10 Ways Lost Was Almost Completely Changed

Lost...but starring Batman! Sort of.

Lost was a necessary sacrifice. Much like how we suffered through the total mess of Batman And Robin to get the gritty reboot of Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight films, or how your town will sacrifice a virginal Catholic police man in a giant wicker effigy to ensure a good harvest in the coming year, Lost died on its feet so that many more could live. But at least it burnt brightly and loudly before then. Ultimately, nobody was particularly happy with how Lost turned out. Fans who had been tuning into ABC's hit mystery series from the very beginning didn't get all the answers they wanted, and the few they were granted access to were far from satisfying. By that point they'd gone through so many plot twists and time travel shenanigans that they were few and dedicated compared to the blockbuster viewership it had at the start. Still, the gamble ABC took on the show partially lead to the current TV drama renaissance, in a way. The likes of Breaking Bad, Mad Men and Hannibal might never have happened if Lost hadn't made the medium look like a viable place to tell these prolonged, weird stories. Even if they never quite get as weird as Demond, the polar bear and the smoke monster. In the end, the show was a noble failure, with ideas above its station and a lot of concepts that didn't quite come off as well as they did. But what ideas they were! It might have ended very differently, however. And began in an unrecognisable manner. And starred...Batman, actually. Here are ten ways Lost could've been totally different.

10. Jack Was Going To Die (And Be Played By Michael Keaton)

Lost wound up amassing one of the most iconic casts on television for a spell, even if most of the actors ended up...not really doing a whole lot once their names were out there. Evangeline Lilly is making up for lost time for adding a double x chromosome to the world of The Hobbit, and Josh Holloway was great in that one episode of Community, but for the most part... ...Matthew Fox, especially, has been absent from our screens since the show wrapped, besides doing the method body transformation thing to play a sinewy serial killer in an Alex Cross movie. His mysterious doctor Jack wound up becoming the de facto leader of his fellow island crash survivors early on in Lost's life. Originally, though, he was supposed to get killed off in the first episode €“ presumably so that you'd know that NOBODY IS SAFE. Also ABC wanted Michael Keaton to play Jack, not this no-name Fox character, which would've been a neat bit of stunt casting to get people tuning in, and killing him off meant not having to spend most of the budget on his salary.

9. And Everyone Else Was Different Too

The casting process is a fickle, malleable thing, both in film and TV. With Lost's expansive ensemble there are an almost infinite number of different combinations to the one that ended up on our screens (at least for the first three seasons, before most of us saw sense and started turning them off). Much like Mad Men, if the auditions had gone just a tiny bit differently, you'd've been looking at a whole different cast. With Michael Keaton being in line to play Jack €“ and then only for one episode €“ Evangeline Lilly's Kate was supposed to emerge as the lead character who all the rest of the survivors look up to. Except in that case she probably wouldn't have been played by Lilly, since the original Kate was envisioned as a middle-aged businesswoman whose husband apparently died in the crash. Which ended up becoming the MO of Rose later down the road. Dominic Monaghan eventually killed it as druggie rocker and Penny Boat truther Charlie, but he at first auditioned for Sawyer. If that sounds unbelievable, know that Josh Holloway's character started life as a slick suit-wearing city con man, and it was only when Holloway auditioned and blew up after forgetting his lines they altered Sawyer. Oh and Sayid? Created especially for Naveen Andrews when he auditioned. Imagine Lost with no Sayid!

8. It Could've Been Cheap

Lost was not a cheap show to make. That feature length pilot episode cost somewhere in the region of $10 million, which puts it up there with your smaller-scale Hollywood productions; at the time, the average budget for a TV pilot episode was more like $4 million. It was such a risky and costly move that Disney, ABC's parent company, actually fired network head Lloyd Braun for the decision. Then Lost debuted, was a huge hit, and they were kind of committed to carrying it on. After all, it was ratings gold. Ratings gold that €“ by virtue of being set on a desert island €“ was mostly shot on location, in Hawaii, which cost a heck of a lot more than if they'd just build a few sets they could re-use all the time like most weekly dramas. Between the large cast and location shooting Lost cost $4 million per episode to make. That wasn't in the original plan, however; the initial pitch for the show suggested that the characters would live in a €œprimitive Melrose Place€ (referencing the soap opera set in an apartment complex) that could be built on a soundstage.

7. It Was A Cop/Medical/Law Room/Character Drama

As it happens, that €œseries bible€ €“ cooked up by creator Damon Lindeolf and writers Javier Grillo-Marxuach, Paul Dini, Jennifer Johnson and Christian Taylor €“ was full of promises that Lost absolutely did not keep. Such as the suggestion that the show would be a blend of a handful of familiar TV formats that audiences were used to, and it would rotate through them regularly. That pitch admits that the €œfranchise€ doesn't fit easily into an existing mould but that it is, in fact, simply a Frankenstein's monster stitched together from a bunch of existing formats: it's a medical show (€œlike an episode of ER€)! It's a cop show! It's a lawyer show! It's a character drama (€œall the stories that populate an episode of The OC play out here on our island€)! It's clear that they were reaching to try and sell the show to the network, but also that they didn't really know what the show was at that point. If they'd made good on all those promises Lost would have been an unwieldy mess. And apparently much more formulaic, procedural and soap opera-like.

6. There Would Be No Ultimate Mystery

Oh yeah, this is the big one. €œThere is no 'Ultimate Mystery' which requires solving,€ they claim. Now go ahead and have a long, bitter laugh, then let's continue. Eventually Lost fell victim to JJ Abrams' obsessive need to turn everything he works on into a €œmystery box€, the elaborate delivery system for a series of MacGuffins that rarely pay off. He's even doing it with the next Star Wars film at this very moment! Lost was his piece de resistance when it came to mystery boxes, though. So the initial assurance that no such thing would ever appear in Lost is interesting. This is, after all, the pitch they used to sell the show to ABC, meaning they at least initially intended to stick by it. Either that, or Lindeolf and co are the most ballsy group of con artists this side of Hustle. In fact, the same document claimed that any mysteries that did appear in the show would be cleared up pretty quickly. The infamous smoke monster, whose origins never really were cleared up, was supposed to be revealed to be a security system for the island's owners, and that was to come up within the first few episodes. Lost without an ultimate mystery might not have been such a hit...but it would've been way less frustrating.

5. The Hatch Could've Appeared Way Earlier

In the end, The Hatch and all the ensuing revelations about the Dharma Initiative and Desmond and the like, didn't get revealed until Lost's second season. Locke stumbled across it in the first season's eleventh episode, €œAll The Best Cowboys Have Daddy Issues€, and he didn't succeed at opening the darn thing until the two-part finale €œExodus€. And still fans had to wait. What was actually down that wretched hole wasn't shown until the show returned for its second go-around, a cliffhanger that was genius and irritating in equal manner. At that point, Lost had already reneged on its claim to tie up the mysteries it brought to light, with countless unanswered questions already piling up. Again, that wasn't the plan. JJ Abrams wanted The Hatch to appear in the pilot episode, even though he wasn't sure what was under it. He just liked mysteries. Lindeolf managed to hold off until episode ten, when they had some idea about the pay-off. Introducing it earlier would've made the reveal either more satisfying...or like it had been even more delayed than it already was.

4. Walt Was Supposed To Be Psychic

So whatever happened to Walter Lloyd? The purportedly 10-year-old son of Harold Perrineau's absent father Michael Dawson, he began as an integral part of the main ensemble €“ the sole kid, before Claire's baby was born, with his own angst and baggage that could be further elucidated with those pesky flashbacks. Then he went ahead and got kidnapped by The Others. Which was only part of the story, because once Michael had managed to track his kidnapped son down on the other side of the island, The Other wound up releasing him voluntarily. He was €œmore than they could handle.€ What did that mean? It never got explained, but Walt and his dad left the show. That was because actor Malcolm David Kelley was growing up too quickly, but initially the plan was to reveal that Walt was a powerful psychic. Yup. Not only that, but he could apparently communicate telepathically with animals, and that was going to the explanation for the polar bear showing up on the island. Lost eventually got a little more wacky and supernatural, but having that concept introduced too early on would've just tipped it into ridiculousness.

3. The Sci-Fi Stuff May Have Been Heavier

In fact, Walt's emergent psychic powers were just the tip of the iceberg for the weird science fiction fare Lost might have introduced. Eventually the show went full genre (despite, again, claiming otherwise in the early pitch document) with all that time travel malarkey in season five, but before that the show was actively resisting those urges. It was a prestige drama, not The X-Files! But it so clearly wanted to be The X-Files. Or rather, The Twilight Zone, with that opening title and weird noise inspired by the classic sci-fi series and put together by JJ Abrams. It was the weirder, more esoteric and supernatural elements of Lost that drew Abrams in in the first place, and by his suggestion that they were heightened. Still, it took a while for that to really take hold. The studio resisted the sci-fi elements, but the Walt thing was very clearly supposed to be more in that vein. Eventually the time travel thing happened, but if Abrams and the crew had gotten their way, there might have been even more weird fantasy stuff earlier than that. Like Batman being a doctor who dies in the pilot, for example.

2. Or Totally Non-Existent

On the other hand, with the involvement of Abrams, the show might never have gone full sci-fi. In that pitch document, the watch words aren't genre shows €“ they sold Lost by invoking the likes of desert island movie Castaway, where Tom Hanks' FedEx product placement is stranded on a beach with only a volleyball for company, and desert island reality show Survivor, which was still a big hit then and everyone wanted in on its huge moneys. €œOur mandate is to give LOST the same treatment as a Michael Crichton novel. Every time we introduce an element of the fantastic, we approach it from a real place. If we do it right, the 'paranormal' will always be coupled with a logical explanation to remind the audience that this is the real world.€ Those are the exact words that follow the Castaway/Lost comparison. So if they had followed that initial line of thinking, Lost would've been a weird show €“ but all that weirdness could've been explained away somehow. It would've been even more grounded than The X-Files, which offered rational explanations for aliens and stuff right up until the point it didn't. Lost might very well have been a conventional drama. A grown-up Gilligan's Island.

1. Self-Contained, Not Serialised

The biggest laugh to be gained from reading that document is the idea that Lost was conceived to be a self-contained show, not a sprawling epic. The idea is that their might be an overarching plot that tied everything together, but that mostly new viewers could drop in and watch any episode without feeling confused. Each episode would tell a complete story with a beginning, middle and end. That's where the claim it would be a cross between a cop show, a soap opera, a courtroom drama and medical series makes more sense. The idea wasn't for Lost to prefigure the highly serialised likes of Mad Men and Breaking Bad, but for it to fit into the standard for TV dramas. It was more like a police procedural, with an active €œcase€ in each episode, so that they could be watched without any prior knowledge of the show or characters. Eventually, that €œultimate mystery€ they also claimed not to be doing and the huge ensemble cast meant that was impossible, but seriously €“ if they'd kept to that, Lost would be a totally different show. No time travel stuff. No losing characters at random. No unanswered questions. But probably also no polar bear, or Hatch, or Desmond, or The Others, or the weird stuff that made Lost great. The fear of serialisation came from the failure of JJ Abrams' Alias. In the end it was sort of a waste of time, but when Lost was on, it was really on. Any of these little differences had happened, it would have been a totally different €“ and possibly not quite as good a show.

In this post: 
Lost
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/