11 Celebrities Who Rejected The Simpsons

Why would anyone turn down immortality in yellow?

Over the years guest appearances have come thick and fast on The Simpsons. If you include the movie, there have been over 660 different celebrities on the show who between them have amassed a number of guest appearances not far shy of 1000. Some have been epic - like Albert Brooks aka Hank Scorpio - and some, simply put, haven't. Just ask Justin Bieber. There have also been stars who started as guests, but ended up fitting in so seamlessly or so successful that they were invited back regularly. Kelsey Grammar was so good as Sideshow Bob that he's become one of the most beloved guest characters the show has ever seen. Likewise Phil Hartman first appeared in a one off in 'Bart Gets Hit By A Car' in 1991 before going on to amass 52 guest appearances as Lionel Hutz and Troy McClure. But for all of those celebrities who became the foundation for some of the best Simpsons episodes, there were some who - rather unthinkably - actually turned down the chance to appear.

11. Don King

The episode: 'The Homer They Fall' The role: Don King as Lucius Sweet Surely the 'just stuck his hand in an electrical socket' hairstyle, thin spectacles and expressive flailing arms were a pretty simple indication that Lucius Sweet is a close sibling to Don King. Obviously, the character was written in his likeness. So why not cast the man himself for the part? Well, the writers had that exact same thought. They pictured the loud, larger than life, animated Don King in glorious 2D, yellow animation, but King had no interest in playing a parody version of himself. All was not lost though as the role eventually went to Paul Winfield, who had previously played King in the biopic Tyson, a performance that was so nailed on that distinguishing the two would have been close to impossible anyway.

10. Clint Eastwood

The episode: 'Last Exit To Springfield' The role: Clint Eastwood as Dr. Wolfe Dr Wolfe was the no nonsense, lie detecting dentist who creates a monster when fitting Lisa with pre-stainless steel braces. Both Clint Eastwood and Anthony Hopkins were asked to voice the role, presumably to bring some sinister intensity to the character, but both declined. Psycho's Anthony Perkins then stepped in but withdrew later when he fell ill before, finally, Hank Azaria voiced the character for the finished episode. Eastwood eventually did appear as a character in one episode though, though he didn't actually lend his voice to the show on that occasion either. Instead, the man of a thousand voices, Hank Azaria stepped in again singing the "Gonna Paint Our Wagon" song while portraying Dirty Harry's more musical side.

9. Bruce Springsteen

The episode: 'Radio Bart' The role: Bruce Springsteen as Bruce Springsteen It's still not entirely known how or why Bruce Springsteen didn't end up on the show, but it is known that he officially turned down guest appearances in 'One Fish, Two Fish, Blowfish, Blue Fish' and that he later rejected 'When You Dish Upon a Star' Though the episode had originally been written for Springsteen, it was Gordon Matthew Thomas Sumner - or as you may know him: Sting - who ultimately became the saviour of the day for 'Radio Bart'. Tangentially, Springsteen wasn't the only celebrity to reject 'When You Dish Upon a Star'. Bruce Willis and Demi Moore also declined the invitation to play the celebrity couple who move into town but fortunately Alec Baldwin and Kim Basinger stepped in instead.

8. Al Gore

The episode: 'Treehouse of Horror V' The role: Al Gore as Al Gore Al Gore was approached to host "Treehouse of Horror V" but he declined, which might well have had something to do with damaging his political career or anything. But this particular story is more about what came next anyway: karma. Years after rejecting the show, Gore, then approached the show in 2000 requesting a special guest spot. The writers, probably with a overwhelming sense of satisfaction, took their opportunity to reject him back. The ex-Vice President has appeared numerous times on Matt Groening's Futurama show but that's hardly the same thing is it? It isn't uncommon for ex-political powers to reject the show. To date no ex-president has appeared on the show, but that isn't through a lack of trying: Ronald Reagan, Richard Nixon, George H. W. Bush, Jimmy Carter and Gerald Ford were all invited to appear on the show and Reagan was the only one who replied - albeit with a no.

7. Don Rickles

The episode: 'New Kid on the Block' The role: Don Rickles as Don Rickles According to lore, being a nice guy is exactly why he rejected the role written for him on The Simpsons. The original sub plot for "New Kid on the Block" was actually different to one that aired. Sea Captain, Horatio McCallister, gets sued by Homer after he is kicked out of his 'all you can eat' seafood buffet despite having not satisfied his appetite. Originally, it was to be Don Rickles opposite Homer in the court room, but not as Horatio. In the earlier script, Homer was supposed to laugh out loud repeatedly during Rickles' stand-up show, ruining the event and landing Homer in court. That would have been a nice idea, though we did at least end up with the recurring Sea Captain character as a result of him pulling out.

6. Tom Cruise

The episode: 'Brother From the Same Planet' The role: Tom Cruise as Big Brother Tom In "Brother From the Same Planet" Bart is introduced to his own big brother and surrogate father. Everything about the character was written to be cool: he was supposed to be a Navy pilot, motorcycle rider and the perfect mentor. He was also supposed to be Tom Cruise. But it wasn't to be as Cruise said no and Simpsons regular Phil Hartman did the voice instead. Coincidentally, Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman also turned down the same role that Bruce Willis and Demi Moore rejected in "When You Wish Upon a Star", making it two rejections from the Mission Impossible star.

5. Jim Carrey

The episode: 'Simpsons Tall Tales' The role: Jim Carrey as Singing Hobo The Simpsons almost fulfilled an odd wish to see Jim Carrey as a drunken raconteur, when they lined him up as the singing hobo in the "Simpsons Tall Tales" episode. But alas, it wasn't to be. Okay, so Jim Carrey actually said yes to being on the show: he actually received the script and intended to play the part. But then, when it was time to shoot, he realised that he was too busy with his other projects to record the lines. Again Hank Azaria stepped in and, to be fair, made an awesome singing hobo but it could have been great with Carrey.

4. George Takei

The episode: 'Marge vs. the Monorail' The role: George Takei as George Takei Ok, George Takei appeared on the show numerous times and has played a handful of different roles but the circumstances of this particular rejection and the solution to the missing character were too interesting to omit from the list. The basic premise of "Marge vs. the Monorail" was to take a pop at public transport. Mr Takei, at the time, was a member of the board of directors of the Southern California Rapid Transit District and because of his position he simply wasn't willing to mock public transport. How cool is that? The Southern California Rapid Transit District had amongst its board members a man who had actually transported. Fortunately though, fellow Star Trek actor, Leonard Nimoy, had no such reservations and after a quick rewrite beamed into the show instead.

3. Shirley Temple

The episode: 'Last Tap Dance in Springfield' The role: Shirley Temple as Vicki Valentine If there was one thing that you should have in order to appear on an animated comedy TV show it would probably be the ability to laugh at yourself. And sometimes, that ability might still not be enough, especially if the writers are feeling particularly offensive. In the case of Shirley Temple it may be that the latter was the problem. Or maybe she just identified a little too closely with the character. Vicki Valentine was a character loosely based on Temple's own life - namely that she was a child star all grown up. The premise of the episode showed that in her latter years, Valentine had maintained her love of show business, but had developed some serious ego and an intense competitive edge along the way to being washed out. Lisa takes the brunt of both of these characteristics and Valentine, despite having some redemptive qualities, comes off as a monster. That's perhaps why Temple allegedly told producers to "f*ck off" when offered the part. Still, Tress MacNeille still managed to bring the character to life wonderfully.

2. Quentin Tarantino

The episode: 'Simpsoncalifragilisticexpiala(Annoyed Grunt)cious' The role: Quentin Tarantino as Quentin Tarantino When show-within-a-show Itchy & Scratchy did a Reservoir Dogs/Pulp Fiction parody, the demigod of brutality and orchestrator of gore, Quentin Tarantino, showed up. Except the real Tarantino didn't. The story goes that Quentin Tarantino accepted the call from the producers but scoffed at the script, apparently because the lines were 'insulting', although which part isn't entirely clear. Perhaps it was the "violence is everywhere in society" lines? Or maybe the decapitation that takes place during the soliloquy? We will probably never know for sure, but one thing is certain: there are clearly no hard feelings between Tarantino and the show because he's been seen in public wearing the Simpsonsised version of the character on a t-shirt since.

1. Prince

The episode: Unproduced sequel to 'Stark Raving Dad' The role: Prince as Leon Kompowsky as Prince Michael Jackson absolutely nailed the role of Leon Kompowsky. Even though he didn't receive credit he was responsible for most of the "Do The Bartman" song and had a significant amount of input into the "Stark Raving Dad" episode as a whole. And what better way to continue the epic super star delusions of old Leon Kompowsky than to bring him back, this time as Prince? Everything was in place: Prince saw the appeal and agreed to the show but it was quickly alleged that the script originally sent to Prince wasn't the same as the one he was recording from. In true super star fashion Prince threw a world class hissy fit and outright rejected to work from anything but the original script that he had seen, and, since nobody knew what script he was talking about, a stand-off ensued. The end result was that Leon Kompowsky never made his reappearance. Still, at least we got to experience the magical MJ episode, right? What other celebrities would you have liked to see appear on the show? Leave your answers in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

I have been described as a sportsman with the brain of an athlete and the body of a scientist. Since it was established that playing wouldn't work out for me I have taken to writing.