10 Ways Gotham Has Redeemed Itself

From Zero to Hero in three short seasons.

Gotham Season 3
Fox

Back in 2014, there was a lot of excitement swirling around the brand new Fox series called Gotham. Focusing on the dark and crime-ridden city in the days prior to the Batman, Gotham met with mixed reviews and mediocre ratings. Bat-fans expressed disappointment about many factors of the show and the portrayal of their beloved characters (in fact, I wrote about it in an article called "Gotham: 10 Reasons Why It's a Bust”).

Following the first season that was centered around warring mob families, Gotham found a way to reinvent itself and focus on why the city eventually needs Batman: the villains. With a possible Joker in Jerome, the development of the Riddler and the Mad Hatter wreaking havoc across the city, Gotham has finally become the show that fans were hoping it would be.

This evolution did not happen overnight. Once showrunners realized that the strength of the villains is what makes a hero great, they began to shift the story to feature some very familiar faces from the Dark Knight’s rogues gallery. Pitting a young Jim Gordon against the early versions of some of the most iconic characters in comics has resurrected the show and made it a must watch for DC fans around the world.

This dramatic change and several others have transformed Gotham from a show without a future into a fixture of the DC TV experience. What other changes have reshaped Gotham into a Monday Night must see?

10. The Birth Of The Riddler

Edward Nygma Riddler Gotham
Fox

Edward Nygma has always been an intriguing member of Batman’s rogues gallery. Don’t let the costume fool you: under the green leotard lies a cold and calculating criminal mastermind.

In Gotham, Nygma began as a creepy and obsessive employee of the Gotham PD who was in love with his co-worker Kristen Kringle. His social ineptitude not only cost him relationships, but it also cost him viewers. Fans wondered how long he would simply be an awkward co-worker before he would emerge as a terrifying villain. Luckily for fans, in the second season he developed a split personality that would eventually take over as his only personality.

After a short stint in Arkham, the Riddler is now working with The Penguin as part of his mayoral staff. After chasing off Butch and meeting Kristen’s look-alike (who many theorists think is a relative who wants to kill him), Riddler is on track to becoming a fan favorite villain.


9. Team Penguin

Penguin Gotham
Warner Bros.

One of the few highlights from the first season of Gotham was the fall and rise of Oswald Cobblepot. Beginning his career by working for Fish Mooney, he is able to threaten and murder his way to the top of Gotham’s criminal underworld.

In order to keep that power, he had to surround himself with people that could keep him protected. The most important team member to date has been Butch. Having worked for Penguin after being brainwashed, he is able to prove his newfound loyalty by having his hand cut off and spying on Theo Galavan. In the time since then, he has run things in Penguin’s absence and has attempted to undermine his mayoral campaign. Currently on the run, he may prove to be a powerful enemy to his one time boss and advesary.

The other main member of Oswald’s inner circle is Edward Nygma. Having bonded during the second season, their friendship has grown into a full blown bromance. Edward’s cunning and genius have helped Oswald succeed in his new position as Mayor, and has caused Oswald to even look at him romantically. With a complicated relationship with the Riddler and Butch possibly looking for revenge, Penguin’s team may end up helping him rise higher while also ushering in his downfall.


8. Mayor Azreal

Theo Galavan Gotham
Fox

The second season saw the rise of Theo Galavan. New to Gotham himself, Theo came from old Gotham blood with deep ties to the Wayne family. Set upon a course of revenge for dishonoring his family, he took aim at the only remaining Wayne alive, Bruce.

Going as far as recruiting a team of Arkham criminals, he begins a string of horrible crime that only he could clean up. Betraying his own team, he kills Jerome in front of a stunned crowd and is instantly branded a hero. By tricking the citizens of the city into electing him their hero mayor, he instantly became the most powerful man in Gotham City. After James Gordon discovered his secrets, he tortures Gordon (a popular pastime for Gotham villains) with his plans knowing that there is nothing he can do to stop him.

Before eventually falling to Gordon and the Penguin, Galavan shows an amazing ability to fight that serves him well in his second life as Hugo Strange’s brainwashed hitman Azrael.

As many comic readers know, Azreal is an anti-hero who sometimes helps Batman and has even filled in for him. On Gotham, he is simply a misguided tool of the evil Hugo Strange. Committing more murders and attacks, Azreal becomes a terrifying figure before he meets his end by way of Butch’s rocket launcher in the Wayne driveway. Not only was he a powerful and merciless character in both of his lives, he also represented the first person of Batman’s team (though he was a villainous version) to appear in costume on Gotham.


7. James In Wonderland

Gotham Season 3 Mad Hatter Actor
Fox

One thing that Gotham really improved upon is making the villains more terrifying. One of the most intriguing examples is the latest baddie, The Mad Hatter. In the comics, he is a master manipulator that can bend people to his will and is obsessed with Alice in Wonderland.

On the streets of Gotham, he is a vengeful opponent who will stop at nothing to make James Gordon pay for the death of his beloved sister. What Gotham has done so well is to change his look enough to make him appear genuinely scary, but they also extended his storyline. Instead of making him a villain of the week, they stretched out his torture of Gordon in order to show how powerful and evil he truly is.

By giving the criminals of Gotham extended looks, the show can develop each villain instead of making them the one-off baddies that many other series do. By taking each of the rogues seriously, the show starts to illustrate why the city will eventually need The Dark Knight.


6. The Rise Of Barbara Kean

Gotham Barbara
Warner Bros. Television Studios

Barbara Kean has come a long way since she was the confused and annoying girlfriend of straight arrow (at the time) cop James Gordon. When the show began, fans did not know what was going on with her. She was confused and confusing at the same time. Luckily, showrunners were able to sort her out and actually make her interesting.

Since her days as Gordon’s girlfriend, she has murdered her parents, had a stint in Arkham, broke out of said mental institution, and has even opened a nightclub. With her character planted firmly in the villains’ camp, she has been free to attack her ex and work with the Penguin while beginning to build a reputation in Gotham’s underworld.

As a villain, it is obvious that she loves to torture James Gordon (she is not alone) and enjoys being his connection to Gotham’s criminals, which keeps him coming back to her. In a happy business and romantic relationship with Tabitha Galavan, and even serving as James’ hallucinogenic tour guide, she has slowly evolved and become a character that fans can get behind.


5. The Fall Of James Gordon

Jim Gordon Gotham
Fox

One of the three pillars of the show (along with Penguin and Bruce Wayne), James Gordon started off as straight-laced cop who was going to change the corrupt culture of the GCPD (as he did in the comics). Because that narrative was too predictable, Gotham’s showrunners decided to tear him down before they build him back up.

After refusing to kill the Penguin in the first season, his morality made him a target of criminals and other police officers. Over time, he began to see the hopelessness of his cause and even turned to Oswald Cobblepot for help with the department. With Penguin’s help never coming free, James was forced to murder a rival crime boss in return for Penguin’s favor. Further incriminating himself, he helped Penguin kill Mayor Theo Galavan before eventually being arrested and sent to prison.

Refusing to take back his badge after being exonerated, he became a bounty hunter and began dating Valerie Vale after his relationship with Lee Thompkins fell apart. After being put through hell by Jervis Tetch and losing his new lady love, Gordon finally returned to the GCPD more humble and driven than ever before.

While James Gordon’s terrible experiences from the last couple of seasons have completely changed his way of thinking, it makes his character much more interesting when he falls so far before his eventual rise.


4. Bruce Wayne

Bruce And Selina Gotham
Fox

When the show first aired in 2014, one of the three main characters featured (with Gordon and Penguin being the other two) was the young and recently orphaned Bruce Wayne. Following the death of his parents, he came off as a whiny pre-teen with a chip on his shoulder and was one of the weak points in the show early on.

In the following two seasons, he has come into his own. Living on the streets with Salina, training to fight with Alfred, and calling out his company’s board for the murder of his parents have all shown hints of the man that he will become. By making him more calculating and mature, showrunners have developed him into a character that fans can follow and enjoy watching.

In the most recent season, he dropped the investigation into his parent’s deaths due to the threats by the Council of Owls. While some saw this as Bruce being defeated, many others saw it as a sign of intelligence to know when he does not have the upper hand and to live to fight another day. Throw in his complicated relationship with Salina Kyle and his strange doppelganger and Bruce will have some very big challenges ahead while he continues to slowly move towards the cape and cowl.


3. The House Of Hugo

Hugo Strange Gotham
Fox

One thing the freshman season of Gotham was missing was an exciting villain. With Fish Mooney, Penguin, and Salvatore Maroni fighting for control of Gotham’s crime, fans yawned and wondered where the interesting villains were hiding.

It turns out they were hiding under Arkham Asylum. With the backing of the Council of Owls, Dr. Hugo Strange was operating a superhuman monster factory. Experimenting with the dead and the living, there was no ethical line Strange would not cross. By using his experiments to breathe new life into Fish Mooney and Theo Galavan, he proved to be a powerful and dangerous villain.

With his lab giving rise to Mr. Freeze, Azrael, Firefly, and many others, Hugo Strange flooded the streets of Gotham with super-powered criminals and finally gave fans what they wanted. Now that he has been kidnapped by a sickly Fish Mooney, fans can expect an exciting new batch of familiar bat-baddies to arrive when Mooney eventually returns to take down the Penguin and take over the city.


2. A Side Of Fish

Gotham Fish Mooney Jada Pinkett Smith
Fox

One of the weakest plot points in the first season revolved around the crime boss Fish Mooney. While she was seen by showrunners as a strong new female character in the bat-mythos, many fans saw her as a corny, overacted villain with no likeable traits. In a genre where the villains are just as beloved as the heroes, she appeared to be an odd choice for a criminal mastermind in Gotham.

Following her death at the end of the first season, she was mostly absent from the second season. When she was finally brought back to life in Hugo Strange’s lab, she had been shown to have developed powers. She had the ability to influence people to do her bidding by simply touching them. What made her abilities interesting was that every time she used it, she would become weaker and closer to death.

While her character can still be annoying, her story has vastly improved. Last seen slipping through Penguin’s fingers with Hugo Strange in tow, she has vowed to make a big return with an army of super-powered followers (created by Strange) to take over the city. If she can make good on her promise, she may prove to be a major factor when Mayor Penguin eventually falls from power.


1. Jerome The Joker?

Gotham Joker Jerome
Fox

From the outset of the series, showrunners wanted to present fans with several possible people that would eventually become the Joker. With an unclear past in the comics, Gotham did not have a model to follow when presenting a young Clown Prince of Crime. That all changed during the second season.

Enter Jerome. Jerome was a psychopath who was freed from Arkham in Theo Galavan’s jailbreak. While working for Galavan, he gleefully murdered people and cackled in a very Joker-esque way. His sheer enjoyment shown during his killing spree made many people believe that he would don the white makeup and purple suit. Unfortunately, only a few episodes into his reign of terror, he was murdered by Galavan who was attempting to look like a hero.

With Jerome being the closest that Gotham fans have had to seeing Batman’s arch nemesis, many were very excited before feeling let down by his seemingly quick death. What they did not know at the time is that Jerome will return. He has not yet been seen in the third season, but it is very likely that his body made its way into Hugo Strange’s lab. With dead villains returning even more dangerous than they were before, imagine Jerome after rising from the dead.


In this post: 
Batman Gotham
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Daniel is a husband of one and a father of 4 and an Office Manager in the desert of Apple Valley, California. He has a Bachelor Degree in Organizational Leadership from Azusa Pacific University. He is a big fan of all things superhero. Please follow him on Twitter @TV_Nerd_Dude.