10 TV Shows That Abandoned Awesome Ideas Halfway Through

The biggest missed opportunities on the small screen, from Lost to Buffy.

Oz Buffy
Mutant Enemy

The creation of a great TV show is like a well-oiled machine, made up of numerous moving parts that have to work together fluidly in order for the series to reach its full potential. Unfortunately, this harmony is never guaranteed, and from time to time a moving part breaks.

This isn't necessarily a bad thing, of course. Breaking Bad, for example, was hindered by the 2007 Writers' Strike, but the brief hiatus gave its crew time to perfect their ingredients, and it's now regarded as one of the greatest shows ever made. But not every show is Breaking Bad.

The following shows all dropped great developments partway through their runs, whether it was because an actor wanted to leave or because the writers simply forgot about plotlines they'd set in motion. Not all of them are devastating to their show, but the wasted potential is difficult to overlook.

With that in mind, then, here are 10 awesome ideas dropped by TV shows and never picked up again, for better and for worse. This article will contain major spoilers for each series discussed.

10. Libby's Past - Lost

Libby lost
ABC

When she was introduced in the masterful second season of Lost, Libby instantly struck a chord with audiences, thanks in large part to her kindness, mental fortitude and budding romance with the ever-lovable Hurley.

Initially a minor character before she assimilated into the main group, Libby's role soon became more prominent, and her past became a lingering question hovering over the show as it was revealed she was once committed to the same psychiatric hospital as her new beau.

Her mysterious connection to Hurley was a source of much discussion for fans, particularly given the mystical twists of Hurley's tragic history, but Lost dramatically dropped the story when Libby was accidentally shot dead by a desperate Michael.

With Libby's death, so died her story, which was shaping up to be an intriguing chapter in Lost's twisty melodrama. The series dropped many storylines through its run, but this one might honestly be the most irritating; she deserved so much more.


9. Abed's Girlfriend - Community

Community Rachel Abed
Sony Pictures Television

Like Lost, Community liked to set stories up and then drop them -- case in point: Professor Slater, who disappeared from the show after the first season's maddening will-they-won't-they cliffhanger -- but nothing was ever stranger than when Brie Larson landed on campus, started dating Abed... and then vanished.

Though Abed and Rachel's relationship was certainly set up to a major story going forward, after a couple episodes Larson stopped showing up. Odder still, Rachel wasn't even mentioned once she left.

It's clear why Larson, Oscar-winner and MCU star, left the series, but the lack of explanation or tact surrounding her confounding and anticlimactic disappearance still doesn't sit quite right when you re-visit Community's fifth season. Who knows what kind of wacky shenanigans she and Abed could have got up to.


8. Palpatine Has "Other Uses" For Maul - Star Wars: The Clone Wars

Star Wars The Clone Wars Maul Emperor
Lucasfilm

Setting up several major cliffhangers in its fifth and sixth seasons, The Clone Wars met an unsatisfactory (though thankfully short-lived) end during its otherwise epic sixth season, leaving many promising plot threads unfinished.

The biggest of these maddening cliffhangers came by way of a resurfaced Maul, who, after taking over control of Mandalore and amassing an army, was hunted down by his former master, future-Emperor Palpatine, and defeated in an epic duel which also claimed the life of his brutish brother, Savage Opress.

Maul is left frightened and trapped, but Palpatine doesn't kill him, instead promising he has "other plans" for his former apprentice. It's a brilliant set-up to big things -- big things that tragically never come.

Though this plotline was picked up in the tie-in comic book Son Of Dathomir, the fact it was never picked up on the mainline show is a serious bummer, especially given how confusing it is to see Maul back in Mandalore again come The Clone War's final season.


7. Oceanside - The Walking Dead

The Walking Dead Cyndie
Gene Page/AMC

The Walking Dead dropped a lot of storylines and characters during its eleven-season run on AMC, but one of the biggest sources of frustration for fans came by way of the woman-led community Oceanside.

Despite playing a major role in the All Out War arc of seasons seven and eight, and then joining the other, larger communities in a new coalition following Negan's defeat, it became slightly odd and impossible to ignore the fact that Oceanside were written out of the series... and then never really seen or mentioned again.

This means that promising characters such as Cyndie and Rachel were never given the growth or screentime they probably deserved, and Oceanside was left out of the show's later action. Even when they came back in the final season, their fate was left oddly ambiguous.

The black sheep of The Walking Dead's expansive collection of communities, Oceanside never got the respect or development they deserved. And when they were gone, no one seemed to care. What a waste.


6. Nick Embraces Aikido - Fear The Walking Dead

Nick Morgan Fear the Walking Dead
AMC

The Walking Dead isn't the only show to have a trouble knowing a good thing when it slapped them in the face -- it's much more maddening and inconsistent spin-off, Fear the Walking Dead, had wasted opportunities in abundance.

The most noticeable of these was the intriguing development of fan favourite Nick Clarke, a former addict-turned-survivor who had been through his fair share of hardships, but seemed poised for a slightly better and more peaceful future when he met TWD's Morgan Jones, who introduced him to Aikido.

Aikido, a pacifistic martial art, allowed Morgan to become a better, more hopeful soul, something it could have done for the once-chaotic Nick. Unfortunately, Nick is unceremoniously killed before he can accept this new chapter in his life. Once he was gone, the show lost its heart, and its most promising character.


5. Peter Has "Always Been The Alpha!" - Teen Wolf

Peter Teen Wolf
MTV

Every show needs someone like Peter Hale -- the renegade anti-hero whose opportunism and deceit often left their true intentions thrillingly in the dark, until the series finally delivers a mean twist and embraces their true nature.

On Teen Wolf, Peter's big reveal was that, despite working with his nephew Derek and former foes Scott, Stiles and Lydia, he wanted to be the alpha werewolf he had been in the first season. Season four explores his endgame, as he clashes with his on-and-off allies and eventually finds himself locked up in an insane asylum.

This could have been the end of Peter's story -- a big bad being beaten, locked away, the end -- but it wasn't. He returns in the show's final season, the same sarcastic deviant he'd always been, but his plans for killing Scott and regaining his power were nowhere to be seen.

By the final episode, it's implied he's part of the main gang, a genuine ally whose past behaviour and lust for power has been forgotten without any real development. Such a shame.


4. Captain Holt's Demotion - Brooklyn Nine-Nine

Brooklyn Nine Nine Jake Peralta Captain Holt
Fox

In the penultimate season of Brooklyn Nine-Nine, the stoic Captain Raymond Holt was demoted to a beat cop and forced to serve on the streets rather than behind a desk. Hilarity should have ensued, but it didn't.

Though there are some sparks of brilliance, including his strained relationship with Jake, Holt's demotion barely sticks around; within just a handful of episodes, he's back leading the Nine-Nine and his demotion is simply never mentioned again, despite lasting for an entire year.

Given how much this new job clashes with Holt's straight-laced, political aspirations, forcing him to work closely with former subordinates who are now his superiors, the fact the Captain really should have been given more time on the street, working cases and hilariously crushing his ego.

Perhaps if season seven had been given more episodes to spread out its stories, we would have seen more of Officer Holt, but alas we weren't so lucky.


3. The Corruption Of Cedric Daniels - The Wire

The Wire Cedric Daniels
HBO

Cedric Daniels, a lieutenant in the Baltimore Police Department's Narcotics Unit, was The Wire's most complex and enigmatic character, played in a career-best performance by the late, great Lance Reddick.

Though his development was often one of the HBO hit's greatest joys -- his leadership of the Narcotics Unit, his career growth from cop to defence lawyer -- one part of his story was never given the attention it deserved.

Investigated by the FBI for some kind of corruption before the start of the series, Daniels' apparently scandalous past in the BPD was never brought to the spotlight in great detail, despite the extra intensity and complexity it would have brought to his story and Reddick's steely performance.

It's not a colossal loss, considering how great The Wire was throughout its run, but even the greats have their flaws, and Daniels' backstory would have made an otherwise perfect show that much better.


2. Herb The Simpson - The Simpsons

Herb Homer
Fox

The Simpsons has always thrived in spite (or more aptly because of) its lack of continuity, but even so this narrative device has had its drawbacks from time to time.

Case in point: The introduction of Homer's wealthy car manufacturing half-brother Herb, who connects with the Simpsons and has his career destroyed by an ill-advised car design courtesy of his estranged sibling. He leaves town in rage, briefly returns to regain his fortune... and has only briefly been seen once since.

Considering Herb's debut episode is often (correctly) regarded as one of The Simpsons' greatest, and he was played by a fully-committed Danny DeVito, it's a shame the lost Simpson was never given a recurring slot on the series, akin to Sideshow Bob.

Honestly, who wouldn't want Danny DeVito to run into Springfield every year or two to butt heads with Homer, Bart et al? It's a missed opportunity if you ask me.


1. Oz Masters His Power - Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Oz Buffy
Mutant Enemy

Buffy the Vampire Slayer often left plotlines unfinished or rushed so various characters could be written off the show, and never was that more obvious than with Willow's monosyllabic rocker boyfriend Oz.

A werewolf unable to fully contend with his power, Oz leaves town during the show's fourth season in hopes of finding a way to control the beast inside him. Even though he does, he's then cruelly removed from the show for good when Willow falls in love with fellow wicca Tara.

Considering Oz's popularity and the potential of his powerful urges, it's very hard to picture a world in which his inner turmoil wouldn't have been a compelling plotline, beautifully complimenting Willow's growth into a powerful witch, and Buffy's conflict over her own life-altering powers.

But then again, if he had stuck around, we wouldn't have got Willow and Tara's groundbreaking relationship, so it's not all bad. Still, more Seth Green is never a bad thing.


Watch Next


Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/