10 TV Characters Who Were Perfectly Cast (The Second Time)

These characters proved that sometimes second time's the charm in the land of TV.

Game Of Thrones
HBO

The role of casting in the filmmaking and television producing industry is arguably the most vital component of the frankly monstrous media machine that is constantly churning out new content.

Get the casting of a role right and fans will likely flock to see your cherished character embark on a compelling journey, crammed full of jaw-dropping twists and turns, no doubt. Get it wrong and sh*t has a consistent habit of hitting the fan. Funny that.

Yet, as has been proven time and time again, particularly on the small screen, one dodgy piece of actor picking for a part doesn't have to be a complete death sentence for a television show. Far from it. In fact, the following collection of gifted souls all proved that sometimes changing things up in the thick of a series can salvage or even improve on an already enjoyable run for one of their featured characters.

From badass sword for hires flipping from one season to the next, to sudden changes forcing an animated voice swap for the better, these TV characters really hit their stride on the second time of asking.

10. Carol Willick - Friends

Carol Friends
NBC

Though not a part of the mainstay six-some that went on to steal the hearts of Friends fans all over the planet, Carol Willick still found herself at the centre of many a storyline over the course of the hit NBC sitcom's run.

Constantly stealing scenes alongside the character's wife Susan Bunch, Jane Sibbett's portrayal of Ross' first ex-wife quickly became a welcome addition to the routinely side-splitting series. Yet, before Sibbett really got her teeth sunk into the part of the Sixth Grade teacher, Carol was actually first brought to life by one Anita Barone.

Appearing in the second-ever episode of the show way back when in Season One, Barone's far less dry turn, which also lacked the same level of witty sarcasm as Sibbett's, didn't exactly live long too long in the memory. In the end, Barone was determined to pursue a career as a leading actor - after originally auditioning for one of the leading roles on Friends - so decided to call it a day after her brief stint in the gang's lives.

The fact that next to nobody even remembers this happened tells you all you need to know about which performance was superior.


9. Meg Griffin - Family Guy

Mila kunis
Paramount & WB

Some things are simply just meant to be. And in the case of eventual monster animated series Family Guy, it appears Mila Kunis was always destined to become one of the most recognisable voices the show had to offer... alongside creator Seth MacFarlane routinely performing insane vocal gymnastics every week.

For a time, though, Kunis' name was anything but associated with the part of Griffin punching bag Meg, with the part actually initially being voiced by Mean Girls star Lacey Chabert. Driving the vehicle that was the pink cap wearing misfit throughout the first season and even a number of the second season's episodes too, it looked like she was well and truly signed up for the hilariously offensive ride.

That was until Chabert decided she needed to focus more on school and the show Party of Five instead.

This turned out to be a blessing in disguise for the showrunners as Kunis' performance quickly overshadowed what came before it, with Chabert's sweeter and more high pitched tone being dwarfed by the much more cynical and, in turn, more comical quality Kunis possessed.


8. Aunt Viv – The Fresh Prince Of Bel-Air

Fresh prince aunt viv
NBC

Changing up a character early in its life as part of a TV show is difficult enough, but to decide on pulling the trigger on the recasting of a role after three whole seasons is an arduous task showrunners likely wouldn't wish on their worst enemy. That was exactly the position The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air found itself in when opting to recast the role of Aunt Viv in the beloved show.

The reasons surrounding exactly why Janet Hubert was unceremoniously let go after three seasons of bringing her fiery and decisive version of the character into existence are still unclear to this day. Will Smith and Alfonso Ribiero each claimed she was difficult to work with later down the line, but Hubert has gone on record to say she simply turned down a poor deal to re-sign with the show.

Despite the messy departure, Daphne Maxwell Reid's turn as Aunt Viv managed to mask the initial jarring sight of someone else playing the part, bringing a much calmer and soothing presence to the show as the Banks family's matriarch. Though in all honesty, both women brought something special and warm to the role.


7. Pam's Mom - The Office

Pam's Mom
NBC

It's safe to say that a few decisions were made on the fly as the American version of the ridiculously popular UK The Office began to pick up steam over the course of its epic nine season run.

Along with character traits and backstories being switched up in order to service the story that was now being told in the later seasons, the odd individual was given a complete visual change-up too. Going from being played by Shannon Cochran and described as a sweet and supportive mother early on, the part of Pam's mom, Helene Beesley, was handed over to Linda Purl from the show's "Niagara" episodes onwards.

Adding a newfound edge and bouncing brilliantly off of Steve Carell's always painfully hysterical Michael Scott during the pair's brief affair, Purl undoubtedly was a much more comical and notable guest performer than her predecessor before getting her heart broken by the aforementioned often oblivious office boss. Though that's likely due to generally having stronger material to play with than just rocking up for a tour of Pam's desk in Season Two episode "Sexual Harassment".


6. Becky - Roseanne

Roseanne Becky
ABC

ABC's long-running and once cherished sitcom Roseanne has seen its fair share of chopping and changing over the years, with the series most recently even binning off the titular lead and reverting to the title of The Conners.

Long before this high profile shift, however, another featured member of the Conners clan was adjusted as the character of Becky Conner-Healy underwent a major change-up from Season Six onwards. Lecy Goranson decided she was more interested in completing her education than appearing on TV and left the show to go to college in 1992.

So, following this departure, Sarah Chalke was drafted into the role of Becky and the show proceeded to revel in the character's evident change of look with numerous gags referring to her "odd" appearance, definitely making for a funnier turn overall.

Strangely enough, Goranson would later return to the role in Season Eight - though Chalke still stepped in when she wasn't available - but left for realsies before the next season. Sure enough, she'd rock back up in the show's revival later down the road as Becky again and looks to be keeping hold of her part for the foreseeable... or until Chalke fancies another dig, I suppose.


5. Ann Veal – Arrested Development

Arrested Development Ann
Fox

Much like Carol Willick earlier in this collection of recast blasts from the past, Ann Veal of Arrested Development fame was actually first brought into the sitcom world by another star for a brief appearance before becoming much more fleshed out and memorable in the hands of another performer.

First swinging onto the brilliant Mitchell Hurwitz show with Alessandra Torresani at the helm, the original Ann produced the type of monotone performance we'd later come to expect of the often overlooked personality in the first season's finale. However, Torresani was soon shifted on and replaced by the expertly dry Mae Whitman for the rest of the character's arc on the show.

In Whitman's hands, the just sort of there figure brilliantly played up to the fact that Michael Bluth simply could not remember she existed and also acted as an excellent foil to the all-round Bambi on ice that was her boyfriend George Michael.

In another universe, Hurwitz had planned to have the part of Ann played by another actor every season, leaning into her lack of memorability as the years went by. But the alternative gave us the gift of Whitman's joyous portrayal, making being forgettable something of an art form.


4. Alura Zor-El - Supergirl

Supergirl Alura
The CW

In another case of an actor being required to jump ship due to commitments elsewhere, here's the time Supergirl's mom was swapped out in front of our very eyes.

With Laura Benanti doing an admirable enough job in the parts of Alura Zor-El and her twin Astra in The CW's Supergirl during the show's first two seasons, the star was forced to call time on her Kryptonian trip due to theatre commitments in 2017. But this need to be on the stage ultimately paved the way for a DC TV return for a former Smallville star.

Going from that show's Lois Lane to this one's mother of Supergirl, the outstanding Erica Durance quickly set about bringing a much more charming and overall charismatic turn to the table, much to the joy of those who'd grown up enjoying her also memorable stint as Clark Kent's love interest.

And said Supergirl commitments still didn't stop her stepping back into Lois mode for the Batwoman episode of the Arrowverse "Crisis on Infinite Earths" crossover event. Meta madness everywhere you look.


3. Queen Elizabeth II - The Crown

Queen Elizabeth
Netflix

Your writer isn't going to sit here and pretend to admit that either one of these excellent award-winning turns as Queen Elizabeth II is clearly better than the other. They both absolutely nailed it, let's be honest

But keeping with the theme of hitting it out of the park on the second time of asking, there's no doubt that Olivia Colman took the ball that Claire Foy had more than effectively ran with - picking up a Primetime Emmy and Golden Globe for her work - and proceeded to keep up the pace in her stint as the Queen on The Crown.

Though Foy's Elizabeth being placed in the real-life figure's younger years gave us a chance to see her dealing with all of the anxiety and uncertainty that came in the wake of WWII, Colman's Queen showed us how the monarch interacted with her children and she also imbued the character with the sort of quiet dignity and sometimes sadness that comes with holding down the royal fort for such a sustained period of time.

Colman would ultimately take home her own Golden Globe and Primetime Emmy for her work, proving that Netflix smashed their Queen casting on two separate occasions.


2. Robin Hood - Once Upon A Time

once upon a time robin hood
ABC

Known more primarily for his work as The Lord of Hell himself Lucifer Morningstar, Tom Ellis once also introduced us to another well-known presence early on in ABC fantasy adventure series Once Upon a Time.

As Robin of Locksley, Ellis was definitely suitably confident, smooth, and rugged. But by the time the character returned to the fray, audiences quickly forgot about the eventual Devil himself playing the Prince of Thieves as Sean Maguire took up the bow and arrow from Season Three onwards. Ellis wasn't able to return to fulfil the already planned arc for the character due to commitments to other shows at the time.

Quickly becoming a fan favourite, however, Maguire's Hood would earn mainstay status on the show, appearing in over 50 episodes when all was said and done. Again, Ellis' portrayal was solid enough, but Maguire's handsome Hood and electric chemistry with Lana Parrilla's Evil Queen more than confirmed the fact that this show definitely benefited from the age-old pain-in-the-*ss that are those pesky "scheduling conflicts".


1. Daario Naharis - Game Of Thrones

DAARIO NAHARIS
HBO

When it comes to switching out characters in the midst of an epic tale, there's arguably never been a more frequent offender than HBO's sprawling tale of battling houses, Game of Thrones.

Everyone from fledgling Lannisters to frosty White Walker overlords experienced an on-screen change-up over the course of the show's gripping eight seasons. But perhaps the most notable and effective character transfer came in the form of a particular lover of a Mother of Dragons.

After making a fairly decent impression as the witty and merciless sellsword Daario Neaharis in Season Three, Ed Skrein was suddenly cut loose, with the actor stating his plans to stay aboard the mega show were thwarted by "politics". In his place, though, came the increasingly more compelling Michiel Huisman, delivering one liners and frequently producing unquestionable fire in his many sexually charged exchanges with Daenerys Targaryen from Season Four onwards.

As you've likely spotted over the course of this list, recasting tends to not be part of the plan in most cases, but here the replacement stud more than did the badass business second time around.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!