10 Times The Walking Dead Went Too Far

The Walking Dead is full of jaw-dropping moments, but which ones took it too far?

The Walking Dead
AMC

The Walking Dead has been on our TV screens for just under a decade now and in that time it has featured some of the most memorable television moments in all of modern pop culture. Be it during the days of the prison or the several times the group has been forced onto the road, the gang of survivors has faced pretty much everything that you could possibly imagine in a zombie scenario, and more.

While the graphic novel series the show is based on has less restraints due to not having to worry about television ratings, that doesn't mean the show pulls its punches. Throughout the ten seasons of the series the characters have faced some horrible situations.

So horrible in fact, you could argue that perhaps things were taken a little bit too far for Rick and the gang. Sometimes it is simply an absolute gore fest that will challenge any viewer's stomach, whereas other times certain characters will be put through consistent traumatic events that seem to offer nothing but punishment. Sometimes you have to ask yourself, why are the characters getting put through this?

10. Dale's Death

The Walking Dead Dale
AMC

Dale is one of the original characters of the show and in the comics survived quite far into the apocalypse, eventually dying during after he was bitten by a walker. Alongside this he'd also lost his leg to The Hunters. Ouch.

TV Dale is a different story though. After AMC's unfair treatment of Frank Darabont which led to his eventual departure from the show, actor Jeffery DeMunn decided he wanted to leave the show out of respect for Darabont. While it was a shame, DeMunn's loyalty to his friend is commendable. What isn't commendable is how the writers decided he should exit the show.

A walker is able to somehow sneak up on Dale in the middle of an empty field and then overpower him, despite the fact that this is the same walker that couldn't get out of some mud earlier in the episode. It gets worse when the walker is somehow able to tear Dale's stomach wide open, despite being a single weak enemy. While you always have to give the show a bit of leeway with the strength of the undead, it's just a ridiculous chain of events.

This was one of the earliest of AMC's infamous blunders, intertwining corporate meddling with poor writing. If only it was the last.


9. Beth's Short Lived Return

The Walking Dead Beth Greene
AMC

Beth was introduced in the second season of the show but didn't really get much focus until the second half of four, where she and Daryl were put together after the prison was destroyed. It was about time Beth took a more prominent role, as apart from a suicide attempt in the second season she had done little else than interact with Judith and Carl. Her father seemed more concerned with guiding Rick, while Maggie was always busy with Glenn.

So after half a season away from the group, fans were excited to see a transformed Beth rejoin the group. But on the cusp of her rescue, Beth decides to try and stab Dawn which results in her getting shot in the head. While it was a shocking death, subverting expectations doesn't equate to good storytelling. It was tragic, but it would've been more interesting to see Beth and Maggie realise they've both changed drastically. Maybe Beth could blame Maggie for always prioritising Glenn over her. Or maybe question why she never even looked for her post-prison.

It also didn't really make sense. With such a small pair of scissors, what was Beth actually hoping to achieve? It felt like she had forgotten every rule of survival she had spent the last two seasons learning.


8. Negan's Entrance

The Walking Dead Season 7 Negan
Gene Page/AMC

What's worse about Negan's entrance, the fact that he killed both Abraham and Glenn in a truly brutal fashion, or the fact that the first death was left on a cliffhanger for an entire off-season in an extremely unsatisfying way?

Well, Negan killing both Abraham and Glenn was quite a smart move by the writers. Everyone knew the story behind Negan's introduction in the comics, so how can you keep that fresh? Make it so Negan kills two of Rick's group, truly solidifying him as a threat. Neither of the deaths hold back either, being an extremely violent show of force that was sure to traumatise Rick's entire group.

This is built upon by the premiere of the seventh season, a fantastic episode which saw Negan messing with Rick for the entire runtime. By the end of the episode Rick is a broken man and Negan can't help but laugh. The episode has the benefit of featuring some of the shows strongest acting from both Andrew Lincoln and Jeffrey Dean Morgan.

But why on Earth was there a cliffhanger involved? It truly cheapened the deaths as they became less about the importance of what this meant for the group and instead became focused on trying to guess who would be receiving the bat.


7. Noah's Death

The Walking Dead Noah Death
AMC

When Beth was killed and all the storytelling potential involving her was lost, fans could take some solace in the fact that the hospital storyline allowed Noah to join the group. Learning that his family had died long ago, Noah became a key part of the group when they arrived in Alexandria. But all this development was thrown out the window in episode fourteen of season five.

Noah has one of the goriest deaths on the show, literally being torn apart by walkers in front of Glenn. But why? Noah only featured in ten episodes before his demise but seemed like such a promising character. This marked the start of a consistent issue with the show, where the writers were too scared to kill off the main characters such as Daryl, Carol or Glenn in fear of fan retaliation, so instead began introducing characters just to kill them off in later episodes.

The problem was fans didn't really have enough time to grow attached to Noah. He was an incredibly unique character, with a busted leg and a go lucky attitude, so it's really quite disappointing that the writers decided to kill him off so early on.


6. The CDC

Walking Dead Cdc
AMC

The CDC marked the first major change from the comic storyline, as Rick led the group to the facility in hopes of finding information and possibly even a cure. Instead they found hopeless Dr. Edwin Jenner, who happily provided all the exposition regarding the world situation and progress on a vaccine.

While Edwin Jenner was a really interesting character and his insistence on suicide being the best option was compelling, introducing the CDC just makes Rick and his group feel so special. In the comic series the group really do start out as a ragtag group of survivors, having to find out everything they can through word of mouth and their own experiences.

The introduction of the CDC also sees Jenner tell Rick that everyone is infected, which Rick decides to keep to himself for an entire season. His reasoning is contrived and was clearly a decision made by the writers so that they could have a big reveal at the end of the second season. It just seems out of character for Rick not to tell anyone.

There is nothing wrong with making changes to the comic storyline, but this change sort of ruins the mystery of the apocalypse and its origins.


5. The Whisperer Border

The Walking Dead The Calm Before Heads Spikes
AMC

After the war with Negan was over, many viewers were curious as to where the show could head next. For those who were able to avoid comic spoilers, they were greeted with The Whisperers. For those fans who were worried that the show would never be able to shock them again as it did with Negan, The Whisperers and their idea of a border was sure to put those worries at rest.

As the survivors think they have found peace with the cult of undead skin wearers, they come across the border that Alpha had told Daryl about. It's made up of ten separate heads on pikes, made up of characters from all the different communities. While the scene is fantastically directed and edited, it does feel like the writers wanted to fill a death quota for the show without committing to enough main character deaths.

Of the ten undead heads, only three of the characters are what you would consider 'main' characters. The remaining seven are side characters that many fans probably couldn't even name. Alek, one of the unfortunate pike members, literally first appeared in this episode where he then dies. Character deaths should be used to further the plot, not to fill a quota for ratings. This scene utilises shock to evoke an emotional response from the audience without having the guts to kill off some major players.


4. The Governor Massacres His Own People

governor walking dead
AMC

After an adaptation of the prison battle so poor that we'd see another one in just eight episodes, The Governor came to realise that he had lost the war against Rick and his group. Coming to a stop on the side of a road, the people of Woodbury begin to voice their thoughts on the conflict. They don't want to fight anymore, they'd rather just return home and let Rick and the others keep the prison.

Instead of going home with his army to try think of an alternative strategy or another way to manipulate events, The Governor decides to gun down his entire army. The Governor was always unhinged, but him killing his entire army after one failed assault is ridiculous. As is the fact that he's able to kill over a dozen of these soldiers without any of them firing back.

While some may defend this as The Governor truly losing his way, it seems more likely that the writers just weren't sure what to do with this group.

Having them all die in the prison battle would've made Rick's group look just as evil as the Governor as we the viewers knew many of them were innocent, so rather than explore that internal conflict they just had The Governor shoot them all.

It just doesn't make sense and doesn't benefit him at all, but instead serves to make sure that season three has one more shocking twist.


3. Morgan's Character Development

The Walking Dead Morgan
Jackson Lee Davis/AMC

Without Morgan Jones it's unlikely that Rick Grimes would've survived his first day out of the hospital. He's one of the first characters to ever appear in the show and when he reappeared in the third season he gripped viewers again as he'd lost his son, Duane, and seemingly lost his mind. Fans were excited to hear that he would be returning to the show as a regular cast member but they were likely disappointed when he finally arrived at Alexandria a few years later.

Morgan had changed drastically from his last appearance, now believing that peace is the only way forward and killing was the ultimate evil. While this isn't all that bad, his preachy approach and constant actions that derailed the plot to fill out episodes got very annoying, very fast. Eventually Morgan's peaceful way of life isn't enough to protect those he loves and he reverts back to his unhinged state.

While exploring Morgan's PTSD could've been a fantastic storyline and there's nothing wrong with a character changing their perspective, it all felt very rushed with Morgan. Whereas Rick's morality and turmoil regarding violence is carefully spread across the seasons, Morgan arrives and immediately begins butting heads with characters at the wrong time. Fans loved to hate Negan, so Morgan preaching peace when all anyone wanted to see was a war was just never going to work.


2. Rick's Departure

The Walking Dead Rick Grimes
Gene Page/AMC

While it is not one hundred percent clear what went on behind the scenes between AMC, the people in charge of the show and Andrew Lincoln, when The Walking Dead decided that Rick Grimes would exit the show, five episodes into the season, with a fake death, that was when The Walking Dead truly took it too far.

Rick Grimes is The Walking Dead. We had followed his journey for nine seasons. While the show could survive without him and his departure could offer a range of storytelling opportunities, why did they have to do it like this? It wasn't saved for a premiere, mid season finale or full season finale and it wasn't even a secret that Andrew Lincoln would be leaving the show!

Instead, Rick somehow survived a fireball of an explosion and was taken away by a mysterious helicopter. Rick's story will supposedly continue in a trilogy of AMC films, which has to be the most bizarre choice that AMC has made in years. While Rick hallucinating seeing old favourites was nice, he didn't even get to say a proper goodbye to Judith or Michonne.

Worst of all though, his fake death is tied to the bridge between communities being blown up, almost as a massive screw you to everything Rick was striving towards for his final five episodes. Rick was such a fantastic, dynamic character who evolved throughout the show, and to just see his final efforts literally blown up? It was truly one the hardest scenes of the show to watch, and for many it was the last straw.


1. Carl's Death

The Walking Dead Carl
AMC

Killing off Carl was the biggest change from the comic storyline the show has ever seen, and apparently it surprised nobody more than the character's actor, Chandler Riggs. The writers on the show truly took it too far in both the real and fictional word.

From a storytelling point of view, killing off Carl in the middle of the war with Negan makes little sense. It just feels like another attempt at shock value to boost the ratings. Not only that, but Carl was the future of the show. So many key upcoming storylines, including Negan, the Whisperers and the Commonwealth all prominently feature Carl.

While The Walking Dead is Rick's story, Carl is the child of the apocalypse. Throughout everything he goes through, including killing his own mother and losing an eye, he continues to survive and push for a better world. To have Carl get bitten and die in the sewers of Alexandria is just hugely disrespectful to what the show is actually about.

What makes matters even worse is just a few months before Riggs was told of his character's fate, he was told that he should stick around in Georgia for at least three years due to the show. This was also two weeks before his 18th birthday! Simply put it AMC handled the entire situation terribly and it's not even really clear why they decided to do it.

At least we'll always have the comics.


Watch Next


The Walking Dead Quiz: Did They Survive Or Perish?

The Walking Dead Rick Grimes
Gene Page/AMC

1. Rick Grimes

Contributor

Media Production graduate from the University of Lincoln. Still not over the fact The Walking Dead, Dexter and Game of Thrones all lost their way.