10 TV Shows That Went From Great To Terrible SO FAST
They only needed one bad season (or one awful episode) to undo all their good work...
Some shows really do drag their feet when it comes time for their decline.
Not every series can stick the landing and remain as gripping as ever throughout their final instalments, sure. But sometimes a show really does take its sweet time letting viewers down (cough The Simpsons cough).
It’s always disheartening when this occurs as longtime fans of the show can often convince themselves, like Homer with his suckling pig, that it’s still good despite the show’s best days being long gone. That’s why it’s sometimes better for a show to simply fall apart fast.
At least, that seems to be the mindset behind the show runners of the series that are listed here
In cases likes these, shows go from unmissable to unwatchable in a few episodes, a few scenes, or even one misjudged moment.
These are the shows which were derailed in an instant and never reclaimed their once impressive status amongst critics and viewers alike after the fact. Some struggled on for many more seasons, some ended almost the moments fans jumped ship, but all ten of these shows went from great to terrible right quick.
10. True Blood
In 2008 vampires were having a cultural moment and American Beauty scribe Alan
Ball was ready for it. Adapting the cult novels by Charlaine Harris, the
screenwriter created HBO’s bloody, campy hit True Blood as a direct riposte to
Twilight’s anodyne teen romance.
If The Vampire Diaries was “Twilight, but the vampires f***”, then True Blood was “Twilight, but the vampires f*** without the censorial asterisks”. Sweaty, gory, and genuinely racy, the show’s hot and heavy action was aided by once in a lifetime chemistry between real life sweethearts Anna Paquin and Stephen Moyer as well as a star making supporting turn from Alexander Sarsgaard.
What could go wrong?
Well, vampires viewers could handle. Serial killers? Sure. Mind readers? Alright...
Werewolves? Maybe...
Shapeshifters? Just about....
But f***ing faeries?!
The reveal of Sookie’e true nature really shouldn’t have come about after a season break when fans were unsure whether to stick with the series. Too absurd and fanciful even for this campy show, this twist drove viewers away and the show never regained them before its flat, disappointing finale.
9. 13 Reasons Why
Some ideas simply don’t need a second season.
Or a third, or a fourth, for that matter.
Released in 2017, 13 Reasons Why was a long awaited adaptation of the young adult novel of the same name. Dealing with heavy themes of sexual assault, drug abuse, and teen suicide, the show was met with critical acclaim upon release.
The central pairing of Katherine Waterson and Dylan Minette impressed in difficult roles, but there wasn’t a weak link in the cast. Potentially melodramatic material was handled well and the show’s finale was a moving, ambiguous success.
Then came season two, eager to outdo its predecessor.
This edgy drama tipped over into morbid absurdity with its overstuffed second season, which had the admirable aim of addressing serious issues but all the subtlety and focus of machine gun fire.
Want a moving depiction of realistic teen drug use? Too bad, here’s some insanely explicit male sexual abuse. Want to maybe realistically depict the aftermath of such a traumatic scene? Too bad, here’s a school shooter bringing an arsenal of weapons to prom.
8. The Office
It's fair to say that an American Office should never have worked, let alone scaled the incredible heights the show did reach.
Anchored by an extraordinary
ensemble cast and a career best turn from star Steve Carrell, the American
adaptation of the dark U.K. comedy turned the mockumentary into a less
merciless and warmer, though no less cringeworthy, workplace sitcom.
Boasting writing from the likes of Mindy Kaling and BJ Novak, the show managed to balance sharp wit and a warm heart. The series had an affinity for its characters but never shied away from their faults and at its core was Carrell’s kindhearted sadsack, a tragicomic antihero for the ages.
Then he left and it took all of one episode for the show to fall apart.
Michael Scott's exit was the beginning of this show's very swift fall from the top, as the series never recovered from losing its star. The show cycled through Will Ferrell (miscast), James Spader (entirely wrongheaded), and Catherine Tate (the best of a bad bunch) as Carrell’s replacement before settling on Ed Helms. By then, though, an agonising season had already transpired and the show’s messy, mean spirited tone was unrecognisable.
Thank god for that finale.
7. Black Mirror
Beginning in 2011 with the audacious The National Anthem, perpetually peeved critic/walking embodiment of Generation X Charlie Brooker had a hit instantly with Black Mirror, which once seemed like the natural successor to Rod Serling’s iconic Twilight Zone.
The show was never perfect, but gripping stand out instalments like The Entire History of You and White Bear offered dark and troubling ruminations on humanity’s irresponsible treatment of technological advances.
Then the show moved to Netflix.
And stayed great!
The series may have gained a bigger budget but remained brutally bleak, meaning rare poignant instalments such as the superb San Junipero shone all the brighter.
Then came the fifth season.
The once edgy and intense sci-fi series became self parody with this season, which included a grunge Miley Cyrus Disney Channel movie and a flat, uninspired video game romance that ripped off the show’s own finer hours.
Without anything new or interesting to say, the show retreated into the “isn’t modern music rubbish? what if you could hook up in video games?” comfort zones of stunted sci-fiwriters, and became an embarrassing shadow of its former self.
6. Riverdale
When the premise of Riverdale was announced the show was met with disbelieving laughter. A dark and edgy murder mystery reboot of... Archie Comics?
As The Simpsons once put in, "duh, stay out of Riverdale".
But despite an inane conceit, this teen hit soon won over disbelievers with its 2017 debut. The show’s trick was to never attempt anything like self seriousness, a goal aided by two generations of game teen stars including series standout Madeleine Petsch, Scream’s Skeet Ulrich, Twin Peak’s Madchen Amick, and the late great Luke Perry.
However since the show began at the height of absurdity with its over-the-top first season, there wasn’t a lot further for it to go without slipping into stupidity. The shift from murder mystery to slasher kept the first half of the second season afloat, but a bizarre Dungeons and Dragons parodying subplot was starting to reveal the cracks.
And so the latter half of the second season's slide into fast-paced self parody was almost inevitable, with the show’s likeable cast not enough to save it from cartoony excess that even seasoned teen soap fans couldn’t enjoy.
And with a hot cast and funny one liners, that’s about as forgiving a target audience as a show can hope for.
5. Glee
Remember Glee?
Not just the show itself, which was spikier than most recall but also clumsily sentimental in a way which never quite gelled. No, remember Glee the full blown phenomenon?
Hard as it may be to believe, there was a brief era during Glee’s first and second season when the show was a bonafide mega hit.
What began as a dark but ultimately kind hearted satire of small town America and its teen outcasts became a world tour, more hit songs than almost any actual musical artist in history, a Britney Spears cameo, an appearance on The Simpsons...
And then it all fell apart overnight.
Ryan Murphy's mega hit ruled the world for a moment thanks to the first season’s punchy wit and unexpected poignancy. But it all came crashing down with the disastrous second season.
Burdened with massive expectations, the writers immediately made it clear they couldn’t handle the pressure. Countless themed episodes, clumsily mishandled “messages”, and far too much pouty Will Schuester ensured that this show plummeted from popularity as fast as it rose. Within a few episodes of the show‘s season two premiere, it was clear that Glee’s time in the spotlight had passed.
4. The Mindy Project
As the mega hit sitcom The Office was closing its doors, the show’s breakout
writer Mindy Kaling was busy working on a series of her own.
A charming fusion of workplace sitcom and Nancy Meyers style slow burn rom com, The Mindy Project debuted to solid reviews and gradually grew more popular over its first three seasons. The series weathered a long term will-they-won't-they romance with skill, relying on a superb supporting cast when the central romance was sidelined...
Only to screw up its potential success with a disastrous string of fifth season episodes.
By turning the main character's love interest into an abusive misogynist late in the series, the show clumsily attempted to graft heavy handed social commentary into its story by rewriting the personalities of its pre-existing, and widely beloved, central characters.
Sure, the show later ret-conned Danny’s complete personality change and returned him to gruff but sensitive heroism by the series finale. But by then it was, as Jojo once said, too little too late.
3. Scream
Not unlike fellow teen hit Glee, MTV slasher series Scream had a fun, pacy first series.
Sure, it couldn’t hold a candle to the quick wit, twisty mystery, and unparalleled suspense of its movie inspiration. But for viewers willing to ignore its inspiration (which the show itself was happy to do), Scream was solid and occasionally scary teen thriller which boasted an effective killer reveal.
Did the show over rely on its talented cast? Sure, but standouts like Amadeus Serafini, Bex Taylor-Klaus, and Tom Maden easily kept the series afloat.
... Only for their hard work to be immediately undone by a slow, predictable second instalment which was doomed from its second episode onwards. That interminably slow instalment saw the action grind to a halt, only to suddenly off a fan favourite with no warning or compelling motive.
With a convoluted yet predictable plot, embarrassing production values, and a quickly vanishing cast, this one deserved to die long before its second season ended.
2. Scream Queens
Oh mega producer Ryan Murphy, will you ever learn?
The Nip/Tuck creator and TV legend is infamous for providing brilliant opening salvos, over complicating his second acts with fan service and knotty sub plots, and eventually breaking fans hearts with a disappointing closer.
Don’t take Glee’s word for it, though—just look at critical reactions to American Horror Story’s Cult, Coven, and Hotel, not to mention the short lived horror comedy Scream Queens.
After a funny, twisty first outing, fans were glad to see this slasher series return for a second season in 2016.
But this time around the show had already killed off a lot of famous faces and superb scene stealers from the first season's cast, such as Ariana Grande, Nasim Pedrad, and Nick Jonas. Meanwhile, the lack of a focused whodunit mystery for the second season soon doomed the series to lackadaisical episodic instalments whose individual plots led nowhere and added up to nothing.
Season one had its moments of cringeworthy fan service, but this one was dead from season two episode one’s opening moments onward.
1. Sherlock
Remember when the Stephen Moffat series Sherlock started and it was a cool, edgy reboot of the classic detective fiction novels which left Guy Ritchie's films feeling stale and tired in comparison?
If not, it's probably because the show's decline has undone any fond memories you have of the early years.
But hard as it may be to believe, there was a time when the funny, fast paced, tongue in cheek Sherlock Holmes reboot had won over a huge fandom, television critics, and mainstream audiences alike. With a career defining turn from unpronounceable name Benedict Cumberbatch, the show benefited from witty scripts, plenty of twists, and a superb cast who reinvented old favourites from Irene Adler to Moriarty.
Then along came Mary, and out the window went the show’s credibility, likability, and popularity.
When the hitherto lovely if underdeveloped love interest was revealed to be not a nurse but an assassin, the show tilted into ludicrous melodrama and never recovered.
The goofy twist cost the show the tension which made even its most over-the-top plots excusable, whilst the shoddy writing underscored the issue with poorly developed female characters which plagued the show since its inception.
Watch Next
The IMPOSSIBLE Sherlock Quiz