fifty-something twenty-year-old is more than a little unsure of her present surroundings, as the writers make clear for about half of the season’s run. But no more so than when she is lured into a false sense of security by her would-be lover.
For the first time since the inception of the series we see BoJack actually invest himself into another person’s life, committing to both the good and bad parts that come with the relationship. Sadly, he conforms to his old ways and the evergreen cycle of bitterness and disparity rematerialises subsequent to Wanda falling in love with him, leaving her with no choice but to remove herself from the situation with some choice words upon her departure.
9. Times change, people change
(“Nice while it lasted” – Season 6, Episode 16)
It was inevitable that it would end like this.
From the outset Diane appears as a strong, independent female lead. As we voyage onwards though we come to realise that at times, she is just as broken or significantly damaged as the actor of whom she bases her book on. This creates an irrational but practical dynamic between these two characters, one that sees them delve into various territories together. A typical will-they/won’t-they type of story commonly found stapled into multiple sitcoms such as Friends, The Office, How I Met Your Mother etc.
Well, to give you the short answer. They won’t and they don’t.
As the series comes to an end, we’re left with a conversation between two characters who have gone through an unprecedented amount of change. Diane has settled down, fallen in love and moved away. BoJack is in prison. These two very different lifestyles portray the mediators that pulled them apart, as well the ones that brought them together in the first place.
The last scene we see from the entirety of BoJack Horseman as a show is the sentimental final image of the two coming to the realisation that their friendship (and any potential chance they had of ever being a couple) is evidently over. As we the viewers are left imitating the actions of the characters on screen as we gaze into the heavens wondering where we go from here.
8. Like Mother, Like Daughter?
(“Escape from LA” – Season 2, Episode 11)
BoJack as a person tends to destroy each and every relationship that he builds for himself over the course of the series. Some violently, some sexually and some just downright despicably.
After leaving Los Angeles to visit an old friend named Charlotte, the ex-girlfriend to his long-time friend Herb Kazzaz (who he subconsciously deems “the one who got away”) BoJack is surprised to find that she now has a family, consisting of a husband and two children.
Originally shocked by this, he tries to flee earlier than expected but eventually grows to become like one of the family in his own respects. This is until he is rejected by Charlotte after making an advance towards her.
To say sorry, BoJack takes Penny (the daughter of Charlotte) to her high school prom. There are a few things that make our emotions twist and turn between turmoil and tension along the way, but it isn’t until we are enlightened as to what may have occurred if Charlotte hadn't opened the door to BoJack's driveway abode when she did.
She walks in on a moment that would have scarred her daughter indefinitely. With the irredeemable look of guilt on his face, opposing that of an anger-induced mother, BoJack revels in his misery as Charlotte stares him dead in the eye and iterates; “If you ever come near my family again, I will f*****g kill you”
7. Todd loses it with BoJack
(“It’s you” – Season 3, Episode 10)
Todd Chavez as a character is potentially (as well as very much intentionally) the most purely innocent, kind and wholehearted personality of the entire ensemble. Which makes it seriously hard to believe that such piercing words of displeasure could come from such a sweet and innocent source. As we see with a dynamic shift in tone when Todd leaves his graceful nature behind in such a benignly powerful scene, one of which effortlessly balances momentary humour alongside an expression of rage. It all culminates in BoJack's secret about Todd’s long-time crush Emily being metaphorically “crushed” by him in the sack accidentally slipping out. It's a move that sees the show instantaneously trading humour for uncomfortableness in one fell swoop.
After mistaking BoJack's interpretation of “everything” as being a reference to, well, literally everything. Such as the time he counted to a million and the time when he was a kid and used to, “bang on his butt like a bongo drum”. BoJack, utilising his old toxic traits attempts to blame Todd for his removal on the Oscar nominations list. Reeling off all of the “nice” things that he’s done for Todd over the course of the last six years, but quite clearly forgetting about the few times he prominently stood in his counterparts’ way of happiness or success. Which is exactly where this conversation begins spiralling out of control.
Subjectively stating all of BoJack's worst behavioural traits in one impulsive snowball that implodes on a lugubrious, yet provocative note. After the main antagonist admits that he has done something widely regarded as taboo in a municipal amount of cultures, Todd proceeds to lose his s**t. Flailing his arms, raising his voice and even going as far as to vociferate obscenities!
Ranting at BoJack that despite all of the iniquities he was dealt and the self-pity he finds himself fetishising more times than not, that the answer is simple, “It’s you”.
6. Beatrice's Funeral
(“Free Churro” – Season 5, Episode 6)
BoJack Horseman is a series renowned for its abrasive, ambitious and adherently funny as well as immensely clever writing. Nowhere is this more well represented than in the titular masterpiece Free Churro.
This entire episode is a complete monologue from beginning to end without so much as a whimper from any other character. In the preceding events leading up to the episode, Beatrice (BoJack's mother) has passed on. The only person left to say anything at her funeral is her unanimously despised son, the concept alone is fascinating and opens up so many avenues. But what really encapsulates and captivates though is Will Arnett's stunning vocal performance. As we observe him battle with his conflicted emotive nature all the while cracking awkwardly sickening jokes, instantly transitioning between rage and hysteria, amid embodying the expression "death at a funeral" to its maximum potential. Leaving us to ponder whether we should laugh, cry or just feel uncomfortable.
This is until the episode abstains with an ulterior but deeply saddened man staring blankly into space as he personally comes to the understanding that “my mother is dead and everything is worse now”.
5. Princess Carolyn’s beautiful delusion
(“Ruthie” – Season 4, Episode 9)
This WGA nominated episode is told from the perspective of Princess Carolyn’s descendant, Ruthie, as she presents a slideshow for “Ancestry day”.
Instating the story of Princess Carolyn and their shared lineage the titular Ruthie decides to narrate the story of Princess Carolyn’s worst day ever. But always reinstating the misleading fact that it all ends happily for her via the existence of Ruthie herself.
This all boils down to a seemingly anti-climactic sequence which sees the focal character winding down with a glass of wine after an existentially dull day. Receiving a phone call from BoJack, spouting his substantially frequent dismay and being anything but his usual self-centred self. Until the conversation diverts as she relinquishes some information about the narrator onto both her horsey counterpart and the viewers now basking in a collective disbelief;
“I imagine my great, great, great granddaughter in the future talking to her class about me, she’s poised and funny and tells people about me and how everything’s worked out in the end, and when I think about that I think about how everything’s going to work because how else could she tell people?”
4. BoJack strangles Gina
(“The Showstopper” – Season 5, Episode 11)
As we know by now BoJack definitely fits into the category of anti-hero and never is this more evident than in this unhinged display of anguish, psychosis and loss of self-control.
Upon characterising the identity of Philbert on a new hit TV show, BoJack personifies the character on the small screen but also begins playing him in his day to day life, unknowingly to himself and those around him. Tied in with his heavily addictive dependence on his prescription pills, his fictitious persona begins to coincide and eventually merge with that of his own. After failing to separate the realms between reality and fiction his symptoms become worse as his spiralling fluctuates into an abyss of troubles.
The biggest one being when he strangles his co-star and at the time girlfriend, Gina.
During filming for the series a scene in which the main star strangles the female lead is the prospect, but in typical Horseman fashion BoJack takes this a step too far. As Gina relentlessly struggles for a glimpse of oxygen, his hands remain clasped tightly around her throat. It isn't until the co-workers circulating the scene shortly debate amongst themselves; whether he’s showing a set of unexpectedly fantastic acting skills or whether they’re observing a very sick man who is secretly crying out for help.
3. Oh, BoJack, no, there is no other side
(“The view from halfway down” – Season 6, Episode 15)
Where to even begin with this one.
This episode from the outset is very heavy viewing especially when you consider the fact that our main protagonist may have potentially died moments prior to this episode opening.
In what looks to be BoJack's own personal purgatory, he finds himself surrounded by the ghosts of the many lives he’s lived and the many lives that he’s ruined. The deceased are all here; BoJack's long-time friend and collaborator Herb Kazzaz, fellow Secretariat actor Corduroy Jackson-Jackson and dysfunctional mother Beatrice Horseman etc.
The premise alone is eerie enough but when we reach the pivotal scene in which we see an array of characters lining up for what seems like a talent show, it becomes increasingly unnerving until it takes a severely dark turn. As the first performer (whose name won't be mentioned just yet) finishes their performance they receive not a standing ovation, encore or even applause. But instead an unidentifiable door opens to what we as viewer’s can only assume is a door leading to “the other side”, another plane of reality. Presumably because all of these people are now dead. It makes sense, right?
The rug is completely pulled from beneath our feet when the audience disperses and the curtains close, yet the door remains wide open. After Herb Kazzaz (who plays the host in this insomniac nightmare) utters the ominous words; “This is it”. He disembarks the world he was once part of, leaving nobody but BoJack in his wake and leaving nothing but a serene helplessness felt by the titular horse. Radiating all the way to the distressed viewers still unflinchingly watching despite the collective sinking of their hearts.
2. The lobotomy/the taste of ice-cream
(“The Old Sugarman place” Season 4, Episode 2 & “Time’s arrow” – Season 4, Episode 11)
Okay, so we're cheating a little bit with this entry, but for good reason! These two episodes may be 9 parts apart chronologically but the sub narrative of these two episodes tell two halves of the same story.
The first of the two (“The old Sugarman place”) documents a subplot focusing predominantly on Beatrice Horseman’s mother (Honey Sugarman) as well as that of her own traumatic childhood. Initially starting life as a common, happy story about a wealthy nuclear American family. It isn't long before the metaphorical wool is pulled away from our eyes and a domino effect sets in motion, stemming from the death of her son (and Beatrice’s brother) ‘Crackerjack’. This causes Honey to have a significant mental breakdown, endangering the life of her youthful daughter and being incidentally neglected by her husband. The hardest part to swallow though is watching this sweetly innocent archetype gradually fall apart, not metaphorically, but physically mentally.
“Why I have half a mind” is a phrase that we hear time and time again becoming synonymous with the character, until it becomes poetically cruel. As the last time we see poor Honey she now actually has half a mind as the result of a lobotomy. Courtesy of a man who would rather silence his wife then allow her to expedite thoughts of feelings.
“Time's arrow neither stands still nor reverses. it merely marches forward” - As we’re told in both of these episodes.
Shedding a little light on just what made Beatrice the conscienceless monster that she’s become today – as well as the inception of the abusive tendencies towards her son. Time's Arrow (the latter of these two episodes) does a wonderful job of amalgamating Beatrice’s vast past in the short space of just twenty-five minutes and to our surprise, the once disdainful parent becomes a sympathetic cornerstone that stands inalienable to the many colourful personalities this series has spawned.
BoJack may have undergone years of therapeutic (or detrimental) alcoholism due to the incessant abuse from his mother, but in the dying moments of this episode the dementia-ridden old lady finally gains some form of memory. Requiting reality for the fabricated illusion of fantasy in belief that she is once again the little girl at the beginning of the two-part story. BoJack realises this, sits down and delightfully describes the scene, indulging her delusions and engendering these two fraternising enemies to bask in a moment so pure and so beautifully sombre that one would intuitively suspect that they were mother and son. A first and last for the series. All the while ending a concurrently tragic relationship with a level of bittersweet closure that is testament to the excellent writing found exclusively here.
1. Sarah Lynn's Death
(“That’s too much man” – Season 3, Episode 11)
Ah, sweet, sweet Sarah Lynn.
Sarah-Lynn is a character who we become introduced to in BoJack Horseman’s first season. Originally being played down as the stereotypical child actor gone bad, she spends most of her screen time in this first season being a freeloading, self-centred run of the mill party girl. But by the time season 3 rolls around she’s developed into a character that shows such fragility and depth that even the main character himself may be a little envious.
Upon celebrating reaching 9 months sobriety (an absolute milestone for anyone battling any form of addiction). The title character pushes his own personal agenda onto a young girl he credits himself with destroying time and time again.
Taking her on a bender filled with alcohol, cocaine and anything else that their hands (or hooves) allow them to get hold of. The two travel to a plethora of destinations meanwhile getting into an absurd assimilation of unadulterated shenanigans in the process. These include but are not limited to; Breaking Diane’s wrist, mortifying an AA meeting, ruining Penny Carson’s life for a second time…the list just goes on and on.
This all results in a climax in which BoJack and Sarah-Lynn confide themselves to the planetarium. As the silhouettes of the two characters are shown we as an audience can feel that something is amiss in this scene. As with each letter BoJack enunciates in his monologue, there isn't so much as the sound of a breath between his words from the highly-intoxicated teen sensation adjacent to him. Culminating in a spine-chilling subtext as we hear BoJack repeatedly question “Sarah Lynn”, “Sarah Lynn” and as the third and final “Sarah Lynn” is cohesively spoken as the screen turns to black; we stare blankly at the TV refusing to believe the inevitable.