10 TV Shows That Completely Wasted Great Characters
Abandoned love interests, derailed character arcs, and that poor deceased Mrs. Ted Mosby...
There’s nothing quite as frustrating as realizing that a show which is in need of a shake-up has introduced a great new character, only for them to end up totally underutilized in coming episodes. It’s not a rare occurrence: between writer’s rooms adding characters only to forget about them a week later and nervy executives demanding the addition of someone new only to then abandon them soon after, it’s inevitable that some much-loved figures end up written out of television history.
But for audiences hoping to see more of these characters and—reasonably enough—assuming they have been added to the line-up for a reason, this is a deeply frustrating move. A lot of shows feel the need to reinvigorate their cast list after a few stale seasons, and in many cases the addition of a new character can be the perfect compromise.
However, in the case of examples included in this list, it didn’t matter how good the characters were since they were never given a chance to have much impact on proceedings before being shuffled back out of the cast list...
10. How I Met Your Mother - The Mother
Anyone who ever considered themselves a fan of this
divisive hit sitcom from the 2000s must have been able to guess that the
long-unseen eponymous character of How I Met Your Mother would inevitably have
to make this list. For the uninitiated How I Met Your Mother followed much the
same formula as Friends a decade earlier and New Girl a decade later, following
a group of twenty to thirtysomething friends as they navigated their professional,
personal, and love lives, but with the twist that the show was presented as the
winding story of ostensible hero Ted telling his children how he met their
titular mother.
As such the elusive mother, eventually revealed to be Cristin Milioti’s Tracy, was merely hinted at for the first nine seasons of this show, without so much as a name revealed for season after season. Then came the final season and her first appearance—and shockingly Milioti managed to be charming, funny, and interesting enough to delight the show’s long-time fans.
All of which only made it more frustrating when the creators decided to off her in the series finale in order to let Ted and his ex Robin hook up, an outcome they’d planned since the first episode. The ending horrified fans who had grown to love Milioti despite how short her screen time was, and it’s proof that planning ahead doesn’t account for audiences deciding they prefer another character to the originally designated love interest.
9. Polly Cooper - Riverdale
Poor, poor Polly Cooper.
Sure, almost everyone in the titular town has had a time of it on Riverdale, given that the soapy structure of the show relies on even minor character facing more than their fair share of serial killers, organ harvesters, fake siblings, secret half siblings, and assorted other challenges we’re all familiar with. However none of the denizens of the eponymous suburb in this campy CW megahit have been quite as mistreated as Polly, and we’re not sure why the writers decided to give her the short shrift.
For one thing, Polly should have been central to the first season as the love interest of Jason Blossom, the boy whose murder the series revolved around. But already she was relegated to the background before being shuffled offscreen into a convent, as the show decided to take Hamlet’s advice “get thee to a nunnery” too literally.
Since then, the character has been side-lined out of the adventures enjoyed by her occasionally mad teen detective sister and scene-stealing former biker mum, played by Twin Peaks starlet Madchen Amick. With a serial killer dad to contend with as well, along with her recent decision to join a cult/ organ-harvesting ring, one would really think Polly was interesting enough to qualify for more than a few minutes screen time per season.
But alas it’s not to be, and fans of the show will
have to wait if they want to more from thus underrated gem.
8. Once Upon A Time - August
This one was deeply frustrating for fans of ABC’s long-running
“Twin Peaks, but with the denizens of Disneyland as its cast” mystery series.
Some arcs way outstayed their welcome on the show and, despite a stellar,
grounded turn from lead Jennifer Morrison and spectacularly hammy work from
villains Lana Parilla and Robert Carlyle, the series struggled with some
painfully flat characters like Ginifer Goodwin’s thankless role as Snow White.
This fact made it endlessly annoying when the show finally gave a decent love interest to its heroine in the form of charming con man August, a shadowy figure whose decision to help out our heroes in season two is thrown into question when flashbacks reveal tantalizing hints at his morally complex backstory.
That is, until the writers forgot about the character during a season break, leaving him sitting in a hotel room turning to a wooden puppet (it doesn’t make any more sense with context) for half a season and eventually abandoning his burgeoning romance subplot to get rid of the fan favourite. To quote Ryan Reynold’s cameo in Harold and Kumar, But—why?
7. True Blood - Franklin
It’s fair to say that True Blood struggled with its
characters, memorable as the mixed lot were, and on more than one occasion a figure
with a lot of potential cropped up only to be unceremoniously offed soon after.
Life was cheap and death was messy in HBO’s megahit, an R-rated answer to the
then-recent Twilight phenomenon starring Alexander Skarsgard, Anna Paquin, and
Bill Moyer.
Amongst the show’s underutilized line-up was short-lived soft-spoken vampire mentor Godric and a little seen vampire queen played by Evan Rachel Wood, but the worst offender is this regard must be demented vampire detective/ eventual staking victim Franklin.
All we saw of the insane private eye was a few scenes establishing him as a threat to our (then-)hero, smooth-talking southern vampire Bill Compton, and his brief liaison with the fiery Tara, but this was more than enough to prove Franklin had plenty of potential and would soon prove a formidable foe for the season.
That is, until he got a stake unceremoniously stuck through his chest after only a few scenes onscreen, leaving viewers wondering why the show bothered with the character in the first place.
6. Lost - Mr Eko
Lost’s unique structure and slowly unveiled central mystery
meant the show could often afford to slowly reveal the backstory of characters,
with plenty of minor figures introduced early and relegated to the background only
for their eventual significance to become clear later in the series. The show
used single episodes to spotlight specific characters, so the general understanding
amongst the fandom was that the more time a character’s motivation and previous
life were afforded onscreen, the more vital they would prove to the overall
narrative.
This theory was thrown off the island after the unheralded demise of Mr. Eko, though, an enigmatic fan favourite who viewers had assumed would prove pivotal to the show’s mystery. Yes, what little we understood of Mr. Eko seemed likely to shed some eventual light on the island’s origins and it appeared the character might have been behind some of the strangeness involved in the crash—only for him to be offed by the smoke monster and prove that no, there’s no grand overarching scheme tying all of this together.
Come to think of it maybe we deserve Mr. Eko some thanks, given he was the first death to warn us Lost was going nowhere fast.
5. The Simpsons - Herb Powell
The Simpsons is one television’s crowning achievements,
a wildly original, inventive, silly, strange, satirical, slapstick, warm-hearted,
relentless comedy which proves the endless potential which the medium holds
when used right. That said, the show’s fast and loose approach to canon also ensured
it is infamous for wasting incredible characters here and there. The likes of Dustin
Hoffman’s substitute teacher Mr Bergstrom and Michelle Pfeiffer’s seductive Mindy
Simmons are criminally underutilized, most likely due to the fame of their actors
and their inevitable unavailability.
But despite this reasonable limitation, there’s no getting around the fact that the frequent money woes faced by the Simpsons could reasonably be solved in most earlier episodes via the help of Homer’s Danny DeVito-voiced brother Herb Powell. And yes, a later season did address this with a throwaway line noting that Herb went broke again, but there’s no getting past the fact that it barely occurs to our hero Homer to catch up with his brother in any situation during the show’s thirty year run, an element which is more than a minor oversight even for a show as intentionally off-kilter as America’s favourite cartoon family.
4. Scrubs - Julie
Look, we could fill this entire list with the “love interest
of the week” characters featured throughout most sitcoms since Diane’s first
conquest darkened the door of Sam’s bar. After all, one-joke short-lived love
interests are a staple of sitcoms, and they often vanish as soon as they appear,
taking their single use character trait with them as they do. But we’re trying
to limit ourselves to the most egregiously wasted characters here, so gone are
the many forgettable faces dated by the denizens of Friends and Seinfeld.
On first glance, Mandy Moore’s klutzy-but-sweet Julie, dated by our nominal hero JD during a later season of Scrubs, fits the “one note girlfriend” archetype. She’s clumsy! And little else. But soon JD is buying a plot of land with her, and the chemistry between then-real-life sweethearts Moore and JD actor Zach Braff is obvious onscreen.
There’s just one problem.
Julie never becomes more than a two-episode stop on the way to JD inevitably ending up with Elliot, wasting the chemistry between the two and making the land-purchasing a strange and pointless fugazi of a subplot.
3. Community - Pierce Hawthorne
This one is sure to be controversial, primarily because
criticizing anything by Dan Harmon still prompts awed horror from some corners
of the internet despite four seasons (and counting) of Rick and Morty featuring
less character development than most individual episodes of competitor Bojack Horseman.
But luckily unlike the sci-fi comedy series, here we’re not singling out Harmon’s
obvious self-insert for critique.
No, it’s the villainous baby boomer Pierce, a late career role for former Caddyshack star Chevy Chase, which Community managed to fumble. The character began as a tasteless but ultimately well-meaning relic, only for the actor’s clashes with the creator to result in Pierce becoming more cruel, racist, and irredeemable before being offed offscreen. Particularly on a show which often became preachy in its willingness to forgive the flaws on the intolerant Shirley and self-centred Jeff, the side-lining of Pierce reeks of wasted opportunity, with a potentially complex and funny character lost to behind-the-scenes in-fighting.
2. Gilmore Girls - Alex Lesman
Yes, alright, so there are some more obvious
characters we could choose from Stars Hollow who also earned a spot of their
own on this list—Prep school bad boy Tristan was wildly underutilized, for one
thing, not to mention the short-lived but much-loved Max Medina. We’re singling
out Alex Lesman, though, because of the character’s singularly strange arc—or lack
thereof.
Generally speaking, Lorelei’s love interests acted as foils to Lauren Graham’s titular matriarch. The likes of the irascible Jason, or the more mature Max, or even aggressively boring Jon Hamm in that one episode, were used to highlight elements of Lorelei which she needed to work on or embrace, as illustrated by her incompatibility with them.
Then there’s Alex. Agreeable, fun, and otherwise inoffensive, Alex appears at a hotelier’s convention and briefly chats to Lorelei, eventually heading on a double date with her, his bawdy friend, and Sookie. The date is a success for Lorelei and Max, and the pair hit it off.
The end.
Or so it seems, since the show never mentions him again—no offscreen break up, no one line “moved to Europe”, nothing. Alex’s level-headed good humour balanced Lorelei’s intense flightiness well, and it’s a shame he vanished to the graveyard for offscreen love interests at some stage between episodes.
1. New Girl - Daisy
Another appearance for the much-maligned weekly sitcom
love interest, doomed to appear for a mere episode or two before being
forgotten for good by everyone onscreen. But damn if this one didn’t sting a
little more than most, and it’s for more than one reason.
New Girl never really worked out what to do about resident weirdo Winston’s love life for its first few seasons, flirting with giving the loveable oddball girlfriends before deciding he was too strange for such a conventional fate. Besides, the show had bigger fish to fry, given the fact that by the show’s second season the chemistry between leads Jake Johnson and Zooey Deschanel was at its most explosive.
However in “Cooler”, the pivotal instalment wherein Jess and Nick’s on-and-off flirtations finally manifested in a kiss, Winston was paired with Brenda Song’s Diasy, a kooky fun-loving party girl perfect for his strange and eccentric vibe.
The couple gelled, their contributions elevated an already-great episode to classic status, and for her efforts Daisy got—dumped two episodes later when she turned out to be a two-timing schemer. Nice, New Girl. Sure, we’re glad Nasim Pedrad got to give Winston’s eventual love interest some real character, but what did Daisy’s barely-glimpsed effervescent self do to deserve being done this dirty?