10 Times Family Guy Blew It

Much like Peter's attempt at a comic strip

Internet denizens like to complain about the creative lull The Simpsons went through in later seasons (especially its teen years), but it€™s Family Guy that has really gone downhill. Recent seasons have seen weaker plots, "shocking for the sake of shocking" episodes, and an overall lack of focus. Sure, the show is often times still good for a laugh, but it's a far cry from the series that was so re-watchable on DVD that sales of its first three seasons to home viewers brought the then-cancelled animated sitcom back to life. It's not as if the show has lacked solid premises at times, either. Right from the get-go, they had a solid cast of characters. However in recent years they have dropped the ball on those, while brutally blowing new creative opportunities, or having one-note characters (Brian's girlfriend Jillian, for example) overstay their welcome. It's not just on-screen, either; many of the worst offenders are behind-the-scenes decisions that have led to a decline in the overall quality of the show. Maybe it's a lack of attention from series creator Seth MacFarlane, who seems to be looking more and more to Hollywood these days. Maybe the production team was spread too thin with three shows (Family Guy, American Dad, and the now-cancelled Cleveland Show). Maybe it's just not a show that can have the kind of longevity that Homer and his clan have had (really, what show on TV does have that sort of longevity?). Whatever the reason, there are ample examples of Family Guy just plain blowing it creatively, both on screen and off. So lets take a look at ten of them.

10. Not Finding A Way For Norm MacDonald To Return As Death

This is an early example. Former SNL comedian Norm MacDonald was a fantastic guest voice as Death (literally, the Grim Repear) in "Death Is A B----" in the show's second season. It was the first appearance of the character on Family Guy, and a highlight of the season. When the show decided to have the character return, however, MacDonald wasn't available - he was busy with his own show, A Minute With Stan Hooper. Okay, fine so far. Family Guy recast the role, picking up former Man Show co-host Adam Carolla. That's sort of like trading Dom Perignon for the home-brewed hooch your second cousin twice removed cooks up in an old washtub out back of his barn, but hey, the show must go on, right? Here's how Family Guy blew it: A Minute With Stan Hooper lasted little more than a minute itself, at least as a viable television series, yet despite MacDonald's schedule becoming a lot more open, they never brought him back! Look, if you want to be loyal to Carolla, we get that. He's not as good as Death, but he was there when you needed him. A guest spot for MacDonald (how about an episode called Death Has a Brother?) or something similar could work though. Or just go full Roseanne and alternate the role based on availability. We certainly wouldn't entertain the suggestion of having Carolla wind up touched by his own character - as long as he promises never to return to Loveline.

9. The Simpsons Guy Crossover

You know what? We were really looking forward to The Simpsons/Family Guy crossover. Sadly, it wasn't very funny. The main problem? The crossover was written solely by a Family Guy writer, and lacked most of The Simpsons usual charm. It was The Simpsons with amped up crudity, and while some scenes worked, most dragged on (did the Homer vs. Peter "chicken fight" need to be that long?). Jokes fell flat, Lisa and Meg of all people had the most compelling storyline, the episode dragged due to its hour-long run time, and in the end, the highlight of the episode was an appearance by Fred Flintstone, in a well-placed joke pointing out that for all the debate, both The Simpsons and Family Guy are just rip-offs of The Flintstones anyway. What a blown opportunity.

8. Having No Replacement For "Laugh It Up, Fuzzball" (The Star Wars Parody Trilogy)

"Blue Harvest" - the Family Guy spoof of the first (by that we mean original) Star Wars movie was probably Family Guy at its peak. The two that followed (spoofs of The Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi), "Something, Something, Something, Dark Side" and "It's A Trap!" were pretty solid as well. And then - nothing. Okay, the prequel trilogy was already a parody of the franchise itself (there's no saving it), but what about Star Trek, or another franchise? The entire cast of Star Trek: TNG has actually appeared on Family Guy. and Patrick Stewart is a regular collaborator with Seth MacFarlane, but it seems the show just really dropped the ball on that possibility. Think the Star Trek films aren't iconic enough? Outside Khan you might have a point, so fine. Consider that Indiana Jones was considered for a while. That franchise would have been the perfect replacement for the Star Wars series. Family Guy, you really blew your chance on that one!

7. The Cleveland Show

The Cleveland Show just wasn't funny. This one isn't a total blown opportunity by Family Guy itself, but more so the show's producers, who of course opted to have the least interesting character on Family Guy get his own spin-off - then saddled us with the responsibility of keeping it afloat by having it air between the shows we actually wanted to watch, The Simpsons and Family Guy. So the creative forces behind Family Guy were still to blame. You might as well have given a spin-off to the Greased-up Deaf Guy.

6. Overusing Time Travel

Stewie and Brian have gone through time so many times at this point that the plots of all the associated episodes have actually begun to just blur together. Lets see. There's "Mind Over Murder" and "Stewie Griffin: The Untold Story" as well as "Road to Germany" and "The Big Bang Theory." We won't count "Road to the Multiverse" though it was very similar, however you still have "Christmas Guy" and "Back to the Pilot." Oh and don't forget "Yug Ylimaf" and "Chap Stewie." No wait. Actually do forget several of those. Look Family Guy: It was cute when Stewie went back in time once or twice but you don't have to do it multiple times per season! The list above isn't comprehensive and doesn't count cut-away gags either! Enough!

5. Sacrificing Story For "Pushing The Envelope"

Remember when Family Guy could be edgy but still have a solid story, like PTV? Compare that to "Herpe the Love Sore" where Brian gives Stewie Herpes. Was there a point to that? No. In fact, the episode managed, while attempting to shock, to come across as downright dull. Sure, you can usually get a surprised laugh or two with the shocking stuff, but the best Family Guy episodes actually had well-crafted stories. Anyone see where those went? Anyone? Bueller?

4. "Brian & Stewie" - 150th Episode Extravaganza

Speaking of "shocking" - now we come to the 150th episode of the series. This was a turning point in the show. Sadly, that turning point led straight down. "Brian & Stewie" is without question one of the worst episodes of the series. Why? It tried to shock. It somewhat succeeded - if you think "shocking" means going for the gross-out. As comedy, however, it failed. Miserably. In case you haven't seen it, forgot, or just plain suppressed the memory: "Brian & Stewie" is the episode where the eponymous characters of the episode title wind up locked in a bank vault. There's no music, no cutaway gags, and no other characters for the bulk of the episode. Just the two mains, locked in a bank vault. And at some point, Stewie has to poop his diapers. Then he winds up getting Brian to eat it. It's drawn out. It's tedious. The bank vault, and the idea of a straight-up, focused, dialogue based episode with Stewie and Brian - those were good ideas. The execution? Damn, Family Guy. You blew it! (Say those words as if they were "Damn nature, you scary!").

3. Turning Brian Into A Douche

Brian started the show as the educated family pet of the Griffin family, the smartest guy in the room. It's a cute joke, really: the dog is the smartest one of the bunch (along with Lois, if we're being honest). Along the way, the show turned Brian's character into a pretentious, unlikable, douchebag of a failed author, for no good reason other than it was probably easier to get laughs that way, as opposed to writing scripts where a Brian could shine as originally written. On top of that, the show has mostly relegated him to being Stewie's sidekick (when he really should be Peter's best pal) - once again, Family Guy blew it. That's still not as annoying as our next point.

2. Stewie No Longer Being Matricidal

When Family Guy first hit the airwaves, far and away the funniest character on the show was Stewie Griffin. "The broccoli must die!" "Victory is mine!" and so on. Family Guy had their own version of Bart Simpson - and he was constantly trying to defeat, and possibly kill, his mother. It was dark humour. It was funny. It made the character stand out. In the early years, people would mention "the baby" even when they didn't really watch the show. Then something happened. Maybe it was a focused effort to move away from being a Simpsons/Flintstones clone, but the character of Stewie began to change. He was now flamboyant if not outright gay (not that there's anything wrong with that, said in a Seinfeld voice). He became more of a smart-ass, and catch phrases that hooked you were dropped in favour of tedious gags like poking fun at Brian for taking forever to write a novel. It might have been done in the name of character development, but in reality, it's a cartoon, and continuity is hit and miss. The show actually buried one of its funniest elements early on as a result of this chance, and really blew it when they did so. Stewie is still a fantastic character, but most of the time we're watching him, we're hoping for a glimpse of the Stewie of old (other than him just breaking out the time machine over and over). Fans got a sort of send-off with "Stewie Kills Lois" and "Lois Kills Stewie" - but really, we still want the old Stewie back.

1. "Killing Off" Brian

So they killed off Brian, a major character, replaced him with a clearly unlikable pooch, then undid the entire thing with yet another time machine trip. Sigh. What did that waste, five episodes? Seven? What? It was only three? Wow. It sure felt longer. You know, we can't help but compare this to The Simpsons, who killed off a character of their own this season. Not a major one, but at least it was a legit death. Brian's death was a cheat. First, there was no reason to kill him off in the first place, other than for a cheap bump in the ratings. Second, there was no reason whatsoever to drag it out over three episodes. Third, but not least - using the time machine yet again to clean up the mess was just lazy, lazy writing. Simply put, they blew it with this one and annoyed a lot of fans. Family Guy will probably chug along at a steady clip for years to come. It can still elicit a chuckle or two. However, they're stuck in Simpsons season 14-18 territory, all thanks to developments like these. Don't agree? Have your own times where the show dropped the ball? Let us know!

In this post: 
Family Guy
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Primarily covering the sport of MMA from Ontario, Canada, Jay Anderson has been writing for various publications covering sports, technology, and pop culture since 2001. Jay holds an Honours Bachelor of Arts degree in English from the University of Guelph, and a Certificate in Leadership Skills from Humber College.