10 TV Shows That Worked Despite Their Absurd Premise

How did Big Mouth ever get the green light at Netflix?

Black Mirror
Channel 4

The world of television is incredibly saturated in the modern day. There are literally countless platforms through which TV shows come, and in all shapes and sizes, from the usual terrestrial channels through to the unending potential of streaming thanks to the likes of Netflix, Amazon, and Disney.

With so much going on, it has become tougher and tougher for a TV show to stand out from the rest of the pack. One of the most reliable ways to differentiate is with, for lack of a better term, a batsh*t crazy premise that is so absurd no one else in the world could have thought of it first.

This guarantees a uniqueness to a TV show, and at the very least gives it a talking point. It gets noticed. Now, these kinds of shows have failed in the past, whether the premise was just a little too weird or for any other reason, but every now and then the balance is struck just perfectly between absurd yet still accessible and marketable.

On paper, none of the following TV shows should have worked, or at least grown to be as big as they have done. Yet, somehow they appealed to the masses in a way that no one but the minds that created the shows could have ever imagined. From comedies, to animated shows, detective shows and beyond, these were just crazy enough to work.

10. WandaVision

WandaVision Scarlet Witch
Disney

Ever since Phase Three concluded with Spider-Man: Far From Home, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has played around with a wider variety of genre and style. Shang-Chi was something of a martial arts movie, Doctor Strange in the Mutliverse of Madness dabbled in horror, and Loki was something completely and utterly unique.

The weirdest MCU project by far however, has been WandaVision. As something of a superhero/action movie crossed with a TV sitcom, the series cycled through each different decades with each episode, while devastatingly exploring loss and grief. As a result, there is nothing like the MCU’s first foray into Disney+ anywhere else on television.

This may not have been such a tough spot for the series had Phase Four eased in with a far more familiar feel, as it was originally planned to with Black Widow and The Falcon and the Winter Soldier. However, a worldwide pandemic and several reshuffles later, the weirdness that was WandaVision was what welcomed audiences back to the world of MCU content after 18 long months.

This was risky, as the first two episodes being in full black and white, and the sheer bizarre nature of the show in general, could have easily lost audiences. However, it seems that everyone bought into the unique premise from the off, and to this day it is still arguably the strongest series the franchise has put out on the streaming platform.


9. Squid Game

Squid Game
Netflix

The horror genre is simply filled with clever, inventive, and often ironic ways of killing people. These days just about everything has already been done before, and so to bring something truly unique to the table often requires getting really absurd. This is how Squid Game rose to such prominence in 2021.

Absolutely no one could have predicted the cultural phenomenon the show would go on to become, and how it would wipe the floor with its competition for the top spot at Netflix, but it all starts with the story.

456 complete strangers competed against each other in a series of sick and twisted games until there was just one winner left, receiving an inordinate amount of money, yet traumatised to the point of wondering if it was even worth it.

A similar premise has been used previously, like in Would You Rather, where strangers were put through horrible ordeals for a cash prize at the end. However, Squid Game making the tasks a series of children’s playgrounds games upped the creep factor, and made the whole thing all the more uncomfortable.


8. BoJack Horseman

BoJack Horseman The Showstopper
Netflix

There have been some truly special TV shows to come from Netflix over the last few years, but few are on the same level as BoJack Horseman. While the animated genre is becoming increasingly saturated, this Netflix original still stands out from the rest.

The town of Hollywoo (formerly Hollywood before BoJack stole the D from the legendary sign), is populated by a mix of both humans and anthropomorphic animals. From BoJack the horse and Mr. Peanutbutter the dog, to Woodchuck Coodchuck-Berkowitz and many more, this makes for a completely unique setting.

Things get weirder still, as you wouldn’t expect an animated show about a humanised bipedal talking horse to be as heavy hitting as it was. Tackling real issues without shying away from the gritty reality of things like mental illness, drug and alcohol abuse, and crippling loneliness, BoJack Horseman was one of the most real shows out there.

And yet, the other side of that coin was Todd’s completely off the wall, ridiculous misadventures and hijinks. Neither of these aspects of the show should work on their own, and yet they were somehow brought together to balance each other out and make one of the most outstanding TV series in recent memory.


7. Naked Attraction

Naked Attraction
Channel 4

One of the most bizarre genres of TV is that of reality. There are apparently no limits to the trashy depths TV creators will go to to get ratings, and as long as they keep doing it, it would seem that people will keep watching.

As these shows gets stranger and (to many) harder to watch, there are always more people tuning in. It’s a vicious cycle that has ultimately resulted in Naked Attraction, a reality dating show with one of the worst premises in the long, sad history of reality dating shows.

There have been series where people choose their dates based on personality alone, fashion sense, or even how good they are at cooking. But how about a show where a date is chosen based on absolutely nothing but what they look like naked? This is something that has somehow garnered huge popularity in the UK.

Starting with five naked options, first their bottom halves are shown and scrutinised in the most cringe-inducing way. Then the top half. Finally the head is revealed, so their naked body can be judged and compared against others. It is nothing short of trashy, horrifying, and the worst kind of undignified.


6. The Good Place

The Good Place Kristen Bell
NBC

It’s a question that has plagued the human race forever, and will continue to do so until the end of time. What happens to us when we die? The Good Place had its own vision, building from the idea that there is a good place (Heaven), and a bad place (Hell, obviously).

When Eleanor died after living a not-so-virtuous life as a saleswoman, she was seemingly sent to the good place as a case of mistaken identity, with the first season of the show following her attempts to conceal who she really was.

There are a lot of huge twists that have rocked TV shows, but the revelation that Eleanor, Chidi, Tahani, and Jason had actually been in the bad place all along, and that Michael had been a demon all along, was huge! Everything shifted, and all of a sudden the entire premise of the show changed.

Instead of trying to keep herself in the good place, Eleanor now tried to get herself out of the bad place before finally accepting that it was time to move onto a whole new level of afterlife.


5. Twin Peaks

Twin Peaks Cooper Bob
ABC

There is nothing particularly different or groundbreaking about a detective story or a murder mystery on its most basic level. In fact, this is one of the most overused premises for a TV show ever, but Twin Peaks took the idea and turned it into arguably the strangest series of all time.

Kyle MacLachlan’s Dale Cooper was an incredibly likeable detective whose love for coffee was legendary, and in the small town of Twin Peaks he discovered that there was so much more going on than one young girl being killed. Even that doesn’t do justice to the sheer weirdness of the show.

There was a ‘waiting room’ that connected to another dimension where people spoke backwards and nothing made sense, more creepy cherry pie than you know what to do with, and an ending that saw the main character with a demented look in his eye screaming and hysterically laughing into a mirror.

In fact, the conclusion of the show’s first run made absolutely so little sense that an entirely new season was created to try and explain it 26 years later. However, this simply raised more questions than answers.


4. Black Mirror

Black Mirror Pig
Netflix

Possibly more so than ever over recent years, TV shows have found success in pointing the finger and the camera at the downfall and decay of society. However, none have done so in such a unique and dark way as Black Mirror.

The tone was set from the very first episode in which the Prime Minister of the UK is forced to have sex with a pig on live TV for the safe return of a hostage, only for the poor girl to have been released before the act even happened.

From here, each episode looked at a different version of the world, usually changed by some form of technology that drastically altered society, though of course with dark and unforeseen ramifications. Each is a new and dark spin on how society is growing and evolving, and the bleak future that may be coming, albeit somewhat exaggerated (hopefully).

Over its 22 episodes, not to mention the interactive Netflix movie Bandersnatch, Black Mirror managed to bring in a ridiculous amount of stars, from Daniel Kaluuya to Hayley Atwell, Bryce Dallas Howard, and Jon Hamm. From the stories to the ever-changing cast, there are no other shows quite like the anthology that is Black Mirror.


3. Mr. Bean

Mr Bean
ITV

When you think of classic characters in the realms of British comedy, you think about the wit and charm of the likes of Basil Fawlty, Geraldine Granger, and of course Derek Trotter. One man however, captured the hearts of an entire nation without ever uttering a word.

Mr. Bean has been described as a child inside a man’s body, and in his initial run of just 15 episodes made audiences fall in love with him. This all came down to the physical comedy genius of Rowan Atkinson, who has the unparalleled ability to make you laugh without the need for words.

Following the misadventures of a man who didn’t speak, struggling with everyday tasks like doing the laundry or driving his car, isn’t exactly the kind of pitch that would excite a TV studio. And yet, Mr. Bean went on to become insanely popular throughout the world, has been reimagined as an animated series, and brought back numerous times in movies and of course for the opening ceremony of the 2012 Olympics.

This show, and this character however, would have fallen flat on its face without Rowan Atkinson. While the lack of any real language made this show accessible to non-English speakers the world over, this wasn’t enough to garner its popularity alone. Atkinson’s comedic timing, and talent for pulling stupid yet unexplainably funny faces, have made this character a TV legend.


2. Big Mouth

Big Mouth Nick Duke Ellington
Netflix

If you ever thought you would watch a TV show about a bunch of young teenagers going through the changes of puberty in incredibly graphic ways, and enjoying it as much as audiences have enjoyed Big Mouth, then chances are you’d be lying to yourself.

Discussions about the size of the children’s genitals, when and how best to masturbate, and having sex with a sentient pillow or two, with some of the most graphic animated images TV can offer, Big Mouth shouldn’t work. Any animator that has to draw a child's penis should have the right to quit on the spot.

In theory, no one should enjoy this show, and yet it has become extremely popular. Something that works in its favour, that again in theory shouldn’t, is Maury the Hormone Monster. The very first scene of Big Mouth shows Nick Kroll’s character emerge in school in Andrew’s imagination to tell the young boy to go and masturbate in school. How did it ever get past this without being cancelled?

Five seasons later, not only is the series showing no signs of slowing down, it has its own spin-off in Human Resources, a show about the monsters whose job it is to get kids to masturbate. Oh, and Jordan Peele plays the ghost of Duke Ellington who lives in Nick Birch’s attic.


1. Love, Death & Robots

Love Death Robots Helping Hand Arm
Netflix

This is the third entry on this list that sits in the middle of the animated series/Netflix original Venn diagram, and in spite of the previous two being about a talking bipedal horse with addiction issues and the monster that makes adolescents want to masturbate, this is easily the weirdest.

Love, Death and Robots is, like Black Mirror, an anthology series detailing a different story in a different world with each episode, with a different cast, crew, and animation style. The key theme running through, of course, is that each episode is based around one or more of the titular aspects.

Here we're talking about a series in which the story of a woman trapped in space freezing her arm and excruciatingly snapping it off to make her way back to her ship was one of the most grounded stories there was.

There are some big names that have been attached to the series over its current three-series run, including David Fincher as a director for one episode, but arguably the most telling name is the creator. Anything brought to life by Tim Miller, the director of Deadpool, was always going to be unique and completely off the wall.


In this post: 
Black Mirror
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.