13 Most Memorable Doctor Who Guest Stars
13. Richard Wilson in The Empty Child and The Doctor Dances
Richard Wilson is really just a good actor in general, and despite his flourishing career in BBCs Merlin, whenever I see him in it or anything else I immediately think, Hmm. Doctor Constantines doing well. It should be a crime to typecast such an amazingly talented human being but I just cant help myself he sticks in your mind so well. Growing up, I always thought the Empty Child arc was the most frightening pair of episodes in the shows history and looking back Im not entirely sure why. Maybe its because I came in late watching the show that night so I had little to no context; maybe its because I was still at the age were saying Mummy was still relatively socially acceptable and thus I had something to remind me of those gas masks every time I saw mother; maybe its because of the faceless freaking zombies everywhere creeping around at the dead of freaking night! Damn you, Moffat! But for whatever reason, the Richard Wilson scene still scares the living daylights out of me even now. If you havent seen it (and shame on you if you havent) the scene depicts Wilsons undeniably chilling voice echoing around a dark, abandoned ward full of gas-mask wearing corpses and flickering lights, describing in full detail the plague that has struck London. Theyre not dead, Wilson reveals in that haunting tone of his, shortly before a gas mask slowly and agonisingly forces its way out of his face, Wilsons stunning performance pulling us in all the way. Horrifying stuff.
12. Derek Jacobi in Utopia
When you think of a human incarnation of the Master, you may think of a power-hungry business tycoon, a behind the scenes crime lord or some kind of second world tyrannical dictator. You do not immediately imagine a long-suffering and lonely scientist working to prevent mankind from total annihilation at the verge of the end of the universe. Shakespearean-trained actor Derek Jacobi is on this list almost entirely because of how little you suspect this gentleman and scholar is in fact the evil mastermind that he is. His tears as he reminisces about his rapid and almost ignorant life and regret at allowing himself to become so aged and close-minded are so heartfelt and touch on an issue so rarely explored on Doctor Who (if at all) its impossible not to see the added touch of realism. Though I never really considered him to be that convincing as the Master, he sure delivered that shock reveal with merciless glee, and, needless to say, did a hell of a lot better than Eric Roberts. However, tired, disappointed Professor Yana is where the glory really lies in this portrayal, and he doesnt half leave an impact. Oh, while Im on the subject Id just like to point out that John Simm is not going to be on the list. Personally, I think of him as less of a guest star and more of a very high-profile actor who played a very high-profile part. And Im really sort of defining guest as two episodes or less, so there.11. Jenna-Louise Coleman in Asylum of the Daleks
Like I was saying, Im not counting this performance very high on the list, firstly because this character may turn out to be a little bit more than just a meaningless one shot (we are talking about Moffat here) and secondly because the girl playing her is the new companion. It would be like putting Colin Baker on the list because he was in Arc of Infinity. Anyway, in my opinion, Asylum of the Daleks is neck-and-neck with The Angels Take Manhattan for best episode of Series Seven so far, mostly just because of her character Oswin Oswald: Junior Entertainment Manager, Starship Alaska. Current status: crashed and shipwrecked somewhere... not nice. Every little thing she said compelled me to turn to my brother and say Im in love, and can you blame me? She was beautiful, funny, flirtatious, smarter even than the Doctor and with just the right amount of lip without giving us too much Donna Noble. Total TARDIS material, despite not noticing that she had an everlasting supply of eggs. And, as Moffat sadistically cast Miss Coleman in the role, we were all convinced that she was going to be disappearing into that blue-box before the credits rolled, completely setting us up for the cruel conclusion, which was both heartbreaking and shockingly cold.
10. Martin Jarvis in Vengeance on Varos
On a planet where the citizens are allowed to murder their leaders if they do anything they dont like (and believe me thats nowhere near as fun as it sounds) Jarvis plays the only sympathetic politician there has ever been in TV history. He is the very definition of some have greatness thrust upon them as it is briefly mentioned that the Governors have no choice in whether they take up their post, and despite his peoples constant bids to dispose of him he wrestles with an extremely powerful mining corporation just so they can have a fairer price for something the planet believes is worthless. Its hard not to admire the courage of the man. While some would argue this is more attributable to good writing than anything else, Martin Jarvis really throws everything he has into making us care about a character weve never seen before and will never see again, and you have to love him for that.9. James Corden in The Lodger and Closing Time
Sometimes seeing a certain actor in a certain place just puts you in a good mood, and Smithy just has that down. I dont really know what else to say about him. Hes just so comfortably sweet and normal and at the same time so funny and so totally out of his mind (see Lesbian Vampire Killers if you dont know what Im talking about) its hard not to put him in absolutely everything on British TV. Sometimes thats a good thing as in the case of The Lodger and sometimes thats a very, very, very bad thing. Yeah, Ill just come right out and say it I didnt care for Closing Time. Maybe it was because it was the Cybermens least threatening/memorable appearance yet, but it did kind of suck. But whatever. It had James Corden with a son named Stormageddon, both being so maddeningly sweet and charming its hard not to like them. Even if you didnt like the ep, at the end you can turn around and say, Hey, remember when Jimmy Corden was in Doctor Who? Yeah, hes cool.
8. Michael Sheen in The Doctors Wife
Someone once mentioned that Michael Sheen was one of the best character actors in the world, and for a while I never really understood why. It was only after realising just how much hes been in that I really appreciated the genius. To go from a cheery yet mocking David Frost to the white rabbit in Alice in Wonderland and still maintain all that dignity has to be admired, and his nightmarish take on the character of House in The Doctors Wife is by far one of the many things that made this episode great. He has everything, Neil Gaimans stylized writing prowess, a malevolent, sadistic mind, and, best of all, Michael Sheens voice. But when Amy and Rory were running through the TARDIS corridors as House began to play with their minds, that was when the episode became truly terrifying, suggesting that even in the TARDIS, youre not safe from this guy and his shockingly cruel games. (The Hate Amy moment is probably the one that sticks in peoples minds the most in terms of flat out monstrosity.) And again, I had no idea that was Michael Sheen. I swear to God, I thought that was Benedict Cumberbatch. In all cases, whether hes playing Tony Blair or a Neil Gaiman monster, you dont see Michael Sheen playing a character, you see the character, perfectly formed. Hes like Gary Oldman, in that whenever you see his name in the credits you instantly go, That was Michael Sheen?7. Simon Pegg in The Long Game
Just a quick heads up, a lot of the rest of this list is going to be dedicated to villains well, to be perfectly honest, theyre nearly all villains aside from a particularly pretty Australian, a Botox-addicted TV presenter and a snooty art critic (epic foreshadowing!). Moving on, Simon Pegg ladies and gentleman! I could definitely imagine him working alongside George Lucas after this role, and given that the guy hes working for is a slimy, greedy monster who lives in the cold and the dark and wants to dominate and torment the lives of everyone in his power, thats hardly surprising. (There, I made a George Lucas joke. Everybody gets one, okay?) Pegg plays a snivelling yet surprisingly threatening yes man working under (literally) the mighty Jagrafess of the Holy Hadrojassic Maxarodenfoe, which took poor old Shaun of the Dead about twenty takes to say correctly. Constantly nodding, agreeing and smiling politely, the Editor (Pegg) manipulates mankind through subliminal news stories and is easily the most realistic villain of Series One. Hes someone we can all see behind the scenes of every great government and television network saying Come on, one more season of Happy Days, what harm can it do?, and the fact that hes so casual, sweet and almost funny with his kooky sense of humour just makes him all the more threatening when you think of just what hes doing to the world. (By the way, if youre getting bored of this, Id advise you to play the Simon Pegg in The Long Game Drinking Game. You just take a shot every time I make a crappy pop-culture reference in those last two paragraphs.)
6. Zoe Wanamaker in The End of the World and New Earth
Zoe Wanamaker is damn good at playing utter psychopaths even in her more comedic roles, and is pretty close to perfect as Lady Cassandra OBrien, a fascinating, scheming, selfish and unforgettable baddie whose very existence is both a satire of the consequences of cosmetic surgery and a dark prediction of where it may be heading. (Blood bleaching, really?) While the idea of someone so obsessed with losing weight they go to the trouble of having their skin stretched across a steel frame is a bit extreme, Wanamaker makes us believe every moment of it with her casual, almost proud attitude towards her lifestyle, one of socialism, multiple marriages and scalpel after scalpel after scalpel, sort of a Jocelyn Wildenstein character, you could say someone who barely seems to notice how horrific they have made themselves and how little substance is left of them. While Roses correct assessment that the most humane parts of her got chucked in the bin was mostly referring to her physical body slowly breaking down, there is also the inescapable reality that this also refers to her mind and personality becoming more corrupt and superficial with every operation. Contrastingly, I think the scene that really cements Wanamakers place on the list is the scene when she, in the dying body of the only man who could ever love her in her eventual state (actor Sean Gallagher), is given the chance to return to herself as a human (Wanamaker) and explain just how beautiful she really is/was. This is something I think every surgery-addict secretly wants to do go back in time and say to their old self You really dont need it. Wanamaker is brilliant, its as simple as that.5. The Entire Cast of Dinosaurs on a Spaceship
Now a lot of my very best friends are total fan-girls so I experienced the hype leading up to this episode first hand. When I said I wasnt really looking forward to it because I knew they couldnt realistically top Asylum of the Daleks, one of my friends squealed in the middle of a crowded park and shouted, But its got Ron Weasleys dad in it! Although I was right in that Dinosaurs on a Spaceship was something of a weak follow up, not even I can deny how much hype was behind the various guest stars. In a world where a lot of DWs audience is made up of those brilliant fan-girls it was a genius decision to put Arthur Weasley, Filch and Lestrade all in the same place. I mean, who among the Whovian community doesnt watch Sherlock every once in a while? (Incidentally, every once in a while is actually Sherlocks production schedule). And what nerdy fan-girl hasnt picked up a Harry Potter book? Im pretty sure the girl who played Nefertiti was famous for something as well, but at the risk of sounding like Ive had my head in the sand my whole life, I didnt pick up on it. But no matter. Not only are the geek icons in the episode, but David Mitchell (the funniest comedian in the universe) and Robert Webb (the well David Mitchells comedy partner lets leave it at that) also make appearances. While they arent as memorable as some of the others around despite being considerably more exposed, it is impressive how Doctor Who managed to get an entire cast made up out of guest stars as well as managing to get away with not making it a cheesy gimmick. While you can say the episode wasnt the best, if we were to judge Doctor Who simply on guest stars, Dinosaurs on a Spaceship would get its own little label saying, This one was fairly pleasant.
4. Kylie Minogue in Voyage of the Damned
Astrid Peth is really the Oswin Oswald of the Tennant years. She was a really cool character played by a really notable guest star that ended up cruelly killed off after one episode and making us truly appreciate the fact that not everybody gets to see the stars. Though the character is sweet enough and cute enough we really only remember her for being Kylie Minogue, and plus, we knew she was going to die. There was no way the show could get Kylie Minogue as a regular, epic though that would be, not to mention that Catherine Tate was already being advertised as the new Who-girl. I suppose you could say that there was always the chance that she would survive and the Doctor would simply refuse to take her as in the case of Lady Christina de Souza (who would have been an awesome companion you stupid, stupid writers!!) but Doc was willing from the word go to have her on board, so yeah. She was dead the minute she appeared on screen. Now youre probably wondering why Ive put her on the list since Ive bashed her so much and you have to admit even River Song has a better chance of getting out alive. Well shes Kylie Minogue. Shes a brilliant actress, shes beautiful to look at, shes as sweet as a honeybee and shes Kylie freaking Minogue. I think just watching this ep with the family for the first time is easy and fun and light-hearted because you can just smile along with Kylie and then make jokes about who to be more jealous of when Ten and Astrid randomly kiss. The fact that she has to stand on a box beforehand is downright adorable too.3. Timothy Dalton in The End of Time
Say what you like about Timothy Dalton, the mans amazing. I know little to nothing about him, other than he might have been James Bond once and he was in that weird-a** live-action Looney Tunes movie, but hes still amazing. Especially as Rassilon. Ive only ever seen Rassilon twice: first in The Five Doctors and second in The End of Time, so I have no idea how he got from one to the other or even if hes in any other episodes, but I completely believe he was the same guy both times. His booming voice, indulgent theatricality and desire to live for all time (which will end in about five minutes if Rassilon gets his way) remain unchanged, with Daltons portrayal in particular embodying everything that was wrong with and corrupt about the Time Lords. In him you see the Time-War, Borusa, the Master (and guess who made him evil and crazy in the first place?), the Doctors trial for his life (both of them), the interference law and ridiculous hats. You see just how insane and selfish a craving for immortality is, and Rassilons power, both supernatural and over his fellow Time-Lords, just adds more threat and violence to this evil, power-hungry mastermind. Although the exposition of the episode is a little rushed (By the way the Time-Lords are evil, moving on) its more than made up for when Dalton appears. This Rassilon is out to destroy everything. And this time, without silly ginger mutton chops.
2. John Cleese in City of Death
Ill admit it right now, I did not this was coming. An all-round stellar episode in anyones book, City of Death featured the Fourth Doctor and the Second Romana in a bid to stop Julian Glover (aka, the big-a** spider from the Chamber of Secrets) from stealing the Mona Lisa so as to fund experiments for his own time machine all written by Douglas Adams, no less. Forgive me for delving into Internet Speak but, epic win! Just to top off what was an already perfect episode of Who, the fourth instalment of the serial gave us a pleasant surprise in the form of John Cleese as somebody in an art gallery I suppose. Now granted Im not entirely sure who the woman hes talking to is, why he isnt doing anything especially funny (Its John Cleese! Indulge a little!), why he isnt the least bit fazed when the TARDIS dematerializes right in front of his very eyes or (to be frank) why on Earth he was needed to begin with, but seeing him for such a brief period of time and the way he comes out of nowhere just puts you in a good mood. Its Jim Corden all over again. Even when it was time for the final showdown between the Doctor and the villainous Scaroth I was still just sat on my sofa saying to myself, Wow. That was John Cleese. Sweet.1. Anne Robinson in Bad Wolf
Let down? Cop-out? Pointless ending, just played out for laughs? Wrong! In a way, this is the perfect guest appearance. At the time, the Weakest Link was one of the BBCs biggest shows, and while Im not even sure if its on any more, Sherlocks not gonna be on forever so Rupert Graves in Dinosaurs on a Spaceship is going to look pretty silly isnt it? In British culture, the only two times when kiddies are allowed to break their stiff upper lip and dive behind the sofa is when the Daleks show up, and when you see Anne Robinsons latest Botox injection. Now put the two in the same forty minutes, and substitute Botox for a steel face that vaporizes you if youre voted off and kills you faster if you run away. Now tell me Anne Robinson doesnt deserve the top spot on the list. The entire story is extremely dark, showing the consequences of the Doctors never-look-back attitude in the form a game-station where anyone can be a contestant and the result of failure is death, predating the Hunger Games by several years, might I add. However, its the Anne-Droid (their words, not mine) that I remember most about the Bad Wolf story, and Roses sudden vaporisation at the hands of the machine is particularly resonant. I recommend watching that scene back; its still brilliant and haunting even now. As in the case of Pegg (who starred as a baddie on the exact same space station bizarrely enough), the Anne-Droid is a pretty humorous character, with Robinson doing what she does best. Being a total b**ch. This jarring twist makes the character and Robinson playing her both funny and creepy, although you actually cheer for her a little bit when she shows up in the next episode and slaughters a trio of Daleks. And then you cheer for the Dalek that blows off her head. Yeah there are some mixed feelings there Have I missed anyone out? Is there anyone who stuck in your mind who should have been on this list? Let me know in the comments, and be aware that anyone who praises Peter Kay as the Abzorbaloff deserves to be exterminated.