12 Awesome TV Shows You Can Only Watch Once

And it's not just about fudging the ending...

The Wire HIMYM Dexter
HBO/CBS/Showtime

Making a great TV show is tough. You have to come up with a dynamite premise, create memorable and relatable characters to place in that situation, and then come up with a satisfying resolution to the whole deal. Unfortunately countless shows have hit one or two of these three goals, but end up falling apart down the stretch.

Very few shows have been able to nail both the entrance and the exit (Breaking Bad, The Wire etc). Too many have found themselves disappointing endings that let down fans and taint the legacy of the show. Whether it'€™s disappointing Netflix bingers or letting down fans who watched from the beginning, some shows just cannot stick the landing.

However, an underwhelming ending doesn'€™t mean that a show cannot be enjoyable. After all, it'€™s the journey, not the destination, right?

Some shows make for great watching the first time, but do not lend themselves to repeated viewings. This can result from a disappointing ending, brutal content, or plot twists that don€™t make sense if you think too hard about it. On the other hand, a show can be so emotionally draining that rewatching it would be too hard on the tear ducts. Here are the top 12 awesome shows that you can only watch once either way.


12. Supernatural

Supernatural cast
The CW

Ok, this one is technically cheating since Supernatural is still running, but for most true fans of the show, the story ended after the epic Season 5 finale €œSwan Song.€ And to rewatch the show to its current point would be a task worthy of Hercules.

The quality has steadily declined since the end of Season 5 and the departure of Eric Kripke as showrunner. Since then, there have been a few bright spots (€œThe French Mistake€ is one of the show€™s best episodes and the Deanmon arc, although short lived, was enjoyable), but most of the output has been mediocre, at best.

It simply is not worth sitting through the 200-plus episodes again. Had the show ended with Season 5, it would be regarded as one of the finest supernatural dramas of all time, but it has more than worn out its welcome now.

Perhaps just stopping after Season 5 and pretending that all of the events afterwards are part of Sam'€™s hallucinations in the pit is the best alternative.


11. How I Met Your Mother

How I Met Your Mother Ted Tracy Ending
CBS

How I Met Your Mother endeared itself to fans quite quickly because it was never afraid to be sappy or sentimental. The conceit was clever enough to give the show plenty of material to work with, and the characters were instantly relatable and hilarious to watch. Who didn't love Barney's life lessons or Ted's nerdy passions?

Everything went swimmingly until the final season, where the mother was finally introduced, and everything was set for the grand finale.

Despite this, the writers inexplicably decided to set the entire season over the course of a two-day lead up to Barney and Robin€™s wedding, before speeding through years of plot development in the series finale. The ending incited fans who felt that the writers had practically negated the entire series with the final plot twist as to who Ted would end up with.

Individual episodes are fun, but rewatching the entire show would be pointless, since the ending renders a lot of the stories that run throughout pointless. It was a fun and emotional ride while it lasted, but the less said about the ending, the better.


10. Spartacus

Spartacus Blood And Sand
Starz

Spartacus was never a ratings darling during its run, but it maintained a steady quality throughout. The mini-series is adrenaline-pumping and viscerally entertaining, with plenty of sex and violence to keep viewers entertained. Essentially, it was the Game of Thrones before the actual Game of Thrones.

It'€™s incredibly sad to view the show now, as lead actor Andy Whitfield passed away following the first season after a bout with non-Hodgkin lymphoma. His replacement did an admirable job, but there was still an air of tragedy that hung over the show.

It still has great quality and entertainment value, but watching the show in its entirety is simply too depressing with the production€™s tragedy in your mind; you simply cannot help but watch the first season with a sense of dread in your mind. Its run was short and sweet, although each season on its own is hugely enjoyable, but watching the show in a straight run is too brutal and sad to be a good time.


9. Lost

Lost Season four
ABC

Much like another JJ Abrams property on this list, Lost was a ton of fun while it aired. It was inarguably one of the best science-fiction shows on television, populated with rich characters and an addictively mind-bending plot. The ending of Season 3 provided fans with one of the best cliffhangers in television history, and it was consistently a hit in the ratings for ABC. And then the ending came.

While some ardent fans defend the ending as €œnot that bad€, most viewers were severely let down how unsatisfying the conclusion seemed. And all that unsatisfying ending did was draw too much attention to the flaws and other unanswered questions that had blighted the show up to that point.

Once you actually stop and think about the entire run of Lost, you realize how many plot holes and dropped storylines there were. What was the deal with Walt's psychic powers? What happened to the virus? Why does the explanation for what the smoke monster is make no sense?

The show was a ton of fun while it aired, but rewatching the entire thing would just be frustrating. Sorry Jack, we don€™t have to go back this time.


8. Alias

Alias cast
ABC

Alias seemed like a show ahead of its time: it was a female led spy show that was both well-written and well-paced.

Or at least the first few seasons were. The later seasons... went sideways fast as the show devolved into laughably convoluted plots about prophecies and conspiracies in intelligence agencies that really didn't make sense if you took more than five seconds to think about them. Garner and company did their best to keep the show on track, but it was painfully obvious that the writers were simply out of ideas.

Like Lost, Alias was fun at the time, but to say that the stories fall apart on a second viewing would be an understatement. By the time the ending rolled around, no one really cared enough to see how it ended, and watched out of a sense of duty rather than enjoyment.

The fact that the show is led by a strong female character does garner it respect, but it isn't worth watching more than once. Maybe JJ should stick to directing movies?


7. Dexter

dexter michael c hall
Showtime

Of all the terrible finales on this list, Dexter is arguably the most disappointing. That's because the first four seasons of the show are some of the best ever on television: equal parts exciting, entertaining and intense. Dexter€™s adventures with hunting down fellow serial killers was the most compelling drama that graced screens at the time.

This culminated in the brilliant showdown between Dexter and the Trinity Killer at the conclusion of Season 4. Dexter really set the tone for shows like Hannibal that provided in depth looks into the psyche of a serial killer.

Unfortunately, Season 5 began a decline in quality that culminated in quite possibly the worst series finale of all time. It was so bad that star Michael C. Hall, who portrayed the eponymous Dexter, even admitted that he strongly disliked the finale as well. Unsurprisingly, fans are still clamoring for an alternate finale that provides a much more satisfying ending. That alone says everything you need to know about its rewatchability factor.


6. Heroes

Heroes cast
NBC

Like many others on this list, Heroes got off to a fantastic start. The first season was ripe with great characters, a compelling story, and potential. It finally seemed that NBC was willing to invest in the show's production value that could provide viewers with an awesome pre-cinematic-universes look at what superheroes would be like in real life. Initially, the show appeared to capture that idea perfectly, and the excellent cast led by Hayden Panettiere, Zachary Quinto, and Kristen Bell certainly did not hurt.

Unfortunately, the show quickly went downhill due to a number of production problems. Much of the show€™s potential was never realized as different storylines were dropped and added in on a whim, which did nothing for fan loyalty.

Ultimately a last ditch attempt to return some quality to the show failed to bolster sagging ratings. The first season is endlessly rewatchable, but the rest of the show is fairly horrendous.


5. Friday Night Lights

Friday Night Lights
NBC

Finally, a show that maintained its quality all the way through until the end. Friday Night Lights is based on a 2004 film of the same name, and the show was an experience for the fans who stuck with it throughout, and the quote €œClear eyes, full hearts, can€™t lose,€ will echo forever in sports history. It will undoubtedly be used time and time again during a coach's inspirational speech to his players. The show was not afraid to pull at the heartstrings, and was anchored by great performances from Kyle Chandler and Taylor Kitsch.

This being said, watching this show in its entirety is an incredibly emotional experience. The acting has a way of making you feel every high and low the characters feel. Even though the show occasionally does descend into sports cliché here and there, it is still an outstanding show overall. If you can make it all the way through again, then power to you.

The show is simply too emotional and involving to experience more than once, unless you have a steady supply of tissues.


4. The Shield

The Shield Vic Mackey
FX

The cop drama is the ultimate hit-or-miss television genre. A show about the police can either crash and burn if it brings nothing new to the table, or it could triumph if it succeeds in putting an original spin on the police procedural.

Michael Chiklis' The Shield certainly triumphed in its depiction of a policeman willing to do anything it took to exact justice. It lasted seven incredible seasons, and attracted some outstanding acting talent. It was nominated for several Emmys, and Chiklis won one for his portrayal of Vic Mackey, the show's main character.

The show€™s dark subject material made it an extremely niche show for fans to watch, and much like the next entry on this list, it was unflinching in its brutality. As great as the show was, to sit through it twice may be asking too much. It was downright difficult to watch at times, and that is definitely a testament to the quality of the show.

Sometimes, the best things are only experienced once. Another run through would be too difficult and would not have the same effect on the viewer.


3. The Wire

The Wire
HBO

The Wire is widely considered to be the greatest show of all time, rivalled only by the shenanigans of one Walter White. The show also received unanimous acclaim, save for a relatively weak fifth season. While the quality is not a question, its intensity is. Indeed, the Wire is on this list because of how outstandingly brutal it is.

One of the show€™s lasting impacts is in its realism, as it feels almost like a documentary. Creator David Simon is unflinching in his depiction of the relationship between crime and law enforcement in Baltimore. His commitment is partly why it's so hard to go back.

Sitting through the entire show twice would prove to be nearly impossible, as most viewers have problems the first time around because of the frighteningly realistic depiction of violence. The show does not hold back when it comes to showing the effects of crime and violence on the lives of the citizens and police of Baltimore.

Any television buff needs to watch this show,however, The Wire is not for the casual fan, and it demands the type of concentration that is difficult to commit to twice.


2. True Blood

True Blood cast
HBO

A much needed respite from the brutal cop dramas, True Blood was the ultimate guilty pleasure show that actually turned into a quality offering at times during its run. The vampire-centric drama started as a rather obvious metaphor for gay rights, and then evolved into a legitimately fun look at the lives of vampires.

The sex and blood filled drama garnered a passionate fan base, as the portrayal of vampires was slightly more edgy than what had come before in shows like Buffy the Vampire Slayer (no disrespect to Ms. Summers intended). Fans went along for the wild ride and looked forward to a bloody finale to the show.

Unfortunately, like too many other shows on this list, True Blood failed to end satisfyingly. After making a mark with its crazy and over-the-top content, it ended in a disappointingly subdued manner, failing horribly to recapture the show€™s sense of fun. Fans were not necessarily livid at the finale in the vein of Dexter fans, but they were simply left wanting more.

True Blood was a blood-soaked blast while it aired, but it isn€™'t worth the time investment for a second go.


1. The Sopranos

The Sopranos Tony Soprano death ending
HBO

That ending. What else is there to say?

The finale created the question of whether The Sopranos€™ legacy is more about the frustratingly ambiguous ending than how great the show was prior to that diner scene. The show was an excellent study of a crime family led by the late great James Gandolfini. His portrayal of Tony Soprano was one of the first in the run of anti-heroes that fans were able to enjoy.

Inevitably, the show's finale was one of the most anticipated in TV history, and it arrived with sky-high expectations.

Even non-fans know of the famous cut-to-black-as-Journey-plays that concluded the show. The ending had fans desperately checking their cable box and calling the cable company asking if HBO had suddenly gone out. They were sadly mistaken.

Reaction was hugely divisive, with some arguing that it was a major cop-out and others claiming that the uncertain ending was the perfect note for Tony to go out on. Whether or not you like the ambiguity, sitting through the entire show again just isn€™'t worth it with the non-ending in the back of your mind.

Which other shows deserve to be on this list? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.


Contributor

Graham Piro hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.