10 Worst Dexter Episodes

Let's hope New Blood never reaches such low points.

Dexter Monkey In A Box
Showtime

He's back.

Eight years since he solemnly took a seat after a day of lumberjack work, Dexter Morgan (or Jim Lindsay of course) has returned to the small screen.

The original Dexter series lit the world on fire for a spell. The titular character, a serial killer of killers, captured viewers' imaginations in a way most showrunners can barely even dream of. What followed was five or so years of gripping television before another 3 or so of deep disappointment.

Initially the biggest show on television, Dexter's ultimate reputation was one of a series that simply stuck around too long. Past its prime and lumbered with a creative team uninterested in shaking anything up drastically, Dexter started churning out a lot of less-than-stellar content.

Fortunately the new, considerably colder landscaped season has done well so far in righting some of the old show's wrongs. Its slow burn storytelling and reintroduction of the Harrison character have done a lot to help longtime jaded fans move on from the dreary days of early last decade.

Hopefully the New Blood team keep it up and learn from the mistakes of the original series, particularly these 10 misfires.

10. Sin Of Omission

Dexter Doomsday Killer
Showtime

Following Rita's surprise death in season 4, the series began sticking to the status quo like there was no tomorrow. While the premise of a gifted blood-splatter analyst secretly slaughtering criminals had captured millions of imaginations, there comes a time when people want more.

While many shows commit to creative gambles in order to remain gripping, Dexter season 6 did anything but for the most part. The few times it flirted with something new, we got Deb falling in love with Dexter. This widely criticised angle is heating up here with Deb seemingly losing her mind over Dexter not making enough time for her.

The rest of the episode retreads old ground with Dexter investigating a new killer he wants taped to his table and Deb butting heads with LaGuerta yet again. The Doomsday Killer, played sheepishly by Colin Hanks (and a misused, imaginary Edward James Olmos who would've been far better in the lead villain role) is one of the more frivolous baddies of the show's long run.

The religious angle doesn't gel well at all with the scientific, amoral style of much of the show's plots and characters. The killer himself lacks the tension villains such as The Trinity Killer and Miguel Prado managed to conjure up as well.

Overall, Sin of Omission is a plodding affair that serves to slowly move along a variety of storylines that were poor to begin with. It's a key example of why many felt the series' quality fell off a cliff with season 6 and the departure of its original creative team.


9. This Little Piggy

dexter vince masuka
Showtime

Remember when Debra attempted a murder-suicide against Dexter? It was one of the few shocking moments in season 8 that could've potentially led to some gripping TV. Instead, as we discover here, it simply leads to more sitting around and talking in Dr Vogel's office.

It's strange that a supposed psychopath like Dexter spends so much time talking about his feelings given he himself once claimed he didn't have any. Regardless, the real Bay Harbour Butcher is understandably miffed with Deb for almost killing him. He even points out she nearly made young Harrison an orphan (which proves to be hilariously rich by the end of this season).

Unsurprisingly, Michael C. Hall and Jennifer Carpenter are on fine form here, carrying a once great show to keep it watchable. Charlotte Rampling also, to her credit, makes the most out of the topsy-turvy Vogel character despite the writing's shortcomings.

It's the plodding pace and tone of what should've been a suspenseful, high-intensity storyline that leaves this episode in the wilderness. Its flaws are only exacerbated with a storyline no one beyond maybe C.S. Lee could've possibly asked for: Masuka's daughter.

The Quagmire of the Dexter series is handed an aimless subplot about a surprise daughter from his days as a sperm donor. The subplot eats up vital TV time in the show's closing stretch, further hampering the already underdeveloped Brain Surgeon mystery that was meant to serve as the season's main arc.

A weak episode in a season that constantly charted new lows for this beloved series.


8. This Is The Way The World Ends

Dexter Travis Marshall
Showtime

In the first season, Dexter mentions there's less than 30 active serial killers in the North American continent. With that in mind, it's simply astounding how many turn up in Miami.

While this slight break in realism is forgivable when the characters are great (like The Ice Truck Killer and The Trinity Killer), it becomes quite glaring when a lesser villain arrives. Colin Hanks' raised eyebrow, pursed lips approach to an evil guy face isn't hugely menacing, nor is the nonsensical nature of his apocalyptic slayings.

After some somewhat interesting narration from Dexter adrift at sea, the episode stumbles into a fairly straightforward cat and mouse game. The inclusion of Harrison in Travis Marshall's Biblical war is a tad forced and feels like a desperate ploy to up the intensity of this dragging story arc. Worse still is Marshall's insistence on referring to Dexter as The Beast, presumably an Antichrist reference rather than that horned thing from Angel season 4.

Things get even more ridiculous when Deb reveals she doesn't just love Dexter, she's in love with him. Given how quickly this angle was dropped in season 7, it's safe to say the writers realised their error here. As Deb gears up to tell her adoptive brother she's into him, she discovers what she should've discovered at the end of season 5: Dexter's a serial killer.

While the surprise ending is exciting, its execution is poor and overly convenient as she walks in on him slaughtering Travis in a church. This was easily the weakest Dexter finale yet at the time. Sadly the worst was yet to come.


7. A Little Reflection

Hannah McKay Dexter
Showtime

A veteran Dexter takes a young, promising psychopath under his wing. Sort of like Rocky Balboa and Adonis Creed sans the character development, dramatic depth, emotional intensity and everything else fans liked about those films.

While Dexter taking up a Harry Morgan-esque role sounds good in theory, it proves to be disappointingly half-baked in practise. Zach Hamilton, a rich kid with a fondness for crime scene photography, is Dr Vogel's latest psychopathic project. For Dexter, he's initially a fresh target.

Bar an amusing scene with Quinn (who very conveniently forgets his earlier suspicions of Dexter in these late instalments), Dexter's hunt is neat and tidy as is so much of the relatively risk-free storytelling at this stage in the game. Sympathising with Zach's surprising honesty about his need to kill, Dexter agrees to become his mentor and everything seems surprisingly happy as the episode reaches its close.

The cliffhanger this meandering episode rounds off on is either wonderful or change-the-channel worthy dependent on one's opinion of the Hannah McKay character. Enjoying some down time with Deb as the writers struggle to decide on any one direction for the Morgans' dynamic, Dexter realises they've both been poisoned.

Hannah, not in prison for life after all, is back and has decided to sedate the adoptive siblings for... reasons. There's some intrigue as the credits roll in knowing what's become of them. Despite that, Hannah's return felt like a needless inclusion in an already stuffed and creatively struggling season.


6. Surprise, Motherf***er

Dexter Doakes Surprise Motherfucker
Showtime

James Doakes was a highlight of the first two seasons of the show. A ruthless, hot-tempered sergeant who didn't play well with others, Doakes was the lone gun who knew something was off about Dexter.

Before his incendiary death, the implication was that Doakes simply had a detective's hunch that nice guy Dexter was not what he seemed. It was a testament both to Doakes' intellect and hubris that he could sniff a bad egg but get everything wrong when trying to expose it.

By season 7, Doakes is a distant, disgraced memory with the public believing he was the Bay Harbour Butcher. The show brings actor Erik King back to reveal he never had a hunch at all. Dexter stupidly gave himself away in a conversation one day that he'd been reading through evidence in the hunt for his next victim.

In the present, Maria LaGuerta's own obsession with outing Dexter reaches its crescendo. While many lauded the shock ending of Debra gunning LaGuerta down, it ultimately derailed the show. Deb's surprise turn to the dark side went against 7 years of character development as a (relatively) straight shooter determined to get things done by the book.

It was bad enough that she'd done nought of interest with the knowledge that her brother was a killer. To make her an accomplice to his crimes by murdering a superior officer was straight up shark-jumping. Between doing a disservice to an earlier, much-loved storyline and awkwardly botching Deb's dynamics with both Dexter and LaGuerta, this episode ultimately has a lot to answer for.


5. Nebraska

Brian Moser Dexter
Showtime

On paper, this sounds like a thrilling, potentially game-changing instalment of the series.

Brian Moser, The Ice Truck Killer, the Mycroft to Dexter's Sherlock, is back in action. Not back from the dead of course but back all the same, taking Harry's place as Dexter's trusty imaginary friend. There were hints of a full-on Dexter heel turn here: would he let go of Harry's code and fully embrace his Dark Passenger?

The two go on a road trip to investigate the unfortunate deaths of Arthur Mitchell's wife (or widow, as only Dexter and the audience know at this point) and daughter. The Trinity Killer is often regarded as the finest villain in the series thanks to John Lithgow's impeccable performance and some deeply disturbing plot twists surrounding him. This epilogue for what's left of the Mitchell family ultimately falls flat though.

Arthur's wife, who seemed as much a victim of his torment as the kids, is repackaged as an abusive parent in her own right here, driving her daughter to suicide. In turn, her son Jonah kills her in a fit of rage. It's all rather depressing and, worse still, pointless in the grand scheme of season 6's strange, religion-focused plot.

Subplots involving a weed farm and Dexter hooking up at a gas station further lessen this once-promising episode's value. Ultimately it's a disappointing affair that does a disservice to several interesting characters and story arcs from better, earlier seasons of the show.


4. Goodbye Miami

The Dr Vogel angle that dominated much of season 8 ramps up a notch here without actually ramping up the entertainment factor.

With the dangerous, psychotic son she cruelly abandoned back, she decides, rather than fleeing, to make him some breakfast. Meanwhile, Deb's hated nemesis, Hannah McKay, is now living with her at her beach house because even when Deb hates Dexter, she apparently does whatever to please him.

There's also the continuation of the Quinn/Jaime romance that was never particularly compelling to begin with. It's obvious to even the most disinterested of viewers that this is one relationship not built to last given Quinn's perpetual infatuation with Deb.

In perhaps the peak of the series' general silliness in the closing stretch, Harrison falls off a treadmill in a scene seemingly guest-directed by Tommy Wiseau. From the stilted, cumbersome dialogue between Dexter's kid and Hannah to his turning into a much larger stunt double mid-fall to the editing, the whole thing is just bizarre. It's almost hard to put into words the absurdly disorienting nature of the show's most poorly directed moment.

Of course Harrison's tumble is a plot device to further exacerbate Hannah's weird fugitive situation, a storyline no one really asked for or wanted in the first place. Between this and Dexter's increasingly counter-productive obsession with killing Dr Vogel's son, this clumsily handled episode was one of many disappointing notes in the show's much derided eight season.


3. Make Your Own Kind Of Music

Evelyn Vogel
Showtime

When it comes to Dr Vogel's views on psychopaths, nothing really makes sense. She dismisses the more humane aspects of Dexter as his flaws, dooming him to failure should he continue treading water in a more conventional life he's ill-equipped for. Understandably miffed, Morgan insists she's underestimating him.

Sadly, this line serves more as dreary foreshadowing of Dexter's impending, self-imposed doom rather than a hint at profound character development. Curiously, it's Dexter's slightly more rooted personal life and approach that, up to this point, has helped keep him in the clear.

Vogel's unblinking surprise son, on the other hand, seems devoid of anything even remotely human. Does that make him perfect? If so, why did she have him locked up and forgotten for decades? Could it be Dr Vogel was a poorly thought out late show twist that only succeeded in undermining (the much more interesting) Harry Morgan?

Other than big time fans of Mama Cass, few will find much of excitement in this late stage instalment of the killer-killer's adventures. That mythical Argentina getaway is mentioned multiple times as Dexter and Hannah's increasingly nonsensical romance chugs along to its ill-fated conclusion. In the meantime, Dexter investigates the death of the short-lived Zach Hamilton character.

For those watching at the time, this episode served only to up the worry-factor in just where this show was heading for its last hurrah.


2. Monkey In A Box

Dexter Monkey In A Box
Showtime

A storm's blowing in and it's going to destroy everything. Not the storm within the show that is, the creative storm that killed its high quality and entertainment value.

Dexter finds himself in a situation nearly all of us can relate to: kill the brain-maiming serial killer who whacked your surprise new maternal figure or flee to Argentina with your infant son and murderous, fugitive girlfriend.

It's a tough one.

After scrubbing Dr Vogel's death crime scene of any evidence related to him (bar all the fingerprints from him not wearing gloves for it...) Dexter has a nice scene with Deb. As good as the acting from Carpenter and Hall is for this re-establishment of their friendship is, it also serves as a sad reminder of how off the rails their dynamic went in later seasons.

In an on the nose, symbolic nod to the show's impending end, Dexter starts selling his stuff, namely his apartment since his boat is required for the finale's infamous ending.

Dexter's ongoing feud with The Brain Surgeon continues to be the weakest of his many rivalries over the years here. Lacking in any real menace or logic, Daniel (or Oliver?) is a hammily acted bad guy further hampered by weak plotting (seriously, who would consider threatening Dexter's family a good call?).

Beyond an intriguing moment with Tom Matthews that some consider proof he knew the truth about Dexter all along, this penultimate episode was a new low for the show. Sadly, it's not the last low either...


1. Remember The Monsters?

Dexter Ending
Showtime

Oh boy...

Coming hot off the heels of Breaking Bad's near-flawless conclusion, Dexter's last outing (in Miami at least) inspired the kind of anguish normally reserved for real life catastrophes.

Depressing, plothole-laden and severely lacking in entertainment value, TV's once-hottest show went out with something not quite a whimper. From the needlessly miserable destruction of Debra Morgan (whose character in general was thrown under a bus weekly in season 8) to Dexter abandoning his son with a serial poisoner, not a single note landed right here.

Initially lead to believe Dexter committed suicide via storm in the heat of his grieving for Deb, the show rounds off on a surprise epilogue scene. Dexter, now sporting a beard and a resting sad face, is working as a lumberjack.

Why?

No one ever expected an answer given the end credits.

In 2021, Dexter: New Blood has spent little time dwelling on tree-chopping Dexter, repackaging him as a hunting store clerk in another state. As well-received as the new season has been, one can't help but feel it's mostly serving as an apology for what remains one of the most dismal finales ever put to screen.


Contributor

John Cunningham hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.