13 Things Non-Fans Always Get Wrong About Doctor Who

Fezzes may be cool, but factual inaccuracies aren't.

If there's one inescapable reality of TV fanaticism it's that, inevitably, every inoffensive medium with truckloads of fans will have more and bigger truckloads of non-fans. But the majority of said inoffensive media haven't been around for half a century, nor are there vast swathes of highly recognisable artefacts associated with them. There are only a handful of franchises that can tick all those boxes and Doctor Who is one of them. Half a century old? Check. A fan base that's almost unparalleled in its loyalty and fanaticism? Check. A volume of non-fans that seems to increase exponentially to the brand's ever-increasing exposure? Check. So much iconic imagery attached to it that even someone who's never watched a single episode wouldn't be able to avoid it entirely? Check. A program as old and widely recognised as Doctor Who is virtually inescapable. You don't need to be a fan to know at least something about it and there are oodles of non-fans who do... or at least they think they do. Fact is, non-fans - including virtually any member of the press who ever reports on anything to do with Doctor Who - have a tendency to get it wrong. And quite right, too. As non-fans it is their absolute right and prerogative - unless they're journalists in which case, given the existence of the internet, it's just lazy journalism. Non-fans frequently invoke a borderline impressed/exasperated reaction from their Doctor Who fan friends when they extol the virtues of the program as they understand it, or start asking questions about specific elements of its mythology. (There's rarely any genuine interest in the answers, particularly when the questions are asked in a pub). In particular there are a handful of specific elements of Doctor Who that non-fans tend to misquote, misrepresent or otherwise misunderstand most often. So non-fans, listen up: here's some clarification about thirteen critical details that raise the ire of your Doctor Who fan friends when you consistently get them wrong.

13. Doctor Who Fans Have Always Been Called 'Whovians'

The term 'Whovian' is bandied about these days in reference to all Doctor Who fans everywhere, but it hasn't always been that way. Unlike 'Trekkie', a collective noun referring to Star Treks fans that was apparently first coined in 1967, 'Whovian' came about in the 1970s when fan clubs started springing up and as recently as twenty years ago it was only ever used when referring to American Doctor Who fans. Back in the 1980s and 90s, British Doctor Who fans weren't Whovians. Australian Doctor Who fans weren't Whovians either and neither were New Zealand Doctor Who fans. South African Doctor Who fans weren't Whovians. It was only American Doctor Who fans who were ever referred to as Whovians. And maybe Canadian Doctor Who fans, kinda by default. It's only been adopted as a collective noun for Doctor Who fans the world over since the series was revived in 2005 and on a really large scale only in the last three or so years. In this globalised 21st century world of ever-decreasing regional differences, no doubt some lazy journalist, engaged in yet another spot of lazy journalism, came across the term 'Whovian' and applied it to whatever Doctor Who-related topic they were reporting on. Thanks to the wonders of the internet, that reference was probably seen by millions of people all over the world within a matter of days - et voila! 'Whovian' = all Doctor Who fans everywhere. And now, apparently, it does.

12. The 2005 Revival Was A Reboot Of The Original Series

To use the term 'reboot' in relation to the revived series of Doctor Who is to suggest that it was restarted in 2005 with only the basic elements of the original series in place, while paying scant regard to the established mythology and effectively creating an entirely new and different program. This is so far from the truth that it's almost laughable. The revived series has so many direct links to the old series, so many themes and concepts that are, quite explicitly, a continuation of where the old series left off, as to make the 'reboot' assertion null and void. The basic elements are indeed all there €“ the TARDIS, Gallifrey, the Time Lords €“ but there's so much more that's carried over from the classic series to the new series €“ references to and appearances by classic series companions in the new series, the backstory of the Daleks and Cybermen, the very number of incarnations of The Doctor himself. Proponents of the reboot theory need only look to last month's 50th anniversary special for absolute proof - if any were needed - that the revival is unequivocally not a reboot. If that isn't sufficient, there's still more proof scattered liberally throughout the previous 102 episodes.

11. The Doctor Is Supernatural / Magic / Immortal

Actually he's just a Time Lord and that thing he does, the whole changing face / body / personality thing €“ it isn't magic. Time Lords are supposed to be able to do that. It's what happens to them when their bodies get injured or damaged or whatever. It's a bit like the way your skin can heal itself when you damage it, only on a much grander scale. When the cells of a Time Lord's body become worn out, they can be repaired just like your skin. That process is called "regeneration". In fact, the full extent of those repairs is such that they end up with a totally different body, mind, spirit, personality, voice, height, outward appearance of age... everything! They're still the same person, with the same mind and all the same memories from each and every previous incarnation, but they're a brand new person at the same time. Time Lords can actually do this twelve times, but after they've had thirteen bodies the cycle just kinda stops. They can't regenerate any more, so when it all goes pear-shaped they will actually die. Maybe. The bottom line here is that it's not magic. There's nothing supernatural about regeneration and The Doctor definitely isn't immortal.

10. 'Regeneration' And 'Incarnation' Mean The Same Thing

Wrong! 'Regeneration' and 'Incarnation' are absolutely not interchangeable. They mean two completely different things. 'Incarnation' describes the end-to-end lifecycle of The Doctor in the one body, from the moment he regenerates into it until the moment he regenerates into another one. An 'incarnation' is, if you like, an instance of the Doctor. e.g. David Tennant's character was the Doctor's tenth incarnation, Matt Smith's was the Doctor's eleventh incarnation, and so on and so forth. 'Regeneration', on the other hand, describes the physiological process of renewal, when the Doctor changes from one form to another. e.g. when the Tenth Doctor changed into the Eleventh Doctor, the process of physical renewal was the 'regeneration'. That's to say, the Doctor 'regenerated'. The term 'regeneration' can be used in a variety of ways. First and foremost it refers to the process of regenerating. It can also be engaged as a question, as in this exchange between the First Doctor and the Fifth Doctor in 1983's twentieth anniversary special The Five Doctors:
Susan: Is he really...? Doctor 1: ...me? Yes. Yes, I'm afraid so. Regeneration? Doctor 5: Fourth. Doctor 1: Goodness me! So, there are five of me now!
So the Doctor's fifth incarnation was the result of his fourth regeneration, just as his sixth incarnation came from his fifth regeneration, his seventh from the sixth and his eighth from the seventh. The recently revealed existence of the so-called War Doctor threw a spanner in the works, in that all the Doctors remain known by the numbers previously used to identify them, but this new one came between the Eighth and Ninth Doctors. So in fact the War Doctor is actually the Ninth incarnation of The Doctor and Christopher Eccleston's Ninth Doctor was actually the tenth incarnation of the Doctor, Tennant's Tenth Doctor was actually the eleventh (and maybe also the twelfth) and Smith's Eleventh was actually the twelfth (or maybe the thirteenth). So you see, it's all really very simple. Sort of.

9. The Doctor Is An Actual Doctor

The question of precisely what The Doctor is a doctor of has persisted for fifty years. Over time, references to his doctorate have ranged from merely "honorary" to a legitimately achieved academic rank, while The Doctor has variously described himself as a doctor "of everything", "of many things" or of "practically everything". As a general rule, The Doctor has aligned himself more closely with science than medicine and, despite his name, has often described himself as a scientist. He's never described himself as an actual doctor. The Second Doctor once mentioned that he studied for a degree in medicine at one time. It was never confirmed on-screen whether he actually attained a medical degree, although the Eighth Doctor did utter "physician heal thyself" as he was about to regenerate. There's also never been any on-screen reference to The Doctor having practiced medicine in the traditional (or any other) sense. Since the series was revived in 2005 it's been established that Time Lords choose their own names and that The Doctor chose his to represent the kind of man he wanted to be. So in a nutshell, all the evidence points towards the inconclusive conclusion that the Doctor might've started a medical agree at some point and may have completed it but probably never practiced medicine and probably isn't really a doctor of anything at all. Possibly... maybe.

8. Layla Was The Doctor's 1970s Leather-Clad Hottie Companion

The similarities are uncanny, but it's still not right. Layla was one of many songs written by Eric Clapton in the 1970s. Leela was one of many companions featured in Doctor Who's in the 1970s. Layla was written by Eric Clapton, who recorded it with his band Derek And The Dominos and released it as a single in 1970. Leela was played by Louise Jameson, who recorded her first scenes in late-1976 and continued in the role until early-1978. Layla was not an immediate success for Clapton. Leela was an immediate success for Doctor Who. Layla was revived in 1992 for Clapton's performance on the then-fledgling MTV Unplugged sessions. Leela was revived in 1993 for Doctor Who's 30th Anniversary special, as part of the Children In Need charity event. Lots of dads and teenage boys and lesbians probably thought Leela was pretty hot, what with the skimpy leather garb and all that flesh constantly on display. The Layla who inspired Eric Clapton's song was a character from a 12th century Arabian poem. No photographs exist of Layla and it's not known if she was any more or less physically appealing to the dads, teenage boys and lesbians of 12th century Arabia.

7. The Word D-A-L-E-K Is Pronounced 'Day-lek' Or 'Dal-ek'.

Everyone knows of them. How could you not? They've been around since day dot of the show. Everyone knows what they look like, the words they use, what they sound like... but oddly enough, after fifty years of their famous metallic threat to "exterminate", there are still some people who just don't know what they're called. More often than not people have an idea of what they're called and more often than not they're almost right. I'm never sure how anyone can almost sorta kinda know what they're called. I would've thought they were the kind of thing you either do know the name of, or you don't. Apparently not. So how to say it correctly? How to pronounce it properly? This is one particularly hot potato that's bound to get any devoted fan of Doctor Who equally hot under the collar. And won't they let you know about it too! So you'd better pay attention, coz this could well be life-saving information: D-A-L-E-K, when pronounced phonetically, is 'dah-lek'. It's not 'day-lek' and it's not 'dal-ek'... it's 'dah-lek'. So that's a 'dah' sound, as in the word darling. It's not a 'day' sound, as in the word daze. Nor is it a 'dal' sound, as in the word dalliance. It's 'dah'!... they're Daleks. Got it? Good.

6. Doctor Who Is That Guy With A Pinstripe Suit And Trainers

Yes, The Doctor did once wear a pinstripe suit and trainers €“ top marks for observation! But since 2005 there have actually been three Doctors to headline the revived series and next week the fourth will make his debut in this year's Christmas special. So a word to the wise: David Tennant hasn't been the only one. Doctor Who fans tend to get a bit precious about these things and the situation could get particularly awkward if you're speaking to one who doesn't rank David Tennant as their favourite Doctor. As strange as it might seem, some Doctor Who fans do actually fall into that category. He might've had the most episodes of the new series Doctors, but not by much: Eccleston - 13 episodes Tennant - 47 episodes Smith - 44 episodes Pipping Matt Smith at the post by only three episodes, Tennant's slim lead shouldn't justify his portrayal of the character being so readily recalled as "Doctor Who", by so many and so frequently, above and beyond anyone else. But, for some reason it seems to... and they do... and it is. Justify it and recall it and extremely frequent, I mean. It's really all just a little bit baffling.

5. Doctor Who Is That Guy With The Teeth And Curls And The Great Big Scarf

OK so here's the thing: between 1963 and 1989 there were actually seven TV Doctors. If you include the 1996 TV movie - which, as any dedicated Doctor Who fan will tell you, you should - then there were eight TV Doctors. All the 700-odd TV episodes made over that 33 year period are from what's described these days as "the classic series". I suppose someone thought that sounded a bit better than "the old series". But here's the other thing: as hard as it might be to believe, Tom Baker wasn't actually the only one. He might've had the greatest number of seasons at the helm of the TARDIS and it's probably also true to say that he had the biggest, loudest personality of all the classic series Doctors. But he certainly didn't have the most number of episodes, nor the highest ratings of the classic series (the insanely high ratings achieved by some his stories when ITV was off the air for ten weeks in 1979 had a grossly unfair advantage over the rest of the series and, arguably, wouldn't have been nearly that high had the ITV strike not happened). So yes, Tom Baker's Doctor with his big teeth, big curls and great big scarf was iconic, but the other seven are all equally deserving of their places on the timeline of classic Doctors.

4. 'Tardis' Is A Proper Noun

Wrong! It's actually an acronym. So it's T A R D I S. "Time And Relative Dimension(s) In Space" - that's what TARDIS stands for. Or "Time And Relative Dimensions In Space" €“ depends which character you look to for the definitive explanation. Either way it's a chain of words that's supposed to represent the fact that the ship exists in two different dimensions within the same space (the whole bigger on the inside thing). Oh and I guess it's also a reference to the somewhat significant fact that it can travel through time and space. So TARDIS isn't a brand or a model name, like Astra or Corvette or Fiesta: Rossiter: Which way? Addams: This way. Doctor 10: No, no, no, no, no. The other way. I've got my Fiesta. Kate: Doctor, hello. We found the Astra in a field. I'm having it brought in. Doctor 4: Well, it's a sort of communications device reserved for wild catastrophes and sudden calls to man the battle stations. Adric: But the Corvette doesn't have battle stations. No, TARDIS is most definitely an accepted name derived of an acronym. When it's written it must be all upper-case letters, just like every good acronym should be. There are no dashes. There are no full stops. It's just the six letters, side by side, all in a row. TARDIS. Not Tardis.

3. Doctor Who Gets About In A Telephone Box

OK so yes, externally it's clearly labelled as a Police Public Call Box. But it's not a telephone box. It's certainly not a phone booth. It's not even a Police Box. The Police Box thing is just, if you like, an outer shell. It's how the ship is rendered to the outside world. Inside it's totally different. And much bigger, just in case you hadn't noticed that yet. It's actually meant to be able to blend into its surroundings, kinda like a chameleon. In fact one of the TARDIS's core components is a thing called the Chameleon Circuit. It's a kind of cloaking device which, when functioning correctly, allows the TARDIS to land anywhere and essentially go unnoticed by materialising in the form of an object that's congruous with the surroundings. But the Doctor's Chameleon Circuit doesn't work and hasn't done for the vast majority of Doctor Who's fifty years. Despite how clever The Doctor is, despite having come into contact with loads of other Time Lords along the way and despite having returned to his home planet of Gallifrey oodles of times over the years, for some reason he's never worked out how to fix his faulty one, nor managed to track down a new one. It would kinda kill the magic if it didn't look like a phone booth though.

2. It's Called "Dr. Who"

No, it most certainly is not called "Dr. Who"! Way back when the show first started in the early 1960s, it was invariably billed in TV guides and listings as "Dr. Who". At the end of each episode, right there at the very top of the closing credits, the character himself was even credited as "Dr. Who" for the first ten or eleven years. And there's enough old photographic and film evidence to show that the program was almost always referenced €“ on scripts, clapper boards, film canisters, internal memos, virtually everywhere €“ as "Dr. Who" even from a production perspective. But the program itself has never been known on screen as Dr. Who. Every single opening title sequence since 1963 has named the show "Doctor Who". If we can safely assume the name of the program in its own opening title sequence is the source of truth, then it's clearly not Dr., it's Doctor. So, dear non-fan, please be sure to take a note of this: it's definitely Doctor Who, it's definitely not Dr. Who. This detail could be more important than you know. That one small contraction could well mean the end of what might otherwise have been a beautiful friendship.

1. He's Called 'Doctor Who'

No he most certainly is not! ...but you're forgiven for thinking so. As with confusion surrounding the name of the show itself, the show itself must take some of the blame for confusion around the name of the character, chiefly due to the name of the show itself. Following so far? Good. Firstly, the show's called "Doctor Who" and the lead character is called "The Doctor". Logical non-fan deduction: his name is "Doctor Who". Secondly, in the very first episode of the show in 1963 Ian Chesterton referred to him as "Doctor Foreman", to which the First Doctor immediately responded, "Eh? Doctor who? What's he talking about?". Logical non-fan deduction: his name is "Doctor Who". Thirdly, despite no such reference in the dialogue, the name of one episode of the 1965 serial The Chase was "The Death Of Doctor Who". Logical non-fan deduction: his name is "Doctor Who". Fourthly, in the 1966 story The War Machines two characters referred to The Doctor as "Doctor Who" six times in two episodes: Wotan: Doctor Who is required. Bring him here.Brett: No. Top priority is to enlist Doctor Who. He has advanced knowledge which WOTAN needs. Doctor Who must be enlisted into our services tonight.Wotan: Doctor Who is required.Wotan: Where is Doctor Who?Wotan: Other means must be employed. Doctor Who is required.Logical non-fan deduction: his name is "Doctor Who". Fifthly, in the 1966 story The Gunfighters, the Doctor announces himself under the assumed name of Doctor Caligari. When someone asks, "Doctor who?", the First Doctor responds, "Yes, quite right". Logical non-fan deduction: his name is "Doctor Who". Sixthly, in the 1968 serial Fury From The Deep, the Second Doctor is referred to as "Doctor Who". Logical non-fan deduction: his name is "Doctor Who". Seventhly, in 1970 a seven part serial was wrongly given the on-screen caption "Doctor Who And The Silurians", even though there was no reference to "Doctor Who" in the serial's dialogue. Either way, logical non-fan deduction: his name is "Doctor Who". Eighthly, from 1970 to 1975 the Third and Fourth Doctors drove an old yellow roadster with the number plates 'WHO 1'. Logical non-fan deduction: his name is "Doctor Who". Ninthly, in his last season 1973-74 the Third Doctor drove a bizarre flying hovercrafty thingo with the number plates 'WV0 2M'. Although never referred to as such on screen, it was otherwise named 'the Whomobile'. Logical non-fan deduction: his name is "Doctor Who". Tenthly, from 1980-86 the Doctor continuously wore shirt collars with embroidered question marks on them. Additionally, between 1987 and 1989 he wore question marks on his vest and his umbrella handle was also in the shape of a question mark. Logical non-fan deduction: his name is "Doctor Who". And finally, eleventhly, throughout the new series countless characters have questioned "Doctor who?" whenever the Doctor has announced himself as "The Doctor". Notable examples include Madame de Pompadour in The Girl In The Fireplace, Dorium Maldovar in The Wedding Of River Song, Clara Oswald in The Snowmen and a whole bunch of Daleks in Asylum Of The Daleks. Logical non-fan deduction: his name is "Doctor Who". But you, dear non-fans, can forget all of that. Despite a compelling body of evidence seemingly to the contrary, his actual name isn't Doctor Who at all. He's just The Doctor.

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a guy who loves words. I discover vast tracts of uncharted enjoyment by chucking words together and coming up with stuff that talks about the things I enjoy and love most. I'm also a massive listaholic, so I'm probably talking about a list, looking at a list or banging away at another What Culture list as you read this. My tone's pretty relaxed and conversational, with a liberal sprinkling of sparkling wit, wilting sarcasm and occasional faux-condescension - with tongue almost always firmly planted in cheek.