10 TV Shows That Almost Had Much Better Endings
Walter White goes full-on Rambo? Yes, please!
The pressure inherent to any TV show ending is huge. After all, audiences have spent years and years watching the story play out and, when it finally comes to wrapping things up, fans aren't quite as forgiving as they might be with a motion picture. Which after a mere two hours feel a lot less consequential than a lengthy TV saga.
You're looking at a vast and epic construct of more than 50 hours, in most cases, going on the notion that most beloved shows run for at least 5 series, comprising of anywhere between 10 to 22 episodes per season. No wonder people get so irked when said show fails to culminate in a way that feels justified.
Not that that's an easy task or anything; you have to tie everything up in a way that seems fitting and yet manages to be unpredictable at the same time; characters must live or die; couples must come together together or break apart; a few curveballs and some ambiguous notes are expected to be thrown in for good measure, too.
Yes, it's tough to find the "perfect" ending because everyone expects something entirely different. In the cases of the following 10 TV shows, though, some of which were deemed unsatisfying, the alternate endings proposed or revealed by the showrunners would have probably made a lot more people a whole lot happier...
10. The Happy Ending - How I Met Your Mother
The Ending: After 208 episodes, How I Met Your Mother finally gave fans the elusive moment that they had long been waiting for: the identity of the "mother" of the show's title - a woman named Tracy, played by Cristin Milioti.
Then, later on, the show dropped a bombshell in its super divisive ending: Tracy had actually been dead for six years, and the reason Ted had been relaying the entire story to this kids was as a sort test to see whether or not they'd accept Robin, his romantic interest for most of the show, as his new lover. Talk about a bum note.
The Alternative Ending: It could have been so much better! At least, going by the alternative ending that can be glimpsed on the DVD release of the show's final season.
In that far better ending, then, Tracy doesn't die from a terminal illness and Ted doesn't end up with Robin. Two changes that would have meant that things weren't so damn depressing, and that How I Met Your Mother wouldn't have ended on a romance that nobody really believed. The final shot would have consisted of Ted and Tracy, the train arriving, and the yellow umbrella floating down the road. Aw.
9. Not Guilty! - Seinfeld
The Ending: Seinfeld, one of the most popular sitcoms of all-time, is still known today for its controversial ending in which the main characters - Jerry, George, Elaine and Kramer - are put on trial and then sentenced to jail-time for all the bad things they've done across the years. Derided for their indifference, a judge tells them:
"I do not know how, or under what circumstances the four of you found each other, but your callous indifference and utter disregard for everything that is good and decent has rocked the very foundation upon which our society is built. I can think of nothing more fitting than for the four of you to spend a year removed from society so that you can contemplate the manner in which you have conducted yourselves. I know I will."
It was a downbeat ending if there ever was one - unexpected and bizarre in equal measure, but also kind of fitting given that the foursome acted like mostly terrible people for the sum of the show's eight seasons.
The Alternative Ending: Despite the fact that the ending to the show served as a sort of comeuppance, it rubbed a lot of people the wrong way. An alternative ending was shot that had the jury finding the foursome innocent, leaving their victims entirely enraged. This would certainly have been a lot funnier, and fitting in a different way.
8. The More Ambiguous Ross & Rachel - Friends
The Ending: After ten years of living across the hall from one another, Monica and Chandler decide to move away, and Ross and Rachel - the definitive will they/won't they? television couple - finally get back together. The gang go for one last coffee at Central Perk.
The Alternative Ending: Though admittedly a bit of a downer, the alternative ending - according to show creator David Crane, anyway - would have avoided the scene in which Ross and Rachel got back together in such a definitive way. Speaking on the ending, he said:
"Do you get Ross and Rachel back together? And at first we were like, 'That seems so expected.' Maybe not. Maybe we do some kind of vague hope for the future."
Yes, Crane genuinely toyed with the idea of not having Ross and Rachel get back together as a fully-fledged couple during the climax of the show, which seems a bit bleak for Friends, yes, but wouldn't that have been a whole lot more realistic, a tad braver, and more worthy of discussion? Probably.
7. Walter White Breaks Jesse Out Of Jail - Breaking Bad
The Ending: A wanted criminal, Walter White returns to his home turf and rescue his former partner, Jesse Pinkman, from the clutches of a gang who have taken him prisoner. Walter is fatally shot in the process (by his own rigged machine gun, no less) and dies in a meth lab. In his saving of Jesse, he's somewhat redeemed.
The Alternative Ending: Whilst the ending that the show opted for was dramatic in its own way, it wasn't very shocking. Nor did it follow through on the show's original premise, which was to turn Walter White into an unrelenting villain of the Tony Montana kind. Giving Walt an aspect of redemption seemed to betray his arc and felt like the writers were too scared to render him as a full on bad guy.
Talking about one of Breaking Bad's alternative endings, Vince Gilligan - the show's creator - said:
"We had an idea for the longest time that Walt was going to break into the downtown jail in Albuquerque and just shoot the sh*t out of the jail with this M60 machine gun and rescue Jesse. We kept asking ourselves, ‘Well, how bad is Walt going to be at the end here? Is he going to kill a bunch of upstanding, law-abiding jail guards?'"
It would have been a very different ending, of course, but one that would have at least followed through on its promise of Walt as a true baddie - the much discussed "Mr. Chips to Scarface" transformation in full.
6. Cohle & Hart Vanish Into The Unknown - True Detective
The Ending: After successfully hunting down a rampant serial killer, true detectives Cohle and Hart come together in a hospital to discuss the case as an injured Cohle - having felt a mysterious connection to his dead daughter during his final encounter with the killer - changes his cynical position and begins to have faith in the universe again.
The Alternative Ending: For those who thought that the ending to True Detective was too "happy" or "neat," how's this for an alternate? According to creator Nic Pizzolatto, he originally envisioned an ending of seriously crazy proportions:
"I even had an idea where something more mysterious happened to them, where they vanished into the unknown and Gilbough and Papania had to clean up the mess and nobody knows what happens to them. Or it could have gone full-blown supernatural.”
It certainly would have been very different and much more in tune with the weird nature of the series. Besides, everybody loves a truly "WTF?" ending.
5. Andy Becomes Mayor - Parks & Recreation
The Ending: The futures of the all the major characters are explored, the most notable of which sees either Leslie or Ben having ascended to what appears to be President of the United States status; Jerry becomes Mayor of Pawnee; Andy and April have a son and name him "Jack." Aw.
The Alternative Ending: The ending of Parks and Recreation was actually pretty damn perfect, but this little inclusion - something that had been intended for a long time - would have been the icing on the cake. In the show, then, it's Jerry who becomes Mayor, but the original plan was a lot different according to executive producer Mike Schur:
"That's what we thought. He was going to shine everyone's shoes and everyone who meets him loves him, and that's why we kept him doing that for a while. And one point in season two or season three, we were like, 'Andy's going to be the mayor someday!'"
Should have happened. Really should have happened.
4. The Fires Of Freedom - Nurse Jackie
The Ending: In the last scene of the show, Nurse Jackie Peyton collapses after overdosing from heroine she snorts up her nose, and it's left relatively unclear as to whether or not she dies. As she lies there and the camera zooms slowly towards her face, Zoey strokes her hair and offers up the very mysterious line: "You’re good, Jackie. You’re good.”
The Alternative Ending: Whilst the ending that was ultimately used was okay-ish, it also felt a little bit like a cross between the ending of The Sopranos and Breaking Bad - not very original, all things said and done.
The alternate ending sounded a lot better, though, and would have seen Jackie caught up in a hospital fire as she tries to rescue a heroine patient. She's consumed by the flames, at which point audiences would have assumed her to be dead, only for Jackie to squeeze herself out of a little window and escape - a metaphor for "freedom and birth," apparently.
3. Joey Chooses Dawson - Dawson's Creek
The Ending: Poor old Jen succumbs to a fatal heart condition and dies. Later, it's revealed that Joey Potter actually chose Pacey, whilst Dawson - successful and living in L.A. - finds out that Steven Spielberg is interested in working with him.
The Alternative Ending: Aw, what could have been, huh? That's to say, the original ending for the show would have seen Joey ending up with Dawson, the one person a lot of fans were convinced to be her soul mate. Kevin Williamson, the creator of the show, thought this too, but then - one day - he suddenly changed his mind. In his own words, he explains:
"Joey chooses Pacey because her childish love for Dawson has given way to her grown-up love for Pacey but Dawson still gets what he wants. Dawson gets what [he wanted when we] started the show, he gets to work with Spielberg. Dawson’s eternal wish, as a character, was delivered so Dawson found his happiness."
Nice as that is, a lot of people were pretty p*ssed off when they found out that Joey had gone with Pacey. And given that the show seemed to be heading towards Team Dawson the entire time, it makes you wonder whether or not - in retrospect - Joey actually picked the right man.
2. The Execution Table - Dexter
The Ending: Dexter opts to fake his own death in order to start a new life by driving his fishing boat into the eye of a hurricane. Later, he's revealed to be alive, but now sports a beard and flannel shirt and works for a lumber company, 'cause that's what exile does to a man, don't you know?
The Alternative Ending: Clyde Phillips' unused ending was far more creative and brilliantly meta, as he explains below:
"In the very last scene of the series, Dexter wakes up. And everybody is going to think, 'Oh, it was a dream', and then the camera pulls back and back and back and then we realise, 'No, it's not a dream.'
Dexter's opening his eyes and he's on the execution table at the Florida Penitentiary. They're just starting to administer the drugs and he looks out through the window to the observation gallery, and in the gallery are all the people that Dexter killed."
The ending the show opted for was pretty average, whilst this discarded ending would have been great in its playing around with audience expectations and riffing on the overused "It was all a dream!" cop-out. It's also interesting because it chooses to kill off Dexter and also gives him a moment before he dies to reflect on all those murders.
1. Carrie Chooses Friendship Over Men - Sex And The City
The Ending: After teasing their relationship across the entire span of the show, Mr. Big finally pursues Carrie Bradshaw all the way to Paris and asks her to marry him. Charlotte is given the go ahead to adopt a Chinese baby.
The Alternative Ending: The ending of the show that was ultimately used was a pretty predictable one, and fans of Sex and the City either loved it or hated it depending on how they felt about Mr. Big; he wasn't always the best guy around, after all.
When that ending was shot, though, the showrunners filmed some alternative endings, too, one of which would have had Carrie marrying the Russian, whilst another... well, it would have had Carrie sacking off men completely and reaffirming her love for her friends. At which point, Samantha says: "Men. F*ck 'em... f*ck all of them."
Given that the entire premise on the show hinged on Carrie's attempts to find and connect with a man, wouldn't that anti-man ending have been a great note to end things on? With Carrie just saying: "Screw it... friendship is more important than guys"? It certainly would have been a lot funnier, and kind of fitting in a weird, unexpected way.
Which endings would you have liked to see? Share your thoughts down in the comments.