10 Wildest Battlestar Galactica Fan Theories
Could Battlestar Galactica be part of another property? It's not impossible!
Science fiction has shown us several possible futures we as a society could become. From the classic dystopian universes where life is cheap and corporations rule everything, to the more optimistic universes where humanity is able to explore the stars and meet new life in an ever-growing galactic alliance dedicated to peace and equality.
In the Battlestar Galactica universe, humanity is pushed to the brink of extinction after creating a race of cybernetic servants, known as Cylons, who predictably rise up and overthrow their masters in brutal fashion.
Battlestar Galactica revitalized sci-fi drama, due to the show's focus on topics such as the reality of God, the meaning of sentience, and humanity's right to live; all mixed with awesome battles and tense, decisive moments that led to massive success.
Galactica's reboot ended around 12 years ago after a decent four-season run. However, fans still discuss the impact the show had on the sci-fi genre, as well as every little detail regarding the series.
This endless discussion has led to the creation of many, many fan theories. Most tend to focus on major events in the show, such as Starbuck's death, apparent revival, and the the series' extremely controversial ending.
The following are some of the wildest fan theories posited by fans, with many being impossible to confirm for obvious reasons, yet they are still fun to think about as we wait for another possible revival of this beloved franchise.
10. Modern Day UFO's Are Actually Cylon Ships
Life here began out there. This is one of the primary tenets of the colonial religion in Battlestar Galactica. Many of the humans in the show believe that there are other lifeforms in the cosmos, though it's believed they are also humans just waiting on Earth for their cousins to come home.
In our universe, the belief that life is out there has always been very complicated, and for one fan theory, that life may be more familiar than we realize.
At the end of Battlestar Galactica, the rebel Cylon Centurions are given sentience and the freedom to go out into the galaxy to choose their own future, free of outside control and subjugation.
Thus, a fan theory arose that in our modern timeline the sightings of UFOs are actually Cylon ships, coming back to check on humanity. In some ways, this theory actually makes a lot of sense in Galactica canon.
The Cylons would know where the second Earth was, as they helped humanity find it, and the Cylon raider ships do appear similar to what we view as a 'traditional' UFO.
The Cylons would want to check on us for several reasons. To ensure humanity poses no threat to them, to observe any possible Cylon hybrid descendants, and also to see if humanity is on its way to recreating the Cylons again and wiping themselves out.
9. Starbuck Is A Time Traveler
Katee Sackhoff's portrayal of classic swashbuckling ace pilot Starbuck quickly became one of Battlestar Galactica's most iconic roles. Thus, Starbuck's rather untimely death during the 17th episode of season three was heartbreaking for many fans.
However, the showrunners decided to do something quite unexpected. They brought Starbuck back from the dead with no real explanation. Immediately fan forums were overrun with theories about this "new" Starbuck.
Most leaned towards this Starbuck being some sort of Cylon creation, perhaps even being a hybrid of sorts. However, the show never actually gave its fans a proper answer, even in the series finale.
Instead, Starbuck just miraculously returns from the dead, leads the surviving humans to our Earth, and then disappears after a final conversation with Apollo.
The fan theories on Starbuck are enough to create a list of their own, but one of the most interesting is that Starbuck didn't die when flying into the wormhole that "killed" her in season three.
Instead, this fan theory proposes that she traveled through time, appearing in season three episode 20 after going through the wormhole and creating a paradox of sorts that resolved itself after Starbuck led humanity to Earth.
Time travel is always a fickle topic to tackle in any movie or TV show, and most creators tend to explain the concept differently in whatever way will best fit their story. While this is a relatively grounded theory regarding Starbuck's apparent survival, it also raises more questions than answers.
8. The Lords Of Kobol Were Aliens
In Battlestar Galactica, the colonists developed a religion that is quite similar to the Pantheistic Greek religion, primarily worshipping the 12 Lords of Kobol, each representing one of the 12 original colonies humanity took over and lost during the second Cylon invasion.
Throughout the show, we learn bits and pieces about the 12 Lords of Kobol, largely through one of the fleet's last remaining priestesses, Elosha, and the discovery of Kobol later in the series.
As with any sort of religious being that is worshipped by humans, there are many theories that the Lords of Kobol may have actually been aliens that came and took humans from their original planet and populated them across several different worlds.
The reasoning behind this theory comes mostly from what little we were able to see of the planet Kobol, and the many "artefacts" left behind by the gods themselves.
These artefacts include the Arrow of Apollo and the Gates of Hera; artefacts even the Cylons don't deny to be real. They simply deny the artefacts to be "divine."
In the end, there is no clear evidence to back this theory up, though it does make a lot of sense, as the humans on the first and second Earth, along with Kobol itself, are never really explained.
How could humanity have left or even gone to any of the Earths, or left Kobol in the first place, without some sort of technological help?
7. The Colonists All Have Aphantasia
This fan theory may take a bit of explaining to understand, but it is by far one of the most interesting theories in regards to Battlestar Galactica.
Aphantasia is a mental phenomenon in which a human being is unable to visualize imagery. Basically, it means that someone is unable to see in their mind's eye the face of a close friend or imagine scenarios like a black cat frolicking through some grass under a big oak tree, as the wind blows gently through the surrounding meadow and the clouds move across a relatively clear sky.
This fan theory takes this idea of a mental phenomenon and applies it to every single human living aboard Galactica's fleet. The theory draws upon moments from the series where things such as "imagination" are viewed by the colonists as a divine message, or in Gaius Baltar's case, a dire sign of mental illness.
The theory even compares the Cylons to the colonials, using moments such as the creation of the Blackbird to show that the Cylons are able to have imagination, while humans are only able to see things when near death or after taking dangerous drugs like Chamala.
This theory requires a bit of knowledge about the complex human mind, but it brings an interesting perspective to the humans of BSG, even implying the only reason we in the modern world have imaginations is because of Hera, the part Cylon mitochondrial Eve of modern humans.
6. The Final Five Actually Became Cylons Through A Cylon STD
Sex is a minor but important part of Battlestar Galactica. Like most mature dramas, Battlestar Galactica has its moments of steamy under-the-cover scenes between many of its characters.
This not only gave the show a bit of spice like any modern TV series, it also sparked a completely out there fan theory regarding the creations of the human Cylons.
This theory proposes that Cylons are actually more like Stargate's Goa'uld, a parasite that infects human hosts and converts them into Cylons. The theory then pivots toward the final five Cylons and how they could actually have been turned into Cylons during any of their sexual encounters with other Cylons.
In fairness to the theory, there is some merit as all but Samuel Anders do have sex with other Cylon models. That means they could possibly have been infected with some sort of Cylon parasite that took over their body.
Realistically this theory makes the least sense, as Gaius never becomes a Cylon despite his time with Caprica Six, and the same can be said for Starbuck, though it's hard to know if ghosts can be infected by robots. In the end, this theory is more of a homage to the first Star Trek series, where the crew is infected with a disease every other week than anything we can directly explain in the Battlestar Galactica universe.
5. BSG Is About A Never Ending Robot Conflict
The human Cylons were one of Battlestar Galactica's biggest draws when it was first released in 2004. The fan theories about who was and wasn't a Cylon exploded across fan pages with every new episode and every new Cylon model uncovered.
Yet one fan theory after the show was finished has a unique take on who is and isn't a Cylon. Basically, this theory states that everyone is a robot, and what we see in Battlestar Galactica is just the continuation of a never-ending cycle where humanoid robots create mechanical robots that wipe them out, then those robots invent humanoid robots who take out the mechanical only to recreate the mechanical Cylons, and on and on.
This theory is based on one of the show's iconic lines "all of this has happened before, and it will happen again". This endless loop as hinted by the show's beginning and ending indicates that there is no more humanity, only what they created now trapped in an endless loop of birth and death.
Admittedly, this theory cant be disproven as the line between being a human or a Cylon is extremely blurry from the show's perspective, and it would make the most sense thematically for the show to have just been a small part of a grander, never-ending conflict.
And in all fairness, robots would be able to handle a larger never-ending cycle much better than humans, who can't even leave one small planet in one tiny corner of the universe.
4. Gaius, Six, And Starbuck Are Angels
Galactica is not a show that shies away from deep questions surrounding the idea of a singular God ruling over humanity and Cylons. There is a surprisingly large mystical element to much of Battlestar Galactica, a series set in the deep blackness of space revolving around a few thousand humans surviving a robotic apocalypse.
That is why this fan theory proposes that some of the beings we see in the show - those who appear to others seemingly out of nowhere - may in fact be angels sent by the big man upstairs to guide the two most dominant lifeforms in the galaxy.
This theory proposes that the Caprica Six we see stalking Gaius, and in turn, the Gaius we see stalking Caprica Six, may in fact be angels sent to direct the two heads of their respective civilizations towards finding Earth.
This could explain how Six appears and disappears to Gaius with no one else seeing her, and why she has knowledge of things that Gaius does not, like the Cylon transponder device on the bridge that nobody else notices. This is also why at the end of Battlestar Galactica, we see Gaius and Six just wandering around our modern Earth, talking in deep metaphors about how we're going to destroy ourselves with technology again.
Of course, this theory also includes Starbuck as yet another angel sent by God herself to lead humanity towards the promised land/planet Earth, our Earth since they do find their Earth but it's a nuclear hellscape after those humans created Cylons.
3. Everyone Died After The Series Finale
The finale of Battlestar Galactica was many things. It was an epic final battle between the crew of the Galactica and the Cylons. It was controversial. It divided the fanbase, and to some fans, it was also much darker than we were led to believe.
Essentially, the ending of Galactica sees the colonists discover our Earth in the early stone age before homo sapiens had even begun to use tools.
In order to not recreate the mistakes of the last colonies, everyone decides to give up on technology and begin humanity completely anew. The colonists even went so far as to send the Galactica and all of the colonist's spaceships into the sun.
We are then led to believe that the colonists lived peacefully and integrated themselves with our ancestors, eventually leading to us in the modern era.
However, one fan theory proposes that after the colonists landed on Earth and tried to begin anew, they all quickly died off, unable to adapt to a hostile environment without their advanced technology.
This theory actually has some proof, as at the very end of the show we are shown Gaius Baltar and Number Six wandering around our Earth discussing how we will inevitably kill ourselves with technology again.
As they wander around, we see the remains of Hera, Sharon, and Karl Agathon being excavated by modern humans. The thinking was that the colonists died off before they could integrate or reproduce to start a new species.
2. Starbuck Is Aurora
Starbuck is undoubtedly the focus of many fan theories. Her death and subsequent rebirth are never fully explained.
How did she know the location of the first Earth? Where did her ability to play a song that triggers the unveiling of the final five Cylons aboard the human fleet come from? How do they use that song to then find our Earth? Then there's her sudden disappearance after talking with Apollo in the series finale. All this only compounded the need for the fans to find some sort of explanation for this character since the show refused to do so.
One fan theory views the returning Starbuck as a reincarnation of the Colonial goddess Aurora, who represents the dawn, as well as being a messenger who led the Cylons from Kobol to Earth.
In the show there are actually several points that indicate Starbuck's connection to the goddess. When Starbuck visits an Oracle aboard the Galactica, she is given a small winged icon of the goddess Aurora, which is later given to Admiral Adama to put as the figurehead for his model sailing ship.
This figure is then given back to Kara after her return from the dead and she is often seen playing with it as she ponders where Earth is. There even is a temple to Aurora on the first Earth. Starbuck's disappearance is then interpreted as her fulfilling her purpose like Aurora, and returning to heaven.
1. BSG Is Actually Part Of The Matrix Universe
Everyone loves a crossover. Pop culture is full of moments where franchises collide in spectacles that astound audiences around. From Frankenstein Meets the Wolf Man, to Spiderman: No Way Home, crossovers have proven to be profitable and oftentimes quite enjoyable.
This desire for everything to become a crossover exists quite prominently in fan theories, and Battlestar Galactica is no exception. There are theories that Galactica is actually set in the same universe as Christopher Nolan's Interstellar, as well as another fan theory that proposes Battlestar Galactica is actually part of the Matrix universe.
This theory suggests that everything we see in Battlestar Galactica is a build-up to the creation of The Matrix, with our Earth being where the Matrix takes place. Essentially the theory claims the machines we see in The Matrix are simply our Earth's version of Cylons.
While there is no obvious way to prove that The Matrix and Battlestar Galactica are in the same universe, there are enough similarities to believe this theory if you squint really, really hard at it. In The Matrix, there are several computer programs that have achieved sentience and have even reproduced, much like the Cylons.
This theory may simply come down to the fact that both franchises have beautiful blonde women in red dresses and robots, but it is still a fun theory to indulge in as the show's never ending cycles of creation and destruction mirrors the Matrix's own philosophy of destruction and creation.