10 Worst Buffy The Vampire Slayer Villains

These Buffy the Vampire Slayer villains are memorable for all the wrong reasons...

Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

Buffy the Vampire Slayer features an outstanding roster of characters. Joss Whedon and his team of writers filled their supernatural world with plenty of memorable personalities, ranging from flawed heroes to grisly demons.

Most of the villains in Sunnydale are memorable for all the right reasons. They can be powerful, repulsive, morally complex, or even a combination of all three. Regardless of which season you’re on, there are plenty of juicy antagonists to watch and enjoy. However, not all of them are commendable.

Every now and then, the villains just fall flat, and this is particularly noticeable during the first three seasons, which heavily rely on the monster-of-the-week formula. Whilst some of these villains are held back by lacklustre designs, others are just plain silly and can actually cause us to laugh due to how ridiculous they are.

Thankfully, most of these villains only make a brief appearance before Buffy and the gang put an end to their wicked ways. And even though they’re disappointing when compared to the show’s other antagonists, the majority of them are still entertaining in their own unique way.

10. Hansel And Gretel (Season 3, Episode 11)

Buffy Hansel And Gretel
20th Television

Many consider Season 3 to be Buffy’s best outing, and it’s easy to see why. The season is stacked with stellar episodes and rounds off the gang’s school years in the best possible way. But there are still a couple of mediocre episodes here and there.

The plot of ‘Gingerbread’ revolves around a set of siblings known as Hansel and Gretel. Rather than being a physical threat, Hansel and Gretel cause havoc by forcing the parents of Sunnydale into a witch-hunting frenzy. With their pale lips and flat delivery, they're clearly meant to be creepy, but their dialogue is so bad it’s hard to take them seriously:

“There’s bad people out there. And we can’t sleep. Not until you hurt them.”

To make matters worse, there’s a curveball at the very end, and it turns out Hansel and Gretel are actually an illusion – the real demon is a goblin-like creature who takes on the appearance of the siblings to manipulate his victims more easily.

Far from making them more interesting, this final twist does nothing to elevate the quality of Hansel and Gretel. With poor dialogue and barely a minute on screen, these characters are a low point of Buffy’s third season.


9. Machida And The Frat Boys (Season 2, Episode 5)

Buffy Machida
Mutant Enemy

Frustrated with her never-ending Slayer duties, Buffy lies to Giles and decides to go to a frat party after being invited by a local college boy. The party is a typical late-nineties affair with plenty of booze and alternative music.

But there’s also something sinister going on. After spiking the girls’ drinks, the frat boys chain them up and offer them as a sacrifice to a demon called Machida in exchange for wealth and status. Yet Machida turns out to be a pretty pathetic villain.

Whilst the makeup and the movements are good, there’s no personality here due to the absence of dialogue. Instead, the frat boys do all the talking, subjecting the prisoners to a series of monkish – and rather annoying – chants. Machida, meanwhile, conveniently hovers around the cave, giving Buffy plenty of time to break free from her bonds.

At this point, you’d expect there to be a banging fistfight between Buffy and Machida – but there isn’t. After grabbing a sword from one of the frat boys, Buffy cuts Machida in half, and that’s the end of him.

Despite a considerable amount of build-up, the frat boys’ master turns out to be an easy takedown for the Slayer.


8. The Ugly Man (Season 1, Episode 10)

Buffy The Ugly Man
Mutant Enemy

‘Nightmares’ is a standout episode in the first season. With some assistance from the Hellmouth, a boy called Billy Palmer causes nightmares to come true, and our heroes are forced to live out their night-time fears in the real world.

Watching these twisted scenarios is great entertainment, but the episode is let down by one thing: the Ugly Man. This guy is meant to be a creepy incarnation of Billy’s coach, who beat up Billy after his team lost a baseball game.

Most of the other nightmares tap into common fears, such as spiders, clowns, public humiliation, and family estrangement, but the Ugly Man just feels out of place. If Billy was frightened of his coach, you’d think his nightmares would feature a realistic version of this fear, not a supernatural one.

Buffy’s first conflict with the Ugly Man is also a low point. Just when she’s having a heartfelt conversation with Billy, this big brute roars onto the scene, shattering the emotional atmosphere at once, and he continues to roar like a maniac throughout this sequence.

Whilst Buffy’s final fight with the Ugly Man has its moments, the episode would have been much better if he wasn’t in it.


7. The Bezoar (Season 2, Episode 12)

Bezoar - Buffy the Vampire Slayer - Bad Eggs
Mutant Enemy

‘Bad Eggs’ is the dullest episode in Season 2. Aside from the continuation of Xander and Cordelia’s secret love affair, there isn’t much to enjoy here.

During class, Mr Whitmore gives each student an egg to look after. Supposedly, the purpose of this exercise is to teach the students how to be responsible. But it turns out these eggs are part of a sinister scheme orchestrated by the Bezoar, a slimy, one-eyed demon who uses its offspring to control people.

Rather like Machida, the major issue here is the lack of personality. Devoid of the ability to speak or express emotion, the Bezoar isn’t a compelling villain – it’s just a giant slimeball in the ground. And whilst it does possess the ability to grab people around the ankles with its tentacles, the Bezoar isn't much of a physical challenge, either.

With a few axe swings, the Slayer emerges victorious in a matter of seconds, and it’s safe to say that no one was particularly upset about the death of this boring villain.


6. Lyle Gorch And Candy Gorch (Season 3, Episode 5)

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Lyle Gorch
Mutant Enemy Productions

In the fifth episode of Season 3, Buffy throws herself into a popularity contest when she tries to become the Homecoming Queen.

But midway through the episode, Buffy’s fixation with the contest takes a backseat. After being mobilised by Mr Trick, a group of villains compete in Slayer Fest ’98 to see who can take down the Slayers.

Amongst the participants are a vampire duo called Lyle and Candy Gorch, who are also husband and wife. Compared to the other contestants – which include a German squadron, a hunter, and a spiky-headed demon – these two vampires aren’t remotely frightening. Candy is quickly killed by Buffy, and Lyle simply runs away when Cordelia threatens him. If the point of the Slayer Fest is to take down the Slayers, why would Mr Trick hire such a useless pair of vampires?

And whilst the writers probably included Candy and Lyle for a bit of comic relief, their humour wasn’t really necessary, as there are plenty of funnier moments from the other characters. Buffy and Cordelia’s tense relationship during the Slayer Fest is loaded with humour, and Xander and Willow’s awkward romance is also amusing.

All things considered, the episode would have been much better if Candy and Lyle weren’t in it.


5. Jesse McNally (Season 1, Episode 2)

Jesse Buffy
Mutant Enemy

Jesse McNally is one of the weirdest characters in Buffy the Vampire Slayer. As a student of Sunnydale High, he shows up in the first episode and has plenty of friendly exchanges with the central characters, especially Xander.

But unfortunately for Jesse, he’s captured by Darla, turned into a vampire, and joins up with the Master. In Episode 2, he attempts to kill Buffy and her friends with his new abilities. Whilst turning Jesse into a vampire is a neat twist, he pales in comparison to the other antagonists – Darla, Luke, and the Master are much more frightening.

What’s more, his death scene is laughably stupid. During an attack at the Bronze, he’s accidentally staked by Xander when someone bumps into him from behind, so he doesn’t even get the chance to show off his new powers. And to make matters worse, no one really cares about his death, either. Even Xander, who was quite pally with Jesse in the first episode, seems apathetic about the whole thing.

It’s a shame Jesse’s time on the show is so lacklustre because the first two episodes are pretty great for the most part, and they would be almost perfect if he wasn’t in them.


4. The Anointed One (Season 1 And Season 2)

The Anointed One Buffy
Mutant Enemy

The Anointed One is the most bizarre villain in Buffy the Vampire Slayer. He first appears in the fifth episode of Season 1, and his arrival is foreshadowed by a prophecy from the Writings of Aurelius.

“…in this time shall come the Anointed, the Master's great warrior. And the Slayer will not know him, will not stop him, and he will lead her into Hell. Five will die, and from their ashes, the Anointed shall rise.”

It turns out the Anointed One is actually a kid called Collin, and after the death of the Master, he becomes the new leader of the Order of Aurelius. Given what was written in the prophecy, you’d expect there to be some kind of showdown between Buffy and the Anointed One – but there isn’t.

When Spike swaggers onto the scene at the start of Season 2, he murders the Anointed One by locking him in a cage and exposing him to a blaze of sunlight. Killing off this redundant character was a wise decision from the writers, but why did they need to include him in the first place?

No matter how many times you re-watch the show, the Anointed One’s time in Sunnydale always feels like a complete waste of time.


3. Adam (Season 4)

Adam Buffy
Mutant Enemy Productions

Every Buffy season features a central villain known as the Big Bad. For the most part, these villains are highly entertaining – the Master, Angelus, the Mayor, Glory, and the First Evil are all classic antagonists. But in Season 4, the makers of the show made a major blunder: Adam.

This bio-mechanical demonoid was created by Maggie Walsh down in the Initiative. Then, after killing his creator, Adam tries to take down the Scooby Gang and create an army of bio-mechanical demonoids just like him.

Though Adam is a powerful specimen, he’s let down by an awful design. There’s just no getting away from the fact he looks like a leftover villain from Power Rangers. The mishmash of cyborg, human, and demon looks horrible – it’s so bad that it’s almost funny.

Adam’s personality isn’t exactly riveting, either. He talks in a low, monotonous voice and rarely varies his pronunciation. Even when he’s talking about something integral to the plot, it’s easy to switch off.

Whilst Adam isn’t the worst villain in the show, he’s definitely the most disappointing one, and he looks particularly pathetic when compared to the other Big Bads.


2. Coach Marin And The Gill Monsters (Season 2, Episode 20)

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Carl Marin
Mutant Enemy

‘Go Fish’ is a dreadful episode with a ludicrous plot. Determined to improve the quality of his swim team, Coach Marin doses the boys with a performance-enhancing drug.

Before long, the swim team start transforming into Gill Monsters, and it turns out Coach Marin nicked this performance-enhancing drug from the Soviets, who had tried to improve the quality of their swimmers with fish DNA.

These fishy demons are clearly inspired by Creature from the Black Lagoon (1954), and – to be fair – they are freaky to look at. But without the ability to speak, these demons aren’t very compelling. They don’t serve much of a purpose beyond giving Buffy something to punch, as Coach Marin is really the main villain.

But he’s not particularly interesting, either. His psychotic obsession with teamwork and success leads to an abundance of corny dialogue, and his use of firearms is a cheap way of getting one up on the Slayer.

To top it all off, the final scene features a group of Gill Monsters swimming away from Sunnydale towards the sea. The soundtrack tries to make the scene creepy, but the Gill Monsters look so stupid bobbing up and down in the water that it comes across as funny rather than scary.


1. Moloch The Corruptor (Season 1, Episode 8)

Buffy the Vampire Slayer I Robot You Jane
Mutant Enemy

Season 1 has its fair share of bad villains, but Moloch the Corruptor is the worst of the lot. Featured exclusively in ‘I Robot, You Jane’, this horned demon originally lived in fifteenth-century Italy but was taken down by some monks who trapped him inside a book.

Before long, the narrative jumps to the Sunnydale High library in 1997, and the aforementioned book is scanned into the computer, causing Moloch to reawaken inside the digital realm. Moloch decides to take on a new alias: Malcolm Black, and tries to win Willow’s affections by messaging her online. Then, he manages to get a new body with the help of some geeky students and a random scientist.

How Moloch was able to manipulate his targets so easily is never explained properly, but the final act is definitely the worst aspect of the episode. Here, Moloch confesses his love for Willow with a series of corny lines that are so terrible even Alyson Hannigan can’t salvage the scene.

Buffy then arrives to save the day, but due to Moloch’s armour, she’s unable to strike a meaningful blow, which leads to a rather dull fight scene. Instead, she has to use the death-by-electricity trope and trick Moloch into punching a powerline.

After spending most of the episode locked inside the digital realm, Moloch’s appearance is a massive disappointment with no redeeming qualities whatsoever.


Buffy The Vampire Slayer Or Angel Quiz: Who Said It - Rupert Giles Or Wesley Wyndam-Pryce?

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Giles
Mutant Enemy

1. "We Came, We Sang, We Fought The Urge To Regurgitate."

Contributor

Love to read and write. Have an unhealthy obsession with Harry Potter. Enjoy running up hills.