11 Times Star Trek The Next Generation DID Have Conflict

Gene allegedly demanded a crew of goody-goody gumdrops, but TNG’s early years say otherwise.

Geordi LaForge fight Star Trek Next Generation Sarek
CBS

In the 30 years since Star Trek: The Next Generation ended, many of its writers and producers have claimed they had to work under a firm “No Conflict Rule” handed down by the Great Bird of the Galaxy himself, Gene Roddenberry.

It is touted as part of Roddenberry’s vision of a perfect humanity that doesn’t quarrel among themselves. This translated into no disagreements between the main cast and an edict that all drama had to come from outside the ship.

However, the 1987 Next Generation Writer’s Guide openly demanded interpersonal disagreement between the crew based on "human faults and weaknesses". What was specifically barred was "melodrama". TNG wasn’t supposed to devolve into a soap opera of love triangles, gossip, and childish grudges.

How that morphed into “no disagreement at all” is a mystery, but the rule seemed to get more rigid and binding as Roddenberry’s influence on the franchise waned, not less. Picard became fatherly, Riker lost all his ambition, Troi turned into a sad chocolate monster, Data became lovable, and everyone fell into a pit of aw-shucks affability.

If we take a close look at TNG’s first two seasons and especially its pilot, Encounter at Farpoint, we can find a lot of interpersonal clashes Roddenberry baked right into the DNA of show. It’s time to finally put the “No Conflict” myth to rest.

11. Riker Wanted Picard's Job

Picard and Riker Star Trek Next Generation TNG Farpoint First Season
CBS

How did we all forget this one? Demoting the captain down to bureaucrat while the first officer has all the fun on away missions was such a major shake up of the Star Trek formula that it left many fans in a rage induced stupor.

Riker was constantly described in promotional materials and interviews as believing the Enterprise was his ship. He just let Picard steer it from time to time. This was a constant source of annoyance for Picard who was, until recently, the swashbuckler of his previous ship, the USS Stargazer.

Picard often had to force himself into the center of things, much to Riker’s dismay, like in Code of Honor where Troi made a sly case for Picard beaming down to Ligon II to bargain for Yar’s release. Often Riker had to be outright incapacitated, as he was in Arsenal of Freedom and Skin of Evil, before Picard could join the away team.

Riker was also very personable, while Picard was mostly an aloof jerk who literally muttered “merde” to himself when things didn’t go his way.


10. Picard Hated Kids

Picard child baby Star Trek Next Generation When the Bough Breaks
CBS

The idea of bringing families on a space voyage didn’t make sense to a lot of fans and writers because the show totally went off the rails concerning its original “generation ship” concept right after the pilot. Families on a ship doing routine patrol not far outside known space is stupid, but a city ship bound for a twenty year mission into the “great unexplored mass of the galaxy” makes perfect sense.

Picard was the ultimate confirmed bachelor. He didn’t understand families and resented their presence on his ship. Just watch him squirm while having to touch a spittle covered toddler in When the Bough Breaks. This put him at odds with Dr. Crusher and her kid, who he referred to as “the boy” and even told to “shut up” in Datalore.

Riker was immediately assigned as a mediator between him and the civilian crew so Picard could avoid "making an ass out of himself" in front of them altogether.


9. Picard Killed Wesley's Dad

Wesley Doctor Crusher Picard Star Trek Next Generation
CBS

Besides the fact that Beverly was a breeder, these two had quite a bit to enrage each other over. First there was their immediate sexual chemistry which butted against the fact that Picard practically left Bev’s possibly hysterical husband, Jack, to die on a mission.

Wesley Crusher never really got over his father’s death and initially resented the captain for his role in it. The scenario was even the basis of his Starfleet Psych Test in the episode Coming of Age.

Picard’s callous utilitarianism was also the cause of quite a few heated ethical disputes with the fiery redheaded doctor who was always keen to deliver aid and comfort in even the most hostile environments and sticky situations. Watching the two argue the ramifications of drug addiction and the Prime Directive in Symbiosis is one of their better sparing matches.


8. Yar Made The Federation Look Bad

Tasha Yar Cat Rape Gang Turkana IV
CBS Media Ventures

Before Worf wanted to shoot everything, Tasha Yar wanted to shoot everything. For her, one well-aimed photon torpedo could solve any and all problems. Yar’s violent tendencies were constantly being shot down and soothed over by Picard’s and even Riker’s cool headedness.

Whether it was lunging at Q in Hide and Q, trying to blow the Ferengi to smithereens several times in The Last Outpost, or getting killed while leaping over Armus in Skin of Evil, Yar’s brash, physical nature seems to contradict 24th Century society’s cuddly mores.

The Lieutenant’s instincts didn’t come from nowhere. Yar may have loved the Federation so much she’d kick you in the face over it, but she was a constant reminder of its failures. At some point the modern, perfect humans of Turkana IV descended into a mass of roving gang rapists that this poor kid and her cat had to escape from.

And, to top it off, the enlightened Federation didn’t do a thing about it even though the Prime Directive probably doesn’t apply to its own colonies.


7. Riker Was An Android Bigot

Riker Data Holodeck
Paramount

Data annoyed everyone in the first season, rambling off facts and minutia until he received many a disgruntled outburst. Telling Data to shut up in one way or another was a more frequent event than it was with “the boy”.

When Riker first met Data in Encounter at Farpoint he couldn’t believe Starfleet would award a machine anything but an honorary rank. His initial mistrust of Data’s artificiality was so strong Data actually called him on it.

“Prejudice is very human,” Data told his commander, flying in the face of everything we’ve been told Roddenberry felt about his flawless crew. Riker’s response was even more hostile, suggesting Data’s sense of superiority was "troubling".

It’s unfortunate that this conflict was totally dropped by the end of the episode. The Enterprise crew may have been blindly accepting of the technology that surrounded them, but a walking computer with desires and the ability to bend steel rods was something else altogether.


6. Troi Wanted Some Riker

Troi Riker Picard Turbolift
CBS

It’s clear the moment these two met in the pilot that they had a torrid history. Troi spoke to Riker telepathically in a way we’re all sure he could hear, but he refused to respond.

It’s always been assumed that Troi wanted a relationship Riker rejected because of his career. However, Dorothy Fontana’s Encounter at Farpoint plot outline tells a different story, with Troi wanting to continue a sexual relationship that Riker fears would lead to him catching feels.

In the episode Haven this characterization was actually borne out with Troi accusing a jealous Riker of being too emotionally primitive to accept concepts like polyamory and the separation of "physical and platonic love".


5. Troi Spilled Everyone's Beans

Troi Yar Geordi LaForge Code of Honor
CBS

Troi was originally supposed to be the new Spock and she was written this way for most of the first season. Even though she could read and parse other people’s feelings she didn’t care much about them nor did she have many of her own.

Troi was blunt with her advice, calling out fellow crew members on their emotional hypocrisy right to their faces. And she often did it in front of an audience.

She regularly confronted Picard publicly, questioning his mental state in front of the Ferengi in The Battle and telling the bridge crew he was pining for his ex-girlfriend in We’ll Always Have Paris.

During Code of Honor she revealed Yar was attracted to a world leader in front of everyone leaving the tactical officer stammering to qualify her less-than-professional horn dogging.


4. Pulaski Was From Mars, Picard Was From Venus

Pulaski Picard Shuttle
CBS

Picard never gets along with his medical officers, and Second Season newcomer, Dr. Kate Pulaski was no exception. There was almost never a call one would make that the other didn’t take issue with.

Pulaski was an opinionated malcontent, not unlike the good captain. But where Picard was terse and distant, Pulaski was loud and in-your-face. It’s classic dog and cat incompatibility.

Unnatural Selection may be the pinnacle of this conflict. The entire episode consists of Pulaski making more and more dangerous requests as Picard argues for pragmatic inaction.

In Time Squared Pulaski almost seemed to delight in discussing whether Picard was still fit for command after encountering his time lagged doppelgänger.

Picard’s desire to hide any weakness from Pulaski was so strong that he preferred to take a several day long shuttle ride with Wesley than allow the cantankerous doctor to operate on his artificial heart in Samaritan Snare.

While Pulaski sneakingly admired Picard and requested the Enterprise as an assignment, she constantly went out of her way to test his authority.


3. Pulaski Thought Data Was A Toaster

Pulaski Data Next Generation
CBS

Pulaski didn’t trust technology, so, obviously, she hated Data on first sight. In her introductory episode alone she called him a piece of technology and constantly mispronounced his name while making fun of him for caring.

In her second appearance in Where Silence Has Lease she rejected that Data's personhood altogether and questioned his ability to do his job. "It does know how to do these things, doesn't it?" she asks when Data is ordered to magnify the main viewer with no visible result. It was her disbelief that Data could think creatively that created the sentient Moriarty in Elementary, My Dear Data.

While her respect for him grows a bit over the course of the Second Season, she was still his biggest foil, most likely taking on the android-bullying role Riker would have played if he had stayed true to character for more than five minutes.

Pulaski especially stands out on this list as she was created by Roddenberry for a specific actress he’d worked with several times before.

It’s also worth noting that the character who brought the most amount of oh-so-coveted conflict to the show was also the most polarizing among fans. Some people are never satisfied.


2. That Time Laforge Told Off Some Engineer

Geordi Laforge Engineer Arsenal of Freedom
CBS

Arsenal of Freedom introduced a trope The Next Generation used a couple of times: that of a more experienced but less talented officer trying to wrest control from the spunky greenhorn who was placed in command in a crisis.

Wesley had this same problem in Pen Pals when a member of his team didn’t take his orders seriously. Troi dealt with it in Disaster where a certain Ensign Ro insisted on ditching half the crew to save the saucer section from a core breach. Finally, Data had to tell a snippy underling to just "do it!" in Redemption after his fitness to command was questioned repeatedly.

But if you want the best example of full blown hostility among the crew, Geordi LaForge telling Engineer Gumby #10 to step off while the Enterprise is attacked by the Echo-Papa 607 is it.


1. Starfleet Was A Pain In The Tuches

Remmick Picard Coming of Age
CBS

The Federation may be a utopia, but Starfleet is still a hierarchical quasi-military organization that has both discipline and bureaucracy. Both lead to ample amounts of human-on-human strife.

In Where No One Has Gone Before, the crew was saddled with a flimflam artist named Kosinski who supposedly had the key to greater engine efficiency. Riker didn’t trust him, Data said his methods were unsound, and even Wesley seemed cool in comparison. He was arrogant and pushy and no one trusted him. But Starfleet brass insisted he do the work.

Lt. Commander Remmick was a JAG officer brought in to interrogate the Enterprise crew about all the weirdness they experienced over the course of the first season. Questioning both the crew’s competence and Picard’s loyalty, it’s clear Remmick was out for blood and everyone vocally hated him for it.

Finally, in the classic Measure of a Man, the crew is hit with a double-whammy from Starfleet: the slimy Commander Maddox who wanted to tear Data down in order to make an army of androids, and Captain Louvois who has to try Data’s case when the android refuses to be dissected.

The crew’s dislike of Maddox was immediate. After all he wanted to steal away their pet robot. Picard’s history with Louvois was deeper with her having lead his court martial after the Stargazer was lost. Louvois suspected Picard wanted to "bust a chair across her teeth" when they first ran into each other.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Mark Farinas hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.