10 Ways Sons Of Anarchy Must Continue

Prequel, or spin-off? Why not both? Here's how it could happen.

For at least two years now, Sons Of Anarchy creator and showrunner Kurt Sutter has been mulling over the idea of a prequel show about the formation of the titular outlaw motorcycle club. Cable network FX is understandably delighted about the idea: Sons Of Anarchy remains its biggest ever hit in 20 years of broadcasting. As soon as the seventh and final season concluded, however, talk started up again in earnest, and Sutter and FX haven€™t been a huge part of the conversation. Some people remain convinced that the prequel has been greenlit, that scripts and creatives are being sourced and courted, and that Charlie Hunnam is in talks to reprise his role as original protagonist Jackson Teller €“ there€™s even one going around that Brad Pitt has already signed on to play his father. Stuff and nonsense, naturally€ but for those pining for some rough n€™ ready biker action, there is a light at the end of the tunnel, and just for a change it€™s not an oncoming train. Sutter has finally confirmed that there are still tentative plans to put together a prequel about the first nine men to form the Sons Of Anarchy Motorcycle Club €“ the Redwood Original. That€™s SAMCRO, to you and me: and that€™s not all. Likely to see production before any prequel is a spin-off to the original show, one based upon the Mayans, the Hispanic-only rival MC to the Sons. Fans of the show may wish it was the other way around, that the prequel took priority, but Sutter€™s busy with his new show, The Bast*rd Executioner, and won€™t be available to ride out any time soon. The spin-off, however, would need a different showrunner, a new take and a fresh pair of eyes. Either way, prequel or spin-off, it looks as though Sons Of Anarchy isn€™t quite over yet. These are the ways it should go from here.

10. The Spin-Off Needs To Be Far From California

Any contemporary spin-off needs to be set as far from the northern California home of SAMCRO as possible without actually leaving the western USA. The idea of the untamed west is synonymous with the concept of the outlaw: Sons Of Anarchy wouldn€™t have worked if it was based on the east coast, the civilised urbanised cradle of the United States. The midwest is all homespun farmland; the south has its own character. But if not California, then where? Breaking Bad had the right idea. New Mexico is the perfect place to set a Mayan spin-off to Sons Of Anarchy. The Mayans control vast areas of California and Nevada, but don€™t have as large a presence in New Mexico, allowing for greater conflict. New Mexico shares borders with Oklahoma, Colorado, Arizona, Texas, two states in Mexico and Utah (via the Four Corners), and has the largest percentage of Hispanics of any state in the Union, representing the descendants of the Spaniards that colonised the area four centuries ago. It€™s famous for its arid, rugged desert scrublands €“ but New Mexico has heavily forested mountainous areas with snow-capped peaks. It€™s a different world to the permanent blue skies and long lazy roads of the Golden State, and it would bring a different feel to any spin-off, essential to giving the new show a fresh identity.

9. It Needs A Hook

Sons Of Anarchy began with a familiar narrative cut and pasted from Shakespeare: the bare bones of the plot to Hamlet formed the skeleton of Sutter€™s story. Jackson was the young prince who€™d lost his father, Clay the uncle who€™d married his mother and taken his father€™s mantle and authority. That€™s not to say that the show didn€™t eventually surpass this initial conceit, because of course it did €“ and Jax isn€™t Hamlet, in temperament or disposition. But any spin-off from Sons Of Anarchy needs its own hook to hang the story on, either a high-concept idea or some form of framework that holds it together. Sons Of Anarchy had Jackson wanting to bring himself out of the corrupting influence of Clay€™s version of the club, to keep his family from being infected, maybe even to save the club itself. No matter what plot points happened around him, that was the core of Jax€™ narrative, and his failure was the arc that defined the show, the spine of the whole thing. Sutter is convinced that an Hispanic MC will have its own ethos, its own vibe, distinct from the outlaw pretensions of the mostly white members of SAMCRO. A show based around the Mayans will need a centre to the story that is wholly its own.

8. A Change Is As Good As A Rest

While it would be tempting to bring in Marcus lvarez as a familiar face, the president of the Oakland chapter of the Mayans has his own territory to maintain, especially given that, following the bloody manoeuvring of season seven, he now has the IRA guns coming into the area through his MC. That gives him guns, heroin and prostitution, the RICO trifecta€ lvarez is going to have his hands full for quite a while. No, we shouldn€™t see any familiar faces for a while, to build up a new cast and allow the show to find its feet. That€™s not to say that cameos and guest appearances from the parent show wouldn€™t be rewarding for the audience at certain points, of course. There are even a few members of SAMCRO still alive at the end of season seven. Even outlaws need to go on vacation occasionally, and there€™s a Sons Of Anarchy chapter in New Mexico€

7. A Real Sense Of Authenticity

Sutter€™s gone on record as saying that any Mayan spin-off will need a showrunner that understands what that means, preferably someone with an Hispanic heritage. Not him, in other words €“ and there€™ll need to be other changes to reflect the racial and cultural make-up of the Mayan MC. Race was never an issue for the Sons except as a signifier of otherness: it was something other people had to deal with, a way of marking other gangs in a convenient shorthand, black, brown and yellow. That€™s to be expected: the MC was all white except for Juice, and even there the poor boy was convinced that his mixed race heritage would be a deal breaker for the club if they found out. The Hispanic and Latino point of contact with their culture, language and history €“ their heritage €“ is a shifting sand of perspective and pride that doesn€™t have an equivalence in white culture, and that would be a big part of any Mayan Sons Of Anarchy spin-off.

6. Different Strokes For Different Folks

Not only would the racial and cultural touchstones be completely unique to the spin-off, but should the new show be set in a completely different state, then all manner of other differences might come into play. For example: New Mexico has the most lax firearms laws in the USA. Gun control is far less strict there than anywhere else, and a New Mexico resident may buy any gun that€™s legal under federal law. There are no waiting periods under state law until you can own a weapon, and no legal restrictions on assault weapons or magazine size. It€™s also legal to openly carry a firearm without a permit€ unless the owner of the property you€™re in has specifically excluded firearms on their premises. Violating that €˜opt out€™ clause by bringing a firearm in is a felony. There are all kinds of different rules and legislation depending on where the show decides to hang its hat.

5. Keeping Out Of Cartel Business

The cartels operate on cocaine, for the most part. Colombia used to be the centre of cocaine production, and has only recently been matched by Peru as the world€™s biggest producer of marching powder. The Mayans, on the other hand, prefer heroin and prostitution to cocaine. It€™s possible that, in the absence of any real competing interests, the MC might have been left alone to continue trading. That climate has changed radically in the past few years, however. Opiate production in Mexico has soared, and US consumption of heroin has actually doubled between 2007 and 2013. It might be that the cartels are no longer prepared to allow the Mayans to control the heroin trade, leading to all manner of bloody shenanigans. Add to that the gang mentality and their natural recourse to conflict resolution via violent means, and you€™ve got a potential powderkeg situation. Sex trafficking is also on the rise, and the Mayans€™ other revenue stream is prostitution. While SAMCRO refused to touch drugs or girls as a rule, believing themselves above the lower kinds of victim crimes, the Mayans have no such hypocritical scruples. It looks as though the turf wars that characterised storylines in Sons Of Anarchy wouldn€™t be going away any time soon.

4. Recasting Is A Dangerous Game

To the casual observer, it would appear that a prequel to Sons Of Anarchy would have a far easier job of getting over with fans of the original series than the putative Mayan spin-off show. That€™s not necessarily the case, however. The key issue in creating a prequel that vibes with fans€™ expectations is casting. Speculation as to whether a name actor would be tapped to play John Teller, Jackson€™s father: currently, the completely baseless rumour has Brad Pitt about to sign on. Casting someone to carry that heavily hyped and iconic character would be hard enough, but the show will also need to recast some of Sons Of Anarchy€™s most famous roles for their younger selves. That includes Opie€™s dad Piermont €˜Piney€™ Winston and Lenny €˜The Pimp€™ Janowitz€ and at some point, Clay Morrow, who was the last of the First Nine to join the club in 1972, and Gemma Madock, who met John Teller in 1978 in a whirlwind romance. How on earth can any young actor be expected to follow heavyweights like Ron Perlman and Katey Sagal? They€™d have to be cast for their looks as well as their talent in order for audiences to suspend disbelief. Recasting such well-known faces is a dangerous game.

3. It Was The Style At The Time

The times make the men. Piney and John are the nucleus of SAMCRO at the very beginning: Vietnam veterans who served together, they returned from the war to find, like other vets, that public opinion was against them and the mood of America sour when it came to talk of the war. Disenfranchised and disillusioned, John and Piney find themselves alienated from society itself. John Teller€™s manuscript makes it clear that he considered the formation of the Sons Of Anarchy as a revolutionary act, a way of stepping outside of the culture he was born into and that rejected him upon his return from Vietnam. That€™s his version of the sixties counter culture: personally radical but politically disinterested. It€™ll be fascinating to see how the prequel deals with the sixties and seventies period setting, and how that setting affects the central characters. Only time will tell: but Sutter€™s certainly got his work cut out for him when he€™s able to devote the time to crafting the prequel properly.

2. The Real First Nine

John€™s idealistic view of the MC he created appears to have been shared by Piney back in the day, but do the other First Nine share his concerns, or were they always out to make a fast, bloody buck? Six of the First Nine were war veterans, so that tells us something. However, given that we€™ve only got anecdotal evidence of what the first days of the club were like, it€™ll be interesting to see what the founding eight men were like before crime, violence and mayhem turned them into walking scars: back when the Sons Of Anarchy was a lifestyle choice and a mission statement, rather than a secretive organisation running afoul of the federal government. Added to that, Piney and John founded the club in 1967, and Clay was the last of the First Nine to join in 1968 as a nineteen year old prospect €“ he too served in €˜Nam, and was formally patched in on his return in 1972. So what was the young Clay Morrow like? He and John were clearly close, as they opened the Teller-Morrow bodyshop together€ will we get to see that relationship change? How far will the prequel take us €“ from the birth of the club to John€™s death, or will it stop at Jackson€™s birth in 1978?

1. Keep The Core Of The Show Intact

Regardless of whether it€™s a spin-off or a prequel, and regardless of any change in character, locale or setting, it€™s important that the centre of the show remain Sons Of Anarchy. Let€™s not forget what drew everyone to this show in the first place: humour blacker than the crows that bookend it, partnered with intense, visceral melodrama and sudden fearless violence, and characters that defy categorisation or convention. All the best continuations of successful shows forge ahead with their own identity while never losing sight of where they came from and how it is that they€™ve come about. Given that Kurt Sutter seems constitutionally incapable of compromise, it seems pretty clear that should Sons Of Anarchy return in any format and at any time, it€™ll retain the same storytelling integrity it had before. What are you looking forward to in a Sons Of Anarchy spin-off or prequel? Would you prefer a sequel, and how do you see that turning out? Tell us all about it in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.