10 Weirdest Storylines In The Whedonverse

Spells gone awry, doppelgangers and singing aplenty from the Avengers maestro.

Before Joss Whedon was the undisputed king of geekdom, responsible for making an Avengers film not just possible but awesome to the nth degree and finally proving that the Incredible Hulk could actually work on the silver screen, he worked on a couple of TV shows that you might have heard of. Well, "worked on" is a bit of an understatement, much like "TV shows". What he actually did was create a number of groundbreaking cultural phenomena that still have a huge impact on the pop cultural landscape even though they've been off the air for a decade or more. And, er, Dollhouse. These series - Buffy the Vampire Slayer, spin-off Angel, the cancelled-too-soon Firefly and to a lesser extent the aforementioned Dollhouse - were full of Whedon's trademark humour, snappy dialogue, pathos and explorations of topics including but not nearly limited to existentialism, gender, isolation, makeshift families, misogyny and, of course, mortality. And people loved them for it. However, in order to create such a diverse and affecting body of work, Whedon and his collaborators experimented with a wide variety of storytelling techniques and plots to test both their characters and the shows' audiences. Some of these resulted in episodes that were much stranger than most TV audiences were used to from their subversive comedy horror shows, and ranged from the sublime to the ridiculous. Here we've collected ten of the best, weirdest examples of plots from all over the televisual Whedonverse so you can see just how crazy things got (and might well do when Agents of SHIELD gets purring)...

10. Willow Uploads A Demon Into The Internet - Buffy the Vampire Slayer, "I Robot... You Jane"

One of the episodes that's regularly regarded as falling more into the 'ridiculous' than the 'sublime' category, "I Robot, You Jane" takes place in Buffy the Vampire Slayer's first season, which is noted for being the most uneven of the whole series as the creators tried to figure out exactly what show they were going to make. Before they settled on the dark, emotion-rich but hilarious template that the extraordinary season 2 set, though, the Buffy gang made episodes like this in which Willow scans a demon from an ancient book into the internet and inadvertently unleashes said monster upon Sunnydale High School...in the form of a robot devil. Yes, they got there before Futurama ever did. As lame as the concept is - the internet is a dangerous place!!! - and hokey as the costume and effects look, we can't help but admire the willingness to try out such a bizarre concept. However, we're equally glad that this concept was tested in the early stages of Buffy, before the show truly established its tone and themes. More on robots on the next entry...

9. Connor And Cordelia Have Sex - Angel, "Apocalypse, Nowish"

Those of you who didn't immediately cringe on reading that heading likely need a little helping of backstory. Cordelia Chase, former classmate of Buffy Summers - not to mention Queen Bitch of Sunnydale High - moved to L.A. to pursue an acting career but ended up helping out Buffy's old squeeze and noted vampire Angel with his detective agency, Angel investigations. Connor is Angel's son of confusing birth, since both of his parents were vampires and both technically dead. In screen time, Connor should only be about two years old by the fourth season in which this episode takes place, but Connor was kidnapped as a baby and grew up in a hell dimension named Quor'Toth, a place where time moves quicker than on Earth, and returns in the third season at around age 17. So right away the whole situation is kind of ew. What makes it worse is the fact that Angel and Cordelia have an unspoken connection but the latter is under the influence of a powerful demon, and as a result has no problem boning the angst-ridden, newly (almost) adult son of her crush. Oh, and this happens while Angel watches through a window in the building opposite. He's understandably upset, but why on Earth does he linger for so damn long?!

8. The Buffybot Gets Knocked Up - Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Season 8

Well, one of them does, anyway. It€™s kind of hard to keep track of quite how many there are these days. Toward the start of the comics-only continuation Season 9, Buffy has a few too many at a house party and ends up blacking out shortly before missing her period and coming to the conclusion that she€™s pregnant. What follows are a couple of issues detailing her indecision over whether to keep the child or not, the result of which would have been a bold statement to make in comics and popular fiction in general€except that decision is taken completely out of her hands by the story€™s conclusion.

Which is€well, the title kind of gives it away, doesn€™t it? It turns out that Buffy missed her period because she was actually inhabiting the body of one of the Buffybots Warren Mears invented and his old friend/former villainous counterpart Andrew still keeps on hand for those times when he needs to drug Buffy at a party and switch her minds with an automaton to €œkeep her safe€.

At least his heart was in the right place, eh?


7. Sci-Fi Apocalypse In Two Short Episodes - Dollhouse, "Epitaph One" & "Epitaph Two"

Dollhouse may not be quite as well loved as Joss Whedon's other shows, and while that might be because of a lack of coherent storytelling or a convincing lead for much of its run, it's certainly not for a lack of cool or interesting ideas. The premise itself pretty much explains exactly why the show never made it past its second season (and even that was a minor miracle): a secret, extremely powerful organisation wipes the minds of pretty young things and implants them with new personalities to do things like become dominatrixes and assassinate people. That's weird enough already, but just wait until you see the finales for both seasons - "Epitaph One" and "Epitaph Two" - which turn the whole show into a post-apocalyptic wasteland and act as a disconnected two-parter that's actually way more effective than the series' nominal finale. Set ten years in the future of the show, it sees much of the cast return, some with radical physical differences (except Eliza Dushku, who still looks 29 ten years from now), exploring the ruins of the Dollhouse and trying to find a cure for the mind-wiping 'disease' that's plagued the world for the better part of the decade. It's a 'throw everything at the wall' approach to ending a show, which is exactly why it works. The Epitaphs don't hold anything back; there are emotional goodbyes and surprise deaths aplenty, and it gives the show a more appropriate and kick-ass farewell than most fans thought Dollhouse would ever get.

6. Vamp Willow Meets Human Willow - Buffy The Vampire Slayer, "Doppelgangland"

One of the best-loved episodes of Buffy the Vampire Slayer in the show's seven-season run, "Doppelgangland" is also one of it's strangest, if you hadn't already guessed that from the title. Calling back to an earlier episode in the third season, "The Wish", in which vengeance demon Anya creates an alternate Sunnydale where Buffy never came to the town, this episode sees Anya casting another spell that goes awry and summons a character from that parallel universe to this one. That character, ladies and gentlemen, is Vamp Willow, and she's exactly as awesome as she sounds. Written and directed by Joss himself simply because he loved her character from "The Wish" so much that he created an entire new episode for her, "Doppelgangland" features confusion aplenty from the Scooby Gang - first as to why Willow has gone all gothy and vampiric, and second as to why there are two of them at all. The two Willows inevitably meet and hilarious exchanges follow, not to mention real Willow's observation that her other self is "kinda gay", which is foreshadowing of the most wonderful degree. More shows should include vampire versions of the lead characters meeting the regular human types, in our opinion.

5. 17 Again - Angel, "Spin The Bottle"

Echoing episodes of Buffy like "Band Candy" and "Tabula Rasa" in which most of the cast lose their memories or regress to younger versions of themselves, "Spin The Bottle" sees the Angel cast returning to their 17-year old states of minds, a state which has some dangerous but mostly damned amusing consequences. Stuck in the lobby of Angel's hotel-cum-agency office together after a memory spell gone awry, the characters try to figure out what happened to them and why they all look so much older than they feel. Much joy comes from seeing Angel, Wesley and Cordelia revert to the versions of themselves we'd come to know through their initial appearances in Buffy (or, in Angel's case as his original human identity, Liam, in flashbacks), but also from the newer additions to the team, all of whom have complex relationships with the world and other people.

4. Dreams Can Be A Bitch - Dollhouse, "The Attic"

Yes, the Dollhouse was a weird place all right, "The Attic" most of all. After Eliza Dushku's doll Echo has caused more trouble for the company than her handlers can stomach, she's placed in an induced dream state in which she's forced to live the same frustrating, violent dreams over and over again for the rest of her time in the facility. That is, of course, until she tracks down other people connected to her dreams via the attic's network of minds who help her come up with a plan to stop the mysterious assassin who's killing prisoners in their dreams. Directed by comics artist (and Joss Whedon's collaborator on Astonishing X-Men) John Cassaday, the episode naturally has a striking visual sensibility, from the sleek corridors to the beautiful, gigantic tree that occupies one floor of the Dollhouse in Echo's mind. A weird and wonderful late addition to the show's final season, "The Attic" is a potent reminder of the vibrant creativity and ballsiness that could be put into episodes of Dollhouse when the crew were at their A-game.

3. Jubal Early - Firefly, "Objects In Space"

Often cited as one of Joss Whedon's finest hours of television (aside from the Buffy episode "The Body", but that's far less sad than it is heartbreakingly sad), "Objects In Space" serves as both Firefly's final episode and the introduction of one Jubal Early, the strangest and most philosophical space assassin in history. "Am I a lion? I don't think so. I do have a mighty roar." That's just a taste of Early's brand of whimsical misunderstandings as he invades Serenity and holds members of the crew hostage while attempting to trap down resident fugitive River Tam. Failing to track her down and threatening to kill River's brother Simon, Jubal finds himself forcing the residents of the ship to face up to their own limitations before starting a conversation with Serenity itself. It's not long before he realises his mistake and is summarily kicked off, but the questions posed during his time aboard Mal's ship are potent enough that you'll be scratching your head thinking about them for long after the episode's over.

2. Puppet Angel(!) - Angel, "Smile Time"

Angel is a puppet. That's all that needs to be said, really, but we'll go on some more if you're feeling a little bewildered. While investigating a creepy children's show called Smile Time (which is also, conveniently, the name of the episode), the eponymous vampire gets himself cursed by the nefarious demons behind the whole thing and becomes a tiny felt version of himself. Which is both adorable and hilarious, as the rest of his team soon go at great lengths to tell him (especially Spike). Our hero spends the rest of the episode in his more diminutive form, but he can still hold his own in a fight and even gets a new scar when he gets a little too close to his werewolf love interest and she literally tears the stuffing out of him. A little too cute (in more ways than one) for some fans, this is much-loved by many others and is a prime example of the weird and wonderful places Angel was willing to go when it wasn't trying to make you despair at the pitiable follies of humanity.

1. Buffy Sings It Out - Buffy the Vampire Slayer, "Once More With Feeling"

Again, this needs no more introduction than the phrase "musical episode", but "Once More With Feeling" is far, far more than that. Don't get us wrong, it's certainly super-weird to have musical numbers popping up while Sarah Michelle Gellar stakes the undead in a graveyard and people dance themselves to death, but this is the kind of weird that makes TV history. As the result of a curse laid on Sunnydale by a musical demon the entire town spontaneously breaks into song as part of a plot for said demon to marry Dawn, but all that plot stuff's rather negligible as the episode's really about the hidden feelings and secrets that come out as a result of the power of musicals. From Xander and Anya's anxieties about their impending nuptials to Spike's conflicting feelings for Buffy and the Slayer herself confessing that she'd been ripped out of heaven when her friends brought her back from the dead, the show is a rollercoaster of emotions and sublime musical jokes, not to mention exactly what the casual viewer wouldn't expect from an episode of a show about monster hunters. What did you think of our list? Weird enough for you? Would you have included any other episodes? Let us know in the comments!

In this post: 
Joss-Whedon
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Film history obsessive, New Hollywood fetishist and comics evangelist.