10 Worst Episodes Of Community
The "gas leak year" wasn't the only time Community lost its way!
If shows like Friends and Scrubs are the Disneyland of TV sitcoms, then Community is Legoland; still highly popular but not quite as successful. The series may have a considerable following, but it's often been considered one of the most underrated shows in TV history.
Across the six seasons of the show (and possibly a movie coming someday), we learned about the diverse members of the Study Group, as they attended Greendale Community College, bonded, had a great time and forged friendships to last a lifetime. However, the show's biggest appeal was its ability to explore different mediums and genres, ensuring that there was never a dull moment.
The series was an overwhelmingly wholesome and hilarious show, with very few problems - well, in the first few seasons at least. Sadly, nothing can be perfect, and although there is a lot of fun to be had with every episode of Community, some fall behind the others.
Whether it's because they took the characters in the wrong direction, had ill-achieved gimmicks or simply weren't funny, these following episodes are the outliers in the series that showed the cracks in the foundation.
10. Cooperative Escapism In Familial Relations
On paper, this episode could have had the Midas touch. There were plenty of threads with the potential to find gold, such as Jeff finally meeting/confronting his father and seeing Shirley's home life. But none of it came together, as it was filled with annoying characters and more of the same.
Cooperative Escapism in Familial Relations followed two thanksgiving based narratives. The first was Britta and Jeff's visit to the latter's father, and the second followed Troy, Abed, Annie and Pierce as they went to Shirley's family thanksgiving dinner and hid in the garage plotting a Shawshank-like escape.
It made sense that Community would one day parody Shawshank, but they hardly capitalised on it here as most people wouldn't have even noticed the parallels. This felt like a missed opportunity, and their rejection of Shirley's cry for help made them seem unsentimental - which was very out of character for them all, except Pierce.
On the other side of the narrative, the confrontation between Jeff and his father was more like a wet firecracker than fireworks - excluding one genuinely emotional speech from Jeff at the end. Any good that did come from the conflict was ruined by the inclusion of Jeff's half-brother Willy, an annoying younger man whose pathetic personality was grating.
9. History 101
Community meets The Hunger Games? Okay, that sound's great. That's what the fans were hoping to say with this one, but it didn't quite go that way.
History 101 was the first episode to address the fact that the study group's time at Greendale was a ticking time bomb waiting to go off. It showed as Jeff competed in a set of elaborate games to win places in the only history class that semester, all so he could gain the required credits to leave Greendale early.
The over-the-top games weren't as fun as they sounded, as the focus was less on Jeff competing and more on the drama of him wanting to leave. If the whole group had been involved in playing the Dean's games, then this could have been great, but limiting the scope made it feel pointless.
Alongside Jeff's mission came a subplot that saw Abed have a crisis about graduating. To quell this, he went to his happy place, which was a set of fantasies that saw the cast in various TV genres. However, it was all over the place, and seeing Abed sink into imagination was something fans had seen too many times by this point.
8. Advanced Documentary Filmmaking
If you're a big Community fan, then you've probably got a lot to say about Ben Chang. This bombastic man - played by Ken Jeong - is one of the most inconsistent yet fun parts of the series. His dramatic fall from being a Spanish teacher, then rise as the school's dictator, then fall again led him through so many paths, but one of the most frustrating was the Changnesia arc. Sadly, this episode encompassed that most.
As the title implies, this one took documentary format as Abed was contracted to document a film about Chang's condition to secure the school a $40,000 grant. Naturally, Jeff thinks Chang is lying and jumps through hoops to prove it, while Troy and Annie run their own investigation.
At this point, it was clear that Chang was a little off the rails as a character. His writing felt far more impulsive than pre-planned, and that sums up this episode well. Things happen with little rhyme or reason, making the whole outing feel like a collection of events rather than a narrative.
Plus, the Changnesia angle was past the realm of believability, and it made this episode feel far too ludicrous, especially as the documentary format was supposed to imitate realism.
7. Basic RV Repair And Palmistry
Losing cast members is a certainty in a long-running sitcom. Sadly, actors can't always stay committed to their communities, and replacing them can be a tricky business. For the most part, Community did a good job of bringing new personalities in. However, something still felt off, particularly when the episodes revolved around the new cast playing off each other rather than grand plots. Sadly, that's all you got in this one.
Basic RV Repair And Palmistry saw the Save Greendale Committee on a road trip to sell a giant hand bought by the Dean. However, nothing runs smoothly, as they run out of gas and end up stranded. It's a straightforward narrative that works around the interactions between the characters.
Unfortunately, while the comedy works well at times, it feels out of place as the chemistry of the old cast is gone. Frankie does a good job, but Elroy's personality feels entirely dull and mundane in this one. Thus, giving him an essential centre in the narrative made it feel hollow.
It also needs to be stated that while the Dean had acted selfishly before, his actions here went over the line. His immaturity and refusal to accept responsibility made him too unlikeable in this outing.
6. Conventions Of Space And Time
After Abed's favourite show - Cougar Town - came to an end, he needed something to fill the void it left, and that came in the form of Inspector Spacetime. This lovingly campy parody of the classic UK series Doctor Who was a great addition not only to the show but to Troy and Abed's dynamic. Giving them something to bond over - other than Kick-Puncher - did a lot for them, but this episode didn't.
Conventions of Space and Time gives you exactly what you read on the tin. It shows as the Study Group venture to an Inspector Spacetime convention and break up into separate stories. This marks the first criticism of the episode, in that there's a little too much going on. Bringing the whole cast into it made little sense as this should have been entirely centric on Troy/Abed.
Too many plots wasn't the only issue, as some of the side attractions had problems that worked counterintuitively towards their characters. This was especially clear with Annie, who spent the outing pretending to be Mrs Winger. This might have been a move a younger Annie would make, but she had grown up by this point, and it felt far too regressive for her.
5. Intro To Felt Surrogacy
Intro To Felt Surrogacy, more commonly known as the puppet episode, is one of the most infamous outings this show has ever created. While breaking out of live-action has been proven to work for Community before - most notably in Abed's Uncontrollable Christmas - this one felt a little too forced and lifeless, like the puppets themselves.
The episode's narrative followed the study group as they were caught in a bout of awkward tension. To try and alleviate this, the Dean made them recount the events leading up to this conflict using therapy puppets. This translated to us seeing some admittedly amusing muppet-like designs of the cast as they went on a hot air balloon adventure.
It's safe to say that no one was expecting this one, and the uncanniness of the puppets took a lot of fans off guard. The joke got old pretty quickly, and soon you were stuck in a limited medium with very little charm. Plus, the show had plenty of experience with bad green-screen effects, but this one took the cake, as there were way too many moments where the VFX curtain was drawn wide.
It was a brave choice, but one that shouldn't have been made in the first place.
4. Advanced Safety Features
Corporate sponsors and product placement are just as inevitable as death and taxes when it comes to TV sitcoms. Shows have got to make their money somehow, and integrating products can be a great way to do that, even if audiences often see through it. Community, however, was great at this, as they integrated them into the story ironically. Still, at this point, the joke had worn thin.
This outing saw the return of Subway - now using the name Rick - who has come back to the school to partake in guerrilla marketing where he advertises to students in the guise of being a regular person. The Dean is particularly susceptible to this and purchases way more than he needs. There's also a subplot that sees Jeff struggle with the fact that the newly introduced Elroy doesn't like him.
Seeing Rick back was something fans were happy about, but the soulless corporate selling here felt a little too on the nose. The first time he appeared, his narrative with Britta wasn't the centre of the episode, so it worked well, but here he felt way more like the primary narrative, and it was simply too much.
3. Alternative History Of The German Invasion
The Germans from Foosball and Nocturnal Vigilantism were a fun bunch in moderation, but no one asked for a full episode of them. Seeing them return to irritate the Study Group was unexpected, and not in a pleasant way. That pretty much sums up this entire episode.
In this chapter of Greendale, the gang begins their new history class, only to be caught up in a battle with the German students who take control of the study room and force them to look for alternative spaces. This did paint an amusing picture of how much hatred the group attained by hogging the classic study space, but that's about it for smart humour here.
If you're a fan of campy German stereotypes, then this might be the one for you, but for most viewers, this was a cheap and lazy set of jabs that harkened to a style of comedy which felt beneath the witty and clever show.
This episode also introduced Kevin and his Changnesia into the fray, which re-set the character in a decent way, but - as stated in an earlier entry - was far too silly and unbelievable.
2. Economics Of Marine Biology
Just like the show had to sell a little bit of its soul for cash, so did Greendale, and that's what the crux of this episode was about. The outing was a return to something simple - which was sorely needed - but didn't do much to stand out.
It followed as the students of Greendale, and the Dean, of course, tried their best to convince a rich student (Archie) to enrol in the college and spend a tonne of money. Naturally, they have to sell out their integrity to do so.
Seeing Greendale sell itself out to please a rich kid had some funny moments but also felt regressive. While high concept episodes had become the norm, and breaks were appreciated, this one walked the line between too simple and too over-the-top that it ended up feeling mundane and out of place.
It's also unfortunate that Abed's little frat warfare narrative was pushed into the background, especially as his off-screen antics sounded way more fun than what we got to see. If the whole episode had been dedicated to that format, then it might have faired better, but that's not how the cookie crumbled.
Then, to add insult to injury, the character of Archie was never seen again, making the entire outing seem pointless.
1. Lawnmower Maintenance & Postnatal Care
"Jesus wept!", well, it wasn't just Jesus who was weeping, as the fans who watched this episode were too.
Parodying movies was a big part of Community's identity, but of all the films to choose, was Lawnmower Man the right one? The outing followed as Dean Pelton purchased a fully immersive virtual reality machine and became engrossed in the digital world, all while Jeff and Frankie tried their best to get a refund on the expensive device.
It does need to be stated that Jim Rash (Dean Pelton) got the most out of this concept as possible, as his performance was highly amusing. Still, the ugly visuals and obnoxious attitude of the character made the whole outing a chore to sit through.
Sadly, the VR aspect of the episode wasn't the only mistake, as it also featured the debut of Britta's parents, who had been secretly paying off her debts. Her attitude towards this was to rage and revolt against them, which made Britta seem severely ungrateful, childish and immature. While we knew she was already all of those things, it wasn't as fun here.