10 Ways The Boys TV Show Is Different From The Comics

When The Boys' comic transitioned to tv, a lot of things had to be changed.

The Boys Season 3
Sony

In recent years, filmgoers have complained that the superhero genre had become oversaturated. Even though most comic films are solid, audiences are starting to tire of the same old tropes like origin stories, villain monologues, and saving the world at the last second. To stay relevant, the genre was in desperate need of a shake-up.

That's why Amazon's adaptation of the Garth Ennis' comic series, The Boys, felt like it couldn't have come out at a better time. It is set in a world where "Supes" have become so corrupt, a group of vigilantes called The Boys band together to expose them. The series was an instant hit due to it's over-the-top violence and dark humour.

Because the comic is so gory and vulgar, fans were worried the adaptation would be heavily toned down. Although this wasn't the case, there have been some major changes.

The structure and premise of the show was the same at first, but each episode has diverted more and more from the source material. By the end of season one, Amazon's The Boys had become so different, even comic fans have no idea what to expect next.

(It goes without saying that this list will contain some minor spoilers.)

10. The Deep's Entire Story Arc

The Deep The Boys
Dynamite Entertainment

In the show, The Deep is an aquatic member of The Seven who goes through an existential crisis after he is outed as a sexual predator. Despite playing a major role in the first two seasons, The Deep is the least significant team member in the original saga.

When Starlight is asked to join The Seven in the comic, she is sexually assaulted by Homelander, A-Train, and Black Noir, not The Deep. In fact, this marine superhero is the only male member of the team who isn't a sex-crazed lunatic. He makes it clear that he isn't fond of Starlight, but he never acts monstrously towards her. Throughout the story, his main concern is making money from merchandise.

His physical appearance in the comic is also dramatically different, as in the comics The Deep is a Black man who wears a very heavy looking diver suit. He can physically take off his headgear but refuses to (even when he has sex), since his employer, Vought, devised a backstory for his "character" which states an Atlantean curse has damned him to wear his helmet forever.

Despite the fact he is depicted with gills on his abdomen in the show, he does not share this trait in the comics.


9. A-Train

A-Train The Boys
Dynamite Entertainment

While Hughie is on a date with his girlfriend, Robin, the lightning-quick superhero, A-Train, zooms through her, shredding her to pieces. It is this incident that inspires Billy Butcher to ask Hughie to join his squad to take down the Supes. The Amazon series also shows that A-Train has a rivalry with a speedster called Shockwave, and a relationship with a Wolverine-inspired superheroine called Popclaw.

However, Shockwave was completely invented for the show. Popclaw was in the comic, but she had a very minor role and never met A-Train at any point. His heart problems and his addiction to Compound V were also created for the television adaptation.

In the comic, A-Train was the newest and youngest member of The Seven before Starlight joined. Because of his lack of experience, he isn't respected by his teammates or Vought, giving him a propensity to lash out. He constantly chastises Starlight, even when he is in front of Vought members, and tries to rape her while on a mission.

The only Seven member he gets on with is Jack from Jupiter (who was cut from the series), probably because he is the only one who is as sexually depraved as A-Train.


8. Madelyn Stillwell And Stan Edgar

Boys Stillwell
Dynamite

The CEO of Vought, Stan Edgar, hired Madelyn Stillwell to serve as the vice-president of hero management, making her responsible for The Seven. Edgar only appeared in one episode in season one, but has become a major adversary for The Boys as well as Homelander in season two.

Mr. Edgar is the CEO of Vought in the comics but he never makes an appearance. In one issue, it's casually mentioned that he passed away and he's rarely mentioned again after that.

Madelyn Stillwell is based on the character James Stillwell; a high-ranking assistant at Vought. He is much more hands-on than his television counterpart since he orchestrates coups, orders the extermination of certain Supes, and commands Stormfront to kill The Boys. He may share the same name as Elisabeth Shue's character but his cold, calculated manner is more in line with Giancarlo Esposito's performance as Stan Edgar.

Gender-swapping Stillwell for the show was a great idea, since it allowed her to use a mother-son relationship with Homelander to keep the superhero in line as she fulfils his desperate need to be loved and understood.


7. The Legend

The Boys Legend
Dynamite

The Legend is nowhere to be seen in The Boys adaptation (for now) but he is a major player in the original story. He is a comic-book seller who was in charge of Vought's publishing series, Victory Comics.

When he learned his son perished in the Vietnam war after using a faulty gun, the Legend was utterly devastated. Having later learned the rifle that killed his son was produced by Vought, he vowed to dismantle the corrupt organisation - and so, serves as an informant for Butcher.

When Hughie joined the team, Butcher set up meetings with the Legend to educate Hughie about the origin of Compound V, the inner workings of Vought, and the history of The Seven. He had another son with Queen Maeve called Blarney C*ck, but had such an antagonistic relationship with him, Legend congratulated Hughie when he learned he killed him.

His character is a handy way to dole out exposition, so it's unknown why he was removed from the show. It's possible he may be introduced later in the series but there has been no mention of him yet.


6. THAT Airplane Scene

Homelander Plane
Dynamite

One of the most horrifying moments in The Boys is when Homelander fails to save a hijacked plane from crashing. This incident was taken directly from the comic but there are some big differences.

First off, the plane crash occurred five years ago. Secondly, this wasn't a random flight; it was THE Plane that was meant to crash into the Twin Towers during 9/11. Vought sent The Seven to reclaim control of the plane, believing it would be a masterful PR move.

But when The Supes entered the plane, it depressurised the cabin, causing the passengers to panic. When Homelander screamed for everyone to settle, his superpowered vocal chords caused the passengers' eardrums to explode, killing most of them.

Believing the mission was a lost cause, Homelander abandoned his team, resulting in the death of his teammate, Marathon Man. Queen Maeve became so disillusioned after seeing Homelander's callousness, she became a drunk and sex addict.

Homelander diverted the plane's path so it didn't crash into the Twin Towers but was unable to stop it from colliding into The Brooklyn Bridge, causing thousands of deaths. It was The Seven's gross negligence of this hijacking which encouraged the CIA agent, Mallory, to reform The Boys.


5. Kimiko

The Female The Boys
Dynamite Entertainment

Kimiko is a mute Supe who serves as The Boys' muscle. When she and her brother were children, they were smuggled to the US where they were forcibly injected with Compound V. When Butcher learned Vought intended to turn her into a supervillain for a scheme to militarise The Seven, he agreed to led her join The Boys.

In the comic, the character has no siblings and is only as known as The Female of the Species. Her father was crushed by female sumo wrestler (not sure why that wasn't incorporated into the show) and her mother worked in a Vought-like company in Tokyo. Since the mother was too frugal to pay for a babysitter, she routinely brought the Female to work when she was a baby. One day, the child wandered into another room and fell in Compound V, giving her superstrength.

The comic version of The Female is far less stable and will eviscerate anyone, friend or foe, if they touch her (save for Frenchie). When Hughie tried to reassure her when she was injured, she instinctively snapped his arm in two. She also works as a mafia enforcer to help quench her murderous urges.


4. Jack From Jupiter's Absence 

Jack From Jupiter The Boys
Dynamite Entertainment

Since The Boys series is seventy-two issues long (excluding tie-ins), there are slew of Supes that can be incorporated into the show. Even though the series is still relatively new, the writers have concocted several superpowered characters including Doppelgänger, Ryan Butcher, Shockwave, Kenji, and Mesmer.

Not only are the showrunners adding characters, they also removing some. For the show, The Seven member, Jack From Jupiter, was swapped out for the invisible Supe, Translucent.

Jack is a supposed extra-terrestrial who becomes momentarily invincible if he says the word "Carpo". Despite this immense power, he is one of the few Supes that doesn't possess superstrength, and so is regarded as the weakest member of The Seven. He may be a hedonistic cannibal and relentless drug-user, but Jack acts as the voice of reason of the group, and has broken up conflicts between his teammates on several occasions.

It's uncertain why the character was removed from the series, but fans speculate it has to do with his unusual appearance. Because of his unique complexion, CGI or motion-capture would probably be needed to bring the character to life, which would've proven expensive and time-consuming. This in mind, switching him for a character who is literally invisible is WAY cheaper.


3. Stormfront

Stormfront The Boys
Amazon

Apart from her electrical powers and psychotic behaviour, the show's depiction of Stormfront has little in common with the original character.

Not only was Stormfront a male Nazi in the comic, he was the first Supe ever. The Nazi Party used Compound V to give him powers, intending to turn him into the nation's main protector.

At first, Hitler's advisors considered having Stormfront put down in case they couldn't control him, but they changed their mind when they saw how popular he was with the people.

Also, Stormfront was never a member of The Seven in the comics. The Aryan led his own team called Payback, and was frustrated because they were constantly sidelined by The Seven.

Although this conflict was implemented into the show, Stormfront was inserted into The Seven so her antagonism with Homelander would be more personal. The writing team also gender-swapped the character since the chauvinistic Homelander would be brought to his breaking point watching a woman steal his spotlight.

It's also worth mentioning that Stormfront was eventually killed by a giant Russian bartender called Love Sausage. (I promise that is true.)


2. The Boys Take V

Compound V
Dynamite

Because the majority of Supes are bulletproof, The Boys don't stand a chance against them in a fair fight. As a result, they rely on firepower, superior strategy, and fighting dirty. But when you are facing superheroes who can effortless crush a diamond or fly around the world in a minute, that isn't always enough.

To even the odds in the comics, The Boys inject themselves with a small dose of Compound V when they have to go toe-to-toe with Supes. Butcher explains to Hughie that the serum makes a person fifteen to twenty times stronger than normal. It takes 24 hours to kick in and wears off after three or four days. When Hughie asked if there were any side effects, Butcher casually mentions it turns your crap blue. (I'm not sure if he's joking.)

Because a Supes' powers are derived from Compound V, Hughie finds it hypocritical that all The Boys use it. According to Butcher, it's a necessary evil since they wouldn't survive a single punch from a Supe otherwise. Knowing that Hughie would oppose taking the compound, Butcher forcibly injected him with V for his first mission.


1. Butcher's Wife

Becca Butcher
Dynamite Entertainment

The most dramatic alteration in the television adaptation of The Boys (so far), is the fate of Butcher's wife, Becca.

In the show, Butcher discovered footage of his wife having a meeting at Vought immediately before she disappeared. Butcher convinced himself that Vought had her murdered after she was raped by Homelander. Although Homelander did violate her, we learn at the end of the first season that Becca went into hiding when she learned she was carrying his child.

In the comic, Becca's fate is much grislier. After she was sexually assaulted, Becca became very cold and introverted towards Butcher. Even though he could tell something was wrong with her, Butcher didn't push the issue. One night, he woke up to find a superpowered fetus had burst out of his wife's womb, killing her. After a gruelling battle, Butcher beat the infant to death with a candlestick. Because the child had the same power set as Homelander, Butcher deduced that the superhero must have raped his wife.

It is uncertain why this premise was changed, but it may have been to surprise comic fans, or to avoid the cliche of a hero being inspired by the death of a loved one.


Watch Next


You'll Never Get 100% On The Boys Quiz

The Boys Hughie Robin
Amazon Studios

1. What Is The Name Of Hughie's Doomed Girlfriend?

In this post: 
The Boys
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows