11 Times Doctor Who Stupidly Spoiled Its Own Secrets

Where's River Song when you need her?

"Fingers on lips!" As it turns out, the BBC really ought to take a leaf out of the Tenth Doctor's book because they're usually directly responsible for their own downfall. As one of the most highly publicised and discussed shows on TV, Doctor Who is always under a heightened level of public scrutiny which means that its paranoid producers are even more inclined to keep its upcoming developments underwraps. So why, then, are they so bloody bad at doing it? In their defence, they have managed to keep a lot of stuff secret over recent years. Nobody saw Missy's grand reveal coming (apart from the fact that everyone totally did!), while Tom Baker's unannounced cameo in The Day of the Doctor was one of those genuinely gobsmacking moments that united the show's fandom in a spontaneous outburst of unequivocal joy. Every now and then, though, something manages to fall through the net. They're only human, after all. Despite the fact the BBC invest a lot of time and effort into protecting the show's future storylines, it's probably impossible to assume that everything will remain under tight lock and key until broadcast. The Internet doesn't help matters but it's actually shocking how many times people associated with the show have messed up by revealing something they shouldn't. Don't believe us? Here are 11 times Doctor Who stupidly spoiled its own secrets. Where's River Song when you need her?!


11. The Doctor Dying In The Series 6 Premiere... Ruined By The BBC Announcing It Earlier That Same Day

The Secret: Each opening adventure is guaranteed to be bigger and better than the one before and the ever scheming Steven Moffat ensured that Doctor Who returned to our screens with an almighty bang in 2011 when Matt Smith's incarnation of the titular Time Lord was shot dead - like, properly dead - within the first 10 minutes of the series premiere. Blimey, Charlie. How It Was Spoiled: Well, the BBC literally confirmed that it was going to happen a few hours before the episode aired. Not only that but they also released actual pictures of the scene in question, for apparently no justifiable reason whatsoever, just in case viewers hadn't cottoned on to the fact that one of the show's main characters was going to be killed off by the preceding 'Who will die?' marketing campaign. The death of the Doctor was shocking, sure, but just think how shocking it would've been if none of us had actually known it was coming. "Spoilers, sweetie!" indeed.

10. Doctor Who Hollywood Movie Plans Exposed In Leaked Sony Emails

The Secret: A Doctor Who movie has been on the cards for as long as the TV series itself but the BBC are finally preparing to take the Time Lord to the big screen as they're steadily planning a feature-length adaptation of their now global franchise. Hurrah! What's more, Hollywood company Sony Pictures will also be on board for the movie (!!!) which is set to surface "within 8 years"... How It Was Spoiled: Leaked emails. *Sigh*. As part of the highly publicised and ongoing WikiLeaks scandal, plans for a Doctor Who movie were recently revealed in exposed exchanges between the BBC and Sony Pictures. The conversations basically involve Sony execs persistently prodding the BBC with a stick until they adhered to their demands. Once again it has been denied by showrunner Steven Moffat who insists that there are still "no plans" for a film. Yeah yeah, Moff. You're not fooling anyone...

9. The BBC Confirmed Matt Smith Was The "Firm Favourite"... Two Hours Before His Casting Was Revealed

The Secret: Amidst fevered fan discussions and intense media speculation, Matt Smith had been secretly chosen as David Tennant's successor in the role of the Eleventh Doctor and his casting was set to be revealed unto the nation in a special New Year edition of Doctor Who Confidential. He'd already been inhabiting the role for over a month and they'd done a great job at hiding it thus far, even sneaking him into the the BBC Television Centre under false pretences for his first official Doctor Who photoshoot on Christmas Eve. Sneaky! How It Was Spoiled: By the BBC running a report citing Matt Smith as the "firm favourite" in a news segment that was broadcast directly before his anticipated announcement. Viewers basically went into the Doctor Who Confidential episode with his name already at the forefront of their minds which meant that it wasn't actually a surprise at all when he did pop up. BBC News subsequently released a statement to affirm that it had been a pure coincidence, which is one thing the Doctor himself has told us never to ignore. Unless we're busy. But why even bother to mention Matt at all, if his casting was just speculation? It all smells a bit fishy to us...

8. Series 8 Scripts Were Leaked Online... Totally Ruining The 12th Doctor's First 5 Episodes

The Secret: A new Doctor always finds himself under an intense level of public scrutiny and this was no different for Peter Capaldi who was announced as the twelfth incarnation of TV's favourite Time Lord back in 2013. Filming on his first string of adventures began in earnest the following January and the BBC were keeping things tightly close to their chest with the promise that the show would come back bigger and better than ever before with Peter heralding the franchise into a shining new era... How It Was Spoiled: And then this thing happened. Well, five things, to be more precise, as the full scripts for the first half of the Twelfth Doctor's debut series randomly appeared online after a security lapse made the documents publicly available via the BBC's Latin America headquarters in Miami. The BBC appealed for fans not to read them, of course, but there's not much you can do as soon as something has succumbed to the darkest realms of the Internet. The official Doctor Who website even tried to bribe fans by releasing a new clip from the upcoming series as a thank you for resisting the temptation. Desperate times, and all that.

7. Christopher Eccleston's Exit Was Leaked, Denied And Then Confirmed Again

The Secret: Christopher Eccleston received critical and fan acclaim for his portrayal of the Ninth Doctor and as soon as he first appeared on our screens, it was undeniable that the role of TV's favourite Time Lord was a part he was quite literally born to play. You can never have too much of a good thing, though (as Doctor Who fans well know by now!), and viewers were left disheartened when it was revealed that Chris would be stepping down from his reputable role as the Universe's coveted defender at the end of his first series. How It Was Spoiled: By a tabloid, of course. It was a newspaper that first broke word of Chris' shock departure before pressuring the BBC into releasing an official statement, which they did as part of a slapdash press release featuring a quote from Christopher Eccleston admitting that he didn't want to become "typecast". The thing is, the quote was fabricated and the BBC later had to backtrack by revealing that they'd gone against their own guidelines by releasing false information about one of their actors. In short, nobody really knew what the hell was going on, but it's no wonder Chris doesn't like to talk about it!

6. Leaked Emails Confirmed That Matt Smith Was Leaving

The Secret: The Eleventh Doctor's tenure aboard the TARDIS had heralded the franchise into new levels of global success but all good things must come to an end and Matt Smith decided to call it a day in 2013 after four spectacular years at the honourable helm of time and space. The actor would bow out in spectacular style during the forthcoming Christmas Special because nothing quite says festive spirit like getting your heart ripped out by your beloved's regeneration... apparently. How It Was Spoiled: How else? Leaked emails, of course! Secret online exchanges between careless BBC employees *somehow* surfaced online which meant that the BBC were pressured into announcing Matt's departure months earlier than they'd originally planned. They subsequently compiled a slapdash press release and preceded to hold their head high about the embarrassing situation, despite the fact it had already been picked up by, like, all of the major newspapers and they, as per, were the last to arrive at their own party. Seriously, guys. When it says 'Reply all' on your email, that's exactly what it means.

5. Rose Tyler Making A Surprise Return In Series 4... Ruined When Billie Piper Was Pictured On Set

The Secret: Rose Tyler broke the heart of the nation at the end of Series 2 when she parted ways with the Tenth Doctor on the shores of Bad Wolf Bay. It was highly publicised as their "final farewell" and, to all intents and purposes, it really looked like it was. "Anything can happen in sci-fi" of course (which Billie kept harping on about like a broken record as soon as she left) and, rather unexpectedly, everybody's favourite shop girl turned Earth Defender was back with an almighty vengeance a grand total of one series later. How It Was Spoiled: Well, Billie being pictured on set by a fan was a bit of a giveaway. After all, it makes complete sense to secretly bring back one of the show's most popular actresses and then make her film in the middle of a crowded Cardiff street. The preceding Internet stir forced the BBC to "announce" her return by revealing that she'd be appearing in an undisclosed number of episodes, for an undisclosed amount of time and for reasons that would remain... erm, undisclosed. At least they took the time to tell us she was back. Because none of us knew that already.

4. Catherine Tate Revealed David Tennant Was Leaving... A Year Before It Was Actually Announced

The Secret: After Series 4 of Doctor Who managed to break ratings records and catapult the show into new levels of mainstream success, the BBC decided to take the next logical step by cutting down its production and churning out 4 sporadic 'specials' throughout 2009 as opposed to the full 13 episode run that its fans had grown accustomed to. Um. It probably made sense at the time. One of the hot topics that dominated discussions was what the 'gap year' would mean for David Tennant's fate as the Tenth Doctor. It seemingly made sense for him to bow out at the end of the specials but the BBC were naturally keeping his future in the TARDIS close to their chests... How It Was Spoiled: By Catherine Tate and her big old mouth! It wasn't her fault, of course, as she somehow (???) didn't realise that David Tennant's future in the role was being closely guarded as one of the biggest secrets in TV history. The Donna Noble actress casually let slip - during a 2007 radio interview - that he'd be stepping down as the titular Time Lord after the 2009 specials, which the BBC promptly denied before eventually confirming it almost a year later. Needless to say, Catherine hasn't taken part in any Doctor Who interviews since.

3. The Series 2 Finale Trailer Totally Gave Away The Daleks' Shock Comeback

The Secret: Fans had been promised a spectacular extravaganza with one of the Doctor's oldest adversaries, the Cybermen, in the Series 2 finale which would've been an epic enough occurrence in itself. The threat soon escalated into new realms of uncharted territory when it was revealed that the Daleks had also come along for the party and the ever persistent pepperpots made an unannounced return during the climactic final moments of Army of Ghosts. Who knew?! How It Was Spoiled: Well, if you'd watched the preceding finale trailer a bit more closely, you probably would've guessed! One fleeting shot featured an innocent civilian being exterminated on the streets and the fact that the death ray was coming from the skies suggested that it wasn't of Cyber origin. The skeleton was a bit of a giveaway, too. The shock reveal of the formidable Cult of Skaro was still pretty pulse-racing but it was all rather disappointing in the end, since the long awaited showdown between two of Doctor Who's most famous foes was overshadowed by the dominating *drama!!!1111one* encapsulating Billie Piper's highly publicised departure. The Dalek/Cyber banter was on top form, however.

2. Doctor Who's Long Awaited Comeback Episode Was Leaked By A BBC Employee

The Secret: Just over a decade ago, the revived series of Doctor Who was nothing more than a hopeful glimmer in the BBC's eye and it felt like the whole world was eagerly awaiting the grand comeback of the nation's favourite Time Lord. It was on track to become one of the biggest moments in British TV history and Saturday 26th March 2005 couldn't come soon enough, especially for one particularly eager employee who decided to take matters into their own hands... How It Was Spoiled: ...by leaking the entire first episode, Rose, online. Seriously. It was a rough cut of the premiere, with no special effects and opening titles with the old theme tune, but a watchable cut of it nonetheless. It appeared online overnight and by the following morning this shocking display of BBC conspiracy had made front page news across the country. But just who had been responsible for the leak, you ask? Well, their identity has never been revealed, but rest assured that their contract with the BBC was promptly exterminated. That's what you get for being impatient. And, you know, breaking copyright law.

1. The Series 7 Boxset Was Released Before The Finale... Completely Ruining The Cliffhanger Twist

The Secret:Just when you think you're finally getting your head around Doctor Who's ever evolving mythology, Steven Moffat decides to throw an almighty spanner in the works. Such was the case in the climactic final moments of the Series 7 finale, The Name of the Doctor, when none other than Sir John Hurt was revealed as a secret incarnation of the Doctor. And thus the stratosphere of the show's fandom was well and truly ripped apart. At least, if you hadn't already read about it on the Internet... How It Was Spoiled: Through a complete and unadulterated cock up, that's how. There's actually no feasible explanation for this happening, other than the fact that the people involved are unbelievably stupid. Fans in the US who had pre-ordered their copies of the Series 7 boxset - due out the Monday after the highly anticipated finale - received their copies the day before its global premiere, meaning they had all of its secrets, plus the momentous 50th anniversary twist, quite literally at their fingertips. A whole 24 hours before the rest of the world. Brilliant. What did you think of this list? Are there any other times Doctor Who stupidly spoiled its own secrets? Let us know in the comments section below!

Doctor Who Editor
Doctor Who Editor

Dan Butler is the Doctor Who Editor at WhatCulture.com. When he isn't writing his own articles or editing other people's, he can be found trawling the internet for gifs of Steven Moffat laughing. Contact him via dan.butler@whatculture.co.uk.