10 Voice-Actor Deaths That Impacted The Simpsons

We miss you Mrs K..

When a voice-actor passes away for any cartoon, the writers have three options: re-cast with a similar-sounding actor/actress; send the character on a "long vacation" until a decision can be made; or permanently retire said character(s) out of respect for the deceased. After being on the air for 25 years, The Simpsons have, unfortunately, seen their fair-share of voice-actors pass on. Very few of their "permanent" voices, but enough in-house- as well as special guests who voiced themselves and reoccurring characters- have passed that the writers have had to make those decisions. Sixty-three voice-actors and actresses- three considered "regular cast" and the other 60 "special guest stars"- have been silenced over the last 25 years. Some of the more familiar guest stars you won't see in this list include: Steve Allen, Johnny Carson, Gary Coleman, Linda McCartney, Tito Puente, Elizabeth Taylor, and Barry White. The ones listed within all played fictional characters within The Simpsons' universe; characters that could have, should have, and potentially would have returned again to visit with Homer, Marge, et al. With all due respect to all of the deceased members of The Simpsons' extended acting family and their loved ones, here we pay tribute to those we lost...

10. Christopher Collins (1949-1994)

Christophercollins1 Actor and comedian Christopher Collins - also known as Chris Latta - made three appearances in the first season. He was the original voice of Mr. Burns, voicing the billionaire 104-year-old in "Simpsons Roasting on an Open Fire" (uncredited) and in "Homer's Odyssey." He also voiced the host of the TV reality-crime show America's Most Armed and Dangerous in "Some Enchanted Evening." Collins was given the chance to voice Moe, but disagreements with producer Sam Simon led to Hank Azaria taking over the bartender, and Collins left the show to return to his comedy career. Collins tragically died in 1994, three years after leaving The Simpsons, of a cerebral hemorrhage. At that point the roles of Mr. Burns and Moe had been solidified by Harry Shearer and Hank Azaria respectively, and it's doubtful Collins' other characters were greatly missed. But as far as The Simpsons go, it would have been a disaster if the voice for two such central characters passed away so early in the run.

9. Rodney Dangerfield (1921-2004)

Rodneydangerfield As a comedian, Rodney Dangerfield was famous for remarking that he got "no respect." As the illegitimate son of billionaire C. Montgomery Burns, Larry Burns felt his father gave him "No regard. No regard at all. No esteem either." In Season 8's "Burns, Baby Burns," Larry Burns was introduced to Springfield, having hitchhiked into town with The Simpsons. Mr. Burns, via flashback, explained that young Larry was conceived during a fling with the daughter of an old Yale girlfriend. Larry, we learned, spent his early life in an orphanage, got a job at a souvenir stand, and once saw a blimp; not exactly the kind of life befitting a Burns heir. Dangerfield played Larry with the kind of innocent buffoonery he would be famous for, both on stage and in film, even bringing back the song and dance number from Caddyshack at the end of the episode, as the entire town danced and drank to Journey's Any Way You Want It. It's also revealed near the end that Larry has a wife and children- "They're probably wondering where I went. I told 'em I was going for coffee; that was a week ago!"- and he's never seen or heard from again. Perhaps, if not for Dangerfield's passing in 2004 due to complications following heart surgery, Larry and his family would have returned to visit Mr. Burns.

8. Lawrence Tierney (1919-2002)

Donbrodka When the writers decided that Bart Simpsons would get caught shoplifting over Christmas, only one Hollywood tough-guy could fill the role of the Try-N-Save's head security guard Don Brodka ("That's right, Don Brodka.") That man was Lawrence Tierney, an American actor most well-known as John Dillinger in 1945's Dillinger. In Season 7's "Marge Be Not Proud", Tierney would be on the right side of the law, busting Bart for attempting to pocket the latest fighting video game Bonestorm, despite Bart's best arguments. ("If I wanted smoke blown up my ass, I'd be at home with a pack of cigarettes and short length of hose.") Brodka would show up- silently- two more times in Springfield: first, he was seen laughing at Nelson as the school bully walked down Main Street with his pants around his ankles in "22 Short Films About Springfield;" in The Simpsons Movie, Brodka was briefly seen in the mob that marched on the Simpsons' house with torches. But the Simpsons could have made more trips to the Try-N-Save, with more run-ins with Don Brodka ("That's right, Don Brodka") had Tierney not died of pneumonia in 2012 at the age of 82.

7. Paul Winfield (1939-2004)

Paulwinfield1 Academy- and Emmy-Award nominated actor Paul Winfield played boxing promoter Lucius Sweet ("He's exactly as rich and as famous as Don King, and he looks just like him!") in two separate episodes. First, in Season 8's "Homer They Fall," Lucius greets Moe in Moe's office/women's bathroom to negotiate a boxing match between Drederick Tatum and Homer, hoping Homer's ability to take punches would create three-rounds of boxing (Homer lasted less than one minute in the first round, when Moe airlifted Homer from the ring to safety.) Winfield's second appearance was in the ninth season's "The Trouble With Trillions," as Lucius can be seen dabbing the sweat from his forehead with cash as he awaits an I.R.S. audit. ("This is an agregious miscarriagement of taxitude!") Drederick Tatum has been seen many, many times since his infamous match with Homer "The Southern Dandy" Simpson. His manager, however, has not. While the real-life Don King has since disappeared from the limelight, his iconic image remains, and Lucius Sweet could have successfully shown up alongside Tatum any time the boxer has made an appearance. Unfortunately for Springfield's boxing fans, Winfield passed away after a lifelong battle with obesity and diabetes in 2004 after suffering a heart attack.

6. George Carlin (1937-2008)

Munchie One of the most popular stand-up comics of his era, George Carlin only ever made his way to Springfield once; in "D'oh-in In The Wind," Carlin voiced "Munchie," a hippie/yuppie alongside Martin Mull's "Seth." Munchie and Seth played a huge part in this episode, as they helped Homer learn his middle name ("From now on, I'm Homer JAY Simpson!") and assisted Homer in a fun "freaking out the squares" segment. Unfortunately, Munchie and Seth's fates are open to interpretation, as Chief Wiggum was apparently set to arrest them due to Homer's inadvertent drugging of the entire town (using the hippies' "secret stash" to make their Garden Blast juice drink) before Homer is shot in the head with a flower. If Munchie did avoid prison, and had Carlin not passed away of heart failure in 2008, both Munchie and Seth could have returned numerous times, including 2008's "Mona Leaves-a" (the death and funeral of fellow hippy Mona Simpson) and as part of the flashbacks in 2012's "How I Wet Your Mother," the last (to date) appearance of Mona, or at any number of protests of Mr. Burns and the Nuclear Power Plants' wrongdoings.

5. Charles Napier (1936-2011)

Charlesnapier1 In Season 12's "Pokey Mom," Marge decided to volunteer at Springfield Penitentiary, teaching an art class to many inmates, including the talented Jack Crowley, voiced by that episode's special guest, Michael Keaton. But also in that episode, voicing The Warden for the first time, was American film tough-guy actor Charles Napier. Napier played the Warden so well, he was invited back three more times to reprise the roll, and later also brought-to-life professional hunter Grant Connor in Season 15's "The Fat and the Furriest" and a completely different prison guard, Officer Krackney, in Season 16's "The Seven-Beer Snitch." With the number of Springfielders who have spent time in jail- and that's the majority of the town- The Warden could have seen as much screen time as Fat Tony or Sideshow Bob. As it is, The Warden was last seen attempting to execute Snake in the electric chair in Season 20's "Gone Maggie Gone," which may have been Napier's last role of any kind (his last film was also released in 2009, The Goods starring Jeremy Piven.) Napier passed away at the age of 75; the exact cause have death has never been released.

4. Ron Taylor (1952-2002)

It was six episodes into the first season ("Moaning Lisa") when Lisa, enveloped with depression, went for a walk late at night and ended up hearing the melodic saxophone sounds of one Bleeding Gums Murphy on a bridge in Springfield. While he didn't play the saxophone in the episode, Ron Taylor did voice the Blues Man, becoming the first "Special Guest" in Simpsons' history. Taylor did not sing The Star Spangled Banner in Season 2's "Dancin' Homer," but would reprise the role in "Round Springfield" in 1995, which was the final official appearance of Bleeding Gums Murphy, as his character passed away, leaving Lisa his saxophone. But in the Simpsons' Universe, a character's death means little to whether or not the character returns, be it in flashbacks or as a throwaway gag. And, given the popularity of Bleeding Gums Murphy, and the relationship he and Lisa shared throughout the series run- Lisa even knit a patch onto her family quilt of his likeness- he could have shown up many, many more times in Springfield. Unfortunately, Taylor died of a heart attack in 2002, seven years after his counterpart Bleeding Gums Murphy.

3. Doris Grau (1924-1995)

Dorisgrau1 The distinctive, raspy voice of Lunch Lady Doris belonged to a former script supervisor on The Simpsons, Doris Grau. First appearing in Season 2's "Bart Gets Hit By A Car," Lunch Lady Doris was as dependable as a secondary character as one could hope for. Working with a terrible budget, she was forced to use gym mats as a meat substitute, and also doubled as Springfield Elementary's school nurse. She is one of the few characters to have a family member frequently appear on screen, as it was implied her son is the Squeaky-Voiced Teen in "Team Homer" (when the teen tells Homer, Apu, and Moe that he couldn't even provide a bowling lane for his own mother, Lunch Lady Doris appears from around the corner to announce, "I have no son.") When Grau passed away from respiratory failure in December of 1995, Lunch Lady Doris was retired for the next decade out of respect (although, because of recording schedules, her voice could be heard as late as 1997, before being silenced following "Lisa's Sax.") She was frequently seen in background shots, but remained a silent character until Season 18's "The Mook, The Chef, The Wife, and Her Homer," when she was voiced by the talented Tress MacNeille. Grau was the first main actor/actress to pass away of The Simpsons' voice-actors, and how the producers handled her character would, unfortunately, set the precedent for how future actors' deaths were handled.

2. Phil Hartman (1948-1998)

Philhartman1 "Hi, this is the-late Phil Hartman. You might remember him as the voice of such Simpsons' characters as Troy McClure, and Lionel Hutz!" The distinctive voice of Philip Edward Hartman brought such life to every character he portrayed on The Simpsons, it was only right that all of his characters be forever retired following his untimely death at the hands of his wife in 1998. Not just his two main characters in crooked lawyer Lionel Hutz and former C-list actor Troy McClure, but every character he was asked to voice: including one-off characters like Bart's "big-brother" Tom; "Undersecretary for International Protocol: Brat and Punk Division" Evan Conover; and traveling musical monorail salesman Lyle Lanley. In the last years of his life, Hartman felt he could make a live-action movie about Troy McClure, and looking at what McClure did in the world of The Simpsons, it certainly would have been fun. McClure hosted "The Simpsons' 138th Episode Spectacular", a half-fictional look at the previous six seasons; he also hosted Season 8's "The Simpsons' Spin-Off Showcase"; and was briefly married to Marge's sister, Selma. But his role of laywer (and shoe-repairer) Lionel Hutz is considered his best by many, and it's hard to argue. Lionel Hutz represented The Simpsons many times in court: suing Mr. Burns when he hit Bart with his car; defending Marge against charges of shop-lifting; (unsuccessfully) fighting for custody of Bart (losing to Mr. Burns); and eventually (and in Hutz's final appearance) taking a second job as a realtor, employing Marge at Red Blazer Realty. Without McClure, other celebrities like Gary Busey and Robert Wagner took brief cameo roles introducing short, educational films. Without Hutz, both the Blue-Haired Lawyer and Gil Gunderson found more time arguing in Springfield Municipal Court. But without Phil Hartman, The Simpsons lost their go-to special guest for any character the writers could come up with, and it's arguable if they've come close to replacing him.

1. Marcia Wallace (1942-2013)

Marciawallace1 The loss of Phil Hartman was more tragic and devastating due to the sudden nature of his death: the 2013 loss of Marcia Wallace to pneumonia and sepsis, however, is still fresh, and- depending how much longer the show continues- time will tell if her death has more of a residual effect on The Simpsons than his. But looking at Mrs. Krabappel's role and past on the show, it will not be difficult to predict that her death will be felt on-screen for years. Wallace's lone character, Mrs. Krabappel was more of a regular-character than any of the other late-actors/actresses' characters listed, and her interactions with Bart as his nemesis, with Principal Skinner and Ned Flanders as a lover, with Rod and Todd as their new step-mother, and with her fellow teachers and administration at Springfield Elementary were each entertaining, funny, and touching in their own rights. Such interactions were always just assumed to forever be a part of the show. With the announcement that Edna will be retired following Wallace's death- and the touching goodbye from her widower Ned and school-bully Nelson at the conclusion of Season 25's "The Man Who Grew Too Much"- the writers/producers are going to either have to "hire" a new teacher for Bart, or stay out of his fourth-grade classroom indefinitely, which will be a huge potential loss of humor for the show. Were there others that I missed you would have liked to have seen? Audrey Meadows as Grandpa's girlfriend Beatrice "Bea" Simmons? Jim Varney as the hoodwinking-carney Cooder? Rod Steiger as Homer's captain in the Navy, Captain Tenille? Share your memories/arguments in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

The 'House is a father of two and husband of one in Minnesota. He is an improv comedian, and in his spare time follows WWE, MLB, The Simpsons, and Bob's Burgers. Growing up he was a huge fan of He-Man, and refuses to believe that it was in fact terrible.