11 TV Shows That Jumped The Shark
For somebody not familiar with memes and urbandictionary.com, the phrase Jumping the Shark is characterised as follows: A metaphor that identifies the exact moment a TV show has reached its creative peak. Or to put it bluntly, its the beginning of the end of a once great show. The moment in which it becomes clear the writers are out of good ideas and the show has begun its decent downhill. Its usually some ridiculous stunt, story line, major character change, or huge fundamental shift in the premise of the show that is viewed as nothing more than a desperate attempt to raise viewership and declining ratings.
-Source: Urban Dictionary
The origin of this phrase comes from a US sitcom based in the late 50s around a family trying to find their way through life, a series which frankly only the densest of people have never heard of; Im talking of course of Happy Days. Im not going to give anyone a history lesson on Happy Days, thats what Wikipedia is for, but I will give you the link to this iconic TV series and the aforementioned Jumping the Shark; Happy Days had just started their third season and opened with an episode called Hollywood: Part 3, and episode where Fonzie answered a call against his masculinity by donning some beachwear (though leaving his trademark leather jacket on, I mean come on!), strapping his feet to some water skis and, literally, jumping over a shark in confined water. This on its own doesnt sound like much of a big deal on paper, but the issue was that this moment is what the whole episode was marketed on: Will Fonzie Jump the Shark?! and when you are having to market your sitcom based on a gimmicky 5 minute moment in a 30 minute (give or take) TV show it is a sure sign that the writers are running low on ideas. Although Happy Days ran for several seasons after this moment it never really recovered from this creative peak and viewer loyalty began to dwindle until the show was cancelled in 1984, and whilst there were other contributing factors to its subsequent failure (e.g. Richie Cunningham leaving, Fonzie becoming a teacher) the fabled shark jump was the start of the long road to the end in many peoples eyes, so much so that it has become the huge idiom that it is today. Now that I have bored half the readers to tears with a brief history of nothing; let me move onto the meat of my article; 10 TV Shows That Jumped the Shark I have scoured websites and youtube.com for a few days now and created a list of shows which I think truly lead up to the base meaning of the Jumping the Shark title. Now I know people will disagree with my list because, lets face it, it wouldnt be the internet otherwise; but I feel I should give you my disclaimer before people start emerging from under their bridges to troll me and my goats: 1) No I havent watched all of these shows, whilst that may seem hypocritical of me to name shows as Shark Jumpers when I havent even given them the benefit of the doubt I will simply say that to make a list of shows based only on shows that I have watched is firstly very arrogant and self centred and secondly not very broad minded; for me to completely ignore a show that could arguably by the top Shark Jumping show just because I havent watched it narrows your field far too much and luckily the internet can help make up for that for me. 2) The idiom itself has grown very much over the years to not only accommodate TV shows but most kinds of creative areas these days. To me the origin of this phrase was in TV so therefore I will be pure to its very routes and stick ONLY to TV. 3) In my opinion a show that is deemed to have jumped the shark MUST be in syndication now, i.e. no longer being shot. This isnt something associated with the urban dictionary term but ultimately a show that has jumped the shark that is still running to me isnt yet a failure; so for example some have said that Two and a Half Men has now jumped the shark, whilst I do believe that after the Charlie Sheen meltdown the show has been a mess the fact is it is still limping along so therefore doesnt count. 4) I will not be including reality or game shows in the list. Game shows dont really have any creative process to lose sight of like a TV show does and anyone who watches reality TV enough to think that there was ever a shark jumping moment should have their TV taken off of them because youre part of the problem! 5) Finally; Happy Days is NOT going to be on the list. Why? Because it is the trend setter by which everything is measured. To me it is like Laurence Olivier winning the Olivier Award; this may have happened (Im not that versed in theatre history) but to me how can someone set a standard in theatrics and win the award for that standard? To me it doesnt make sense. Plus Happy Days ran for a good 7 years after the Shark Jumping episode so one could argue if it truly had that moment in the first place. Im nearly at a thousand words and so far I havent even gotten to my list, I dont know if that is a good thing or a band thing? Rather than dwell on that maybe I should just finally get to the list. So here it is, my list of shows that jumped the creative shark;11. Friends - Ross And Rachel Have A Baby (Season 9, Episode 1)
Not the most obvious choice for some people, I was certainly torn up until the last knockings; many would argue that the Shark Jumping moment was the end of Season 9 when Rachel and Joey got together. Now whilst I do agree that was a big mistake, for me that was more of a final straw breaking the camels back than someone jumping over the big fish; Rachel and Joey as characters are almost identical to each other which doesnt really create any interesting story telling, needless to say the writing staff were either thinking the same thing or they just listened to the fan outcry because within 3 episodes of the next season the trigger was pulled on the relationship. This was more of a final nail in the coffin scenario, what I personally think started Friends decline (knowingly or subconsciously) was the end of Season 8 and beginning of Season 9; when Rachel gives birth to Emma. That whole situation, right down to how they got pregnant to me was such a fuster cluck of writing that I didnt know whether to laugh or cry, I chose cry; I didnt want to give creative any encouragement. Sure condom companies do put on their packets that they are only effect 99% of the time or something like that but I can assure that is more to do with liability just in the off chance they do fail, the likelihood of that actually happening is very slim. Even then when a girl does fall pregnant it is usually because of a split or the condom coming off, them just failing seems like the beginning of a religious propaganda film, you can almost imagine the amnesty ring crusaders taking the stage saying And thats why, kids, we should all wait until we are married until we have sex. Then we have the birth, after a stupid skit where Rachel thinks Joey wants to marry her Ross decides once again to not pursue things with Rachel just because he doesnt wanna be just anybody. Sorry What Culture guys, get your censors out: b******t! Ross and Rachel have arguably been in love with each other for the whole run of Friends, yes they broke up for a legitimate reason but the reason they stayed apart was something akin to schoolyard antics; this situation is a perfect scenario to set them two back up as a couple again. However it seems the writers decided to insult our intelligence and write a sloppy excuse for Ross to not ask Rachel to get back with him AFTER THEY JUST HAD A BABY TOGETHER! PFFFT!
10. House House Operates On His Bad Leg - (Season 7, Episode 22)
I loved House when it first started; Huge Lauries depiction of Sherlock Holmes as a specialist doctor is hilarious and gripping at times. However there was always a fear that such a larger than life character would only grow bigger and bigger in an attempt to appease fans, and the problem with that is that when something swells so big, it undoubtedly bursts. This moment for me is, take a deep breath because this is going to be long; when House decides to operate on his bad leg because he discovers tumours have formed because of an experimental drug he has been using that he stole from the rat testing lab because the drug is a muscle growth stimulant but because House is such an idiot rather than admit to what he has done he decides to try and remove them himself in his home bathroom. Yes you did read that right. Again I could have maybe chosen the more obvious choices like when Cuddy finally warmed to Houses boyish behaviour enough to date him or when he finally overcame his opiate addiction but to me they actually opened up more creative possibilities; changing things and seeing how House can adapt to these new situations. Unfortunately House couldnt adapt to the new life he was living, or the creative couldnt in the least, so House eventually fell off of the wagon, Cuddy dumped him and he wound up trying to do something even more wacky than he did last week, like operating on your own leg! This to me was someone in creative coming up with a shock tactic, something like Guys, I got the perfect idea for House and the fans will be so shocked by it! Theyll never see it coming! We never saw it coming thats true, because it was stupid; even for Greg House! That to me was a lead in for its demise; he then decides to try and kill Cuddy because of his heartbreak at the end of season 7 and because of that I decided I was done with House, as did many fans after that, the 8th season would be the final one.
9. Star Trek: Enterprise Xindi Attack Earth All Of Season 3
Now I am probably one of the few fans of Star Trek Enterprise in existence (sorry ladies, this one of a kind guy is spoken for!) but to me Star Trek Enterprise was at least an attempt and trying to give the franchise a much needed shot in the arm. Fans argue that it went against everything Roddenberry, it broke canon and that production was, putting lightly, crap across so many areas. Whilst this was true; I can argue that breaking from canon and deviating from Rodden-law has been two of the many reasons a certain two Star Trek films have seen such success in the last few years; they picked up from where Enterprise left off, Enterprise fell mostly because of production issues in my opinion, fans could have forgiven the break in canon if the show was more watchable. I digress, Im here to talk about when Enterprise jumped the shark; and no Im not going to say the minute it started! Enterprise had at least two good seasons that were at least entertaining but then for the third season they decided to mix things up a bit by introducing us to an alien race we had never encountered before; the Xindi. Enterprise as a whole was a very complex series within Star Trek so trying to explain the Xindi storyline will probably cause a low sense of self worth that youd be mistaken to thinking you had just left a One Direction concert. However the basis of the story was the Xindi had been led to believe by some evil race of the future that Earth was a threat to them and that they must be destroyed before they get too powerful, so the Xindi create a weapon with the help of these future dwellers, which looks like it was designed by George Lucas and Anthony Burgess, and launch an attack on Earth (attacking Florida, maybe they were sick of the queues at Disney). This then causes Starfleet to respond by sending the Enterprise to the Delphic Expanse (where the Xindi are dwelling) which is a huge nebula cloud where the laws of physics dont operate apparently. The whole of Season 3 followed this story, in fact Im fairly certain that Enterprise was one of the first TV Shows (probably after 24) that had a continual story running through a whole Season. Whilst this is common now and revolutionary in its day (I for one was initially excited) the tapestry quickly unravelled; the writers seemed to be struggling to come up with stories to keep the momentum going with the Xindi story, they restricted themselves and ultimately things which you would probably not see beyond the brainstorming session were green lit for lack of a better option. There were other things about this season that stick in fans throats as well; I think this was the first season that saw Star Trek actually added to the opening credits, they changed the already hated theme song to make it sound more acceptable and instead made it worse, Tpol became a more emotional Vulcan (oxymoron if ever there was one). Needless to say this season was the turning point for the few fans Enterprise had and whilst it did get one more season it was only through hardcore fan reaction that there was ever a season four, and even that wasnt enough to save the floundering franchise.
8. Roseanne Winning The Lottery (Season 9, Episode 2)
I never actually saw this season of Roseanne but having read the program synopsis and fan reactions to this (as well as it being featured on many other Shark Jumping lists) you cant really ignore it. Roseanne was an American sitcom based in the life of a hard working class family; a show which made Roseanne Barr and John Goodman household names. The premise of the show was very basic by todays standards; both parents working to bring home a very limited income to support their family of 3 4 kids, but this was revolutionary at the time, considered one of the first American sitcoms to address many taboo areas like gay rights, alcoholism, domestic violence and abortion, but also to have a strong female lead who was loved because of her personality not her looks. The show was a hit throughout most of its run; however when the last season rolled around it was decided that all the values that we had come to love would be thrown out of the window. The family won the state lottery giving them x amount of millions of dollars, needless to say you then see the family rolling with the A list of that day, splurging money left and right, having to deal with rich people problems and even breaking up the then-thought unbreakable and popular relationship of Roseanne and Dan (John Goodman). This was met with fan backlash, the show had been turned completely on its head and it was almost like you were watching a different program; on top of that towards the end it we find out that the whole series was the fictional work of the fictional character Roseanne Barr played in that series, (I thought Lost was complex enough!). That final moment seems to me as a means of saying we changed the show dynamic for the last season because we knew we could redeem ourselves with the oh it was all fake angle in the last episode, I think by that time most of the fans had switched off and didnt find that out until the age of YouTube.
7. Will & Grace Bloated Guest Star list/Stanley Not Dead Season 6/Season 7 Final Episode
Another sitcom which gave me pause on where the Shark Jumping was; the majority of fans will say that it was when more and more guest stars started popping up to bolster ratings, whereas my own personal moment of thinking in my head Really? had to be when it was revealed that Will had been working for Karens thought-to-be-dead husband Stanley. Ill leave this one to a vote for you to decide but in any event here are the cases for both. Guest stars in a TV show can go either way depending on how they are utilised; people will tell you there are rules on how you go about using Guest Stars like for example You can never have more than 2 in one show or They cant make more than two appearances in a series, these are things I have heard from people when discussing Will and Graces Shark Jump but finding actual evidence of these rules is like trying to find loose change on the floor of the houses of parliament. I think these are just unwritten rules that people who think they know the business will use as ammo, in reality so long as the guest stars are used correctly there is no reason to complain; I certainly wasnt complaining about it when I initially watched Will & Grace, but in hindsight and looking back I can see some cracks in this argument now. Take Karens wedding for example, there were stories going on here like, for example, the wedding itself as well as Grace and her husband going through some troubles but these felt more like the gap fillers between the guest star appearances rather than the other way around. You then start to think that maybe this is why the roster was filled with these guest stars, to create a distraction from the fact that they were struggling to write for their main cast, and the more guests there are the higher the likelihood of gaps being filled. In Karens wedding alone I can count at least 3 guest stars (4 if you include Leslie Jordan reprising his role as Beverley Leslie). Also as I said before, if they are used correctly you can get away with Guest Stars; with John Cleeses character he went from being a somewhat eccentric stuffy romantic to basically an arse who couldnt give a damn about his wife to be, but not even over time it literally changed on the wedding day. This was to obviously give Karen a reason to request a divorce and show John Cleese the door but still it could have been handled better than that but clearly the writers bit off more than they could chew with all the guests. This is probably the strongest candidate for the shark jumping but I just wanted to add my two cents (because I cant spend them in the UK anyway) regarding Stanleys return from the dead; to me it was yet another wasted storyline just to get people to react. Stanley NEVER made an appearance on screen; he was an obscene character usually used as a joke for when Karen was on set. Stanleys character didnt really create any form of last impression on the fans, his death created more sympathy for Karen than Stanley himself because we never met the guy, so why would we care about his return that much? Of course for Karens sake it was interesting, but it lacked the impact of a visible character returning from the grave, plus Alec Baldwin was the guest on this episode so yet again another guest star curse.
6. Heroes All Of Season 2
I have looked over this one time and time again, majority of people are again in agreement over when this show jumped the shark but no one can truly pick a specific moment in itself so I will just say Season 2 as a whole was a write off for Heroes. I have read a few people saying that they think from the get go Heroes was flawed and interestingly they do have a point; Peter Petrelli had to save the cheerleader to save the world because if Sylar (a man who can absorb special abilities somehow by cracking their heads open?!?) got a hold of her he would become invincible (because this cheerleader is invincible, obviously). This is ultimately a flawed story, Sylar cant kill the cheerleader nor can he wound her long enough to extract what he needs to become invincible (because she is invincible, duh!) but also plot changes caused rewrites of the script which rendered the whole Save the Cheerleader campaign irrelevant. Whilst this seems quite a valid point many fans, myself included, were distracted enough with the shiny shiny of Heroes to not even notice this. Season 2 is a different kettle of fish though, a mix of bad creative ideas like Sylar not being dead (and is instead in Mexico or something?) and is drained of his powers, he then takes up border dodging with some locals, one of which has some weird I cause death with weird black eyes and goo power that Sylar slobberingly wants the same way I wanted my friends Charizard Pokemon card in school. This story ultimately ends with her turning on her brother and shacking up with Sylar, a decision so popular that you never see her again (maybe Sylar did kill her). You also had Hiro going back in time to a Feudal Age Japan to train his idol (who happens to not live up to the pedestal Hiro places him on), a very boring sub plot which did nothing to the bigger picture of Season 2 (if Season 2 even had a bigger picture). Then you had Peter Petrelli ending up living in a box (living in a cardboard box, yeah hes living in a box!) long enough to end up in Ireland, again devoid of powers. This season was SO boring that after a while I just took the Blu Ray out (money well spent) and it has sat on my shelf since. Season 2 of Heroes to me is summed up by looking, ironically enough, at comic books themselves. Say you took the many decades of history that DC and Marvel have ranked up and displayed it as a timeline, yes you would have lines veering off from it where dimensions are breeched or where people jump through time but ultimately you could follow it, to some extent. Now imagine someone then told you to compress that down into a years worth of reading, to a degree it is impossible without sacrificing A LOT of material. This is what Heroes was like; comic book writing where the writers start with an idea, expand on it, realise they have wrote themselves into a corner so therefore have to make up some weird BS to get themselves back on track. Over a long period of time in the DC or Marvel worlds you can find these things more palatable, but over a Season of so many months its harder to swallow, especially for a mainstream audience.
5. The X-Files 1998 Film/Mulder Leaves Post Season 7
This is actually quite an ironic one, there is an episode of X Files called Jump the Shark and although this actually isnt the jump the shark moment it almost feels like the writers were acknowledging that they are on borrowed time with this franchise. Again, this is not a franchise I was ever a big fan of but it did have a cult following and indeed people seem to think that there was a turning point which the show never recovered from. The first bad seed was the first motion picture; whilst it has received a lot of praise from critics it had a mixed reception from the fans. This bad seed then began to take root and before you knew it this bad seed grew into a mutant shark weed plant (New comic book coming this fall!) David Duchovny plays the iconic Fox Mulder character in this franchise, a character who arguably is irreplaceable (probably more so than Scully, Gillian Andersons character), ultimately though you seem to find the more irreplaceable the character, the higher the likelihood that they will leave the show; whether it be for fear of typecasting, egos of the actor, egos of the studio or contract disputes, in Davids case it was the latter and thus Season 7 became the last season he featured prominently in the line up. He continued to make the odd appearance in Season 8 and made a return for the franchise finale in Season 9 but it was clear that fans felt there was too much of a void left by Mulders absence next to Scully; I mean they have become one of the most famous pairings from the least 20 years of TV. Fox tried to keep the program going but ultimately something was lost with the absence of David Duchovny and the Evil Mutant Shark Weed Plant ended up devouring the franchise. (Side note: I am aware that I could be in breach of my own guidelines because another X Files film was made since the series concluded and there may be a potential third in the mix, however I am not counting films made after cancellation or spin offs for that matter either, plus the second film was apparently worse and the third isnt even off the ground yet, it may not even get that far.)
4. Lost Smoke Monster (Season 3, Episode 5)
This one seems obvious and yet to be honest is another difficult one to pin point, its like Heroes; there are so many potential sharks that you are almost spoilt for choice. People get defensive about Lost by saying that, unlike Heroes, Lost was always pre-planned to have the weird and wonderful back story to it (Heroes had lots of last minute plot changes). This in my opinion though doesnt absolve Lost writers, it makes me wonder what kind of grass they are smoking; to sit around and come up with everything that made up Lost and think Yeah that will work from day one must either be in some drug induced coma or literally be so lame at their job they resorted to throwing darts at an idea board. Now I will admit that I never watched Lost and dont have any intention of watching it anytime soon (I never say never) so feel free to rip me apart for that divulgence but let me explain why I havent. The first season I missed purely by accident, I didnt have Sky or cable at the time and at the time Netflix, Love Film and Hulu were not options available to me. I did intend to catch up but then before you knew it Season 2 rolled around and when I heard what was happening in Season 2 I almost did a double take thinking this IS the same program right? It went from being a dramatised reality show to an episode from the original series of Star Trek, especially when you reach our Shark Jump; the evil smoke monster! You got to be honest, a show as wacky and messy as Lost, if you have fans that have stuck with you up until this point and then you do something where they literally go Thats it Im done! then you really must have dropped the ball, either that or maybe Lost was just one big experiment to see just how far fans would go with the franchise, in which case hats off to you sirs! In any case, I digress, in S3E5 of Lost we have Mr. Eko (or something like that) being killed by some strange smoke deviant who we later find out to be a middle aged guy in the last season (?!?!?). Yep thats it, thats the moment that people thought OK you have gone too far. However to Losts credit they managed to churn out another few seasons after that so even though the common majority seem to believe that to be the Shark Jumping moment it did last long enough to wrap up franchise, kind of like putting a bow on a pile of dog turd but who am I to judge?
3. Dallas Pams Dream (Season 10, Episode 1)
Classic trend setting TV drama, without Dallas we wouldnt have half the shows on this list nor would we have the proverbial Cliff Hanger we have become so accustomed to in modern TV; you cant really utter the phrase Who shot JR? without someone knowing what you are talking about. Dallas was THE show to watch in the late 80s in America and its popularity kept it going for many seasons (in fact its popularity has spawned a reboot in the last year or so, which I am also not counting because it is a reboot not a continuation of the original series). As with a lot of big programs though, especially ones that are known for keeping your audience hooked with shock tactics, you reach a point where you either keep going the way you are and the audience loses interest or you can keep getting bigger and bolder which could either cause fans to stay with you or switch off. Eventually with Dallas the moment came where fans probably thought themselves that they had fallen asleep and woke up from a weird dream. At the end of Season 9, central character Bobby Ewing, dies after being run over by a love-sick Katherine Wentworth when she realised he would never love her (not before breaking up his marriage to his then wife Pamela Barnes via a forged letter). Dramatic story worth enough to make any Soap Opera writer proud, however the beginning of Season 10 literally undid that entire season within the first few minutes; after waking from a deep sleep, Pamela Barnes hears her shower in use and decides to go and investigate who it is; opening the curtain she finds (dramatic music) Bobby Ewing! It turns out the whole of the last season was just a bad dream concocted from the seemingly paranoid trophy wife Pamela Barnes (she should write for Lost). This caused a flurry of backlash from diehard fans, essentially you wasted a year or so of their time just so you could get a cheap pop for the start of the next season, you also wasted a year of production/money to create a season of a TV show that is essentially irrelevant to the continuity, you could actually watch the whole of Dallas and not miss out by skipping Season 9; thats just poor production across the board, whoever gave the go ahead for this should be made to watch reruns of Jeremy Kyle until the end of time for that piece of garbage. This moment, in fact, has become such a joke of a moment that Family Guy even used it to end an episode which was, essentially, a jab at Season 9 of Dallas (the whole episode deviated from continuity so they made it a dream of Pams). At least it made for a good comedy moment in a cartoon then, not a complete waste of money.
2. Brady Bunch Cousin Oliver Joins the Family (Season 5, Episode 7)
I hate the Brady Bunch. Tried so many times to watch it and every time I feel like someone is raking my eyes from inside my skull with a blunt fork, its only the parodies and piss takes that I can really watch without vomiting uncontrollably. So once again I have never watched this program enough to really comment on the Shark Jumping moment, although I did think that it would have been the moment that Jan Brady was recast in The Brady Bunch Hour (seeing as this has been parodied and ribbed by so many over the years) but instead the owner of Jaws in this instance is that of Brady family member Oliver Tyler (not directly related, second cousin...distant...maybe adopted). Apparently the appearance of this child was like the birth of the antichrist, actually no it is like the appearance of the Silver Surfer before Galactus devours the Earth, actually no Ill stick with antichrist because that oozes more evil. So who is Cousin Oliver? Well he is the son of Jack (Carols brother) and Pauline Tyler who have to go and live in South America and apparently they couldnt get him over the border because they leave him with The Brady Bunch (maybe they knew he was a bad omen and Jack was finally getting revenge on his sister for all the times he busted his playboy collection to their mother?). Maybe border patrol saw something in Olivers eyes, maybe he saw his own demise and the demise of his great nation in those red glowing eyes and refused to let them cross...or maybe it is all a co-incidence! I personally think it is, Im not going to deny that fans didnt seem to warm to the new arrival, in fact everyone seemed to hate him some referring him to as an utter annoyance, one I saw Oliver on the show I knew it was over. His shows were also rated as the worst of the entire series to the point that Robert Reed (Mike Brady) refused to appear. I personally feel you cant lay this child entirely to blame for what happened with the Brady Bunch though, it had been running for so long and had such a limited humour appeal that I cant help but feel the show was probably on its last legs anyway, though the timing of the shows demise does seem suspiciously close to Olivers arrival (within 5 or 6 episodes!) Whether there is any truth to this or not will have to be deduced by scholars in the distant future musing over our primitive ways whilst the Morlocks try and overrun their society, it seems to have become the associated reason for the Brady Bunchs demist though, so much so that the actor who played Oliver Tyler joked of it on a celebrity Weakest Link saying I hope I dont kill this show too! So that is my list of Shark Jumping shows, however just when you thought it was safe to move off of the page I have a little RED HERRING one for you, a show that Jumped the Shark in my opinion but has not been acknowledged to have done so because in theory it could have been avoided. Its complicated to explain to let me just get on with it so it will hopefully make more sense:
1. RED HERRING: Only Fools And Horses
That whole list consisted of American TV shows that it felt only fair to choose a show from the UK to end on, and not just any show; a TV sitcom voted the best UK Sitcom of all time. Indeed Fools and Horses still stands in popularity to this day because it is well written in terms of characters, stories and the comedy itself; to this day I still find myself laughing as if I had seen it for the first time. This is not just my opinion either though, Fools is constantly re-run on UK Gold and still pulls in ratings to this day, creating new fans in new generations. So how can this show be a Shark Jumper if it is so damned popular to this day? Two words: Christmas Specials. Now that is a bit too absolute, that majority of the Christmas Specials were good too, it was the last few that really brought the show down; to be more precise, the specials that occurred after the Trotter brothers had finally realised their dreams and become millionaires. Originally Fools was supposed to finish winter 1996 with the final episode Time On Our Hands, which for all intents and purposes it did with record number ratings; 24.3 million people tuned in to watch it (myself included) a record which is still untouched to this day by any other UK TV show, the show itself was also the perfect send off for the Trotter family; their whole lives they have been scrimping, saving, ducking and diving, wheeling and dealing their whole lives in the hopes of getting that one deal which earns them millions of bunce, to borrow a phrase from the show, and all along sitting in their garage from day one they had an antique watch that was essentially priceless to antique dealers that ultimately went for a whopping sum at an auction house. The show ended with them walking off into the sunset from their old life contemplating investing their new fortune in the stock market (something that long suffering Rodney and Uncle Albert are reluctant to do considering Del Boys business acumen). A perfect farewell to the Trotter family, something that is hard to pull off these days with most shows being run into the ground and ending on a sour note. Well this is where our fairytale ending does turn sour; five years later the BBC (I assume) thought they could make some more money from the Only Fools and Horses franchise by churning out another 3 episodes, after all the last one had a third of the country tuning in because they thought it was the end, imagine how many more would tune in for the return? Well John Sullivan (creator of Only Fools and Horses) did indeed give us not just one, but three more Christmas Specials for the next three years. These shows ultimately undone the Trotters dream of being millionaires and put them back in Nelson Mandela house wheeling and dealing again. To myself and many fans of the series this was a slap in the face, you ended this franchise on such a high note and so perfectly and managed to undo all that by beating the dead horse. All the characters were too old now really, Del had long retired his bachelor lifestyle and was having to bring up his teenage terror Damian along with his long term partner Raquel. Rodney, despite being fully grown and married and trying for a baby, was still a clueless little boy really (something which they couldnt really pull off anymore), sadly Buster Merryfield (Uncle Albert) had died a few years prior to the re-launch, as had Kenneth MacDonald who played Mike (the local landlord), everyone else was really just too old to really reprise their roles properly. Im not going to deny, I watched them out of curiosity and there were storylines which hadnt been concluded, i.e. the Freddy The Frog Robdal story, but it felt as though these questions could have been answered years ago when the cast were younger and it also felt as though these specials were just an excuse to rekindle fan affection for the franchise so they could launch Rock and Chips (prequel spin off following Del in his youth) and The Green Green Grass (spin off with Boycey and Marlene) I will never forgive them for forcing another three Christmas Specials after they ended it so well, even Roger Lloyd-Pack (Trigger) admitted it was a mistake to go back and make three more. The thing is they didnt need to do it, not even to use them as a launching platform for the spin-offs, they would have probably been as popular, if not more so, if they had made them on the back of the original finale. So why is this a Red Herring? Well because the entire run of the show is pretty much perfect, yeah there are a few pot holes here and there but ultimately Only Fools and Horses is untouchable, it was only when they made the poor decision to make 3 more specials that they Jumped the Shark, but its a Red Herring because some people actually choose to ignore the last three specials and still treat Only Fools as if it had ended in 1996. Me personally I acknowledge the three specials as canon, but I have not (and will not, if I can) watch the shows again; to me it is a prime example of someone getting too greedy and ending up like that scene from Monty Pythons Meaning of Life; just one more little bit and before you know it youre guts are exploding all over the other fat cats. Dont be greedy and leave well enough alone and we may have no more Shark Jumps, but lets face it thats never going to happen and that would give the internet one less thing to talk about, and we cant have that!