10 Worst Doctor Who Villains

Daleks. Cybermen. The Master. And then you have these poor excuses for villains...

Doctor Who
BBC

Like all franchises, Doctor Who holds a massive rogues gallery filled with some of the most iconic villains and monsters within the entertainment industry. From the likes of Daleks, Cybermen, Sontarans, Ice Warriors, Zygons, Autons, Weeping Angels, and The Master. These adversaries (amongst many others) have cemented themselves into the minds of billions of audience members on the planet.

However, with every Top Tier list, there's always a Bottom Tier. And Doctor Who is no exception to this rule. There have been a lot of enemies introduced on the show that have been utterly awful. Questionable even. To the point where you question the creator's creativity, as well as their pride for even daring to place these poor excuses for villains on our screen.

Believe it or not, it was a lot harder to pick ten villains to go on this list. Not that there isn't plenty of bad enemies to pick from. It's simply the case of making sure I've selected the absolute worst of the bunch. And to make it easier on myself, I kept to New Who for the time being. Maybe I'll take a look at Classic Who's travesties at some point in the future....

10. Jagrafess

Doctor Who Jagrafess The Long Game
BBC Studios

Starting off fairly safe, we have the Mighty Jagrafess of the Holy Hadrojassic Maxarodenfoe. That's certainly a mouth full. No wonder The Editor gave it the nickname "Max". Saves time. And many fluffed lines (poor Simon Pegg). As gigantic, slimy, sharped teeth blobs on the ceiling go, the Jagrafess is up there with the best of them. Does this make it a enticing villain. Absolutely not.

More flaws come in when you consider this creature was supposed to be the downfall of humanity's Fourth and Great Bountiful Human Empire. The Long Game is always a slog for me to get through, and the Jagrafess is one of the fundamental flaws that takes me right out of the episode (amongst other crucial elements). I genuinely find it difficult to comprehend that this monster is capable of doing what The Editor informed the Ninth Doctor.

It just looks like a wild beast, that isn't capable of intelligent thought, even if its growls are supposed to convey some sort of dialogue between it and The Editor. Things are made all the more jarring when it's later revealed that the Daleks installed the creature to aid them in manipulating humanity, thus furthering their plans to resurrect themselves. Yeah, sorry, not really buying it. That, and it's just a bland, uninteresting CGI beast that doesn't do a lot, and can be defeated by simply reversing the cooling system on Satellite Five. Moving on.


9. 79B Aickman Road

Doctor Who The Lodger James Corden Craig Owens
BBC Studios

A lot of you are probably looking at the title of this entry and thinking to yourselves, "Who the hell is that?" Remember The Lodger? The episode where the Eleventh Doctor stays with Craig Owens? Yeah, 79B Aickman Road is the flat above that lures innocent bystanders inside and ultimately kills them. Not intentionally of course. It simply requires a pilot, and attracts those who wish to escape their dull existence, thus giving the broken Auto Pilot hope that it could get the ship up and running again.

Unfortunately, human minds haven't got the will power to do such a task, and ultimately are killed in the process of take-off. There was a time that I simply enjoyed The Lodger for what it was, but over time I've grown to dislike this story more and more. If the Eleventh Doctor's weird behaviour wasn't cringe-worthy enough (alongside Craig Owens not being an annoying side character), then it's the fact that the villain is just an awful, lazy concept.

You're hoping that the build-up to what is really upstairs is something worth wild, but it really isn't. Sure, it's a neat little shock to find out that there really isn't an upstairs flat, but once you get past that it's just nothing special, and just dull, like most of the episode. In fact, I'd go as far as to say it's just all pointless. The fact that this would later connect to the Silence in Day of the Moon, makes for even more laziness in trying to make this lame villain something worth giving a damn about. And it gets defeated by love... Enough said really.


8. Harvest Rangers

Doctor Who Bill Bailey The Doctor, The Widow And The Wardrobe
BBC Studios

The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe. Such a wasted opportunity on the part of Steven Moffat. What could've been a fun take on The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, similar to what Moffat did with A Christmas Carol a year prior, quickly divulged into a travesty of a story. Its opening scene promises a thrilling adventure, but then immediately throws all that away to tell a bland narrative instead.

I actually don't mind the Arwell family, and felt the emotional baggage on Madge's shoulders. Disappointingly, everything falls apart once they go to the Christmas Tree planet, which you'd assume would be the main highlight. Then, of course, you await for the villains to arrive. Naturally, you assume it'll be the creepy looking Wooden King and Queen. But nope. It's actually the Harvest Rangers, who do absolutely nothing, and are easily captured by Madge, who fools them with her fake crying.

This sequence is utterly baffling, and is some of the worst example of Moffat trying to force in comedy. What's worse is he's wasting the comedic talents of Bill Bailey for crying out loud. Seriously, what's with Doctor Who in wasting comedians? Okay, it's only happened a couple of times, but still. The only reason these three dumb, pathetic characters are deemed villains is because they're preparing to harvest the forest. Poor attempt at environmental messaging?


7. Sentient Oil

Doctor Who The Pilot Heather Water Creature
BBC Studios

What Steven Moffat did with The Pilot was somewhat genius, in that it felt like a soft reboot for the series, acting as an easy pick up point for newer viewers, whilst still respectfully accommodating for older fans. Sadly, the opener teeters when the villain is introduced. Apart from the fact it just seems to come out of nowhere, it's absolutely laughable.

It had become apparent by Moffat's last series as show-runner that he loved indulging with the idea of transforming everyday objects and elements into something utterly terrifying. The likes of memory, statues, shadows, children, clocks, and even the fricking monster under our beds. And then he does puddles. Credit to him for trying to make a puddle scary, but it didn't quite work.

Sure, there is that one scene in Bill's flat which is incredibly tense, and spine-tingling, almost something out of a horror movie, but this is really the only moment that plays to Moffat's strengths. The rest of the time the "sentient oil" simply takes on the form of Heather and chases Bill and the Twelfth Doctor around space and time.

The real issue lies in how it is able to travel such long distances, and what the entity really is in the first place, because it's left a complete mystery. Plus, this thing ties into the weak romantic subplot between Bill and Heather, which is completely underdeveloped, and simply doesn't hold the weight, and pay-off that Moffat intended.


6. The Wire

Doctor Who The Idiot's Lantern The Wire
BBC Studios

Mark Gatiss comes across as a bit of a hit-and-miss writer. Sometimes his stories are good. And other times they're not. When it comes to The Idiot's Lantern it just becomes complicated. There's a great story to be told at the heart of this script, and the whole subplot with the Connolly family is actually pretty decent. The journey of Eddie being this stern, self-absorbed bully is something of a treat, especially when the Tenth Doctor puts him in his place, and gives his family the courage to eventually show him the door.

Then you get to the Wire and things become rather clumsy in its execution. The whole premise of something existing in the television is actually chilling, and an idea one would expect from Gatiss, given his love for horror-esque elements. Even the imagery of people having their faces removed is so unsettling. But the Wire herself is just a cringe-worthy villain, especially when she just screams she's hungry over and over again.

It's annoying, because the Wire is a despicable creature, who's only interest is rebuilding her original form, but the way the actress portrays the role makes that bitter element just come across as cartoonish. In many ways, the Wire acts more like a whiny child who constantly demands for ice cream until it gets one. Not really something you want for your main villain. Yeah, this one is frustrating because the Wire had such promise with its concept and threat level, but the execution completely lets this one down.


5. Iraxxa

Doctor Who Empress Of Mars Ice Warrior
BBC Studios

Oh look, another monster crafted by the mind of Mark Gatiss. Unlike with The Idiot's Lantern, this story is downright awful. In fact, it's that bad I've not sat down and watched it since its initial release back in 2017. I hold a bitter memory of this episode, and looking back at old reviews I did on the episode, yeah, it's fair to say I don't have anything nice to say about it.

It's a shame really as I appreciate Gatiss as a creative individual, and adore the Ice Warriors as a Doctor Who monster. However, Empress of Mars delivered nothing but disappointment in both its writing, and direction. Nothing remotely worked and it's an absolute travesty on the part of the Ice Warriors, especially with the appearance of the first female member of their race.

What made matters worse was the acting. Iraxxa just came across like a pantomime villain. Childishly absorbed. Overly loud. And completely non threatening in her portrayal. Even the sly inclusion of Alpha Centauri to retroactively explain how this embarrassing skirmish between two opposing ideological led parties resulted in the Ice Warriors joining the Galactic Federation. This Classic Who plug-in ultimately just made matters worse for me.

And before anyone argues why this villain is so high on this list based on memory alone, it's simply because those before Iraxxa are more tolerable, and I can more easily watch/enjoy their respective episodes. When it comes to Iraxxa (and her thankful one-off appearance) I may never materialise there ever again because my experience was just so painful.


4. Abzorbaloff

Abzorbaloff Peter Kay Doctor Who
BBC Studios

I'm sure there are plenty of you reading this entry wondering how on earth this abomination isn't at number one. Then again, maybe you like the Abzorbaloff. In which case, each to their own. While I will admit this creature is awful, it's clearly not the complete worst of the bunch. But it is an embarrassing remainder of how wrong villains can be utilised.

The saddest part about the Abzorbaloff is it was invented by a child during a Blue Peter competition. That said, it still doesn't make this monster any less ridiculous. Then again, there was nothing preventing Russell T Davies doing something interesting with this children's design, considering the monster could literally absorb its victims. That, in itself, is rather horrifying.

Shamefully, the Abzorbaloff is played off as a massive joke, pushing poor Peter Kay to undergo the worst performance in his long, talented career. Basically, you know you've screwed up when the actor playing the role shows demonstrates a clear sign of regret. Love & Monsters as an episode really does no favours for the Abzorbaloff, throwing away so many enticing ideas about an innocent individual becoming obsessed with The Doctor, who slowly discovers the darkening nature of his adventurous lifestyle, for the sake of a half-baked narrative that takes none of its core ideas seriously.


3. Mr Clever

Doctor Who Nightmare in Silver
BBC Studios

This is another entry which completely baffles me. Considering Nightmare in Silver was written by Neil Gaiman, it shocks me that we received such an underwhelming instalment for not only The Doctor, but worst of all the Cybermen. Frankly, I don't think the cybernetic creatures have had a good story in New Who since their resurrection in Rise of the Cybermen and The Age of Steel. Since then, they've gone from bad to worse.

Naturally, it was the hope that Gaiman may be the solution to their failure. However, his creative decisions were very odd, almost as if he didn't understand the Cybermen at all, or he thought he was writing for a completely different monster entirely. The icing on the cake was Mr Clever, the Cyber Planner that latches itself onto the Eleventh Doctor.

This enemy was a strange addition to an already mix-bag narrative, given the entity held no resemblance to a Cyberman whatsoever. For starters, it had too much emotion and charisma, which is unbecoming of a Cyberman (i.e. emotionless cybernetic monstrosities). Maybe its connection to The Doctor altered it, but even then it's a massive stretch of the imagination to consider this thing a product of the Cybermen, forcing Matt Smith to undergo a confusing performance.

Had it been a completely different alien computer, then perhaps this would be a different story, but as it stands, Mr Clever fails on every level, and brings more shame to the baffling concepts applied to this once iconic foe.


2. Krasko

Doctor Who Rosa Krasko
BBC Studios

Rosa went out to deliver an important message, whilst also shining light on a crucial piece of history that helped change the face of modern society. However, what ultimately let down this historical storyline was its villain. Krasko was an utter embarrassment. Not only was he underdeveloped (thus being presented as a mere one-dimensional adversary) but Krasko was painfully trapped within a blatant attempt at political commentary.

Politics in Doctor Who are nothing new. In fact, a lot of stories within the show's long television history have been elevated by the writer's political views. The Daleks themselves are a by-product of this mindset. So it wasn't beyond expectation to assume Krasko could be turned into a successful antagonist. Sadly, this wasn't the case.

There was a huge danger in establishing Krasko as a racist because this is an extremely sensitive subject matter. At the same time, you can't simply have the character be defined by that one and only element. It makes Krasko come across lazy both as a character and as a concept. Maybe more could've been done with the villain, especially in displaying why he was such a vile, disgusting piece of work, attempting to rewrite Rosa Park's triumphant achievement. Instead, Krasko is the victim of a biased viewpoint, which tragically lowers the quality of the overall narrative and the message it's trying to convey.


1. Jack Robertson

Doctor Who Arachnids in the UK
BBC Studios

Yeah, it's pretty hard to think of a worse villain within modern Doctor Who. Similar to Krasko, Jack Robertson was a painful attempt by Chris Chibnall to display a political message. Again, this isn't a terrible idea. So many Doctor Who tales have told absolute belters when it comes to storytelling based around the writer's beliefs, and personal opinions on the world around them. The Third Doctor's era is a testament to this.

Unless you've been living under a rock for the last four years, you'd be aware of President Donald Trump. Whether you liked him or disliked him, it's fair judgement to state he was a controversial leader. But that hardly meant you needed to have an entire narrative revolved around a blatant Trump wannabe. Everything about the character was supposed to poke fun at the American president, and this is a sure way to alienate viewers (particularly the American audience).

Not only are you potentially throwing shade at those who supported Trump, but you're probably pushing away those who dislike Trump. Think about it. You're essentially reminding them of all the hard times they experienced under his leadership, whilst desperately craving escapism from reality. You're also wasting a well established American actor in Chris Noth. Sure, if this was meant to be some kind of parody, you could perhaps get away with this (depending on the execution). But it's not. It's played dead straight, and made all the worse because of it.

This was just a poorly executed concept that has left many Whovians feeling bitter. Given Robertson will be returning in Revolution of the Daleks, one can only hope that the character might actually be reworked, and be presented as a viable villain.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Loving husband and full-time nerd. My pastime is analysing and sharing my thoughts on things. I dabble with video games, enjoy a good horror movie, and love my superhero content. And Doctor Who is my favourite show of all times.