10 TV Actors Who Hated Their Storylines

They may love their characters but these actors HATED where the storylines took them.

mike breaking bad
AMC

There are plenty of actors out there who spend years, even over a decade or so dedicating their lives to specific TV shows. These actors deeply love their characters, their stories, their journeys, their fans - when they come out the other end of a series they have nothing but good things to say about the experience.

Not everyone can be so lucky though. Even actors who have been loyal, integral parts of hit shows for a long time can’t always talk their way out of storylines they dislike. Depending on your star-power, the threats you’re willing to make over quitting, the fuss you kick up about it or the alternatives you provide, you might just have to suck it up and go along with it.

Particularly in long-running shows there is bound to be at least one or two dud storylines. Whether they don’t resonate with the audience, they don’t really make sense with the story or you can tell the actors’ hearts aren’t in it, even the best writers can create a flop. It doesn’t doom a whole show, and it doesn’t have to ruin a character, but in certain circumstances it can definitely earn the actor’s undying hatred…

10. Blake Lively Hated Serena’s Morals - Gossip Girl

Gossip Girl Serena
The CW

From what we can tell as a public who don’t know her personally, Blake Lively seems like a dream - a really lovely, genuine person. You couldn’t get a more mismatched character for her to play then than high-flying, morally twisted it-girl Serena van der Woodsen on Gossip Girl.

It was only several years after the finale of her fame-making show that Lively spoke out about her disdain for her character’s actions. In particular she felt uncomfortable portraying a character so nonchalant and at times proud of doing terrible things.

“People loved it,” she explained, “But it always felt a little personally compromising… you want to be putting a better message out there.”

Increasingly dramatic and horrific storylines were coming her way, seeing her character cause someone to overdose, sleep with someone’s boyfriend, even shoot a guy. She explained that she came to resent her on-screen self because of what she was promoting to an audience largely made of teen girls - girls who were looking up to Serena as a role model.

Her desire to be a good person was at odds with her character’s dramatic storylines, and with such a young, impressionable audience it’s no wonder she felt it weighed on her conscience.


9. Jason Segal Thought Marshall Was Boring - How I Met Your Mother

How I Met Your Mother Marshall Last Words
CBS

Staying on any one TV show for too long can become draining, I’d imagine - you definitely become susceptible to burnout. However for the most part that’s because you know your character so well that you want a new challenge, not because actually the whole thing has become incredibly boring - yourself included.

Whilst also admitting that it was the stupidest, most banal problem to have in the world, Jason Segal complained in a GQ interview of how his character in hit sitcom How I Met Your Mother became the most boring person in the world.

He reflected on the latter seasons of the show, explaining that his character was excluded from any interesting storylines that would’ve offered any development. Marshall became a predictable, 2D character and Segal felt trapped in those stagnant waters.

His reluctance to commit to the final season was born of his discontent with Marshall’s direction, and almost led to the show being cancelled early. For the sake of the cash and of finishing what he started, he decided to stick it out - but that hasn’t stopped him from making jabs at the show’s disappointing writing ever since.


8. Jonathan Banks Hated Mike Betraying Kaylee - Breaking Bad & Better Call Saul

Mike Breaking Bad
AMC

Across products within the Breaking Bad universe, there have been a few times where Mike actor Jonathan Banks expressed his disagreement with the depiction of his character's relationship with his granddaughter, Kaylee. It seems that these wrong decisions were made for the sake of the storyline running but weren’t for the best of the character. In the more recent show, Better Call Saul, there is one instance where Mike yells at Kaylee in a seemingly out-of-character turn.

“It’s one of those scenes where Peter and I disagree a little bit but there’s a lot of things I do that maybe I wouldn’t have done,” Banks admitted, “Or if I were directing it it wouldn’t have been my choice."

Back in the days of Breaking Bad this little issue was equally as prescient. Banks is alleged to have strongly opposed the decision to have Mike abandon Kaylee when the DEA sets their sights on him, seeing that it made no sense to do so much for her and love her so much, only to leave her with her last memory of him being a traumatic abandonment.

“She was his only joy in the world and she will grow up hating him,” explained one Reddit user. He’s not one to keep his gripes to himself, claiming that if he dislikes where a story is going he’ll say so. But even Banks can’t always get his way!


7. Idris Elba Hated Stringer Bell’s Death - The Wire

The Wire Stringer Bell
HBO

It was unfortunate for fan-favourite actor Idris Elba that his character was always destined to bite the dust.

Playing Stringer Bell in HBO’s acclaimed series The Wire, Elba managed to gain quite the crowd of fans. His expert performance lent the character a nuance and depth that few predicted, even prompting the show’s team to admit that they hadn’t foreseen such a positive audience response. What he didn’t know as he built up his reputation on the show, however, was that Stringer Bell was never going to see things through to the end.

In season three’s penultimate episode, Bell’s time to go arrived. On reading the script, Elba admitted that he was shocked and hugely disappointed. With such huge audience support he had predicted a far longer run, but showrunner David Simon later came out to say that regardless of any audience reaction, Bell’s death was set in stone.

They had confirmed two years prior that it was what was going to happen, and nothing was going to change that. On a personal level Elba hated that this pre-confirmed storyline meant the end for his Wire run, however admitted that it was at least thematically appropriate to the narrative.


6. Lena Headey Thought Cersei Deserved More - Game Of Thrones

Game of Thrones Cersei Jamie Lannister
HBO

It’s no secret that a number of cast members left feeling unsatisfied with the ending of Game of Thrones, and one star who has always tried to approach the issue with grace is Cersei actress Lena Headey.

Headey always claimed a close connection to her character, being able to think as Cersei would. In season eight this was put to the test as the big finale approached, and Headey was made to take the character in a direction she really didn’t like or identify with.

Aside from the character’s death (we’ll get to that) she felt that in the final season, some of Cersei’s agency and determination were chipped away. A big example was Cersei’s tryst with Euron: having sworn she would never sleep with him, she goes back on this and beds him. And Headey was not impressed at all.

“I kept saying, ‘She wouldn’t, she wouldn’t, that she would keep fighting,” said Headey, “But [showrunners David Benioff and Dan Weiss] obviously know what they’re doing and were adamant Cersei would do what she had to do.”

When it came to Cersei’s death, once again Headey felt that she gave up without much resistance. She claimed that she wished Cersei had a big fight or a final stand against someone, that her death was of more consequence to herself and others, but alas.

Ultimately she went back and diluted some of her comments (as all the stars did - oh how I wonder why) but the sentiment remained that Headey was sadly disappointed with Cersei’s ending storyline.


5. Barbie Ferreira Reportedly Walked Out Over Kat's Story - Euphoria

euphoria Barbie Ferreira kat
HBO

Barbie Ferreira managed in the first season of Euphoria to gain quite a fan base, acting as a fiercely independent role model who overcame the trope of the 'fat friend' to be entirely her own person. Fans loved what she was doing and where she was going, and Ferreira herself seemed happy too. Roll on season two, however, and some issues started to arise.

The juicy bit of mystery in this entry is that we don't know yet what exactly in the storyline caused such an outcry from Barbie. An anonymous tip alleges that one day she got into such a huge argument with the director, Sam Levinson, that she packed up and stormed off set. Apparently it was all to do with how dark the season was going, and in particular how her character - Kat - was being taken in a dark new direction that she absolutely did NOT vibe with.

With Barbie expressing how disappointed she was with her season two storyline, Levinson seemingly made the decision to cut a bunch of her lines - leaving her appearances through the season a bit patchy. Yikes.


4. Matt LeBlanc Hated The Rachel Romance - Friends

Joey And Rachel Friends
NBC

Of all its infamous storylines, one of the most objectionable Friends endeavours was of course the Rachel/Joey romance plot.

From the moment it was proposed, the entire cast begged for it to be thrown out. It was weird, they argued; Rachel and Joey are more like siblings - it would be like hooking up with a brother or cousin! And we all know hooking up with a cousin is more of a Ross thing…

Joey actor Matt LeBlanc hated this idea even more than the rest, saying that right from the start he felt icky about it - calling the relationship “wildly inappropriate.” It simply didn’t make sense for his character. Not only was he a serial womaniser and this was more of a lovely-dovey thing, LeBlanc insisted that Joey would never be a bad enough friend “take someone else’s girlfriend,” never mind one of his best friend’s girlfriends.

The storyline was given the go-ahead despite complaints from the whole cast, with the studio citing the need to keep things new and exciting - not just “spinning the same plates.” It made no sense to anyone really and to this day is hated by cast and fans alike.


3. Evangeline Lilly Thought Kate Sucked - Lost

Evangeline Lilly Lost Kate
ABC

It’s one thing for an actor to say they really hated specific storylines throughout their character’s arcs, but another thing entirely for them to admit that overall they just thought their character sucked. Evangeline Lilly falls into the latter category.

For six years Lilly played romance-riddled Kate Austen, and it was precisely these romances that she despised. Speaking on The Lost Boys podcast she admitted as time went on she became increasingly frustrated at her loss of autonomy, and this was compounded even further by how obnoxious she found her character.

She felt that Kate was robbed of all depth, only existing as an instrument for creating drama revolving around the Jack/Sawyer love triangle. Her character was made “immature” and “whiny” when convenient, taking any power away from her thoughts and decisions otherwise.

Trying to make the best of the situation, Lilly recalled that she always tried to bring strength and independence to the role when she could. She wanted Kate to be better, stronger and symbolise something more in line with feminist values. Unfortunately you can only do so much with what you're given, and her stories about treatment on set just highlight quite how much she was up against additionally.


2. David Tennant Hated The Idea Of A Cross-Over Christmas - Doctor Who

Doctor Who Tenth Doctor David Tennant
BBC Studios

There are some storylines that actors hated so much that they never made it to your screens, thanks to said actors giving them a hard pass and refusing to entertain the idea any further. One thing we can thank David Tennant for then is for us receiving The Next Doctor as we know it, because without his intervention we would’ve had something absolutely terrible.

The plan was to have JK Rowling’s Harry Potter come to life because of some sort of space bug, pitting the Dr Who cast against witches and wizards, and featuring a cameo from Rowling herself. The episode was written, JK Rowling interviews planned and then suddenly it all fizzled out to nothing. Why? Because Tennant has good taste.

Tennant is said to have hated the idea, thinking it sounded like a cheap gimmick rather than a genuine episode. Luckily for him, he was in a powerful enough position that his dislike for the idea was enough to have it changed. He didn’t want it to happen, he didn’t want to act in it, and fundamentally the showrunners had to “keep him happy.”

Thanks Tennant, that could’ve been absolutely god-awful.


1. Laurie Holden Hated How They Did Andrea Dirty - The Walking Dead

Walking Dead Andrea Alternate Death Scene 3
AMC

At the beginning Laurie Holden thought she really had it all made. She signed a deal to do eight years of The Walking Dead, believing that she would grow to be one of the strongest survivors and bring in the new post-apocalypse world.

It’s true that in the comics she lasts for longer than she did in the TV show, and that she’s far more likeable whilst doing so. Based off of this and the things she had been told, Holden had started the process of buying a house nearby to filming locations, planning her future and her career around the show.

Sadly for her they didn’t stick to comic storylines, instead taking Andrea down a road to becoming one of the most hated characters of the early seasons. She gets in a relationship with the evil Governor, betrays her friends, becomes insanely annoying and then dies an underwhelming death.

She thought her arc would see her overcoming the grief of her sister’s death to eventually couple up with Rick and deliver communities from evil riding atop a horse. It’s no wonder she grew to dislike the story so much given it’s so far from the one she was promised.


Watch Next


Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Know The Walking Dead?

The Walking Dead Rick Grimes
Gene Page/AMC

1. What Was The Name Of Rick's Older Brother?

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's shortest contributor (probably). Lover of cats, baked goods and Netflix Originals.