12 Characters Once Upon A Time Wants You To Forget About

Exploring the most disappointing, baffling and nonsensical character disappearances that the series hope viewers have forgotten about?

Once Upon A Time Apple We€™re currently in the summer hiatus between seasons three and four of ABC€™s popular Once Upon a Time. Although the show started out strong in its first season debut, emulating Lost€™s flashback formula to shine a light on the stories of a number of the fairytale characters stuck in Storybrooke, the show arguably lost its tight focus somewhere during the course of its second season. Over the course of seasons two and three, numerous characters explored in season one €” as well as a few more along the way €” have either disappeared with no explanation or been reduced to simple offhand references by other characters, seemingly in favor of bringing even more characters into the show whose stories often conveniently involve Snow White, Regina Mills or Rumplestiltskin through sheer coincidence or as a new branch of their family tree. In doing so, many of those characters' stories have been forgotten in the wake of seeing who the show can cram in next, as if to say, €œLook, it€™s Peter Pan! It€™s the Wicked Witch of the West! And now we€™ve got Elsa from Frozen!€ So while we wait out the next few months to see whether or not everybody€™s new favorite Ice Queen has arrived in Storybrooke to build a snowman, what better opportunity to take a look back at a few of the most disappointing, baffling and nonsensical character disappearances that the series seems to hope viewers have forgotten about? Be warned that the following article contains major spoilers for the series.

12. Mulan

Of all the characters on this list, Mulan arguably has the highest chance of making a future appearance, hopefully in the upcoming fourth season. Introduced in the season two premiere, Mulan was last seen early on in season three, having nearly-confessed her love for Princess Aurora before tucking tail and joining up with Robin Hood and his band of Merry Men. While the show didn't explicitly state that Mulan was in love with Aurora, the implication was heavily suggested and opened the door for the show to explore some interesting territory with both characters. But then viewers never saw Mulan again, with actress Jamie Chung joining the cast of the now-cancelled Believe on NBC. Her disappearance would be a non-issue, especially since it made far more sense to explain away her absence than Meghan Ory's Ruby's abrupt departure near the end of season two and sudden reappearance near the end of season three as if no one had noticed her character had vanished, if it weren't for the fact that when the second curse brought everyone back to Storybrooke, Robin Hood and his Merry Men were all dragged along for the ride... without Mulan. As of season four, nearly every character is in Storybrooke, including Aurora, but not a word has been spoken about Mulan. With Chung still a vocal fan of playing Mulan and with such a big question mark hovering over her in the show, Mulan's return is most likely bound to happen. But for now, viewers have had to sit back and forget she exists.

11. The Huntsman

The Huntsman -- or as he was known in Storybrooke, Sheriff Graham -- was the first major death on the show. Just seven episodes into the series, Graham died in Emma Swan's arms after Regina crushed his heart. Although he had little to ultimately do, Jamie Dornan was likeable in the role, reprising both his Fairy Tale Land counterpart and Sheriff Graham one more time a piece in two different flashback episodes in seasons one and two. With Dornan to be seen next year as Christian Grey in the film adaptation of 50 Shades of Grey and his role on OUAT long since at an end, the Huntsman is a character whose absence at least made sense. But then the season three finale saw Emma Swan and Captain Hook catapulted through time, only to land in Fairy Tale Land at a time when the conflict between Snow White and Regina was at its peak. Through some Back to the Future-level antics, Emma was able to unite her parents, run into a few other fairytale characters and ultimately get back home to Storybrooke. But one thing oddly missing? The Huntsman. Although the show challenged Emma and Hook to fix the damage to their timeline -- a logical motivation -- the use of the Huntsman in the arc could've provided Emma with a far greater moral dilemma. Emma had begun falling for him in season one before it all came to a harsh end, and armed with the knowledge of his future death, she could've had to face the quandary of saving Graham from his own fate, especially due to her interactions with Regina practically begging for him to appear. But he didn't, the show went on and the Huntsman's existence wasn't even mentioned. With Dornan's star level bound to skyrocket next year, viewers will probably never see him again.

10. Sidney Glass/Genie/Magic Mirror

Sidney Glass made his first appearance in the second episode of season one as a reporter for Storybrooke's local paper, as well as Regina's Magic Mirror in the past. Oh, and let's not forget that, before becoming trapped in the mirror, he had been the Genie of Agrabah. For all intents and purposes, Giancarlo Esposito had a pretty sweet spot as a character who had a great reason to be showing up left and right in past and present. But then Esposito was snapped up by NBC's Revolution and season two came and went with only minor reference to Glass being locked up underneath the town's hospital by Regina. In season three, Esposito managed to make brief -- and we mean brief -- flashback appearances as the Mirror and as Glass, albeit voice-only for the latter, before disappearing yet again, with no explanation of what exactly had been going on with poor, locked-up Glass since season one. Even further, after all the fairytale characters return home in the midseason finale of the third season, the Mirror is still never seen or heard from again. And then, on top of all that, when all the characters return back to Storybrooke, Glass continues to stay missing. While his absence can at least be explained off-camera by Esposito's role on Revolution, it doesn't explain why no character has ever seemed to notice his seemingly-permanent absence or why the reformed Regina seen in the second half of season three never freed him. With Revolution now cancelled, we may see Glass show up again, but at this point, the show seems to be banking on the fact that, if the characters have forgotten about him, hopefully the audience has, too.

9. Maleficent

Maleficent's last in-person appearance occurred at the end of season one, in a flashback where she ended up warning Regina of the consequences the curse would have on her in the long run. When the curse was enacted, Maleficent was trapped underneath Storybrooke's library/clock tower and appears in her dragon form during a fight with Emma and then as an undead being against Hook near the end of season two. As one of pop culture's most infamous fairy tale villains, it's surprising how little viewers have gotten to see of Maleficent. Outside of a brief vocal cameo in an episode of spin-off show Once Upon a Time in Wonderland, Maleficent hasn't made any flashback appearances in the main show and her current status as an undead being -- as well as how the departure from and return to Storybrooke in season three may have impacted her -- continues to go unresolved. With the character's new surge in popularity upon the release of the Angelina Jolie film, along with the show's willingness to ride the wave of what's trendy as seen in the arrival of Elsa to the show, it wouldn't be surprising if Maleficent finds a way to re-enter the show, but also unsurprising if she continues to be left in the dark.

8. Cinderella

Cinderella was one of the first characters to ever get a flashback episode, getting her chance to shine near the beginning of the series. Long story short, after managing to temporarily sneak out of a bargain with Rumplestiltskin, who wanted her first born child, the curse hit and she was trapped with everyone else in Storybrooke as Ashley Boyd, perpetually pregnant until Emma Swan arrived. Looking to collect on the debt owed to him, Mr. Gold attempted to obtain her baby when she unexpectedly went into labor until Emma was able to free her from it. And that was that. Outside of a small appearance several episodes later and an even smaller appearance in the opening moments of Once Upon a Time in Wonderland, both Cinderella and Ashley have been missing ever since from past and present, respectively. The series has never really tackled what Rumplestiltskin wanted with her baby and, for those still looking for an answer to that question three seasons in, it doesn€™t seem that one is ever coming.

7./6. Hansel & Gretel

Like Cinderella, the brother/sister duo of Hansel and Gretel were the focus of an early season one episode. After their father goes missing, the two bump into Regina, who convinces them that she will help them find their father if they can steal a poison apple from the Blind Witch. After succeeding, Regina offers them a chance to live with her, which they decline, leading her to make sure they and their father will never find each other again until Emma later reunites them all in Storybrooke. Despite the fact an entire episode focused on the characters, they are never heard from or mentioned ever again. While it€™s understandable that they weren€™t and aren€™t relevant to the overall narrative as much as simply teaching Emma one of her many early lessons about parenthood, the fact that they €“ and their father, for that matter €“ haven€™t popped up if even for a catch-up cameo makes one wonder if it was worth spending time with them in the first place.

5. Anton the Giant

Jorge Garcia is just one of several veterans of Lost to make an appearance on the show over its run. Introduced partway into the second season, Garcia's Anton the Giant gets a centric episode, makes one last appearance in which it's revealed he's been helping the citizens of Storybrooke to farm a crop of magic beans in the hope they can use them to get home and then inexplicably disappears forever. Garcia's likeable enough that one can't help but want to see more of him, even if it means popping up now and again, but the show hasn't bothered to follow-up with what happened to him after the return to Fairy Tale Land or the return to Storybrooke. Viewers may not be clamoring over whether or not we'll ever see him again, but we expect that those involved aren't concerned either.

4. Astrid

Aside from Hansel and Gretel, Astrid is the only other character on this list to show up in one episode only to never be seen again. Whereas the siblings' story at least felt complete, their absence is easy to make sense of; Astrid's is just downright baffling. Introduced as a love interest for Grumpy/Leroy in both the past and present and as an ally to the Blue Fairy/Mother Superior, her unexplained disappearance would be much easier to grasp if neither of those characters also never showed up again. Leroy has continued to be a recurring, scowling presence in Storybrooke for all three seasons, while Blue manages to show up now and again to help when it's convenient for her, but Astrid is never with either of them. Leroy remains, apparently, single, while Blue is even "killed" by Peter Pan's shadow, after which a funeral is held that Astrid, unlike a few other unnamed nuns, doesn't bother to attend. Was there a plan for her originally? Maybe. But if there was, viewers should've swept their expectations under the rug a long time ago, much like the show did with her.

3. Greg Mendell

Greg Mendell arrived in Storybrooke during season two as an outsider who just happened to see Rumple performing magic on the drive in before crashing in the process. Choosing to stay despite everyone's best efforts to suggest he leave, it's later revealed that Greg had found himself in Storybrooke as a child alongside his father when the town appeared out of nowhere. Regina's maternal desires inadvertently caused her to scare off Greg's father when he walked in on Regina attempting to have him arrested leaving town so that she could keep Greg. After a frantic car chase in which Greg's father found himself arrested by Sheriff Graham and Greg on the outside of town, free from Regina, Greg was left an orphan, with no one in the outside world willing to believe that his father had been trapped in an imaginary town. Finally returning to Storybrooke as an adult to learn what happened to his father -- and with a burning hatred of all things magical -- Regina ultimately throws it in Greg's face that she killed him in cold blood. It's a shockingly cruel moment, and the show's decision to position Greg as the villain and Regina as the hero in their face-off is bizarre. Of all the characters throughout the series, Greg's beef with Regina was, perhaps, the most legitimate, having been robbed of a normal life and of his father simply for being an innocent child. But as the series firmly wants its audience to root for Regina, Greg's conflict was trivialized and he was quickly killed off in the season premiere of season three without Regina ever having to truly come to terms with what she did.

2. The Mad Hatter/Jefferson

Sebastian Stan's Jefferson/Mad Hatter popped up near the end of the show's first season and quickly became a fan favorite. Although it feels like he was on the show a lot longer than he actually was, Jefferson reunited with his daughter before vanishing three episodes into the show's second season. Stan brought such a refreshing energy in his debut, which carried through to his final appearance, that the few times he has been mentioned since, both on the main show and the Wonderland spin-off, serve as a harsh reminder of how disappointing his absence is. Being reunited with his daughter is at least a satisfying conclusion to his story arc, but knowing that he could potentially help with many of the problems that have faced the main characters in the time since keeps it from being as fulfilling as it should be. With Stan's career now much larger than Once Upon a Time -- he's the Winter Soldier, after all -- the chance of Jefferson returning to the show seems incredibly slim.

1. King George

As one of the show's primary non-magical villains, King George disappeared from the show after delivering quite a big threat to David in Storybrooke several episodes into season two. Angry from all that had transpired between them in Fairy Tale Land, George informed David that he was going to ruin his life shortly before nearly succeeding in framing Storybrooke's resident werewolf, Ruby, for murder and destroying Jefferson's magic hat that could've allowed David to reunite with a lost Snow and Emma. Presumably, David subsequently locks up George in jail and the issue of what to do with him would be dealt with sometime later. But apparently, George now has a cell next to Sidney Glass, as he's never seen again in Storybrooke, behind bars or otherwise, either plotting or acting on a plot to continue to destroy David's life. Outside of one in which he's barely involved, he hasn't even shown up in flashbacks since. With much bigger fish to fry in his wake -- such as Cora, Peter Pan, the Wicked Witch of the West and now, presumably, Elsa -- it's doubtful that King George will ever get another opportunity to follow through on his anger. Do you miss any of these characters? Is there someone we've ironically forgotten about? Sound off below!

Contributor
Contributor

Writer, film enthusiast, part-time gamer and watcher of (mostly) good television located on the fringe of Los Angeles, who now has his own website at www.highdefgeoff.com!