10 ‘Unsolved’ Mysteries From Lost (That Have Really Simple Answers)
Stop moaning and look closer... the answers are all here.
In one of Lost's final episodes 'The Mother' states "Every question I answer will simply lead to another question." Clearly there to warn fans they may not get totally logical solutions to the plethora mysteries they'd obsessed over for the past six years, it didn't really do its job; there was still a substantial backlash when plot threads were seemingly left untied. As someone who was hooked by the show from beginning to end I always found these criticisms a bit unjustified. Some questions would be left hanging for seasons at a time, but thats pretty par for the course in modern television - Game Of Thrones relishes in it. Many people who make these criticisms are those who gave up on the show somewhere around the midway point, but theres a sizable amount of long term fans who came away from the series feeling like nothing was answered The reason the finale didnt answer loads of questions was because most had already been solved; you just had to put a few pieces together. There are some out there (how Mikhail kept coming back to life and the just how Ben got Anthony Cooper to the Island) that dont have any satisfying solutions, but for the most part showrunners Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse did a good job of giving fans all they needed. Here are ten of those mysteries everyone moans about despite there being perfectly simple answers. Honourable Mention - The Supply Drops And The Hurley Bird Got Answers (Eventually)
There were naturally some long standing mysteries that never got a mention beyond their initial set up, which naturally led to some fans being pretty peeved. When it became apparent people were only half pleased with a character based ending the writers made a short epilogue that gave confirmation to several mysteries fans had assumed the answers to; the Hurley bird was genetically engineered by the Dharma Initiative and the supply drops continued as theyd never been told to stop. Had it not been for that these could quite easily have popped up on this list; the answers were pretty obvious.
10. Who Was In Jacobs Cabin?
The Mystery: Back when Jacob was a name wed only heard a couple of times, the biggest piece of info we had on him was his cabin. First used in The Man Behind The Curtain as a way for Ben to trick John Locke, it became apparent there was an actual magical force present. Things got more complicated in Season 4 - it was home to the vision of Christian Shephard and some other mysterious being - but fans were willing to go with it. Once it was revealed Jacob had been living in the foot of the four toed statue the whole, we had to ask; what was up with the cabin. The Simple Solution: It was The Man In Black. Early on in Season 6 we got confirmation the visions of Christian Shepherd on the Island had been the smoke monster the whole time, so that means for at least half of our visits the cabin had been his home. Once you accept that its not too difficult to extrapolate everything there was The Man In Black; much of the cabin dwellers involvement was manipulating John to move the Island, which directly led to Jacobs death. The ash circle must have been added by Jacob at some point between the monster being stopped at the sonar fence in Left Behind and the cabins first appearance.
9. Who Built The Statue?
The Mystery: My personal favourite mystery in Lost was the four toed statue. After Season 2 kept its sights primarily on Dharma and the science of the Island, for the finale to plant the seeds of something more mystical shook fans who thought we were close to understanding it all. Such a haunting image led to all sorts of theories as to what the rest of the effigy may be - a time travelling Sawyer who lost his little toe, the founder of the Other race - but in the end the answer was (sort of) realistic; the statue is of Taweret, the Egyptian Goddess of fertility and childbirth. But even though the show took us back pretty far, we never got an answer to who built it. The Simple Solution: The Egyptians built it. The subject of the statue really should be all thats needed to solve this, but it seems some fans really wanted a definitive answer. Eventually it was confirmed on the Lost Podcast it was built by early Egyptian settlers (probably in tribute to the Islands magical effects on fertility in males), but given the amount of other Egyptian imagery (the Temple in particular, but all of the Island are covered in hieroglyphics) it feels a bit unnecessary to be pointed out.
8. Why Was Libby In The Mental Health Institute?
The Mystery: With such a focus on characters over mystery throughout the show its odd that some just managed to slip through the cracks. When the Tailies were introduced fans were rather ambivalent towards them until their interesting backstories were revealed. Best of all was Libby, whose reveal she had been in the same mental institution as Hurley was only topped by her unexpected death a couple of episodes later, coming before the mystery has been addressed at all. And after she popped up in a flashback to give Desmond the boat that took him to the Island, the mystery never appeared again. The Simple Solution: Its to do with her husbands death. The unofficial reason for this mystery lying dormant is that actress Cynthia Watros was arrested for a DUI during the shooting of Season 2, but as Libby was brought back for the Flashsideways purgatory it seems the writers just took this mystery as solved. When she gives Desmond the Elizabeth we learn she is a widow (oddly enough her former husband has the same name as Hurleys imaginary friend), so given the timeline (she was in Santa Rosa a year or two before meeting Desmond) its easy to conclude it was from the depression of losing her husband.
7. Who Was In The Other Outrigger?
The Mystery: When it was announced midway through Season 3 that Lost had a definitive end date many fans took this a sign all mysteries from here on out would have definitive answers. This was evidently not the case. In Season 5s The Little Prince, Sawyer, Juliet and the rest of the time travellers end up in a shootout with an unknown group while using one of the Ajira gangs outriggers. Before time jumping away, Juliet managed to hit one of the pursuers, but despite the promise of a solution (not to mention many teasing appearances of Outriggers through to the series end) the show never gave us an answer. The Simple Solution: It was either Ilanas team/The Black Rock crew. This is one of the harder solutions as Damon Lindelof has gone on record saying he wont give an answer. We were meant to get a proper solution in Season 6, but by that point some the people who were intended to be in the other outrigger had been killed off. This suggests it was Caesar and the rest of Ilanas team, but there was never any time to show it properly. Another, more interesting answer was given in the Complete Series box set; it was some of the surviving crew of The Black Rock who had somehow begun to travel in time too. This is regarded as non-canon, but its a pretty cool resolution.
6. Why Did Walt Have Powers?
The Mystery: Originally meant to be a key character throughout the shows run time before Malcolm David Kelley hit puberty and began to age faster than was ever believable on the Island, Walt was the first of many characters to have some form of supernatural ability. Able to see future events, project himself over long distances and learn complicated skills very quickly, he embodies the shows early days of setting up mysteries with no goal really set out. Even though Kelley would pop up a couple more times in the show no real time was given to what was so special about him and why he had powers. The Simple Solution: He just did. Its a bit of a cop out, but this is the only reasonable answer. Back when his abilities were introduced the show was still in its Lord Of The Flies phase, so they stood out more. A couple of years later Miles was able to talk with corpses, Hurley could see ghosts and the whole show became a drive to save a magic light, making him pretty normal in the Lost world. Where the powers come from is kept pretty vague, but the suggestion is it has something to do with the electromagnetic power. As Walt spent a lot of time in Australia (where we know one of the pockets is) he probably developed his abilities from gradual exposure.
5. What Was The Sickness?
The Mystery: The notion of The Sickness went through various iterations, with Danielle Rousseau presenting it as a form of madness, while Kelvin used it as a trick to keep Desmond from going outside of the Swan, but all these contradictory stories just had fans confused. The Islands healing nature only further complicated things and as season after season went by without any direct addressing of it, people were split between it being a lie in-world or a misleading mystery from the writers. The Simple Solution: It was The Man In Black (mostly). Most mysteries in Lost can be solved with this rationale, although its unclear what the original intention was. We saw various versions of the sickness, but their identical name seems to be more a misleading play than an overarching link. The 'official' Sickness is one of The Man In Blacks methods of controlling Jacobs candidates and probably his most forceful. Essentially mind control, it pits survivors of various wrecks against each other (although how that doesn't break the rules I dont know). Much of the confusion comes from Danielles misunderstanding of the source; she doesn't connect the monsters attack and her crews descent into madness. The other types of sickness are less fantastical; Kelvins lie to Desmond seems to be part of Dharmas mind games while the childbirth complications are another real, if completely different, issue.
4. What Was The Deal With The Polar Bear?
The Mystery: This is a mystery that was solved in the show pretty comprehensively, but as its one Lost cynics will always ask fans if it ever got solved its worth giving it some focus. The big mystery of the Pilot, aside from what was the monster in the jungle, was why there was Polar Bear on a tropical island. Laying dormant for a good couple of years, many people state this delayed solution as a reason the show lost them, but in reality it was easily solvable long before the epilogue gave a definitive answer. The Simple Solution: Dharma brought them to Island to experiment electromagnetism on. The answer to this seems to have changed over the course of the show. Season 1 hinted Walt brought it to the Island after reading Hurleys comic, but once the show's general direction changed so did the answer changed. When Sawyer is captured by the Others they put them in a cage originally inhabited by a polar bear, which explained the physical why, if not the reasoning. But by Season 4 it was wrapped up. Early on Charlotte found a polar bear skeleton, complete with Dharma collar in the desert and come the finale we learnt the frozen donkey wheel had the ability to teleport things off the Island, from which can be concisely concluded Dharma were using the bears to experiment the effects of electromagnetism on.
3. What Were The Others Actually Up To?
The Mystery: Being hidden superhumans in Season 1, fake primitives in Season 2 and civilised suburbanites in Season 3, many fans were confused what exactly the deal with The Others was. You have Ben Linus who initially seems to be in complete control but who turns out to be an oblivious pawn of The Man In Black working with Richard Alpert who is knowingly fighting Jacobs corner. Lingering questions - what was Ethan up to, what was the deal with air hostess Cindy turning to work with them, whats with the lists - only muddy the waters further. The Simple Solution: Alpert has them working for Jacob but The Man In Black intervenes. We known Richard was working as an emissary for Jacob and that seems to be the general purpose of the Hostiles as they find Jughead and clash with Dharma. The confusing stuff happens after Ben gets involved. The scientists are gassed and theres little conflict, making way for the Others to focus on other things - hiring new recruits (turning them with the indoctrination video) and trying to solve the pregnancy problem. Then at some point The Man In Black begins to get involved and he begins to mislead Ben, giving him false information that sets his plan in motion. The high number of lists is just the being a addressed plot is mainly because the writers put too much initial focus on them; they weren't all that important.
2. Why Cant Children Be Born On The Island?
The Mystery: Having Claire pregnant when the plane crashed was brilliant move on the writers part. Ignoring the implausibility of both mother and baby surviving the crash it gave an inevitable and anticipated major event fans could prepare for long before any major mysteries were set up. Of course, in true Lost spirit it actually turned out to be a gateway into a key running plot; there was a serious problem with childbirth on the Island. Tying into the themes of life and death as well as juxtaposing the increased fertility, it was something always alluded to by the show, but never tackled head on. The Simple Solution: Its an after effect of the Purge. When the fans settled on the (eventually correct) theory the statue was Tawaret many assumed its destruction marked the end of the Islands childbirth, but its actually something a lot less spiritual. Following in-world chronology the last birth before the problems began was Alex Rousseau in 1988 and we know a pregnancy started on the Island can work based off Ethans birth ten years earlier. This means something had to change between then and Juliet being hired to help solve the problem. The biggest event in that time was the Dharma Purge, which was achieved by using the Tempest station to distribute a deadly toxic gas. While anyone without a gas mask would die, there could easily be some other side effects, including the inability for pregnancies to last longer than a few months. This is why Claire and Sun were fine with their children; they weren't affected in the Purge.
1. What Were The Numbers?
The Mystery: 4, 8, 15, 16, 23, 42 (and their sum 108) run through all of Lost; theyre the corresponding numbers on Jacobs list of the final six candidates, the variables on the Valenzetti equation, the numbers Hurley won the lottery with, the sequence that must be put into the Swan computer and so many more background appearances even Lostpedia can't fit them all in one page. Despite being such an integral part of the show, the numbers were made up halfway through Season 1, so clearly weren't part of the original plan. Still, given how the show would continuously adapt itself, everyone expected there to be some overarching solution. The Simple Solution: They were just numbers. Do you think we crashed on this place by coincidence? Locke asks Jack in the Season 1 finale. While he may have been right to question that in relation to the passengers of Oceanic 815 being brought to the Island, as far as the numbers are concerned that is exactly what it was. Many of their appearances were linked (their obsession with the Valenzetti equation probably inspired Dharma to use them for the Swan's computer sequence, as well as transmitting them from the island, which in the end led to Hurley playing the lottery with them, while his recurring bad luck was Jacob pushing him towards the Island), but theres no underlying force to it. The show just put too much emphasis on them, leading to the illusion of importance. Got any more Lost mysteries people always think are unanswered, but actually are? Surprised by some of the ones in this article? Have your say in the comments below.