10 Times Joker Was Actually The Real Hero

Heard the one about the sinister supervillain who was actually the hero? Let us fill you in.

the joker
DC Comics

When it comes to comic book villains, The Joker is in the upper echelon of the most sinister, the most vicious, and the most despicable of the bunch. When it comes to being outright nuts, few can match the famed Clown Prince of Crime.

Despite all of that, mind, are you aware that The Joker hasn’t always been positioned as the no-good nefarious bad guy that we’ve all come to known and somehow love?

Since debuting in the funny books way back in 1940, there have actually been some rare occasions where, rather than being the cause of comic-book chaos, the Harlequin of Hate has actually been the one rushing in to save the day.

It may surprise you, but these instances aren’t merely one or two occasions; instead, Mr. J has proved himself to be, well, a hero multiple times throughout the character’s history across the various different mediums.

To get you up speed on some of these times, here are some of the most notable times where The Joker really, really wasn’t all that bad of a guy.

10. A Pillar Of The Community – Superman: Distant Fires

Superman: Distant Fires - Joker
DC Comics/DC Comics

The ‘90s was a strange decade for Superman. While this period of the Man of Steel’s history is famously remembered for the high-quality mullet that Kal-El adorned throughout much of the decade – well, and the small matter of his death and subsequent resurrection – one Super-story that many may have forgotten about is 1998’s Distant Fires.

Now, this may well have been a Superman tale, but one person featured predominantly in the arc is The Joker. After a nuclear war renders many superheroes either dead or powerless, one other side effect of all of this is that The Joker regains his sanity.

As the majority of survivors make their way to a city called Champion, it’s there that we see the Clown Prince of Crime turn over a new leaf and start to create plans on how to maintain and protect the city from a bunch of mutants and, eventually, a deranged Billy Batson.

Joker, pillar of the community; who’d have ever believed it? And to think, all it took to achieve this was literal Armageddon.


9. Ridding The World Of Alexander Luthor Jr. – Infinite Crisis

Infinite Crisis - Joker
DC Comics

You may well make the argument that this isn’t really the sort of thing that warrants having the “hero” tag placed on you, but man oh man did Alexander Luthor Jr. have it coming!

The Earth-3 son of Lex Luthor, Alexander proved to be a thorough bastard of the highest order throughout 2006’s Infinite Crisis arc. As a story, this particular Crisis had some major ramifications; Jason Todd’s resurrection, the destruction of the Justice League’s Watchtower, and the death of Superboy being just some of the more shocking moments of the tale.

After escaping from the grasp of Batman, Alexander Luthor Jr. was greeted in a Gotham City alley by the Clown Prince of Crime and Lex Luthor. With Lex taunting his alt-world son, The Joker spewed acid into Luthor Jr.’s face before swiftly shooting him in the head from point-blank range.

The reason for the clinical execution of ALJ? Why, that was because he didn’t involve The Joker in his plans. But still, at least the Jester of Genocide was able to put a stop to Alexander’s twisted plans; even if it didn’t exactly follow the Hero 101 handbook.


8. Stopping The Batman Who Laughs – Dark Knights: Metal

The Batman Who Laughs - Joker
DC Comics

You know the situation must be ominous when it causes Batman and The Joker to team up and become temporary bestest buds.

In Scott Snyder’s 2017 Dark Knights: Metal, readers were introduced to a new villain known as The Batman Who Laughs. Hailing from the Earth-22 corner of the Dark Multiverse, this no-good sort was essentially a hybrid of the Caped Crusader and his Jester of Genocide rival.

Interestingly, this all-powerful bad guy had begun life as his world’s heroic version of Batman. After one too many battles with his world’s Joker caused the Earth-22 Bats to go insane, he snapped and became The Batman Who Laughs.

What made this alt-world foe so formidable for our standard Batman, is that The Batman Who Laughs knows every tactic that the World’s Greatest Detective will use. As such, Batman resorted to asking The Joker to assist in taking down this new threat; after all, the Clown Prince of Crime and his antics always adds an extra level of unpredictability to matters.


7. Taking Down The Black Glove – Batman: R.I.P.

Batman R.I.P.D. - Joker
DC Comics

You can always rely on Grant Morrison to try something different. For the last couple of decades, Morrison has been one of those writers who has regularly split opinion; some heralding him a true genius, others lambasting his work.

When Morrison tackled the World’s Greatest Detective in 2008’s R.I.P.D. story, the narrative would see The Joker becoming a pseudo hero due to him helping Batman take down the nefarious Black Glove organisation.

Granted, Joker’s way of “helping” meant killing members of the Black Glove group, but still, he was fighting the good fight alongside his longstanding rival. For those Black Glove members who were still alive, the Jester of Genocide tricked them into being captured by Nightwing, Robin, and the League of Assassins.

Some may suggest that what The Joker did in R.I.P.D. was more for self-preservation, while some may argue that it was merely yet another killing spree to add to his infamous list of heinous acts. Either way, The Joker helped Batman to stop a clinical and vicious group of villains.


6. Helped Batman Save Gotham City – The LEGO Batman Movie

The LEGO Batman Movie - Joker
Warner Bros.

Given how The LEGO Batman Movie was always going to be marketed heavily towards younger viewers, the chances of us seeing The Joker partake in some of his famed brutality and ultra-violence was always going to be slim. Instead, we ultimately saw Batman’s greatest rival teaming with the Caped Crusader to save LEGO Gotham City.

Despite spending the entirety of the movie pleading for Bats to admit that The Joker was his greatest villain and that the Dark Knight had nothing but hatred for the Harlequin of Hate, these enemies came together for the greater good. It just took a plot that involved a whole load of explosives, King Kong, a T-Rex, Voldemort, Daleks and a slew of other notable villainous sorts to provide some clarity on the situation.

The relationship between the LEGO takes on Batman and Joker would play out like a tormented bromance of sorts; both realising that they needed each other more than they could ever previously admit. D’aww.


5. Finding Peace – Batman: Going Sane

Joker Going Sane
DC Comics

Whether in comics, movies or even in the various Bat-driven TV shows to have adored the small screen, one notion that has often been explored is the idea that it’s the very presence of Batman that has seen so many of Gotham City’s citizens turn to a life of crime.

A prime example of this concept is seen played out in the Going Sane arc that ran in Legends of the Dark Knight. In that story, Batman is believed to have been killed at The Joker’s hands. With Bats out of the equation, the Harlequin of Hate decides to leave his carnage-causing ways behind.

Gaining some clarity and sanity, Joker takes on the name of Joseph Kerr – Jo Kerr, geddit?! – and settles down to a life of normality. Of course, this would all only last for three issues, with Mr. J then returning to his old ways. But the point here is, without Batman being around, The Joker saw no reason for needing to be a villain.


4. Gives Away Millions Of Dollars – Joker’s Millions

The New Batman Adventures - Joker's Millions
Warner Bros.

Batman: The Animated Series and The New Batman Adventures are rightly held on a pedestal as some of the greatest animated TV shows ever seen. BTAS was revolutionary in its style, tone and storytelling, and TNBA took those foundations and added an extra layer of energy to proceedings.

It was The New Batman Adventures that saw audiences treated to an episode titled Joker’s Millions. In that outing, a broke Clown Prince of Crime saw his frown turned upside down after being left $250 million by deceased criminal rival King Barlowe.

With this hefty wedge of cash now at his disposal, The Joker calls time on his criminal career and even throws a party to celebrate him going “legit”. Not only that, but the reformed Jester of Genocide was carefree in sharing his millions with the residents of Gotham City.

This would all turn out to be a ploy orchestrated by Barlowe on his death bed. In a parting shot to his rival, Barlowe had only actually left The Joker $10 million of real money. By this point, Mr. J had already spent that amount – but was left with an inheritance tax bill on the full $250 million!


3. Putting A Stop To Crime – Batman: White Knight

Batman: White Knight - Joker
DC Comics

It seems only right to start this feature with a look at the most recent of tales to be included in this piece. That tale being Sean Murphy’s eight-issue Batman: White Knight limited series that concluded last year.

Set in an alternate reality, White Knight plays with the standard formula of Batman and Joker stories; flipping the roles of the long-times rivals. Here, we see the Jester of Genocide become the hero of the day, with Batman viewed as Gotham City’s biggest villain.

After being cured of his insanity, in a nod to Tim Burton’s 1989 Batman movie, we find out that The Joker’s real name is Jack Napier. Deciding to make the most of his newfound sanity, Jack becomes a Gotham council member whose sole aim is to put a stop to the criminal activity that has for so long dominated the city.

Managing to change the public perception of himself and of Batman, Napier is of the belief that the Caped Crusader and his bullish, brutal ways are the core reason for Gotham being in such disarray.


2. Detective Joker – Catwoman Annual #3

Catwoman Annual #3 - Joker
DC Comics

In 1996’s Catwoman Annual #3, we got to see The Joker protecting and serving as a bona fide detective. The Jester of Genocide, a man responsible for so many needless and savage deaths, working for the good guys? Surely not. Well, kind of.

You see, this story did indeed feature The Joker as a detective going by the name of Jock Bozer, but the tale was all a classic “what if?” Elseworlds affair.

Who was this badge-wearing Joker tracking down, you may ask. Given that this was a Catwoman title, Selina Kyle was the criminal in Det. Bozer’s sights. And not only her, for Batman was both her husband and her partner in literal crime.

Throw in The Riddler as Joker’s police partner, not to mention a Dick Wayne who is reluctant to go down the same dark path as his criminal parents, and you have an Elseworlds tale that’s all kinds of fun. Hell, The Joker would even get promoted to become the police department’s new commissioner by the time all was said and done!


1. Bullied Youngster Becomes Beloved Hero – Countdown

Countdown - Joker
DC Comics

Over in Earth-3, the Countdown series delivered a Joker who was an out-and-out hero. Not a reformed villain. Not a split personality anti-hero. A proper, proper hero.

This alternative look at The Joker saw the character suffer from extreme bullying during his early years. Tormented by his classmates, the youngster would learn to channel his pain by cracking wise later in life as a comedian called Jackie.

During one particular comedy routine, Jackie poked fun at the villainous Owlman – Earth-3’s totally evil take on Batman – which in turn led to Owlman slicing a permanent grin on to the face of the stand-up. From that day forward, Jackie took on the moniker of The Jokester and vowed to fight the good fight against Owlman and all other evildoers.

Countdown marks one of the rare times where there is not even a single hint of villainy within its spin on The Joker. For once, the character was nothing more than a genuine hero who had overcome the odds.


In this post: 
joker
 
First Posted On: 
Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.