12 TV Shows That Were Cancelled Way Too Soon

Why do bad things happen to good TV shows?

There was an uproar online this week - well, there€™s an uproar online every single minute of every single day, but this one was particularly notable - when it was announced that NBC would not be renewing Hannibal for a fourth season.

The show€™s fans, €˜Fannibals€™, didn€™t hold back with their anger, and the creator Bryan Fuller took to Twitter to ensure that they were exploring other options. Perhaps the biggest reason for the outcry was that the show seemed to be doing so well. It clearly has a loyal fanbase, but also the love of the critics. However, its dark themes and violence ultimately proved too much for NBC to continue with.

Having a cult following and critical approval is not enough in the TV world dominated by what makes money. It€™s why shows you love get might only a couple of seasons, while there are now more bad seasons of The Simpsons than there are good ones (even if the good ones are unbelievably great ones), and The Big Bang Theory is never going to end.

Unless the show you love has mass appeal then there is always going to be the risk of it getting canned. It€™s nothing new, and is sadly just the way of the world where audiences don€™t make the decision, but men in suits who probably don€™t even watch the shows do.

There€™s a long line of shows that were cut down in their prime, sparking confusion, outrage, and attempts to bring them back, and here€™s a look at some of the most notable examples.


12. Veronica Mars

Long before she wanted to build a snowman, Kristen Bell was best-known as Veronica Mars, the former popular girl at school who balanced her studies with some extracurricular crime-solving.

It was praised for its portrayal of the darker side of school, not shying away from just how brutal life can be in high-school, as well as investigations concerning murder and rape.

It ran for three seasons and had established a cult following, if not a huge audience, before it was cancelled by The CW. The fans tried all manner of methods to stop the show from being cancelled, with the best being that they sent a box containing 10,000 Mars bars to The CW executives, albeit to no avail.

It did eventually get to continue its life in the form of a movie, thanks to crowdfunding website Kickstarter. It€™s $2m goal was met in just 10 hours as it went on to break a number of Kickstarter records, with the movie eventually being released in 2014 to reasonably positive reviews.


11. Selfie

The title was aimed at capturing the minds of a social-media obsessed generation, and this sitcom was a modern take on the story of Pygmalion. Instead of upgrading her social status, this show€™s Eliza wanted to be €˜Insta-famous€™, but when she started to get some online hate hires marketing expert Henry to give her an image makeover.

The name and the premise both risked coming off as a little cringey, a desperate attempt to cash in on something that would be quickly outdated, but with Karen Gillan and John Cho in the lead roles there was room for this to develop into something more about the characters.

However, it was cancelled after just seven episodes had aired, with the remaining six being shown on streaming service Hulu. With time the show could have developed into a genuinely pretty good sitcom, and when you consider how many poor shows get such a long run (looking at you, Chuck Lorre) it€™s a shame they didn€™t take a chance on this one.


10. My So-Called Life

My So-Called Life had its own so-called life cut extremely short in the mid-90s, when it was cancelled after just one 19 episode season.

It followed the travails of teenager Angela - played by Clare Danes - as she attempted to deal with all the drama and adventure that high-school brings, from clashing with her mother and having a crush on Jared Leto€™s Jordan, to themes of homophobia and teen alcoholism and drug abuse.

It received huge critical acclaim for what was perceived to be an extremely accurate portrayal of teenage life, but that wasn€™t enough to save the show, especially when it was revealed that Danes wasn€™t keen on committing to another season.


9. Sports Night / Studio 60 On The Sunset Strip

Aaron Sorkin is best-known as the man responsible for creating The West Wing, a political drama juggernaut that can constantly be found near the top of lists of great TV shows. You€™d think that would mean anything he does for television would be a hit, but before and after he had shows that were cancelled fairly early.

Sports Night was a half-hour comedy-drama focused on a fictional sports news show of the same name, while Studio 60 On The Sunset Strip was a behind-the-scenes look at a fictional live comedy sketch show, starring Friends€™ Matthew Perry.

Neither of Sorkin€™s efforts at making a successful TV show featuring a TV show really worked, at least not in the eyes of the networks. While both were praised for their writing, with plenty of the smart, rapid-fire dialogue Sorkin is known for, they never really found a proper audience, and only lasted for three seasons and 67 episodes between them.


8. Deadwood

Not just a Western, but a HBO Western. That meant it had a big budget, morally complex characters, played by stars Ian McShane and Timothy Olyphant, and a lot of swearing. While it was the latter reasons that won the show a legion of fans and a host of Emmys during its three-season run, it was the first one that meant it didn€™t go beyond there.

While now they are happy to lavish unprecedented sums of money on their shows, it was more of an issue back then. Plans were initially mooted for a shorter fourth season, which in-turn became the development of two TV movies. In the end it was scrapped altogether, leaving a lot of viewers disappointed that they never got to see more of the town of Deadwood. There€™s been talk at various points of a revival, but ultimately they haven€™t amounted to anything, and don€™t appear to be anytime soon.


7. Spaced

This is a bit of an exception on this list, as it wasn't exactly cancelled per se. Rather, the show€™s writers - Simon Pegg and Jessica Stevenson - decided not to continue it. Even so, it was a massive shame that we never got more than two seasons and 14 episodes of one of the great modern British sitcoms.

Directed by Edgar Wright, and also starring the likes of Nick Frost and Mark Heap as well as Pegg and Stevenson, the show followed the latter two as strangers who end up getting a flat together and basically try and figure out what exactly they are doing with their lives.

There wasn€™t a definitive end to Spaced, and that - along with how smartly and hilariously it was written - have led to repeated calls for a third season, something Pegg and Stevenson are constantly asked about. It probably isn€™t going to happen, and maybe by now it shouldn€™t, but it would've been great to see more of their lives.


6. Angel

When Angel walked away at the end of Buffy season 3, having helped the Scooby Gang defeat the Mayor, many may have been worried they wouldn't be seeing their favourite (at the time, anyway) vampire-with-a-soul again, but he soon popped up over on his own show.

Angel was the darker, moodier, younger sibling to Buffy The Vampire Slayer, but managed to move out of the shadows and become a popular and very good show in its own right. It ran for five seasons before its cancellation, which left creator Joss Whedon - not for the first time - feeling dismayed at the premature end of one of his shows.

Although like Buffy it has since continued in comic-book form, many fans were left feeling that it deserved another couple of seasons to take it level with the parent show, as there were still a lot of places it could have went and expanded even further in a post-Buffy world.


5. The Bryan Fuller Collection

If Joss Whedon is the prince of cancelled TV shows, then Bryan Fuller is the king. Probably not a crown he wants to wear, to be honest, but it is something that keeps happening.

Aside from the recent cancellation of Hannibal, there have been three other shows ended early that have left viewers perplexed by the decision.

The first, Dead Like Me, centred on a girl who dies and becomes a reaper, helping people find the afterlife. After that was Wonderfalls, about a gift shop clerk who talks to the figures around her, and then most notably Pushing Daisies, which won a number of awards in its two-season run focused on Ned, a pie-maker with the ability to bring things back from the dead with a single touch.

All of them had their fans, and were praised by critics, but it wasn€™t enough to save them from the axe when ratings started to fall.


4. Utopia

Utopia felt like a breath of fresh air when the first season aired on Channel 4 back in January 2013. The story is of a group of people who find themselves in possession of the sequel to a cult graphic novel, believed to have predicted the worst disasters of the last century.

It was full of mystery and thrilling moments, with a lot of violence, swearing, and astonishingly striking visuals. It did enough in its first season to get a second, but after that it was confirmed that it had not been renewed for a third season.

There are online campaigns hoping to get the show saved, with Netflix being the most likely home, but so far they haven€™t amounted to anything. It is, however, getting a starry US remake by HBO, with Gone Girl€™s David Fincher and Gillian Flynn directing and writing respectively.


3. Arrested Development

The story of the dysfunctional Bluth family was one of the smartest and sharpest sitcoms in recent years, packed full of meta-humour, elaborate gags, crazy plots, and a starry-cast including Jason Batemen and Michael Cera.

While it received widespread critical acclaim, the show never found an audience when it was on the air and was cancelled after three seasons. Its influence was clear on other great sitcoms that followed in the years to come, most notably Community (which has had its own struggles in keeping itself going), and it found a cult following on DVD.

That was enough to persuade Netflix to eventually bring the show back for a fourth season in 2013, with talk of a 5th ongoing, but it wasn€™t quite the same as if it€™d had the lifespan it deserved originally.


2. Freaks And Geeks

It seems crazy now to think that this show was cancelled after just one season, given the status of its creator and cast. Executive Producer Judd Apatow is one of the biggest names in Hollywood comedy, creator Paul Feig is going to be directing the next Ghostbusters movie, and the likes of James Franco, Jason Segel, and Seth Rogen don€™t need any introduction.

Back in 2000 though they weren€™t household names, and their TV show Freaks and Geeks was tragically short-lived. It was a great take on the high-school genre, following Lindsay Weir (Linda Cardellini) and her younger brother Sam (John Francis Daley) and their friends, who make up the titular freaks and geeks.

It felt like a more realistic take on school life, and was of course hilarious, but poor ratings meant that it was cancelled after just twelve episodes had aired. Fan campaigns led to the remaining six being broadcast, but there were no more after that. The cast and crew have had the last laugh by going on to much bigger things, but not necessarily better ones.


1. Firefly

The ultimate show when it comes to those whose life was cut devastatingly short, Fox basically made a total mess of Joss Whedon€™s Firefly.

They aired the show out of sequence, preferring a later, more action-fuelled episode to the actual pilot, which, y€™know, set up what the show was about and who the characters were. For some inexplicable reason ratings were low, and the show was cancelled after just 11 of the 14 episodes had been broadcast.

The Space-Western was full of the sort of whip-smart dialogue and well-written characters that made you care about them that Whedon is known for, led by the fantastic Nathan Fillion. Despite running for just one season, this stands as one of the finest pieces of work the Avengers director has ever done, one of the great single seasons in TV, and who knows just how good it could have become given the time it deserved. It did eventually get a film, Serenity, to tie things up, but most fans are never going to get over the fact there wasn't a season 2.


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.