10 Times Doctor Who Made Obvious Mistakes

1. The Nightmare In Silver Cybermen

Doctor Who Ryan Yaz Graham
BBC Studios

While running zombies have become slightly more acceptable in the years following 28 Days Later, the sprinting Cybermen of Neil Gaiman's difficult second Doctor Who episode haven't.

The design is sleek, and therefore feels slightly more like there are cybernetically-augmented human remains housed within. However, the decision to make the Nightmare in Silver Cybermen infinitely adaptable was a step too far. They felt like machines learning how to respond to threats, rather than the cold, logical cyborgs that were first created in 1966.

The horror of the Cybermen is that there's a person inside each one, whose personality and emotions have been stripped away from them. They're augmented by all manner of horrifying Cyber-attachments, and there's a reason for that teardrop design on the eyes.

It's telling that after introducing these comic-book robot warriors, Steven Moffat went on to write two of the most horrific Cybermen stories ever told. Dark Water/Death in Heaven has the Cybermen offer a cure for death itself, while World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls mutilated the Doctor's companion into Cyber-form, and had her remain conscious of her fate after the procedure.

After all the body horror, Gaiman's Cyber-sprinters now feel like a distant, unwanted memory.

Watch Next


You'll Struggle To Beat This Moffat-Era 'Doctor Who' Quiz

Doctor Who Vincent and the Doctor Matt Smith Karen Gillan
BBC

1. Who Had Left Young Amelia Pond Home Alone In 'The Eleventh Hour'?

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Citizen of the Universe, Film Programmer, Writer, Podcaster, Doctor Who fan and a gentleman to boot. As passionate about Chinese social-realist epics as I am about dumb popcorn movies.