10 Times Doctor Who Has Broken Its Own Rules
From messing with time to killing in cold blood, these are some of NuWho's worst rule breaks.
Doctor Who is known for its timey-wimey, high concept, madcap adventures, but sometimes the show doesn't like to play by its rules.
Despite the Eleventh Doctor once demanding 'Never tell me the rules', Whovians have noted an abundance of discrepancies, inconsistencies, and space-time-shattering plot holes throughout the show. Whether these are creative decisions between production teams, lazy or forgetful writing, or even just abandoned storylines, Doctor Who has seen its fair share of rule breaks.
Due to the programme's love for technobabble, complex time travel plots, and in-universe explanations, Doctor Who was bound to come across some strange moments. Since the 2005 revival series, when Doctor Who began a new continuity, many problems and inconsistencies from the classic run were deleted in favour of a blank slate. However, when you establish rules in any series, you really should keep to them.
From messing with the rules of time travel to the Doctor betraying personal rules such as killing in cold blood, these are 10 Times Doctor Who Has Broken Its Own Rules.
10. The Rule Of Thirteen
A long-established Doctor Who rule is the Time Lord 'Rule of Thirteen' - that is, twelve regenerations, thirteen lives. A rule carried over from the classic series, modern Doctor Who has been playing hard and fast with it.
When the Doctor first appeared in his Ninth incarnation at the beginning of NuWho, without a regeneration from the Eighth, it wasn't before long that a secret Doctor was introduced to audiences. 2013 revealed a hitherto incarnation - known as the War Doctor - who had existed between the Eighth and Ninth Doctors.
When the Tenth Doctor regenerated for the first time in 2008's Journey's End, that was another regeneration used up. By the Eleventh Doctor's demise, he had apparently used up all of his regenerations and was on his last life.
However, a friendly deus-ex-machina in the form of a brand new regeneration cycle was granted to him by the Time Lords. This allowed him to regenerate into his Fourteenth and Fifteenth incarnations - the Doctors we refer to as the Twelfth and the Thirteenth.
However, this apparently wasn't the first time the Doctor had been awarded a new set of regenerations - if Series Twelve is to be believed. Introducing the 'Ruth Doctor' in 2020's Fugitive of the Judoon, fans have been scratching their heads deciding where she fits into the Doctor's already packed regeneration cycle.
Furthermore, The Timeless Children stated that the Doctor has regenerated possibly thousands of times before the First Doctor, but had their memory wiped. But how? What other rule-breaking deus-ex-machinas have occurred in Doctor Who's murky history?
Fans are just going to have to wait and see to find out how many other rules have been broken to satisfy these plot twists...
9. Fake Regenerations
With the Doctor now able to regenerate seemingly unlimited times, the stakes created by these 'fakeout regenerations' no longer seem to be as pressing. However, their existence still begs the question, 'Huh?'
From time to time, the Doctor has displayed the ability to simulate regenerations, or at least use solve-all regeneration energy to progress the plot.
Claiming that using his regeneration energy would cause him to 'lose an arm or a leg somewhere down the line', the Twelfth Doctor even volunteered it to Davros is 2015's The Witch's Familiar. Indeed, the Doctor has summoned mysterious regeneration on a whim to heal a selected few such as River Song, or stage elaborate plots - just like he did in 2017's The Lie of the Land.
But how? If the Doctor can magically heal characters with this deus-ex-machina energy, why doesn't he use it more often? Could it be weaponised, as seen in The Time of the Doctor? And how can the Doctor pretend to regenerate without actually changing his face?
Audiences saw the Tenth Doctor partially exterminated in Journey's End. He then cast his regeneration energy aside, but The Time of the Doctor stated that it had counted as a complete regeneration. Does this mean the Twelfth Doctor's fake regenerations also mean he wasted a life?
The less said about the fake Teselecta-Doctor pretending to regenerate in 2011's The Wedding of River Song, the better.
8. Disobeying The Laws Of Time
Don't mess around with time. Fixed points. Paradoxes. Don't change anything.
And usually, the Doctor knows when to save people, and when not to. In 2008's The Fires of Pompeii, the Tenth Doctor chose to save a family from Volcano Day - despite their fate being fixed in time. Shortly after, he faced a similar problem.
The Waters of Mars saw the Doctor arrive at Bowie Base One in the middle of a hostile takeover from benevolent, water-based beings. Knowing that the crew were to die in a nuclear explosion in the base - something which would stop the Flood from invading Earth - the Doctor was forced to not intervene. He knew he couldn't save them.
However, declaring that he was in charge of the rules of time and he was "Time Lord Victorious", the Doctor broke his own rules and saved several crew members. However, realising that her death had been a fixed point, Captain Adelaide Brooke took her own life in a bid to set history straight - and remind the Doctor not to meddle with time.
The Ninth Doctor previously established the laws of time as early as 2005's Father's Day, insisting that history shouldn't be messed with. In that episode, companion Rose Tyler didn't follow the rules and broke time - by saving her father.
The Eleventh Doctor, however, had learned his lesson from The Waters of Mars by the time of 2011's The Wedding of River Song. Furious that River Song changed the timeline and destroyed history, he even staged an elaborate fake death to set things right.
It just goes to show that it's better to stick to your rules when it comes to time travel.
7. Inconsistent Angels
When 2007's Blink introduced audiences to the Weeping Angels, fans praised their original, instantly memorable and unique set of powers. Able to move faster than lightning when unobserved, and zap prey into the past, it wasn't before long that the Angels became overused, confusing, and inconsistent.
2010's The Time of Angels/Flesh and Stone introduced the concept that any image of a Weeping Angel becomes a Weeping Angel. However, this new rule raised some eyebrows, especially since images of Weeping Angels have been seen throughout the series. Notably, Blink's Sally Sparrow was a photographer who had captured images of the Angels, but they hadn't come to life. Obviously, this rule hadn't been created yet, but some forgetful writing set it in stone.
This strange rule also caused problems for fans when 2012's The Angels Take Manhattan revealed that the Statue of Liberty, one of the most photographed structures in the world, was also a Weeping Angel. If the Angels did indeed infect photos with new Angels, you would think the world would be overrun by evil Statues of Liberty. This doesn't seem to be the case, as the Whoniverse hasn't seen any reports of postcards or holiday snaps coming to life and attacking tourists.
Photos of the Angels have also been since in episodes such as 2015's Time Heist and in various minisodes, showing this power to be inconsistent - and possibly forgotten. Other inconsistent and forgotten powers include the Angels' ability to infect victims by looking directly into their eyes. This wasn't a problem in Blink, also not invented until the next episode, but subsequent appearances haven't fretted with this particular danger.
This just proves that the Angels are more consistent - and more effective - when their iconic abilities aren't overcomplicated.
6. Time Lord Detection
With so few of his species left in existence, and thought to be the last of the Time Lords throughout most of NuWho's early days, you would think the Doctor's ability to know his own would be more consistent.
2007's The Sound of Drums stated that the Doctor would instantly recognise one of his own people, but the Master's surprise appearances since have consistently disproven this conclusion. On the run, the Tenth Doctor told his companions that when he saw the Master, he'd know him straight away - a gift of the Time Lords. But what about Missy? And the 'O' Master, who first appeared in 2020's Spyfall?
Unable to detect Professor Yana in Utopia due to his biodata being concealed by a Time Lord fob watch, this surprise appearance made sense - but why couldn't the Twelfth Doctor work out who Missy was in 2014's Dark Water? Likewise, O's secret identity shouldn't really have been so secret if the Doctor really did have Time Lord detecting powers.
Like Professor Yana, the 'Fugitive' Ruth Doctor pulled the wool over the Doctor's eyes by concealing her identity within a fob watch, but no narrative reason has been provided for why Missy and O completely slipped under the radar.
These rule breaks, and the Doctor being in the dark, should probably just be put down to 'plot twists'.
5. Lost In Translation
2005's The End of the World established that the TARDIS gets inside the minds of travelling companions, translating weird and wonderful alien languages and even foreign tongue. A crucial part of adventures through time and space, the Translation Circuit has been shown not to work when the Doctor is absent or unconscious - but this doesn't account for all the times it hasn't worked.
Aside from episodes such as The Impossible Planet, where the TARDIS couldn't translate due to reasons explained within the narrative, the translation of alien and foreign languages, and text, has been largely inconsistent.
Alien species such as the Judoon in 2008's The Stolen Earth spoke their own language, even with the TARDIS present, and had to use their own translation device. This was also the case in 2020's Fugitive of the Judoon, despite the Doctor and the TARDIS being on the sidelines.
The Translation Circuit also hasn't worked for several other aliens, including the Hath, the Boneless, and various creatures in 2013's The Rings of Akhaten - including 'Do'reen'.
Human language has also been hit or miss with the TARDIS, with 2017's Extremis failing to translate the Pope's Italian dialogue. 2013's Cold War and 2015's Before the Flood strangely saw the TARDIS omit the translation of Russian text, and 2010's Vincent and the Doctor featured an abundance of French text throughout.
Many of these rule breaks can be attributed to production design forgetting about the TARDIS' powers, but Russell T. Davies and Steven Moffat have both claimed that some of these translation blunders are due to 'plot convenience'. Mystery solved.
4. Crossing Timelines
Time travel is tricky, and rules have to be obeyed. One of the revival series' first instances of this was Father's Day when the Ninth Doctor warned Rose Tyler not to cross her personal timeline, not to change the past, and certainly not to interact with other versions of herself.
When Rose held a younger version of her, the time-feasting Reapers managed to cause chaos - even devour the Doctor. This proved that timelines shouldn't be messed with. However, this rule didn't seem to apply to Kazran Sardick or Amy Pond who met versions of themselves in 2010, or even when Amy interacted with a future version of herself in The Girl Who Waited.
Crossing timelines were also dealt with in 2015's Before The Flood, and the Twelfth Doctor had to be very careful not to change history - even if it meant not saving a life.
Even interacting with other regenerations is meant to be impossible, or at least very dangerous, according to the Doctor. Episodes such as The Day of the Doctor explained why the characters could meet in-narrative, but Twice Upon A Time failed to reason why two Doctors could occupy the same adventure. Likewise, no explanation is given as to why two incarnations of the Master could meet, dance, and kill each other in 2017's World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls.
With the number of paradoxes and wounds in time occurring throughout NuWho, you would think the Reapers would be on hand a bit more often.
3. Gallifrey Falls No More
During the revival series, particularly during Russell T. Davies' time as showrunner, the destruction of Gallifrey and the Doctor's subsequent guilt fueled many of the major storylines. However, the decimated planet was eventually resurrected by the Doctors in 2013's 50th Anniversary Special - where it was instead trapped in a pocket dimension.
The Doctor's lost planet was an important part of the Doctor's character, but its destruction was effectively overwritten by some clever retconning. Returning to the moment when the War Doctor obliterated Gallifrey, the Tenth and Eleventh Doctors helped summon all of their other incarnations - crossing timelines in the process - and saving their homeworld.
By the end of the adventure, the War Doctor had forgotten that he saved the planet - meaning that the Ninth and Tenth Doctor had in fact been grieving for no reason instead of searching for the planet.
Gallifrey wouldn't stay saved for long, however, with Chris Chibnall opting to wipe it out all over again in his second series. Perhaps Gallifrey will stay dead for good this time, but looking at Doctor Who's fondness for resurrections and retconning storylines, it is doubtful.
2. Cold-Blooded Murder
The Doctor doesn't use guns. The Doctor doesn't kill. Ever. Apart from when they do.
The Tenth Doctor is perhaps the most notable of the modern Doctors to abhor violence - and guns in particular. Much of Series Four's arc featured the Doctor referencing 'no guns' and suffering the consequences of those who used them. The Doctor's Daughter and The End of Time both saw the Tenth Doctor on the edge and ready to shoot, but he withdrew from cold-blooded murder.
The Twelfth Doctor... not so much. 2015's Hell Bent featured the Doctor breaking his own rule and pulling a gun on the Time Lord General - someone he had fought alongside during the Time War and was effectively on his side. Prepared to stop him from saving Clara, the General suffered the Doctor's wrath - gunned down in cold blood.
Despite the Time Lord's ability to regenerate, and the Doctor having previously checked which regeneration the General was on, this murder was still brutal and totally uncalled for. With audiences having witnessed the Doctor's arduous and heartbreaking 'deaths' over the years, and aware that everything about the Time Lord changes upon regeneration, this murder was particularly thoughtless.
The Doctor has been known to kill others too, gun or no gun. 2012's Dinosaurs on a Spaceship is notable for the Eleventh Doctor's cruel and explosive defeat of Solomon, and the Thirteenth Doctor spared no time in leaving mutant spiders to die in 2018's Arachnids in the UK. Even the Fugitive Doctor introduced in 2020 didn't shy away from guns.
However, a death caused recently by the Thirteenth Doctor has far more thoughtless and cold ramifications...
1. Killing A TARDIS
The TARDIS has been a constant companion to the Doctor throughout their travels, and unlike any other vehicle, this space and time machine is alive, sentient, and ever-evolving. 2021's Revolution of the Daleks seemed to forget this, however, when the Thirteenth Doctor quickly and uncaringly decided to kill one.
Recovered in 2020's The Timeless Children, this spare TARDIS was one of the only survivors of the newly-destroyed Gallifrey. This also made it one of the few TARDISes in known existence, if Clara and the Master's TARDIS were still in circulation. Despite knowing this, the Doctor used it to trap the Daleks she had carelessly summoned to Earth with an old hologram switcheroo... and then caused it to implode.
If trapping the Daleks inside one of the most powerful machines in the universe wasn't bad enough, heartlessly destroying it to sort out a problem she foolishly caused certainly is a cause for concern. Particularly seeing that the TARDIS is a sentient lifeform.
2011's The Doctor's Wife helped to humanise the Doctor's TARDIS, showing the audience that it is a sentient machine which deliberately intervenes throughout the Doctor's life. Episodes such as 2013's Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS reiterated the TARDIS' sentience, but the conclusion of Revolution seemingly forgot this and reverted the TARDIS to a mere vehicle for the Doctor to crash.
Breaking so many rules with either lazy, forgetful writing, or by suggesting the Doctor to be ignorant and heartless, this questionable moment raised a lot of eyebrows in the Doctor Who fanbase. It ultimately asked the question, 'Is there any rules Doctor Who won't break?'