12 Genius Decisions By Star Trek Captains
Don't you wish you were as clever as a Starfleet captain?
We can argue endlessly about who is the greatest Starfleet captain of all time (and why it’s Jean Luc Picard). And there are plenty of articles out there that do just that. But, what is undeniable is that Starfleet officers are the cream of the crop. And if you’re one of the lucky who’ve worked your way up to the rank of Captain you’re probably pretty sharp.
Most Starfleet Captains we see on screen are certified geniuses. Think about it, you’d almost have to be in that job. You're zipping around space, in command of hundreds of crewmembers. Not to mention you're in charge of some of the most advanced tech that the Federation has to offer.
So, let’s talk about some of the genius decisions made by these elite individuals.
12. John Harriman Decides To Let Kirk Do His Job
You may not remember the name, John Harriman. That’s because he only shows up for a few minutes in Star Trek: Generations. Harriman was the commander of the Enterprise 1701-B. He barely had the ship out of dry dock before a crisis struck.
The Enterprise receives a distress call from an El-Aurian refugee ship that is caught in some sort of energy ribbon. When the Enterprise arrives Harriman makes several suggestions to save the refugees. However, each of his plans fails. Lucky for Harriman, he has a secret weapon sitting right on his bridge- Captain James T. Kirk.
Kirk was onboard as a spectator for the ship’s maiden voyage, but, seeing as he’s arguably the greatest captain of his time, Harriman presses Kirk into service. Putting away his pride, Harriman asks Kirk for the correct course of action. Kirk saves the day, proving Harriman’s decision to hand over the reins to be a genius move.
11. Pike Decides To Share His Academy Transcript
Captain Christopher Pike found himself with a difficult task when he took command of the USS Discovery. The ships previous captain, Gabriel Lorca, turned out to be a mirror universe imposter. He dragged the crew into his universe and forced them to take part in his devious plan to overthrow the Terran Empress.
Needless to say, the crew of the Discovery had trust issues. So, Pike needed to gain their respect. However, he didn’t have the benefit of time on his hands. Starfleet had ordered the Discovery on a mission of immediate importance. So, Pike made a spur of the moment brilliant move to gain his new crews' rust.
He threw his entire Starfleet service record on the main viewer for display, worts and all. He even highlighted his failures at Starfleet Academy. This amazing display of humility immediately ingratiated him to his new crew. And, it allowed him to get to work quickly.
10. Sisko Decides To Punch Q
You remember Q, right? He’s the immortal, omnipotent, omnipresent, trickster. He plagued both Captains Picard and Janeway. Sure, Starfleet is all about discovering new lifeforms, but Q is not the kind of lifeform you want hanging around. He’s prone to things like instigating Borg attacks and altering the timeline.
That’s why Benjamin Sisko may have found the best way to deal with this non-corporeal bully. He punched him. Like, right in the face. It was brilliant.
A little backstory, Q showed up on DS9 in pursuit of a woman. When Sisko discovered him he demanded that Q leave. In a very ‘Q’ move the alien transformed Quark's Bar into a boxing ring and challenged Sisko to a fight.
And Sisko rocked Q right in the jaw. That was the last time anyone saw Q aboard Deep Space Nine. That single punch saved Sisko and crew a hell of a lot of trouble.
9. Picard Decides To Destroy The Enterprise
The Enterprise crew finds themselves trapped in a strange black void of space. Nothing in this void seems right. Romulan Warbirds appear out of nowhere and are destroyed with no resistance. The Enterprise’s sister ship, the Yamamoto, appears from thin air, or space, then disappears.
Eventually, Picard and crew discover they’ve become play-things of an alien entity called Nagilum. Nagilum has power over time and space. He can keep the Enterprise trapped in his void indefinitely. The alien seems to be very interested in the concept of death. He tells Picard that he’d like to run some experiments and it will only take a little over half the crew...
Picard, not satisfied to play lab rat, decides to set the auto-destruct sequence rather than submit to Nagilum. Realizing that the Enterprise is no use to him, Nagilum relents and lets the ship go. With that single decision, Picard out-maneuvers an omnipotent alien.
8. Janeway Decides To Trust The Borg... Kinda
Captain Katherine Janeway was one of the most resourceful captains in Starfleet. Stranded, with her crew, in the Delta Quadrant, Janeway had to deal with obstacles that no other captain could imagine. Arguably her greatest hurdle was navigating a huge expanse of Borg space as she leads her crew back to Earth.
Janeway did what she had to do. She forged an uneasy alliance with the Borg Collective. She even promised to help defeat one of the Borg's most fearsome rivals.
This may seem like was a stupid decision since Janeway could have let the Borg's enemies destroy them. But, that would leave her no closer to achieving her goal of getting her crew home as quickly as possible.
Waiting out a prolonged war between two advanced species was not an option for Janeway, but dealing with the Borg wasn’t ideal either. Janeway knew she couldn’t trust the little, cyborg jerks. So, she played them like a ukulele. As soon the Borg prevails in their war they, predictably, turn on the Voyager crew and Seven Of Nine attempts to assimilate the consoles.
But, Janeway anticipated this betrayal and activates a contingency plan - "Operation Scorpion" - which sees Chakotay, under her instructions, use a neural relay to distract Seven while Torres electrifies the console, knocking Seven out. So the Captain used an uneasy alliance to the benefit of the crew while keeping her mind focuses on the likelihood of the betrayal.
7. Sisko Decides To Poison A Planet
Before the start of the Dominion war Starfleet’s biggest concern was the Maquis. One of the Maquis’s most effective lieutenants was the former Starfleet officer Michael Eddington. Starfleet orders Benjamin Sisko to capture Eddington.
Complicating matters, Eddington was formerly Sisko’s security chief on board Deep Space Nine. They have a history, and Eddington takes advantage of his relationship with Sisko.
Eddington knows that, as a Starfleet captain, Sisko has to abide by certain limits. These are boundaries that Eddington doesn’t have. He proves this by poisoning the atmospheres of several Cardassian planets.
Sisko outsmarts Eddington by doing the opposite of what his former security chief expects. Sisko fights fire with fire. In an act that would make Picard cringe, Sisko poisons the atmosphere of a Maquis colony. It’s a bold move that forces Eddington to concede defeat.
6. Picard Decides To Antagonize His Torturers
Picard is one of the most clever officers Starfleet has ever produced. This entire list could consist of Picard's decisions. But, that would be boring. So, let’s focus on a decision he made in one of the most stressful, and trying moments of his career.
Along the Federation-Cardassian border, there existed a planet called Celtris III. Late in the 2360s Starfleet suspected the Cardassians of developing illegal weapons on this planet. So, they sent Picard on a covert mission to investigate. As it turns out the Cardassians had set a trap to capture Picard. The Cardassians want Picard for information on the defensives of a strategically important system. They catch him and begin torturing him.
What follows is a battle of will between Picard and his Cardassian torturer, Gul Madred. Madred subjects Picard to severe torture, trying to break his spirit, but Picard relents.
In a momentary lapse of judgment, Madred shares too much with Picard. Madred relays a story of his childhood when he was beaten up by a group of older boys. They stole his food, but he brags that they had to break his arm to do it.
His story is meant to prove his resolve to Picard. But, in an act of pure brilliance, Picard uses the information against his torturer.
He tells Madred that no matter how much pain he inflicts, Picard will only view him as a sad, scared little boy. While Madred still had physical power over Picard, it is clear at this point that the Cardassian has lost the battle of wills.
5. Kirk Decides To Cheat On A Test
The Kobayashi Maru is an infamous psychological exercise inflicted on Starfleet cadets. It presents would-be command officers with an unbeatable simulation. The purpose is to teach officers to accept no-win scenarios.
Here’s how it goes- the cadet is placed in command of a starship. The crew receives a distress call from a civilian vessel- The Kobayashi Maru. The ship is stranded in the Neutral Zone and under attack from Klingons. The cadet can either enter the neutral zone, violating a treaty with the Romulans, and potentially sparking a war. Or, they can leave the civilian ship to be destroyed by the Klingons. It’s lose-lose. So, how did Kirk win?
Simple: he decided to cheat the test.
Kirk reprogrammed the simulation so that it was possible to save the civilians with no negative consequences. Now, this may seem cheap to you, but Starfleet gave Kirk a commendation for “creative thinking.”
Kirk came out of the Academy with a reputation for success in the face of impossible odds. That would eventually land him in the captain's chair.
4. Janeway Decides To Trust A Crew Of Terrorists
Before being flung into the Delta Quadrant by the Caretaker, the USS Voyager’s mission was to capture a Maquis vessel. Both Voyager and the Maquis were stranded in the Delta Quadrant together. The Maquis crew’s ship was destroyed and Janeway took them on board Voyager.
At this point, Janeway had a choice to make. Since the Maquis were considered terrorists by the Federation, she could throw the entire crew in the brig. Leave them there for the entire 75 years it will take to get home. She instead integrates the Maquis into key positions on the ship including first officer and chief engineer.
This could’ve been a disastrous decision, but Janeway’s judgment is proved right. The Maquis crew are invaluable assets during Voyager’s journey home.
3. Kirk Decides To Use Three Dimensional Space
Khan Noonien Singh is without a doubt the greatest foe that James Kirk ever encountered. Khan is the man who finally taught Kirk the true meaning of a no-win scenario.
Sure, Kirk beat Khan, but only after losing his most trusted friend, Spock. But, how did Kirk defeat Khan? With a stroke of pure genius.
The Enterprise enters the Mutara nebula to even the odds between his own ship and Khan's - the commandeered the USS Reliant - on Spock's recommendation. Within it, the two ships engage in a prolonged space battle that leaves both badly damaged.
Khan seems set to destroy the Enterprise when Kirk, again with Spock's help, realizes that Khan has made a tactical error. Khan, who is used to battling on the surface of a planet, is only thinking in two dimensions.
Kirk drops the Enterprise vertically and positions the ship below the Reliant. It’s just the surprise that Kirk needs to trap Khan and deliver a fatal volley of torpedoes.
2. Archer Decides To Throw The Vulcans Under The Bus
Archer and crew are bored from following the safe, and well-traveled Vulcan star charts. They don’t feel like explorers and they’re itching for some excitement. So, of course, they decide on visiting a Vulcan monastery... so... exciting?
When Archer and crew arrive they find things a bit off. The door looks smashed and the monks are not very communicative. Not that any Vulcan would be accused of being too chatty.
After poking around for a bit the away-team discovers a group of Andorian’s. They've been harassing the monks for several weeks. Having never encountered the Andorians, Archer relies on the Vulcans to fill him in. The Andorians are a suspicious and aggressive species. They've been at war with the Vulcan’s and only recently entered into an uneasy peace.
The Andorians don’t trust the Vulcans or their monastery, though. They’re determined to discover what the Vulcans are really up to. They take Archer and his away-team hostage. While looking for an escape Archer discovers a hidden Vulcan listening post beneath the monastery. As it turns out the Andorians were right, and the Vulcans were spying on them.
Archer orders the listening post scanned and hands the information to the Andorians. This seems like a bonkers decision considering the Vulcans are humanity’s best ally. But, making nice with the Andorians pays dividends in the long run. The aliens come to Archer’s aid years later during the Xindi war.
So, a brash decision, but a brilliant one nonetheless.
1. Rachel Garrett Decides To Die Defending Klingons
Rachel Garrett may be the most influential captain to ever take command of a ship named Enterprise.
You heard that right.
That’s because if it weren’t for one pivotal decision, made by Garrett, the Federation itself would be destroyed by the Klingons. So, how did she save the galaxy from Klingon domination? To explain that we have to go back in time a few decades.
In the 2340s Captain Garrett, while in command of the Enterprise 1701-C, responded to a distress call from Neandra III. Neandra III was a civilian Klingon outpost under attack from a group of Romulan Warbirds.
Now, the Federation, at the time, was not on the friendliest of terms with either the Romulans or the Klingons. A lesser officer might have let these two bitter enemies kill each other. That’s not what Garrett did though.
Garrett made an ethical and brilliant decision to defend the Klingon outpost. But, the Enterprise drifts into a temporal anomaly (because of course, it does, this is Star Trek). The ship and her crew are transported decades forward into an alternate timeline.
There they learn from Captain Picard that Starfleet is at war with the Klingons. What's worse, the Federation is on the eve of total annihilation. The only way to save the timeline is for Garrett and her crew to travel back and face certain death at the hands of the Romulans.
But in defending the Klingon outpost they will lay the groundwork for an enduring peace. So, for the second time, Garrett chooses to sacrifice herself, her crew, and her ship for the good of the entire galaxy.
A truly brilliant decision.