10 Worst How I Met Your Mother Episodes

From beekeepers to balloons, which episodes let the show down?

How I Met Your Mother
CBS

How I Met Your Mother is a show which took its viewers for a ride, guiding them along as they witnessed the ups and downs of our five beloved characters. Some moments were heartwarming, others hilarious, however some fall by the wayside. In a show with nine long seasons, there are inevitably some stinkers in the mix. Many people have serious issues with the ninth and final season, and rest assured that the train-wreck which ended the show is significantly represented here.

This list combines public opinions based on sites such as IMDb as well as some others which really should be rated lower. Some of these episodes might not be wholly bad as each one has to compete with dozens of others from this show which generally produces gold.

So prepare yourself as we turn back the clock and find out which episodes are badly written, which ones are badly acted, and which ones are just plain bad. Whether its absurdity, banality or characters just not acting like they're supposed to, get ready to be plunged into the pits of How I Met Your Mother.

10. The Time Travellers

How I Met Your Mother
CBS

As the highest-rated episode on this list, you might be wondering what I’m talking about with this one. This episode was comical, had a nice song between multiple versions of Ted and Barney, and once again made reference to Robots vs. Wrestlers. It sounds like a good formula for a solid episode, however there’s something about it that leaves a bad taste in the mouths of many.

Audiences enjoy the wacky nature of How I Met Your Mother and can deal with the show bending reality slightly – ‘slightly’ being the optimal word. The idea of time-travel in this show already creates a premise a little too wacky to get behind, but the realisation that Ted is in fact only imagining it all doesn’t soften the blow. In fact, the thought of our main narrator and key protagonist sitting alone in the bar with only his vivid imagination to keep him company is outright depressing.

I get that this is supposed to be a low moment for Ted, realising that nobody has time for him anymore, but in such an upbeat show the audience really didn’t need an entire episode to explain that Ted is lonely. The plot doesn’t progress, and everyone is left with the bitter taste of solitude.


9. The Burning Beekeeper

How I Met Your Mother
CBS

Before the disasterpiece that was Season 9, the season which will make up a good chunk of this list, there was Lily and Marshall’s housewarming party in Season 7.

I’ll be the first to admit that I enjoyed this episode. It had an innovative formula of telling the same story several times in different places in the house, letting the viewer piece together the information as they watch along. However, this by no means indicates that The Burning Beekeeper is a good episode. Similar to the last entry, this episode bends reality a little too much, especially towards the end when the entire house is infested with bees. A maddened beekeeper pumping the house with gas and setting himself on fire, leaving hundreds of bad CGI bees keeping people trapped in the house, would be right at home in the plot of a B-movie horror, not a sitcom.

The change of setting is a shock to the system too. If the audience had gotten to know this house and its various rooms for longer, the episode would’ve felt more engaging and frankly more like How I Met Your Mother, however everyone is too used to Ted’s apartment and MacLaren’s for a new setting to really feel comfortable.


8. No Questions Asked

How I Met Your Mother
CBS

Coming in at the number 8 slot is the first of many episodes from Season 9. Many of the plot-lines which made up the disappointing final season felt forced, and the main one centred around Marshall and Lily was no different. Despite Ted being the main protagonist, Marshall often steals the show as the inherently good and likeable main character who can do no wrong.

Because of this, it was too much of a shock to see him going behind Lily’s back and keeping things from her to the extent that he did, and No Questions Asked really is the pinnacle of his deception.

The episode is one of many which raises flaws in Barney and Robin’s relationship, something the season does in abundance, likely to make the audience more okay with the finale. Having Robin and Barney be independent people in their own right is fine but the show paints it as some disastrous issue they're going to have to work past and it just feels forced.

And the absurd ending of Ted stuck in a mailbox feels like the show's weak attempt at physical comedy.


7. The Stamp Tramp

How I Met Your Mother
CBS

This episode has a witty title, I’ll give it that. Unfortunately, in this 22-minute instalment in Season 8, the episode offers little else. Having seen episode after episode of Barney growing as a character, falling in love with Quinn and ultimately proposing to her in one of the most epic and heart-warming ways ever seen on the show, this episode manages to eradicate it all.

Seeing Barney return to his old ways, hunting out strip-clubs which are eager to please him lets the viewer know that nothing has changed in him despite this emotional journey. Episodes that dehumanise Barney are some of the worst. He might be the comic relief character, but he's still supposed to be a person with depth and feelings - something the show touches upon but always pulls back from.

At the same time, Marshall is slandered for being a good man who puts faith in people, and his overwhelming goodness is punished without remorse which nobody ever likes to see. The gang go on an entire tirade about who gives the best stamps of approval and frankly why should anyone care?


6. Mom And Dad

How I Met Your Mother
CBS

The change of scenery previously mentioned is something fans aren’t too comfortable with in How I Met Your Mother. Perhaps it was Season 9's greatest downfall, setting it away from where we know – well, that and the poor writing.

The entire season was supposed to focus on the wedding; however it seems impossible to stretch a single event, however monumental, into 24 episodes. So, of course, amidst the wedding planning, there are episodes such as these which are clearly there only for filler content. One thing people like to see in shows like this is continuity, and it’s something this episode has none of.

Other than the continued journey seen with Marshall and Daphne, this episode doesn’t move the story along at all, instead having Barney revert to being childish as he tries to get his mother and father back together.

And even if you're used to Barney being childish by this point, his brother James is along for the ride this time as the two build up a great deal of sibling rivalry in seeing which of their fathers they can hook their mother up with.


5. Nannies

How I Met Your Mother
CBS

Only a few episodes before Stamp Tramp, this episode encapsulates all of the problems that the later episode has but accentuated tenfold. This showcases the first in a series of antics of Barney trying to get over Quinn. ‘Bangtoberfest’ is a crude event, even for Barney, and especially so when he’s only just broken up with somebody he was about to marry.

If that wasn’t enough, Barney’s selfishness directly impacts Lily and Marshall’s happiness when he has sex with a nanny who they were keen on hiring. Barney might not believe in marriage and commitment, but he’s always cared for the show’s leading couple and him sabotaging them like this feels wrong – even for the typically self-centred character.

On top of that, Ted and Robin squabbling about who has a better relationship while simultaneously pushing all of their problems down might be realistic, but it’s painful to watch at best.


4. Slapsgiving 3: Slappapointment In Slapmarra

How I Met Your Mother
CBS

Yet another journey into absurdity and redundancy, this episode concludes one of the show’s longest running jokes in a poor and tasteless way.

We were all amazed when Robin turned out to be a pop-star, beginning the whole slap-bet bit. We rejoiced during Slapsgiving, especially with Marshall’s gorgeous piano piece and singing which to this day is one of the best songs in How I Met Your Mother. So perhaps our expectations were too high, maybe the show shot for a standard they were surprised to meet and couldn’t reach again, because the last slap comes as a miserable disappointment.

Marshall tries to psyche out Barney by telling him a long-winded, ridiculous and convoluted tale about how he learned a devastating technique from the masters of slap. It might be purposely over the top and exaggerated, but it's also a waste of time.

It made no sense, bent reality far too much for the show, and was obviously another filler episode in this drawn-out snooze fest of a final season.


3. Sunrise

How I Met Your Mother
CBS

One of the key problems with Season 9 is that it did the opposite of what everyone expected it to do. After Barney and Robin going back and forth in their relationship for the entire show, it was nice to know that they were finally together.

Barney’s plan for the proposal was legendary, and when they came together at last, the audience knew that these two characters were right for one-another. Except, are they? Because while I expected to go into Season 9 rooting for the couple, the wedding which nobody thought would ever happen, it seemed the entire season was forcing the audience to doubt themselves. Instead of hyping people up for the wedding, episode after episode made everyone doubt the match.

This is one of those episodes, showcasing that Barney will inevitably return to his old ways and teach younger men how to have a good time and live in his own image.

It's a flash-forward if you will, a big neon flashing sign saying "this man can't handle a marriage".

Meanwhile, it deals far too much with Ted’s feelings for Robin, and the Robin Balloon which he eventually lets go is contradicted by the rest of the show. The entire idea of this love triangle, and the fact that it's more than just Ted having a crush on Robin as she seems to reciprocate the feelings, is too uncomfortable to deal with in a season that's supposed to be tying up all of the loose ends. It’s also super weird.


2. Bedtime Stories

How I Met Your Mother
CBS

I like innovation as much as the next guy. It's extremely refreshing when shows try out new things. Unfortunately, this particular new thing was unsuccessful.

Trying to lull baby Marvin to sleep, Marshall recounts stories featuring his friends and tells the entire episode in rhyme. It was a cute idea, and if it had only went on for a few minutes people might've loved it, but over 20 minutes of a nursery-rhyme format is simply too much.

It was too different from the regular format. Narrating the entire episode in rhymes was irritating making this not only a bad episode but a difficult one to watch.

This episode’s uniqueness made no sense in relation to the context of what was going on. It was something people would expect to see in the first couple of seasons when the writers are throwing things at the wall and seeing what sticks, not halfway through the final season where stakes are supposed to be high. This is a half-hour which I’d majorly advice skipping on re-watches.


1. The Broken Code

How I Met Your Mother
CBS

Several times in this article it's been said that Ted is the main protagonist and nobody could really dispute that. There may be five main characters, but Ted is the narrator and the one everyone sees at his lowest. A good protagonist should be nuanced, they should have depth and not always do the right thing, but they should at least be a character the audience can always root for to some degree.

This was one of the rare episodes where nobody was rooting for Ted, tarnishing the whole thing from the get-go.

The Bro-Code is something mentioned throughout the show, the rules which unite men in camaraderie and outline what friends should and shouldn’t do, particularly with regards to women.

Ted has broken that code by still having feelings for Robin, and for comforting her and holding her hand at the carousel. This episode centres around Ted’s betrayal of Barney, a plot point which is both far too heavy for the show so close to its end and also makes Ted completely unsympathetic.

What did you think of this rating? Leave your opinions down below.


Watch Next


The Ultimate How I Met Your Mother Quiz

Ted Mosby How I Met Your Mother
CBS

1. What Object Was Ted's Best Friend While Growing Up In Ohio?

Contributor
Contributor

Hi, I'm Rhys, aspiring author and WhatCulture writer!