10 TV Shows That Aired Their Worst Ever Episode In 2015

Shark jumpers, assemble!

Nobody sets out to make a bad episode of a television show, but it happens. All of a sudden, a new, misjudged installment will air - one which forces you to come to terms with the idea that a show you love isn't quite perfect after all, or wasn't as consistently-realised as you thought. It doesn't necessarily mean the show is ruined; just that, for an hour, it screwed up. 2015 was a great year for television, of course, but it has also marked a time at which certain television shows hit their lowest points ever, airing their worst episodes to date. Episodes that didn't have you quite so desperate to come back for the next installment the following week, or finally convinced you to close the laptop, stop the binging and go to bed. Here, then, are 10 television shows - all of which are at least already into at least their second season - which aired what were clearly their most lackluster offerings to date across the span 2015. Be it because they were unusually boring, awkwardly jumped the shark, or took the show in a direction that nobody was a) expecting or b) really wanted...

Honourable Mention: The Abominable Bride - Sherlock

Original Air Date: January 1, 2016 Sherlock, the BBC's rather inspired modern take on Arthur Conan Doyle's iconic character, starring Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman, no less, hardly put a foot wrong in its first three seasons. The show thrived on great acting, clever twists and strong writing. And then along came this "Christmas Special" on New Year's Day 2016, a release date which relegates it from inclusion on the main list, sadly (given its close proximity to 2015, though, an honourable mention seems fitting). Set in the Victorian era, The Abominable Bride should have been non-canon - a true "one off" with zero ties to the actual series. Unfortunately that wasn't to be, as writers Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss delivered a bewildering 90 minute mess that tried so hard to be clever it ended up feeling like a load of old tosh. Turns out the whole thing was just a dream (or something), as The Abominable Bride - which started off promising - failed to gel with the show's modern continuity.

10. New Business - Mad Men

Original Air Date: April 12, 2015 Mad Men is, generally speaking, such a tightly constructed and inherently novelistic show, that a rotten episode like New Business really stands out. Especially since, for the most part, Mad Men's seventh and final season was a work of genuine mastery. After that long you kind of expect a show like this to be flailing, but Mad Men stayed strong right up to its very last episode. The only real blip was this random installment, which feels like it was written in a hurry (by an intern, who also happened to be the son of a high-level executive working at AMC, who demanded he got to write one). The most jarring moments in New Business concern Diana, who Don Draper suddenly - in a highly out of character turn - tries to connect with. It doesn't feel like him at all, and you're left staring at the screen wondering what the hell happened to the guy (there's also the lackluster way that the show brings Megan's storyline to a sad and somewhat flat end). Usually when you watch an episode of Mad Men unfold, it's as part of the "whole" - like reading the next chapter in a brilliantly dense book. New Business needed to be cut.

9. The Closet Case - Modern Family

Original Air Date: October 7, 2015 There are many people who think that Modern Family has been in decline for a good number of years now, and whilst it's hard to argue that the show is anywhere close to "in its prime" (c'mon, it's not), it still maintains an overall quality that makes it worthwhile viewing. Sadly, the season seven episode The Closet Case - which aired last year - marked what is perhaps the worst chapter in this family's ongoing saga. As a piece of television, it pretty much summed up all the problems that Modern Family is currently experiencing in a handy 22 minute slot. A far better title for the episode might have been "How To Not Make A Modern Family Episode," because... well, you get the idea: it's crap. The plot concerns Phil's attempts to help Haley convince his wife that Dylan should move in, but ends up backtracking on the idea in the process. Other sub-plots involving Manny and a girl at school and Mitch and Jay bickering about a job offer (that's right!) feel thrown in at random, giving The Closet Case the poise of a wholly shambolic and farfetched yarn. Not to mention it's all over the place thematically, you can guess the result of every plot thread, and none of it rings true. It's everything that Modern Family needs to quit being.

8. Triggering - Girls

Original Air Date: January 18, 2015 Whatever way you look at it, Girls is an inherently irksome show. Its characters alternate between being downright insufferable and seriously annoying, but there's something about them - their realism, perhaps - that makes Lena Dunham's series so darn watchable. You never want to miss an episode, in that "watching a car crash" sort of way. Go figure. So whilst most Girls episodes are bound to give you at least a minor case of the frustrations, season four's Triggering offered up the worst episode of the show to date. The plot has Hannah in Iowa, getting to grips with her life away from New York City, which ultimately leads to her clashing with her fellow students in a writers' workshop. Pretty direction aside, Triggering fails as both a drama and a comedy; bad news for a show that wants to be both. It's neither funny or weighty - an episode without a real purpose. So it all actually winds up feeling like a cold and depressing slice of television; the kind of downbeat slump of an episode that might have you wondering whether to tune in the following week. Which is never a good feeling to have when it comes to Girls, a show that seems to straddles that "Am I done with this?" line on a continuous basis.

7. Pot Luck - Louie

Original Air Date: April 9, 2015 One of the biggest complaints that audiences had with regards to Louie's fourth season was that it wasn't funny. Even if you're a huge fan of the show and the sort of person willing to defend it against naysayers of all shapes and sizes, it's a difficult criticism to turn down: season four had the feel of a dark drama with just the occasional flashes of comedy. But it wasn't bad. As experimental as Louis C.K got with season four - and it did get experimental - the quality of the writing was still there. It just wasn't that amusing; the gag count was too low. Still, you'd think that the first episode of season five - Pot Luck - would have at least attempt to right some of season four's wrongs. Nope: instead, it existed as a bonafide extension of that approach. Only far worse, with a lot less wit. Pot Luck is without a doubt the weakest episode of Louie to date, then: the story, which sees Louie attending a party of New Age parents and making a few faux pas in the process, is as arbitrary as they come. Its worst crime, however, is that - unlike pretty much every other episode of the show - Pot Luck has nothing interesting to say. You come away from it wondering what the point was. And that rarely, if ever, happens with this show. Boo.

6. Chapter 33 - House Of Cards

Original Air Date: April 9, 2015 House of Cards' third season is generally thought to be its weakest to date; something to do with the fact that Frank Underwood is now the President of the United States and has reached his ultimate goal, perhaps? It served to kill a lot of the drama, that's for sure. That said, season three is still a relatively strong season, but there is one episode in particular that sticks out like a sore thumb - Chapter 33. It's almost certainly House of Cards' most ill-judged episode, something that becomes apparent as soon as you realise that it's going to mess around with the established structure of the show for no reason. That's to say, Chapter 33 opens with Frank and Claire renewing their vows, then jumps back in time to show how they got there, whilst also throwing in a random Doug Stamper storyline at the same time. It's a bit of a headache, to be honest, and an unnecessary embellishment. Trying to work out what's happening drains the episode of its watchability, and knowing that Frank and Claire make up before they do sucks out all the tension. All in all, it's the kind of episode you'd skip if you ever decided to go back and watch House of Cards for a second time - one of very few chapters that feels wholly inconsequential.

5. Of Course He's Dead - Two And A Half Men

Original Air Date: February 19, 2015 Sometimes a show gets to a point where even the people making it don't give a sh*t about it; they're just waiting for it to be over. That's the sense you get when you sit down to the final ever episode of Two and a Half Men, Of Course He's Dead, which is one of the most downright bizarre finales in the history of television. On one hand, it's the ballsiest episode of the show ever produced; it turns down the conventional "happy" ending you get with most long-running sitcoms of this kind, and - instead - goes for the overtly meta, making reference to Chuck Lorre's well-publicised feud with former star Charlie Sheen in the most unexpected way imaginable. Seriously: the show ends with "Charlie" (shot from behind with a double, because Charlie Sheen refused to come back for the finale) knocking on the front door, only for a grand piano to suddenly fall on his head. The camera then pulls back to reveal creator Chuck Lorre, who turns to the audience, says "Winning!" and is crushed by a second piano. It's f*cking nuts. Thing is, Two and a Half Men has never been one of those clever, meta-inclined shows in the sense that its final moment is. As such, Of Course He's Dead ultimately serves as a serious *f*ck you" to all the fans who actually watched the show for close to a decade, liked it, and genuinely wanted it to end in a fitting manner. Sorry, guys.

4. 4.1 & 4.2 - Luther

Original Air Date: 15/22 December, 2015 Luther's long-awaited fourth season consisted of just two episodes; they're so closely connected, however (they might as well be a single episode), that for the purposes of this article they're going to be considered as such. Luther, created by Neil Cross (who writes all the episodes, including these two), started off well in its first season, but ever since has pretty much gotten by on the strength of its lead actor alone. The plots have become increasingly mental and the show has struggled to be clever in the way that it thinks it is. The episodes that make up season four of this once likeable show are without question its worse, bringing new meaning to "jump the shark." Luther has always embraced a semi-heightened sense of reality, of course; the series has clung to a pulpy tone ever since it first aired back in 2009. And yet here things are ridiculous to the point of parody, as the titular hero - played admirably by Idris Elba - comes out of "retirement" to try to catch - wait for it - another serial killer. Sounds juicy, right? Unfortunately, these episodes mark Luther at its most trite and plodding. It takes forever to get to anything meaty. There's nothing to see here, ultimately, save for Elba's performance, because we're just going through the motions.

3. Unbent, Unbowed, Unbroken - Game Of Thrones

Original Air Date: May 17, 2015 A lot of people would probably argue that Game of Thrones' fifth season was its weakest to date; whilst there were some brilliantly memorable episodes scattered throughout, the season was also notable for its plodding pace, and the fact that lots of characters spent the sum of 10 whole episodes not really doing much - or getting anywhere. But the worst episode of the season (and the worst episode of the show to date) has to be the massively controversial Unbent, Unbowed, Unbroken, which featured a highly disputable scene in which Sansa Stark is raped by her new husband Ramsay Bolton. Many felt that the scene was wholly unnecessary and added nothing to the show, and it's a perspective that makes sense. Though Game of Thrones is a gruesome and brutal show, it doesn't usually leave such a sour taste in your mouth having watched it: Unbent, Unbowed, Unbroken did exactly that, though. It felt like the show taking things too far for no reason. Not to mention that the rest of this episode felt mostly inconsequential, regardless of the rape scene. Remember how disappointing that five-way Sand Snake fight was? Meh.

2. The Western Book Of The Dead - True Detective

Original Air Date: June 21, 2015 The entirety of True Detective's second season was totally ridiculous from start to finish, but the first episode of Nic Pizzolatto's difficult second album - The Western Book of the Dead - is truly the worst episode of the show to have aired. Expectations were high for season two, of course, given the success of the Matthew McConaughey/Woody Harrelson season a year previously. But from the very start of season two, things seemed wrong. Really wrong. Not only did The Western Book of the Dead mark True Detective as the most pretentious and self-conscious show on television, it was plainly boring from start to finish - not to mention it felt like a parody of "ooh, brooding." For an hour, audiences sat and tried to figure out what the hell was going on for the sum of this episode, as Colin Farrell, Rachel McAdams and Taylor Kitsch were drawn together after the murder of a high-ranking city planner. The whole episode was a blur of strange words and bizarre plot revelations - not to mention the bizarre, laughable lines. Things got a bit better later on in the series, but this was a seriously naff episode of TV.

1. The Man Who Came To Be Dinner - The Simpsons

Original Air Date: January 4, 2015 The Simpsons has been on a downward slope for a while now, but no episode to date has come to define the sheer ambivalence felt by the show's writing staff than The Man Who Came To Be Dinner - an episode that essentially works as a certified slap to the faces of all those fans who care about things like, oh, "continuity" and "canon." The Man Who Came To Be Dinner is the worst episode of The Simpsons ever not necessarily because it isn't funny, but because it marks the true moment at which Matt Groening's once great sitcom died a horrific death; it's the ultimate "jump the shark." What's so bad about it, you ask? Well, the plot sees The Simpsons going up to space after being abducted by Kang and Kodos. For real. This isn't a Halloween episode. It doesn't turn out that "it was all a dream," like that LEGO episode did. This actually happened in the same timeline as all the other, great Simpsons episodes. It's a real kick in the balls to know that - all these years later - nobody on The Simpsons writing staff is saying things like: "Wait, are we really doing this? Seriously?" Like this list? Agree or disagree with our choices for these episodes? Got any other episodes that you think should have made the final cut? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.