10 Times Star Trek Stole From Itself

Some Star Trek plots are just too good not to re-use.

Star Trek The Next Generation The Naked Now
Paramount

With over 60 years of history under its belt - including nearly 800 episodes of television - it's no surprise that Star Trek's sources for inspiration are as wide and as wonderful as the galaxy it titularly explores. Ancient history, mythology, even real-world events have all found their way onto the show's scripts in one form or another, but what's also informed a lot of Star Trek... is Star Trek.

Sure, virtually no franchise can boast as many original concepts, but for every genre-defining new installment there's also a cinema full of fans watching Into Darkness, feeling like they've seen all of this before.

The series featured examples of this as well. Control, in Star Trek Discovery's second season, is a very thinly veiled version of the Borg, while Picard's ending borrows a lot from the episode The Schizoid Man and What Are Little Girls Made Of?

The examples on this list are among the most egregious in Trek's history. Along with the highly obvious ones, we've included a few of the lesser talked-about ideas as well. Some are simply good-intentioned references, and some of them are full-on theft.

10. Star Trek: The Motion Picture

Voyager 6 V'ger Star Trek—The Motion Picture
CBS/Paramount

Star Trek: The Motion Picture is a masterpiece. Director Robert Wise married his vision with Gene Roddenberry's, delivering the most beautiful of any of the Trek movies. The story idea is, however, borrowed from an earlier episode of The Original Series.

The Changeling featured the probe Nomad being encountered by the Enterprise. It was sent out from Earth, before it encountered and fused with the probe Tan-Ru. By the time it is found by the Starfleet ship, it is on its way back to Earth to deliver its findings. However, it has become so powerful and so advance that, left unchecked, it threatens all of humanity.

V'ger is an evolved form of the Voyager 6 probe that was launched from Earth in the 1990's. It disappeared through a black hole, emerging on the other side of the galaxy. There, it encountered a machine race who upgraded it and sent it back toward Earth, gaining sentience. It needed to deliver its findings to the creator, threatening all of humanity along the way.

The Motion Picture is, in essence, a big budget remake of the earlier episode. The plot is thin enough that it could have suited a shorter story, though for Jerry Goldsmith's score and that shot of the Enterprise in drydock alone, it was worth the effort!


9. Fascination

Star Trek Deep Space Nine Fascination
CBS

This third season episode of Deep Space Nine reunites Lwaxana Troi with Odo, in what became a surprisingly tender double act. She is suffering from a type of fever that means she projects her amorous feelings onto other inhabitants of the station, leading to several scenes of pure chaos. While the episode is a lot of fun, it is in fact a comedic version of The Next Generation episode Sarek.

The earlier episode is a far more serious take on this idea. The elder Vulcan man is beginning to lose control of his emotions, transferring them to the crew of the Enterprise. The fight in Ten Forward is the most famous scene from this show.

In Deep Space Nine, while the idea is fun, the execution is a little thin. Sarek's episode had an emotional core that made the audience truly care for the trouble that he was going through. Lwaxana is effectively going through a combination of heat and menopause, which is played for laughs, robbing the story of any core.

This is another example of where Star Trek really should have just left well enough alone!


8. Dawn

Star Trek Enterprise Dawn
CBS

This episode sees the re-use of a well-worn theme in Star Trek. Dawn features Tucker trapped on a planet with Zho'kaan, an Arkonian with whom he is unable to communicate. It bears a strong resemblance in the plot to Darmok, as well as both The Enemy and Gravity in theme as well.

Re-using themes like this is no crime. Dawn suffers a little from the fact that it brings very little new to the idea. Zho'kaan is a poor substitute for Captain Dathan, even though the mutual understanding that the two characters come to have for each other ends on a slightly happier note, with both surviving.

After their rescue, they are able to make use of the universal translator, which dilutes the message. Darmok's strength lies in Picard coming to understand the complex language of the Tamarian people, forcing himself into fluency while both men face mortal peril. Here, while Tucker is able to help the Zho'kaan see that he means no harm, there is little in the way of mutual understanding.

This episode is fairly middle of the road, though Connor Trinneer delivers a solid performance.


7. The Naked Now

Star Trek The Next Generation The Naked Now
Paramount

The Naked Now was The Next Generation's third episode and none of the characters had been well defined by this stage. Gene Roddenberry wanted a script that would rapidly detail the wants and needs of the crew. In The Original Series, the episode The Naked Time had served to deliver this well.

However, he didn't want to be viewed as simply retreading the other series. He assigned D.C. Fontana to write this episode, though once it was handed in, the script underwent heavy rewrites. She stated that his method was to take scripts once the second draft had been completed and rewrite them - all of them. Where possible, he would insert sex scenes which, Fontana believed, debased the female characters. She requested that her name be taken off the episode.

The final result was played for comedy but came up short. George Takei described it in his autobiography as a case of 'children dressing up in their parents' clothes', while producer Maurice Hurley said the episode represented an example of 'Don't we have a new idea?'

Swing and a miss for early TNG.


6. E²

Star Trek Enterprise2
CBS

E² is very similar to the earlier Deep Space Nine episode Children of Time, with both episodes featuring the main cast meeting their own descendants. Writer Mike Sussman noticed this similarity straight away and brought it to the producers, though they overruled him. They felt that enough time had passed that people would not pick up on this. They were, however, wrong.

Both episodes feature the children and grandchildren of the main cast. Both episodes feature an older version of one of the originals. It is Odo in the Deep Space Nine episode and T'Pol in the Enterprise episode. Finally, both episodes end with either the colony or generational ships vanishing.

Odo's actions in Children of Time are a deliberate attempt to rewrite history, a plan that works perfectly but erases Gaia from existence. Lorian, T'pol and Tucker's son, attempts to first overpower Enterprise, then protects it. He and his ship have a more ambiguous fate, as they simply never emerge from the subspace corridor. It is possible that they were destroyed by enemy vessels, or that they were wiped from time by Enterprise's successful journey.


5. Doctor's Orders

Star Trek Enterprise Doctors Orders
CBS Media Ventures

This episode from Enterprise's third season is a bottle show, featuring John Billingsley and Jolene Blalock. The rest of the crew are put in stasis while the ship travels through a dangerous period of space. This plot is lifted wholesale from Star Trek: Voyager's Seven of Nine focused episode, One.

The idea is simple. One crewman is tasked with taking care of the ship while the rest sleep. Phlox and Seven are effectively in the same boat here, gradually succumbing to hallucinations as time goes by. Interestingly, the Enterprise episode was directed by Voyager alum Roxann Dawson.

The script also featured a scene that shows Phlox growing more and more frightened, only to be confronted by two Xindi Insectoids, although they are imaginary. Billingsley was concerned that this would paint Phlox as a coward, and felt overall that the episode was fine, but not great. He felt that the character was better suited to more contemplative stories, featuring philosophical quandaries. He was not, in Billingsley's opinion, an action star.

The plot worked more successfully in Voyager, as Seven was a character who was better suited to dealing with the ramifications of being alone. While everyone here delivers a strong performance, the episode ultimately suffers from its premise.


4. Judgement

Star Trek Enterprise Judgement
CBS

There is no other way to say this: Judgement lifts the courtroom scene from Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country and plops it down into the second season of Enterprise. That aside, it has a lot of fun in the retread.

The set is recreated lovingly from the film, with Archer standing on the same platform that Kirk and McCoy occupied in the film. Even the judge that towers over them all is wearing a similar costume, though it is shown in much sharper relief in the television episode, while the film counterpart is hidden in shadow.

Both plots focus on fabricated charges against the Starfleet officers, with Klingon prosecutors doing their best to secure a conviction. Christopher Plummer's Chang is here substituted by John Vickery's Orak. Michael Dorn's Colonel Worf is swapped out for J.G. Hertzler's Kolos.

It is an hour of strong performances all around, as most of the action is confined to the courtroom itself. It seems to have come from an idea of someone asking 'what if we just stretched out Kirk's trial?' and thus, the episode was born.


3. Warlord

Star Trek Voyager Warlord
CBS

Warlord is an example of Jennifer Lien being given something to do with Kes's character. She gets to display her range as, except for Elogium and Before and After, Kes was often simply used as set dressing. Lien plays both Kes and Tieran, and the audience gets an excellent performance. The plot was borrowed from a Deep Space Nine episode.

The Passenger was a first season story from Voyager's predecessor, with Dr Bashir possessed by the spirit of alien criminal. The two episodes are different enough in their execution that they stand apart. Warlord is the superior effort of the two.

Having Kes wage a war with herself in this episode gave Jennifer Lien some fantastic moments and may go down as one of her best episodes in Star Trek. The episode is also unusual for Trek in that it spends the majority of its time focusing on the bad guys. Lien was subjected to some teasing on the set, though it was good-natured. She may not have got to do much in Voyager, but with this episode, there is at least one strong story involving Kes.


2. The Squire Of Gothos

Squire Of Gothos
Paramount Home Entertainment

Trelane was introduced in The Squire of Gothos, acting as an early template for the Q. He was a trickster, with powers far exceeding the crew of the Enterprise. He is only defeated by the timely arrival of his parents, whisking him away before he can pass judgement on Kirk. The obvious parallel is the later character of Q himself, but Trelane was also heavily inspired by an earlier character.

Charles Evans, or Charlie X, was another child of seemingly infinite power who accosted the Enterprise. He takes control of the ship, thanks to his advanced abilities. At the end of the episode, the only way that the ship can be saved is when Charlie's new adopted parents arrive to take him home again.

Evans and Trelane bear a striking resemblance to each other, with the Squire being the stronger version. The latter is a funnier episode, as Charlie X being quite dark in places. It is also a better exploration on the nature of omnipotence and responsibilities. Charlie was made the way he was, Trelane was born that way.

Both episodes are highly enjoyable, though William Campbell, who would later return as the Klingon Koloth, steals the show.


1. Star Trek Into Darkness

star trek into darkness
Paramount Pictures

When rebooting a franchise, it is inevitable that ideas can and indeed should be carried forward. While that doesn't mean they should be copied wholesale, taking elements that worked perfectly for an earlier incarnation should, in theory, work well for a later one as well, if handled properly.

Star Trek Into Darkness is an example of these ideas not being handled properly. The film is a subpar remake of The Wrath of Khan, with no character development, hamfisted plot inclusions and an entirely pointless cameo by Leonard Nimoy. This felt like the film was begging to be taken seriously.

From the lacklustre attempts to conceal the identity of the main villain to the utterly ridiculous breakdown of Spock, the film simply doesn't work. Each homage to the earlier film is a light being shone on the failings of the latter one. Star Trek Beyond wisely chose to write a new story for the Enterprise.

The idea of a reboot is absolutely welcomed, with Star Trek 2009 being a fine example of balancing old and new. Into Darkness, in taking far too much of what made The Wrath of Khan strong, was weakened for it.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"