10 TV Shows That Should’ve Been Awesome (But Utterly Failed)

Rsz 1rsz Firefly1 TV success is a fickle thing. There are shows which are fantastic from the outset that, for reasons unknown, get cancelled almost immediately€“ shows that had incredible potential but didn't work in practice, or shows that promised the world, but fell flat on their face. On this list there are programmes should've gone the extra mile, that should've made it in the TV Hall of Fame: dramas that should've been on a level with The Wire, superior-to-Friends sitcoms, or Joss Whedon shows that could've been as big as Buffy. There are plenty of shows on this list that got their dues further down the line, but their initial rejection, non-renewal, and ultimate failure relegates them to "should've been awesome" status. Others simply had potential that they never lived up to. One of them was even a roaring success that, after a long hiatus, released a long-anticipated new season that was met with a chorus of "you have made a terrible mistake". (Ten points if you can guess which one).

10. Freaks And Geeks

Rsz Freaks Geeks 640 908873 No "should've-been-incredibly-successful but wasn't" list is complete without a nod to Judd Apatow's cult comedy Freaks and Geeks. Set in the 1980s, it centred on the lives of two very different siblings, "freak" Linda Cardellini, and "geek" (the incredibly adorable) John Francis Daley. The show follows both of these characters in their high-school subsets with an empathy and a realism that was largely without affectation. With the help of the supporting cast (James Franco, Seth Rogan, Jason Segal, need I say more?) Apatow managed to craft a sensitive but hilarious coming-of-age comedy. Whilst Freaks and Geeks circled dangerously close to after-school-special territory with storylines preaching acceptance of oneself and others where even the worst bullies had a back-story, it was consistently and outstandingly entertaining. Despite being nominated for various awards, including three Emmys, Freaks and Geeks was cancelled even before all the prepared episodes had been aired. These were then only shared due to a strong fan-led campaign, demonstrating the dedicated following that the show had even before cancellation.

9. Undeclared

Rsz 1rsz Undeclared The Complete Series 20050816075413676 Undeclared is Freaks and Geeks' little brother (as well as theoretical follow-up) in terms of shows that should have been incredibly popular but weren't, and gaining its dues when it was too late. It was a Judd Apatow brainchild with his motley crew of usual castees, and works in the same way. Awkward, hilarious, and filled with raw comedy talent, Undeclared could have been The College Sitcom as it acutely identifies the horrible fears and terrible situations that occur on a daily basis in the transition of school to college. For some reason, Fox cancelled Undeclared mid-season despite the show's strong plot and witty dialogue matching Apatow's most successful films. The best that can be said is that at least there are 17 golden episodes to still enjoy, and the world that Apatow created is clear and just as enjoyable in the films he went onto make.

8. Whites

Rsz 1rsz 81illhe6col Sl1500 Whites is a show that few people seem to have even heard of, despite the big British comedy names showcased. Alan Davies (QI, Jonathan Creek), Darren Boyd (Smack the Pony, Green Wing), and Katherine Parkinson (The IT Crowd) should have made for a golden opportunity for British-stamped awkward hilarity - and it worked. Whites was intelligent yet absurd, with the entire cast (including a wealth of brilliant side characters) working perfectly to create what should have been a prolific British sitcom. Despite airing on BBC2 there seemed to be very little excitement or proper marketing for Whites, quite unlike debuts of similar shows such as Green Wing. Due to budget cuts Whites was cancelled after one season of six episodes to the dismay of many, and a campaign to "Bring Back Whites!" failed. Now the only place to find Whites is in the vaults of Netflix, last shown on the BBC in late 2012.

7. Firefly

Rsz 1rsz Firefly1 Firefly will always have a place in the hearts of many as a show that was unfairly torn from audiences by the evil Fox Network. There is very little to say about Firefly that isn't already known €“ most people probably clicked on this hoping Firefly was on it. For those not in the loop, Firefly was a Joss Whedon project labeled as a "space Western" following a group of outcasts from the law in a dystopian future as they take freelance jobs in mostly-illegal transportation of goods and people. Firefly is the ultimate example of how a dedicated (read: somewhat obsessive) fandom can turn an utter failure into a resounding triumph. At the time that is exactly what Firefly was: a failure. Cancelled mid-season after only eleven episodes, Firefly was just a kooky sci-fi show that had no discernable audience €“ aside, of course, from the near 5 million viewers per episode. Firefly also benefited from a huge period of discovery by people who hadn't watched it before its cancellation, and what seemed like a tragic failure sputtered and shuddered back to life. First came the film Serenity, and since then several Serenity comics have been set in the world of Firefly. If Firefly utterly failed commercially as a TV show, it has succeeded outrageously as a story.

6. Party Down

Rsz 1rsz Party Down Best Jokes Photo Gifs Gallery Cover Party Down was an adorable comedy following the lives of catering staff looking to make it big in Hollywood. Sassy, sarcastic, and very very silly, Party Down was relatable and often bittersweet in its depiction of having to work a job you hate to pursue your dreams. Not only that, but it featured the comedy stylings of Jane Lynch (Glee), Adam Scott (Parks & Recreation), Megan Mullally (Will & Grace), Martin Starr (Freaks & Geeks) and Lizzy Caplan (New Girl). Regrettably, Party Down's huge asset of its fantastic cast was ultimately what let it down. They lost Jane Lynch to Glee and Adam Scott to Parks & Recreation, meaning that Party Down never got its chance to go too close to the sun. It received great reviews, but a mix of cast loss and low ratings meant that it was cancelled after two excellent seasons.

5. Hex

Rsz 1rsz Hex Wall Hex 574662 1024 768 When Hex first came out it was hailed "The British Buffy". With its begrudging blonde heroine (for the first season, at least) and lesbian best friend working against supernatural crime, Hex also brought more sex appeal, sarcasm, and unflinching teenage angst than its only possible comparison. The show was prepared to go hard rather than go home, and was often touching, intelligent, and downright hilarious. Not only that, but it's cast was faultless €“ hands up if you like Michael Fassbender. Hands up if you like him playing a sexy evil angel who only wears suits. Unfortunately it suffered from glaring plot holes and ridiculous plot tangents (why, WHY would you shag the self-professed bad guy who murdered your best friend and drove your mother into a mental institution?) Season 2, whilst having a very strong beginning, turned into a confusing and poorly-thought-out farce more than anything else, leading to it's close on a huge cliffhanger which still goes unresolved.

4. Tru Calling

Rsz 1rsz 110213 211914 Trupct20callingpct20fotopct20erbij Riding the wave of success from her stint as Faith in Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Eliza Dushku's next offering Tru Calling should have been a runaway success. The premise was unusual and promising €“ a morgue worker discovers that she can speak to dead people, and then goes back in time to the day before and must save them from an untimely demise. It may not be perfect but it's no worse than, say, Ghost Whisperer, and surely Eliza Dushku in a tank top is pretty certain to save most things? Alas, this was not the case. The first few episodes were enjoyable enough, but then the show fell into a formulaic and ultimately uninteresting gutter where the writer's best efforts for a backstory couldn't pull it free. It does seem like there was potential for the plot to come, if what was hinted at in one of the writers' Live Journal were to come true. Yet clearly this was not enough, and Tru Calling was abruptly cancelled mid-season.

3. Heading Out

Rsz Heading Out Heading Out was the brainchild of Sue Perkins, who has rocketed into being a British national treasure thanks to her presence on The Great British Bake-Off. Adverts suggested that it would essentially be the lesbian Miranda, another British treasure that has been wildly successful in the UK at least. Perkins plays a 40-year-old gay vet who is still not 'out' to her parents, and follows the efforts of her friends giving her an ultimatum to tell her parents the truth, or to have it done for her. This idea was definitely novel - how many mainstream comedy shows follow a protagonist's woes coming out? - and Perkin's influence should have done it proud. However the show itself was too awkward, too clunky, and the gags were often weak. There was definite potential, but that potential seemed to have nowhere to go. Due to low ratings the sitcom did not receive a second series, although Perkins has said that it was intended to be a six-part sitcom rather than anything longer lasting.

2. Dollhouse

Rsz 1rsz Dollhouse Tv Series Miranda Penn 1 Dollhouse is another Joss Whedon epic that should have been. Set in a world where there are institutions renting people (known as Actives) who can be endowed with particular sets of skills, Dollhouse follows an Active played by Eliza Dushku on the discovery of her own self-awareness. On the face of it, Dollhouse appeared to be an exciting, innovative, and interesting programme. The inclusion of Eliza Dushku on another Joss Whedon project inadvertently allowed for comparisons to Buffy the Vampire Slayer, in which Dushku was a rollercoaster ride of TV enjoyment. Unfortunately for Dushku, Dollhouse was fated to run a similar path to Tru Calling. Attracting mixed reviews, Dollhouse seemed to promise much more than it delivered. A viral campaign in 2009 got many Whedon-ites prepared for an adventure unlike anything that had ever been seen, and the pilot episode was generally received well as a thought-provoking and accessible opener. The remainder of the series, however, did not live up to expectation and was cancelled after low ratings.

1. Arrested Development (Season 4)

Rsz 1rsz Ads4 When I say Arrested Development, Lord knows I don't mean the series in it's entirety. Everyone and their elbow knows the joy that Seasons 1-3 brought to the masses, and the way it impacted on American comedy. No, I mean the fateful season 4 that debuted earlier this year. The long-awaited Season 4 was bound to experience myriad negative reviews if just because of the prolific nature of what came before it, and the period of time over which fans built their expectations and excitement. Sadly the show's production seemed wracked with problems as, due to many of the actor's schedules, many of them filmed their parts separately. A large part of Arrested Development's humour relies on the awkward tensions between the characters, so it would be necessary to have them in the same room at the same time. It's easy to tell that the actors weren't bouncing this off each other like the audience is used to, and so the comedy definitely suffered. Season 4 was by no means awful in and of itself, but as a continuation of the legend that was, Arrested Development Season 4 was a failure.

Contributor
Contributor

Fan of Taylor Swift and the Dead Kennedys (a duet I can only dream of). I like dystopias, slasher films, and video games that make me feel things.