10 Worst Uses Of CGI In Anime History
What were they THINKING.
Mixing CG animation and 2D animation is one of the toughest needles to thread in the business.
You essentially have to have a CG team and a normal animation team that are completely on the same page all of the time, as well as the money and resources to work out all the kinks.
It's no wonder that so many anime just choose to fully commit to one or the other, because trying to make both work in tandem is a task that few have ever succeeded in. While definitely not impossible, it's a lot harder for most studios than others.
This list is proof of that, as these are some of the biggest blunders in trying to use CGI in anime.
They take all of the progress made by anime such as Land of the Lustrous, Dorohedoro, and even RWBY and throw it all out the window into a bottomless pit, making all observers wonder why we even bother trying to put CG in anime at all.
10. Dragon Ball: Resurrection F
Back in the early 2010s, DragonBall fans were given the first bit of goodwill in literal decades in the form of two back to back movies that officially carry on the canon.
However, these movies would be made by Toei, and though Toriyama would be on board at every point to make sure these movies were faithful to the source material, one can only control a heartless corporate entity like Toei so much.
While nowhere near as bad in Battle Of Gods, where it's offset by the rest of the movie being legitimately great, the mediocre sequel Resurrection F's egregious and obvious use of CGI in fight scenes is far more noticeable.
Mostly because they do it way more than they did in Battle Of Gods, where it was present in - at most - 2 minutes of one fight scene.
In Resurrection F, however, the CG is far more noticeable, used a lot more, and it looks SO BAD. That really is the rub here, because the next film - Broly - uses CG a lot more, but it looks a million times better than it does here.
9. Initial D
By now the CGI animation of Initial D is legendary among anime fans, with it being this low because - frankly, the PS2 era graphics of the cars has become part of the show's charm.
There's no doubt just enough of a following behind this show to warrant a remake of the show with slightly better CG graphics but there's plenty of doubt that any Initial D fan would WANT better graphics.
It's like making the story better in Kingdom Hearts, it's just kinda missing the point.
But with that having been said, while season 2 ironed out the graphics just enough to be noticeable but not eye gougingly horrible, season 1...is.
This show, about illegal drag racing in the winding hills of Japan, prided itself on its cutting edge CG animation when it first came out. Which many of you reading this will probably burst out laughing upon reading because the characters and the cars almost never look like they inhabit the same space.
Because while the human characters have lots of detail added to their designs, "detail" was a bit beyond even the best CG technology back then.
8. Sailor Moon Crystal
Sailor Moon is one of those properties that just never goes away, because frankly, it's really damn good even all these years later. But the otherwise universally acclaimed reboot - Sailor Moon Crystal - had one pretty glaring annoyance throughout. That being the insistence on using distracting CGI animation for the transformation scenes.
And mind you, the transformation scenes are in EVERY episode, and take up quite a bit of time, so you have plenty of time to notice how the two animation styles just do not mesh in the slightest.
While not necessarily as bad as later entries, and nowhere near as primitive as Initial D's cars, you still notice it when it happens and it's a distraction from what should be the main attraction of any given episode: seeing our heroines transform to head into the action.
7. Fate Stay/Night
The best thing that could have happened to this franchise was being adopted by Studio Ufotable. Because before they were, when the Fate series did CGI, it looked - well - like this.
Fate Stay/Night was already a poor adaptation of the original story that would be corrected with the later reboot, Unlimited Blade Works, but their portrayal of the dragon was just the icing on the cake.
Really, you could see it as the perfect amalgamation of everything wrong with this original adaptation. It's incredibly rushed, the budget isn't nearly as big as it needs to be, but they shoot for it anyway, and ultimately it comes out more laughable than anything else.
The dragon just looks so damn fake, and that's when it's standing still. When it tries to move, it's even worse. And yes this was the mid 2000s, but by then we were already seeing stuff like the Garden of Sinners series, and frankly they could have just drawn the dragon and saved themselves the embarassment.
6. Golgo 13
There is a vast multitude of things wrong with Golgo 13: The Professional, to the point where making fun of a sequence that hyper-focuses on shoddy late 80s CGI helicopters that feels a good 10 minutes longer than it actually is feels like missing the forest for the trees.
That being said, good lord this is bad.
A common theme you'll find with every entry on this list is that it isn't just the quality of the CG itself, but how long the show or movie just lingers on it, as if convinced that they've done a great job here and you're really gonna be impressed.
However, even for the time, CG was being used to greater effect in other anime like Magnetic Rose.
The fact that the scene goes on for as long as it does, dragging on to the point of feeling longer than it actually is, is what puts it where it is on the list. And yet it's nowhere as egregious as the entries to come.
5. Knights Of Sidonia
Knights Of Sidonia's CG animation is frustrating because it's the sort you can tell was made by people who genuinely loved what they were doing and wanted to make it work, but the technology just wasn't there yet for what they were trying to do.
While at times the anime can look downright marvellous, those moments are few and far between, offset by character models that just fall short of clearing the uncanny valley.
As I said, it's frustrating, because when it all meshes together, it works gangbusters. But other times you just wonder where the characters are looking because it certainly isn't what they SHOULD be looking at, and their facial movements are just a bit too stiff to be natural.
Fortunately Sidonia is mainly about mech battles, which CGI is VERY good at making look cool, which is what keeps this series from getting any higher. But hopefully Polygon pictures will have worked out all the kinks should they decide to revisit this property in the future.
4. Urda: The Third Reich
You know the top three of a list is a treat when what is widely considered one of the worst anime films of all time and some of the worst CGI ever put to screen doesn't even crack it.
2004, the same time that the Lord Of The Rings films were in theatres, this atrocity was put to the big screen and making everyone wonder why they even bother with CGI in the first place.
Now, granted, the shoddy animation is hardly the worst thing about this movie, but boy is it up there.
This film, about fighting time traveling Nazis and yet is somehow so soul crushingly dull you'll want to claw your own brain out with a spoon, features animation mistakes that hadn't been made with CGI since the late 80s.
Hair could not look more fake if they tried, stiff face and body animation, characters who behave like they operate on different planes of reality than everyone else, and so much else that just leaves your jaw slack in horrified awe at just how wrong this movie gets every step of its animation.
3. Handshakers
The only reason this atrocity isn't higher is that the rest of the animation is so oppressively terrible that you almost miss the terrible CGI when it DOES show up, but I couldn't let this list go by without giving GoHands' awful creation a good thrashing.
Handshakers is one of those anime that only comes around once in a blue moon. Rarely do you get a production that gets this much wrong on this level. The fact that this and our final entry came out so close to each other is an oddity in the anime industry, but we'll get to that when we get to that.
As for Handshakers, this show is a product of a team of otherwise skilled veteran animators throwing themselves at technology they just barely understand to bring to life one of the most shoddily built stories this author has ever experienced.
The 2D animation is bad enough, but the CGI stands out even among that, with textures so flat they'd be an insult to any primitive game console I could compare it to.
The CGI animation used for the characters' weapons - I'll grant you - is MEANT to make them look slightly unnatural and otherworldly, but that excuse can only go so far when it doesn't even look like the characters are holding anything because there is just that little merging between the two animation styles.
2. Berserk (2016)
What more can be said about Berserk 2016? It is easily one of the most infamous anime made in the past few decades, just based on its animation alone.
Story-wise, it's perfectly fine, being the first proper adaptation of the late great Kentaro Miura's fantasy masterpiece that wants to actually adapt PAST its most famous arc.
But what makes the show live in infamy is its appallingly bad CGI animations. If you know even the first thing about how CGI works, Berserk 2016 is more horrifying than half the stuff the Eclipse has to offer.
It's pretty rare these days to find a show with such bad animation that, to simulate walking, they just lift the character model up and down while he's moving forward. That's stuff that hasn't been done since 70s Hannah Barbera, but is common practice in Berserk 2016.
Miura deserved so much better in a lot of things for a lot of reasons, and this show is definitely high on that list.
1. Ex-Arm
But at least Berserk's animation isn't so bad that the f$%king FRAME RATE drops. Ex-Arm on the other hand...
When Ex-Arm was first announced, its trailer became the source of near universal (and well deserved) mockery for its final image being a declaration of war (its words, not mine) against all sci-fi and fantasy series around the world. An image that was preceded by some of the worst CGI anyone had ever seen in an anime.
Ex-Arm makes mistakes in CG animation that haven't been made in literal decades. Every character's face is stuck in a default half-smile expression, their eyes locked into a thousand yard stare.
There is so little animation on the faces that they had to put a lens flare over a kissing scene just to keep some illusion of natural movement that would have been undone by the sight of two CG faces clipping into each other.
Anyone who isn't a main character is animated with some of the most awkward, stuttering 2D animation you'll ever see in your life, just in case you foolishly thought there would be ANY reprieve from this horror.
Ex-Arm's CGI is terrible in a way we just don't make anymore. Berserk 2016 looks like Land of the Lustrous compared to this. What else could possibly be at the top of this list? It could only be the masterpiece of garbage that is Ex-Arm.