12 Darkest South Park Moments Ever

Going down to (the darkest depths of) South Park...

South Park Indiana Jones
Comedy Central

Trey Parker and Matt Stone have proven themselves as television’s sharpest satirist over twenty-three seasons. They expose the stupidity in intellectual pursuits and make the seemingly stupid complex and worthy of discussion. They have also created iconic characters and, in the sleepy little mountain town of South Park, a place where anything can, and does, happen.

Also key to the success of South Park is the quick turnaround in making the show, which keeps their social commentary fresh. Parodies and their inspiration are often separated by mere days, leaving their animated rivals lagging six months behind. In the case of the dark and disturbing, emotions and wounds are still raw.

And it's fair to say that the creators excel in drawing laughs from the darkest aspects of life. South Park is both lauded and condemned for this. To the creators' credit, neither has affected them.

So, come on down to South Park where familial cannibalism, Satanic sacrifice, and a former superhero existing on a diet of foetuses are just another misadventure in Stan, Kyle, Kenny, and Cartman’s formative years.

12. The Brutal Death Of Chef

South Park Chef
Comedy Central

The Return of Chef (Season 10, Episode 1)

In one of the most notorious episodes of all time, Chef is brainwashed by The Super Adventure Club, a cult of child molesting globe trotters. The plot serves as a parody of Chef’s voice actor Isaac Hayes leaving the show after Stone and Parker mocked Scientology.

The boy's almost succeed in getting their beloved mentor back, however, The Super Adventure Club tranquilise Chef and abduct The Boys before revealing their secret to their captors. Finneus, their leader and founder, discovered that children’s bodies contain “Marlocs”, which are released by molestation. These “Marlocs” made Finneus immortal, until he was hit by a train in 1892.

The Boys free Chef from captivity, but torn between his loyalties, he stalls on a rope bridge. He attempts to return to the club, but the bridge is hit by lightning causing it to collapse. Chef is subjected to a barrage of slapstick abuse including hitting numerous jagged rocks and his face being devoured by a mountain lion. Chef empties his bowels as the final confirmation of his death.

In a genuinely heartfelt moment, Kyle gives a eulogy telling South Park, and its fans, we shouldn’t be mad at Chef for leaving, “we should be mad at that fruity little club for scrambling his brains”.


11. The Boys Burn Ms. Claridge, Blame Trent Boyett

Trent Boyett
Comedy Central

Pre-School (Season 8, Episode 10)

The Boys had dark misadventures even as toddlers. Back in pre-school, they enlisted Trent Boyette to set a fire, so they can put it out by urinating. However, when they fail, their teacher Ms. Claridge is set alight. Natrually, the Boys attempt to put her out by urinating on her. Trent pleads with them to tell the police the truth, but they deny their part so he is dragged off to juvenile hall for five years.

Later, Trent uses his newfound freedom to get revenge on The Boys. Ms. Claridge is now confined to a wheelchair/iron lung contraption only able to communicate in beeps – once for yes, twice for no. Her torment continues in the present day when her battery runs out in the middle of the road. Rather than help, the citizens assume she is being cold, ignorant, and distant.

When The Boys finally apologise to their pre-school teacher, Trent corners them. Cartman is ready with his mom’s taser. His shot misses Trent, however, the shock powers Ms. Claridge’s wheelchair. She careens off and crashes into the Little Gas Shack causing a fiery explosion.

When Ms. Claridge is questioned if Trent was her attacker she beeps twice, however, the officer takes this to mean ‘yes, yes’ and Trent is taken away for another five years.


10. The Inconvenience Of School Shootings

South Park Cartman Butters
Comedy Central

Dead Kids (Season 22, Episode 1)

With a title as blunt as Dead Kids, it should be unsurprising that the plot of this episode takes a dark turn from the get-go. The Boys and their class are in the middle of maths when gun fire and chaos sound from the corridor. They continue to learn unperturbed even when a SWAT shooter bursts into the class.

Stan’s mother, Sharon Marsh rushes to the school upon hearing the news, teary and panicked. Stan and those around him appear confused and embarrassed by her outburst. Even Sharon’s husband, Randy, is nonchalant at the news. He doesn’t understand the big deal as Stan was neither the shooter nor a casualty. He deduces it is his wife’s time of the month.

Sharon gathers the parents, but they too are nonplussed. Craig’s mom steers the conversation towards the unsafe playground equipment, which is also an eyesore. Sharon explodes at the unreasonable comparison made between child murder and park upgrades.

Rather than winning everybody around to her valid concern, by the end of the episode Sharon gets a phone call that Stan has been shot, however, she accepts “it’s not the end of the world”.


9. The Boys Retrieve Semen From Their Dead Teacher

Tweek South Park
Comedy Central

Simpsons Already Did It (Season 6, Episode 7)

After Cartman’s Sea People don’t live up to his wild fantasy, particularly their inability to play basketball, The Boy’s put them in Ms. Choksondik’s coffee. Soon after, their teacher dies. The Boy’s, with Tweak in tow, take a vow of silence. To take their mind off the situation, they watch cartoons and weakly affirm that nothing has changed.

However, they learn from the news that during the autopsy, coroners found “semen” in her stomach. Prompting Stan to exclaim “they found the Sea Men. It’s only a matter of time before they find the women too”. What begins as a funny yet juvenile double-entendre, the comedy of errors takes a macabre turn.

The Boys go to the morgue to dispose of the semen/sea man evidence inside their teacher’s corpse. Cartman reaches inside her body and pulls out goo. However, The Boys are interrupted by coroners bringing back the actual semen sample. Cartman is forced to climb inside his teacher’s corpse to hide.

The semen and the sea people are mixed to create a parody of The Simpsons’ Treehouse of Horror segment The Genesis Tub, itself based on a novelette by George R. R. Martin.


8. Superman Eats Foetuses

South Park Krazy Kripples
Comedy Central

Krazy Kripples (Season 7, Episode 2)

In this controversial episode, the quadriplegic former Superman actor Christopher Reeve’s campaign for stem cell research is lampooned, alongside the controversies raised by opponents to such research. The Boys vow to “stay clear” and not say anything about the debate, consequently featuring little in this episode.

In the world of South Park, the stem cell process is stripped of its medical ambiguity. Reeve is simply shown dipping into his personal supply of dead foetuses. He snaps the neck and sucks out the “juices”. This immediately results in improved body movement.

Rather than be grossed out by Reeve’s crude and potentially immoral process, the citizens of South Park marvel and hail Reeve as an inspiration. However, he soon gains superpowers from his vast consumption of foetuses. He quickly becomes a supervillain with his own Legion of Doom lair. Gene Hackman, who portrayed the antagonist in Superman (1978), is the only one who can stop Reeve’s quest for world domination.

Rather than fight it out, Hackman champions a ban on stem cell research. After this sanction is passed, Hackman declares that Reeve’s “foetus-sucking days are over”. He is sentenced to be exiled somewhere he can never touch another foetus again – the Phantom Zone.


7. Linda Stotch Plots Murder-Suicide

Butter's Very Own Episode South Park linda
Comedy Central

Butter's Very Own Episode (Season 5, Episode 14)

When she discovers that her husband visits gay bath houses, Linda Stotch plans to kill herself and her son Butters. She drives him to the dock. Jingle Bell Rock on the stereo and Butters jabbering about finger painting give the scene an eerie tone.

Linda explains "if a mommy has to end her life, she can’t leave her baby alone in the world to be raised by a sick pervert". She tells him to stay in the car with his seatbelt fastened, before taking the handbrake off, exiting, and watching the car roll into the lake.

Linda composes a suicide note lambasting her husband with a noose hanging behind her. Mr. Stotch blames the internet for his perversion and declares he loves Linda despite the bath house visits. The two decide to cover up Butters’ death and blame "some Puerto Rican guy". Stone and Parker use this as an opportunity to mock The Ramseys and O.J. Simpson who attach themselves to the "some Puerto Rican guy" excuse to distract their own critics.

Butters’ return is one of the few times his home is shown to be anything approaching affectionate. However, he learns the horrible truth when his parents confess all at a press conference.


6. Crack Babies + Athletics = Profit

Butters South Park
Comedy Central

Crack Baby Athletic Association (Season 15, Episode 5)

The darkness of this plot is starker due to the episode’s sympathetic opening in which Kyle is moved by a commercial highlighting the plight of crack babies. He is compelled to volunteer at South Park Hospital, which has a large crack baby ward. Cartman is also a volunteer. A suspicious Kyle trails Cartman and discovers his frenemy’s new enterprise, the Crack Baby Athletic Association.

Cartman proposes to give the babies a future by having them compete in Crack Baby Basketball. This involves filming the babies fighting over a little ball filled with crack and uploading the footage to the internet. A clear and uncomplicated violation of an extremely vulnerable group.

In a shock twist, Kyle, one of the shows few moral centres, is persuaded to join the business when he learns they made $1,000 in eleven days. Cartman also has an offer from EA Sports, who will pay $100,000 for the video game rights. However, EA screw The Boys over by tricking them into signing over their rights to the Crack Baby Athletics Association.

The Boys learn a valuable lesson. Big companies have a greater capacity for evil and are able to embark on darker paths than mere individuals.


5. Britney Spears Blows Off Half Of Her Head

South Park Britney
Comedy Central

Britney's New Look (Season 12, Episode 2)

In one of the creators' most timely and sharp satires, the episode mocks and empathises with their target in equal measures. Britney Spears makes the mistake of trying to escape media scrutiny in South Park. However, she is papped urinating on a ladybug and the photo is sold for $100,000. The Boys pressure perpetual victim Butters to dress up as a squirrel, with the aim of papping Britney “crapping” on him.

To cut through the hoard of other would-be paparazzi, The Boys claim to be Britney’s kids. Britney is overjoyed, however, her spirits crash when she realises it is just a joke. Britney is dismayed that she is never going to be left alone. In a macabre turn, she puts a shotgun in her mouth and pulls the trigger.

Britney survives leaving nothing north of her lower jaw. She is a gruesome sight only able to communicate in guttural garbling. However, Britney’s management continue to spearhead her career. In a parody of a disastrous real-world performance, her management force her to perform at the MTV Video Music Awards. She gargles over a beat, while being shunted around the stage by dancers.

As one reporter reviews it, “she looked tired, she looked fat, she didn’t have a head. It was just completely phoned in”.


4. The Woodland Critters' Satanic Sacrifice

South Park Woodland Critter Christmas
Comedy Central

Woodland Critter Christmas (Season 8, Episode 14)

Even “the most wonderful time of the year” isn’t safe from South Park’s satire. Stan stumbles across the Woodland Critters in a forest. They plead with him to help them ensure the safe delivery of their saviour. Stan is convinced to kill “the evil mountain lion” but is wracked with remorse when he finds her cubs.

After his grim task, Stan learns that the Woodland Critters are Satanists, awaiting the birth of the anti-Christ. Deery the Deer opines “think about it, do you really think God would have sex with a porcupine?”. Stan is forced into finding a host “non-baptised and heathenistic against Christ”. Instead, he calls on the mountain lion cubs to kill the porcupine’s baby. As they still have their baby teeth, Stan is persuaded to take them to the clinic to learn how to administer abortions.

Kyle stumbles across the Critters and becomes a willing host for the anti-Christ, wanting to use its Satanic power to make the world a better place for Jews. He is soon in agony as his soul burns. Fortunately, the cub’s previous medical training allows them to perform an anal abortion on Kyle.

Stan uses a wish granted by Santa to resurrect the mountain lion mother. A happy ending, until an aside that Kyle died of AIDS two weeks later.


3. Cartman Feeds Scott Tenorman His Parents In Chilli

South Park Scott Tenorman Must Die
ViacomCBS Domestic Media Networks

Scott Tenorman Must Die (Season 5, Episode 4)

This episode is the popular go-to for the darkest episode of South Park due to it pushing the evil side of Cartman to its extreme.

In a feud over the sale of pubic hair, Cartman is repeatedly bested and humiliated by Scott Tenorman. Cartman plots revenge, training a pony to bite off Scott’s wiener in front of his favourite band Radiohead. He arranges a Chilli Carnival as a venue for his payback.

When the pony doesn’t arrive, Scott assumes he has the upper hand in a plot to feed Cartman pubes. When they try each other’s chilli, Cartman reveals he knew about Scott’s scheming and switched out the pube chilli. He counted on Stan and Kyle betraying him and revealing his scheme. Knowing Scott would send his parents to deal with the pony, Cartman informed Jenkins, the gun-happy pony owner, that there were “violent pony killers” in the area.

Cartman glosses over his night with a hacksaw before asking Scott if he likes his “Mr. and Mrs. Tenorman Chili”. Scott finds his mother’s ring finger, her engagement ring still attached, in the bowl. Radiohead make a brief cameo to mock Scott as a “crybaby” as Cartman licks Scott’s “yummy and sweet” tears.


2. Steven Spielberg And George Lucas Rape Indiana Jones

South Park Indiana Jones
Comedy Central

The China Probrem (Season 12, Episode 8)

The episode opens with Kyle withdrawn. However, the source of his angst is far from typical childhood troubles. He and his friends witnessed a rape and did nothing. The plot lingers on this dark revelation for an uncomfortable length of time, until Kyle’s nightmare reveals the absurdity. In a commentary on the panned Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, the victim is revealed to be Indiana Jones, and Stephen Spielberg and George Lucas his attackers.

Kyle implores everyone to remember the rape, recruiting people to his cause. There are two particularly disturbing recollections, both parodies of gut-wrenching movie scenes.

The first is the lawyer’s recollection which parodies the scene from The Accused where the protagonist is gang raped on a pinball machine. The second is Sergeant Harrison Yates’ which satirises The Deliverance’s rape scene in which the protagonist is assaulted by hillbillies who force him to squeal like a pig. Both are bizarre but missing humour.

The famed directors are brought to justice when police officers find them in the middle of raping a Stormtrooper. Along with the dead and raped bodies of Yoda and Short Round, this is enough evidence to put Lucas and Spielberg behind bars indefinitely.


1. Mr. Garrison's Father DIDN'T Molest Him

Mrs Garrison
Comedy Central

World Wide Recorder Concert (Season 3, Episode 17)

The show’s darkest storyline is surprisingly a B-story, in which audiences get their first glimpse at the disturbed sexual life of elementary school teacher, Herbert Garrison.

Soaked in rain and sound-tracked by a melancholic piano score, Mr. Garrison confronts his father. In his childhood home, Garrison asks about the sexual abuse. As expected, his father denies it. In a dark comedy twist, Garrison responds, “I know. I want to know why not”. Garrison quizzes his father as to why he could go off and screw any whore on Ryland Street but when it came to his own son, he was just too busy?

Mr. Garrison later grills his mother if she knew his father never sexually molested him. She breaks down screeching that his father loved him and claims she would’ve made him if she’d known otherwise. Garrison says she stood by and let it happen. “You saw him come home drunk and then just go right to sleep.”

In a typically disturbing South Park resolution, the family’s rift is healed when the Garrison parents pay saxophonist Kenny G, disguised as Garrison’s father, to molest their son.


Watch Next


In this post: 
South Park
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

An English Lit. MA Grad trying to validate my student debt by writing literary fiction and alternative non-fiction.