10 Most Twisted Characters in American Horror Story

Ian Mcshane American Horror Story Son of a Witch! As 'American Horror Story' enters its third season it seems to be going as strong as ever. This year we see the witches of New Orleans (the new Salem) clash with the voodoo queen herself. It's an all out bloodbath, featuring an ensemble cast of some of the fiercest women on television €“ Kathy Bates, Jessica Lange, Angela Bassett and Emma Roberts are putting their bitchcraft to good use. For anyone who doesn't know the Horror Story formula, each season has a new setting, new story, new characters, but uses the majority of the same cast. So you can learn to love the cast rather than their character €“ who lets be honest, probably won't make it past episode two. What you are left with is an ever changing show, but with the people you love. The brainchild of Ryan 'Glee' Murphy, it is a departure from the happy-clappy songs of McKinley high school; sure they may have Sue Sylvester, but the FX show has rape, incest and gallons upon gallons of blood. Now I may have a bit of a Jessica Lange bias (appearing in all three seasons), but grab a pillow, dim the lights and take a look at the '10 Most Twisted Character in American Horror Story.' MASSIVE SPOILER WARNING IN EFFECT

10. Moira O'Hara (Frances Conroy/ Alexandra Breckenridge) 'Murder House'

American Horror Story

Bringing a whole new meaning to the phrase 'granny pants', Miss O'Hara served as the main eye candy for lothario patriarch Ben Harmon throughout 'Murder House.' Appearing to some as a prim dressed housekeeper in her later years and to others as a scantily-clad twentysomething. Women's intuition allows them to see the true nature of a person, whereas men see only what they desire- Hence the two tone layering of the character and some very creepy sequences involving the Harmon housekeeper. A universal cringe goes round the room as you see Frances Conroy mounted on Mr. Harmon, much to the disgust of his own daughter. Previously employed by the Harmon's neighbour Constance, she had a brief affair with her husband Hugo, but when he tried it again in 1983 she brushed off his advances. An enraged Hugo tried to rape Moira but was caught by his wife; Constance shot Hugo in the heart, but not before nailing Moira one in the eye, hence Frances Conroy's milky eyed appearance. Moira's loyalty to Vivien Harmon makes her by no means the most twisted character in the Horror Story collective, having said that she makes the list just for biting off a property developer's penis. OUCH.

9. Sister Jude (Jessica Lange) 'Asylum'

Jude

The first entry for Jessica Lange on this list, sucking the fun out of nun, Sister Jude ruled Briarcliffe with an iron fist and was all too quick to reach for her rack of canes. Born Judy Martin, she was a fiery blonde with a penchant for singing, men and alcohol; this decadent lifestyle lead Judy on a path to destruction and ended with a drunken hit and run, killing a small girl. Her drunken behaviour crashed into a nunnery and consequently let her embrace God under the tutelage of The Mother Superior. She is in charge of Briarcliffe but ultimately falls off the wagon, losing it to Dr. Arthur Arden, then framed for murder she becomes a patient of the sanitorium herself.

Sister Jude believes that mental illness is just the fashion and that investigative reporter Lana Winters lesbian tendencies are the sickest of them all. Her committal to the asylum soon changes her views and Jude strikes up an unlikely alliance with Lana. She gets some of her own treatments and the electroshock therapy she most gleefully used on her patients has a bitter sting when used on her.The Jude we see in the latter half is a shell of her former self, rocking in a chair and unable to remember her name, she is someone you can't help but feel for. Jessica Lange steals the season with her iconic 'Name Game' song, putting her vocal cords to good use. Jude remained a victim of the system and left to rot in Briarcliffe long after most of the others; the Monsignor denied her existence there, claiming Jude had died- In fact she remained in solitary for years. Lana Winter's eventual expose releases Jude from the asylum and she lives out her latter years in relative happiness with Kit Walker and his children. It all ends happily ever after!


8. Sister Mary Eunice (Lily Rabe) 'Asylum'

29462 Sister Mary Eunice Gif Urbp Gif

A pure soul and gunning for the award of 'Most unfortunate member of Asylum', it is a toss up who had a worse time at Briarcliffe €“ Sister Mary Eunice or Lana Winters? Everything seemed to be going well for Mary Eunice until the events of 'Trick and Treats' where an exorcism forces a demonic spirit into the body of the happy nun. Sadly for her fans, this is pretty much the last of her true identity that we see. She was a fragile and innocent girl, scared of Sister Jude and someone who put too much trust in Dr. Arden. After her possession the tables turn, it is she who takes control of the relationship as Dr. Arden struggles to subdue his sexual advances towards her. Whatever shred of Mary Eunice is left slowly deteriorates over the season and she takes great glee in all things antichrist- In particular the scene in the film 'The Sign of the Cross' where the Christians are fed to the lions.

Demon Mary Eunice released Lee Emerson, stabbed the Mexican with a pair of scissors, got Sister Jude drunk and had her wicked way with the Monsignor €“ it was a busy week! After raping Monsignor Timothy he was left with no other choice, they argued on top of the stairs and the real Mary Eunice finally appeared, pleading with him to save her. The only way to save her soul was by throwing her from the top of the stairs, this killed Mary Eunice and the demon within, ending its reign over the sanitorium.


7. Charles Montgomery (Matt Ross) 'Murder House'

Mont

Founder of 'Murder House', Dr. Montgomery is the reason this whole bloody mess began. Surgeon to the stars and with a brilliant mind, he is one of the foremost doctors in his field, but when he turns to drink, his life, his wife Nora and their son fall apart. Developing Frankenstein syndrome, Dr.Montgomery turns to backstreet abortions as well as dismemberment. All too quick with the scalpel, Dr.Montgomery is great at giving one patient a Joker-esque Chelsea smile just because she looked too sad. He fully descends into madness when his son Thaddeus is dismembered and his remains brought to him by the police. Not content with losing his only son Charles Montgomery reanimates him using a girl's heart €“ Vouila, newly born monster hybrid Infantata. As a mortal he meets his end at the hands of his wife, shooting him then turning the gun on herself. In the afterlife he goes some way at redemption by helping to deliver Vivien Harmon's twins.

6. Leigh Emerson (Ian McShane) 'Asylum'

Emer

A filthy Santa in dire need of some psychiatric help and more than a shower, Lee Emerson played a bit part in 'Asylum' and focal point of their festive episode. He claims there is no God, but there is a Santa Claus; a man who bears the brunt of Briarcliffe's tortures, making him even more hellbent on revenge and in particular Sister Jude.

The worst bit about Emerson is that he didn't only ruin Christmas for himself, but for all the inmates of Briarcliffe; his attack on Christmas Eve 1963 lead Sister Jude to banish all future Christmas festivities and confine him to solitary for the next year. His stint alone in his cell made Emerson the twisted Santa we meet in 1964. Released by the possessed Mary Eunice, he kills guard Frank and acts his revenge on Jude, giving her a taste of her own medicine and caning her on her desk. Afterwards Emerson, Arden and Mary Eunice frame Jude for the murder of Frank and get her committed to Briarcliffe. He feigns redemption and after being baptised Emerson nails the Monsignor to a cross and escapes custody. In modern times and according to the autobiography of Lana Winters, he still remains at large, hunted in five states and having slaughtered seven nuns.


5. Fiona Goode (Jessica Lange) 'Coven'

Tumblr Mvjha4hjr91rhu4a0o1 500 Gif

"Don't make me drop a house on your bitch"...probably the best line of 'Coven', if not all of 'American Horror Story' ever. This season Lange once again steals the show as the smoking hot older lady. In 'Coven' Fiona Goode is the Supreme of Salem descendants, head witch and general badass not to be messed with.

Her obsession with eternal youth and power is her greatest weakness; she digs up a seemingly immortal Kathy Bates in hope of discovering her fountain of youth. Also, you can't forget she offed the previous supreme back in 1971 AND slit newbie with Madison's throat in exactly the same way, suspecting she would take her crown. Her constant battle with the council of witches is nowhere near over. In the episode 'Burn, Witch, Burn' Fiona turned everyone against her childhood enemy Myrtle Snow, having her burned at the stake. This isn't the last we have seen of Myrtle as already her body is being brought back to life by resurrector of the dead Misty Day- here's guessing she will be coming for Fiona. Despite this, there is an element of humanity to Fiona; in the hospital she saves the life of a stillborn baby and is clearly wracked with guilt when her daughter Cordelia is blinded with acid.

Already the signs of weakness are showing, as Fiona gets weaker with cancer, somewhere out there the next Supreme is growing stronger. Lets only hope Fiona doesn't go the way of her predecessor.


4. Dr. Arthur Arden (James Cromwell) 'Asylum'

Ard

James Cromwell stole the hearts of millions as the loveable farmer Hoggett from 'Babe', but it is in 'Asylum' that he scares us witless as sadistic Nazi Dr. Arthur Arden. For the first half of the season he and Sister Jude duke it out for supremacy over Briarcliffe, ultimately with just one of them coming out on top. Much as Dr. Montgomery was in 'Murder House,' Arden was this season's Dr. Frankenstein, with his genetic experiments and creatures in the woods stemming from his crimes as a war criminal at Auschwitz.

He hacked off the legs of Chloe Sevigny's nymphomaniac character Shelley and turned her into his pet project, but this wasn't his creepiest moment. A Freudian wet dream, he had an odd obsession with Sister Mary Eunice's purity, so one night forces a lady of the night to dress as a nun before sexually abusing her. When Anne Frank (yes THE Anne Frank) arrives at the asylum it appears his web of lies might be coming undone, but a shot to the leg doesn't stop Arden and it gives him the opportunity to seize Briarcliffe from Jude.

After the loss of Mary Eunice he is overcome by grief, seeing no need to live anymore. Unfortunately for Arden his redemption comes a little too late €“ seeking forgiveness for all his crimes, he throws himself into the crematorium with her body. His storyline of the monsters fizzled out mid-season and his disappearance is never fully explored, which is a sad end for a truly menacing character.


3. Marie Delphine LaLaurie (Kathy Bates) 'Coven'

Bates

A blast from the past and a woman who literally looks like she has just been dug up, LaLaurie completes the comedy duo of Bates and Lange which is serving as the main dynamic so far on 'Coven'. Her story begins way back in 1830's as the socialite-turned-mutilator meets her match in Marie Laveau (Angela Bassett). LaLaurie is punished for her treatment of black slaves, including sewing feces in their mouths and making a human minotaur. Laveau enters her house under the guise of giving her everlasting beauty, but what she actually gives her is much darker €“ the gift of everlasting life. After witnessing the murder of her three daughters and husband, LaLaurie is locked in a box and proceeds to be buried underground for the next 200 years without even so much a crossword to complete.

Found by clairvoyant witch Nan and dug up by Supreme Fiona Goode, it appears that LaLaurie is struggling to adjust to life in the 21st Century. The scene of her crying at the 'magic box' when she realises there is a black man in office is one of comedy gold and Bates exudes madness in a role that fits her archetype perfectly (Misery, anyone?). I can't wait to see where they take the character next this season as I am starting to worry she is going a bit soft on us.


2. Bloody Face/ Dr. Oliver Thredson (Zachary Quinto) 'Asylum'

Thred Gif

Hooray, you all cheer at the end of 'Asylum' episode 5 'I Am Anne Frank:Part 2', as our heroine Lana Winters is saved by knight in shining armour Dr. Thredson. Alas, this is Horror Story and no one is ever what they seem! Dr. Thredson/Bloody Face is an articulate and sympathetic man, with a skill for making human skin lamps and cranial mint bowls (Now available in John Lewis).

A victim of the system, Oliver Thredson is abandoned by his mother at a young age and forced to live in an orphanage. After starting a prosperous career in medicine his first signs of delusion are shown as he identifies the body of a woman. Longing for the touch of a mother, he undresses and lies on top of the corpse. Thredson was originally brought to Briarcliffe to judge Kit Walker's innocence, but began to develop an interest in the case of Lana Winters. Elements of his creepy persona lurked in 'I Am Anne Frank: Part 2' as his conversion/aversion therapy resulted in Lana being forced to touch herself and alarm bells rang as he withdraws a picture of her former lover, revealing he had been to her house. By the time episode 6: 'The Origins of Monstrosity' starts, he is in fully Bloody Face mode. He keeps Lana hostage in his love dungeon, raping her and creating his bastard incest son Johnny Morgan, A.K.A. Bloody Face 2.

What a relief it is to see is that the mid point of the season isn't the end of Dr. Thredson, he continues to be a large presence at Briarcliffe and Lana cannot prove his guilt until the closing episodes of the entire season; his twisted ways carry on and he isn't simply discarded in favour of the Bloody Face persona. Both Thredson boys are responsible for some of the most memorable scenes in 'Asylum', the episode 'Milk' springs to mind and means you will never think of breast feeding with an innocent mind again.


1. Tate Langdon/ Rubber Man (Evan Peters) 'Murder House'

Tat

In terms of bodycount and horrific actions, Rubber Man just about pips Bloody Face as the ultimate big bad in Horror Story. In life he was Tate Langdon, the disturbed and horny teen son of Constance, but in death he is the murdering, raping, S&M fetish €“ Rubber Man. Appearing as Dr. Harmon's psychiatric patient , Tate originally seemed like just a misunderstood teenager. His infatuation towards Dr. Harmon's daughter Violet developed into the twisted Romeo and Juliet element of the first season, whilst his revelation of being a ghost was one of the first major 'say whaaaat' moments of the series. In 1994 Tate horrifically burns Constance's boyfriend Larry Harvey (admittedly for murdering his brother), then goes on a mass shooting at Westfield High School, notching up 15 kills before he even departs his mortal coil. After being gunned down by a S.W.A.T. team he has continued to destroy the lives of those who have inhabited the house since, raping Vivien Harmon and killing off bitchy queens Chad and Patrick. In the gruesome two parter 'Halloween', Chad was drowned in an apple bobbing bucket whilst Patrick was sodomised with a fire poker. 'Halloween' gave us a much more in depth look at Tate's backstory and reasoning behind what he is. After death and since becoming the 'Rubber Man' alter eg , Tate became even more unhinged; it finally seemed like Violet could restore some harmony to his troubled life, but ultimately his involvement with her lead to her committing suicide. So why does Tate come before Bloody Face? One €“ in death Tate is immortal and has superhuman strength. Two €“ he looks amazing in the Rick Genest style make up (above), which is now one of the iconic images from all three series, and three €“ as deranged as Tate is, you still feel some sympathy towards him and imagine there is a shred of human dignity under there. Given this fact, that is the most disturbing part! Who else do you love to hate in 'American Horror Story' and where would you like future seasons to go? Sound off below.

Contributor
Contributor

Warden of the north - bearded and tattooed. Lover of all things Horror Storied, Throned and Walking whilst Dead. Twitter: tomtomchap