10 TV Shows With Massive Budgets That Failed

The high-profile shows that had the money, but ended up being huge flops.

Marco Polo
Netflix

Streaming services have become arguably the go-to way of consuming visual media for most of us, with platforms such as Netflix, Amazon, and Hulu offering a wealth of content for relatively fair prices, all in the comfort of your home.

The days of campy sitcoms with bad props, questionable writing, and a weird aspect ratio are long behind us, as we are deep into a new golden age of television, only this time it's in 4K. Even the world's most renowned names from the film industry are switching over to streaming because they recognise that there is much more freedom to explore their subjects in a 10-episode long story arc than in a 90-minute feature. You are now as likely to see an original Martin Scorsese film or the latest adventure flick starring Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson, on your laptop as you are in the local cinema.

However, history has proven time and time again that no matter how much money you pour into a production, or how many famous names you attach to it, you are still not guaranteed that it will be a hit. Sometimes, the whole ends up being smaller than the sum of its parts.

With that in mind, let's take a look at ten TV series that had massive financial backing but, for one reason or another, failed to capture an audience.

10. Hemlock Grove

Hemlock Grove
Netflix

Hemlock Grove came early in Netflix's foray into original content, and they definitely did not hit the ground running.

This was the streaming giant's only second original title ever. The initial success of House of Cards was encouraging, but it did not carry over in the same way to Hemlock Grove. Based on Brian McGreevy's novel of the same name, the series explored strange events in the titular Pennsylvania town. McGreevy himself was the showrunner and the cast was led by Famke Janssen, Bill SkarsgÄrd, and Landon Liboiron.

The critics' reviews after the release of the first season were mostly negative, and the show never really managed to create an audience of its own, but despite that, Netflix went ahead and ordered further two seasons.

The further it went on, the more the ratings decreased and the plug was eventually pulled. With an estimated budget of $4 million per episode, Hemlock Grove ended up costing Netflix around $130 million in total.


9. Joey

Joey Spin-Off
NBC

Spin-offs are always tricky to pull off, and that is especially true when the original show was so beloved. Joey never came close to the heights of Friends.

When Friends finally came to a close after ten seasons in 2004, NBC were not ready to completely give up on their cash cow. Matt LeBlanc was immediately contracted for a spin-off that would follow his character's life after he moved to Los Angeles to pursue acting.

Joey premiered four months after the Friends finale in the exact same time slot on NBC's schedule and initially attracted a viewership of over 18 million, but that number would steadily decline as the episodes went on. The writing simply wasn't as good and the characters weren't as engaging as in the parent show, so people eventually stopped tuning in.

It was moved to a different time slot when the second season began, which meant that it had to compete with ABC's hugely popular American Idol. This did not help the show's already dwindling audience numbers, and it was eventually cancelled after the season ended.

While it's difficult to pinpoint the exact cost of the show, it's probably enough to mention that LeBlanc was earning a reported $15 million per season.


8. The Get Down

Yahya Abdul Mateen II The Get Down
Netflix

A highly ambitious project from Netflix and Baz Luhrmann, The Get Down quickly imploded on itself.

Set in the 1970s Bronx R'n'B and disco scene, the show looked and sounded amazing, but beyond that, it had very little to offer.

Luhrmann spent over a decade developing the concept for the series and even managed to bring in key historical figures to act as advisors and executive producers on the show. These included Nas, Grandmaster Flash, DJ Kool Herc, and others. That kind of attention to detail, along with an inspired and youthful cast made The Get Down feel very authentic on the surface, but the writing often felt shallow and even cartoonish.

Ultimately, the exorbitant cost of production was the show's undoing. Reported budget estimations range from $180 to $200 million, which is on par with any Marvel movie, and the viewing figures simply weren't high enough to justify such investment. In 2017, Netflix announced that The Get Down will end after just 11 episodes.


7. Camelot

Camelot Joseph Fiennes
Starz

Starz tried to recreate the success of Spartacus with another history-based series, but Camelot didn't fare quite as well.

As any large-scale history show, Camelot required huge sets, lots of props, and a multitude of costumes. All these things cost money, and when you add to it the salaries of all the big names in front and behind the camera, the budget quickly ballooned.

At first, Starz were ready to back it, pumping a reported $7 million per episode into the show, but as it went on new issues kept cropping up and the ratings weren't there to justify all that, so it was cancelled after its debut season. Apart from financial troubles, the network cited scheduling conflicts with some members of the main cast as a big obstacle.

What didn't help was the fact that there was a certain series premiering on HBO at around the same time, covering similar themes.


6. Cop Rock

Cop Rock
ABC

Cop shows were all the rage in the '80s and '90s, so ABC decided to add a different twist to the format by making it a musical.

Yes, you've read that right. Cop Rock was a show about LAPD officers singing their way through solving crimes, with lyrics that you simply have to hear to believe. If you're wondering why such a thing was ever greenlit, then you should look no further than the show's creator.

Steven Bochco came fresh off writing and producing Hill Street Blues, a wildly successful cop drama that was regarded as revolutionary at the time. His stocks were high and ABC put their trust in him, but Cop Rock was misguided and ended up being one of the decade's biggest TV flops.

While Bochco recovered relatively quickly -- he created NYPD Blue just three years later -- ABC took a $25 million hit (huge money at the time) for just eleven episodes, and went on trying to pretend like it never happened.


5. Vinyl

Vinyl Boby Cannavale Olivia Wilde
HBO

HBO, Martin Scorsese, and 1970s New York music scene. What could possibly go wrong?

This is one of those that look perfect on paper, but in reality it was a big, expensive mess. After Boardwalk Empire capped its successful run in 2014, and Game of Thrones was heading towards its final two seasons, HBO looked to plant the seeds of their next big prestige drama.

Intentionally or not, they followed the same blueprint that worked on Boardwalk Empire, appointing Scorsese to direct the pilot, with Terence Winter taking over for the rest of the show's run. They even had Mick Jagger as a consultant!

But it failed to live up to the promise, and it was visible from the start that Vinyl will not be able to reach the heights of previous HBO classics. The pilot alone cost $30 million to make and it only attracted around 750.000 viewers, making it the lowest-performing HBO pilot in years.

The rest of the season was all over the place, with creative differences being cited by multiple people as a major issue behind the scenes. So even though HBO announced that they are extending it for a second season only after two episodes had been shown, the rest of the run proved to be so chaotic that they changed their mind and decided to cancel it altogether four months later.


4. Marco Polo

Marco Polo
Netflix

Netflix's first truly massive production was a period piece set in the Mongol Empire during the titular character's early years.

Up until then, Netflix were largely focussing on small-scale shows, but this time they decided to go big and rival some of HBO's biggest productions. In fact, when they commissioned Marco Polo for $9 million per episode, it became the second most expensive TV series in the world, behind only Game of Thrones.

But, needless to say, the cultural impact wasn't even close to that of the HBO flagship, and critics and fans alike were mostly blaming the writing. The show was visually stunning -- which is to be expected with a budget like that -- but the stories were often labelled as "dull" and "messy."

However, Netflix didn't let that faze them and they extended it for a second season, but the response was mostly the same and eventually they had to cut their losses and admit defeat. At the time of cancelling, the total cost of Marco Polo was reportedly in excess of $200 million.


3. Supertrain

Supertrain TV
NBC

We go all the way back to 1979 for one of the first -- and worst -- flops of all time.

NBC saw the success of ABC's The Love Boat and thought they could make their own, better version of it. So instead of placing the story on a beautiful cruise ship on the open sea, they decided to set it on a train.

Try imagining the logistics of building three entire sets of trains that looked relatively realistic but still were practical enough for the cast and crew to film on them. Now imagine how much that would cost... in 1979 money.

The sets alone cost over $5 million (around $20 million in today's value), but NBC also went all-in on the marketing, betting the farm on the success of the futuristic show. But the final product was a bunch of underwhelming, over-elaborate storylines on cramped and poorly-lit sets.

Fun fact: the concept of the show was sold to the BBC before it was ever aired in The USA. NBC hoped to recoup some of their production cost by selling the international rights, but upon seeing the terrible reception the American version got, BBC decided to never air the show.


2. Terra Nova

Terra Nova
20th Television

Fox Network signed Steven Spielberg to executive produce this sci-fi epic that includes dinosaurs.

It is probably slightly unfair to call Terra Nova a flop because it never received embarrassing reviews or had laughable viewership like some of the other entries on this list. In fact, the series premiere was watched by 9.5 million people and was generally liked by critics. But as the season went on, the figures took a bit of a dip, and the reviews regressed to average at best.

In most cases, this could have been attributed to a new show finding its feet. Riding it out and putting some trust in it would seem like a reasonable course of action, but the problem was that Terra Nova was so expensive to make that it simply didn't have that luxury.

It required over 250 sets, a lot of CGI, and some expensive people to operate it all. The pilot alone ended up costing around $14 million, with each subsequent episode having a budget of $4 million. That would be a lot even for a streaming subscription or a premium cable network, so Fox were quick to cut all ties with it and get out with "only" about $100 million spent.


1. Kings

Kings Ian McShane
NBC

This NBC biblical drama was a retelling of the King David story but set in a modern-day setting.

The original idea seemed great on paper, especially when you imagine King David being played by Ian McShane, fresh off his masterful performance as Al Swearangen in HBO's cult classic Deadwood. NBC were quick to give the green light to creator Michael Green, but things didn't exactly go as they hoped.

A lot of things were happening behind the scenes of Kings, and it was ultimately disagreements and odd choices when it came to marketing that spelt the end of the series. NBC opted to not include the show in their 2009 SuperBowl slot and, even though the show was clearly inspired by biblical figures and events, they decided to not mention that in any of the promotional material, instead leaving the promos intentionally vague.

This caused them to miss out on a potentially big target audience and essentially doomed Kings right from the start. With expenses quickly rocketing over $50 million, the network finally brought the axe down after only a single season.


Contributor
Contributor

Big fan of TV shows, music, and indie films. Gets too emotional when watching football. Secretly thinks he could run a Premier League club based only on his time spent playing Football Manager.