15 Annoying Mistakes You Never Noticed In Mad Men

It's a very, very mad world...

When you set a fictional show amongst real-life events, you probably need to make sure you know your history. There€™s perhaps no bigger or better show, in recent years, that has had to confront this problem than AMC€™s Mad Men. The fictionalised tale of Don Draper and the goings on at everyone€™s favourite ad-agency are very much set against the backdrop of the 1960s. Not only is it set in the decade, but the era is a huge influence over the show. Of course this impacts on how the characters look, but also their actions and interactions. Big events of the decade are featured, and the characters react to them. From the Civil Rights movement to the moon landing, we've seen momentous occasions through the eyes of the characters on the show. And yet while they€™ve largely managed to capture the setting and the historical context accurately, with so much going on over the past seven seasons there€™s bound to be a few mistakes. Showrunner Matthew Weiner and his team are known for paying attention to detail, indeed with a show like Mad Men the devil is very much in it, but even they can get things wrong. As the finale approaches at a tragically fast pace, here's a look at some of the errors, and while they by no means ruin they show, they might just drive you a little bit mad€


15. €œIt€™s Toasted!€

Mad Men was making mistakes way back in the pilot episode, which is pretty understandable for a new show. The first ever episode introduces us to Don and the world of Sterling Cooper, centred around a pitch for a new advertising campaign for cigarette company Lucky Strike. Don eventually comes up with the winning slogan €œIt€™s toasted!€ Thus, Sterling Cooper gets the account, Don is firmly set on his path and the rest, as they say, is history. Except, of course, that the slogan already was a part of history. €œIt€™s toasted€ was part of a campaign run by Lucky Strike way back in 1917, some 43 years before the events of the episode. So either Don Draper is a time-travelling ad-man (and really, you wouldn€™t totally put it past Matthew Weiner) or this is one the show got wrong, or at least adapted history in order to suit their own ends.

14. The Wrong Type of Typewriter

Again from the pilot, this one comes when Peggy Olsen is being shown around the office, set to embark on a new career as secretary at Sterling Cooper (she€™s come a long way since then). The typewriters that appear in the office are the IBM Selectric model, and Peggy is told not to be afraid of the new technology, since it€™s been made so easy to use even a woman can do it. While this may perfectly capture the sexism that was rife back in those days, there is one little detail it gets wrong: the IBM Selectric did not actually come out until 1961 (the pilot is set in 1960). Weiner has actually commented on this, stating that they were aware of it at the time, but the correct typewriters were too hard to obtain, too costly to repair, and would€™ve required one hell of a job in the sound-editing room, so they bit the bullet and went with the mistake.

13. Bryn Mawr

No, this isn€™t a Welsh character who found his way to Madison Avenue in the 1960s, but the name of the college attended by Don€™s first wife, Betty. Back in season one episode The Ladies Room, she says that her neighbour€™s jealousy reminds her of her days in a sorority at Bryn Mawr. While it€™s easy to imagine Betty as being part of a sorority, there was just one little problem with this; Bryn Mawr didn€™t have sororities. Matthew Weiner commented on this error, telling the New York Times: €œMaggie Siff, who played Rachel Menken, went to Bryn Mawr, and she said that€™s wrong. You do what you can.€

12. The Medium Is The Message

Back in 1960 we see Joan Harris (played by Christina Hendricks) quoting Marshall McLuhan, the noted media theorist. While McLuhan had already seen his first book published by the start of the 60s, his work €˜The Medium Is The Message€™ was not actually published until 1967. Weiner said: €œUnless she was in his class in Canada, she wouldn€™t have known. He was probably using it already, but it was not in print.€ He also admitted that it was the biggest blunder he made during the first season of the show. In fairness, if that€™s the worst mistake you€™re making, then you€™re probably doing a pretty good job.

11. I Am So Over You

Another rather contentious Joan quote from season one, this time from the episode Long Weekend. Here we see Joan saying €œ1960, I am so over you.€ Linguists have argued that using €˜so€™ in order to quantify the extent of something would not have been used in back in 1960, and Weiner has admitted that there were arguments in the writers€™ room as to whether or not the phrase would make it into the show. Ultimately it did, mostly thanks to Cole Porter€™s 1948 song €˜So In Love€™. The phrase €˜I hear you€™ was reportedly not so lucky.

10. Fallout Boy

How do you get over a setback at work? You might talk about it, or shrug it off, or maybe even have a drink to take the edge off. If you€™re Roger Sterling, you arrange for a pair of twins to entertain you and Don for the evening. Because of course when you€™re Roger Sterling, there€™s no problem a little casual sex can€™t solve. It all proves a bit too much for him though, and he ends up having a heart attack. When Don goes to visit him in the hospital, there is a sign for a fallout shelter in the background. Unfortunately for the show, these signs did not actually start appearing until 1961, while this episode was set in 1960.

9. The Other Mrs Pete Campbell

Alongside her work on Community, Alison Brie is best known for being the woman who inexplicably married - and stayed that way - Pete Campbell on Mad Men, Trudy. Pete, faithful and loving husband that he is, keeps a picture of his darling wife on his desk at work. However, back in the pilot episode, the person in the frame is not Alison Brie. Pilots are obviously filmed before a cast is fully locked-in, so it€™s likely that Trudy simply hadn€™t been cast at this point. It does offer a glimpse of a world where Alison Brie isn€™t on Mad Men though, and that is a world that no one wants to live in. So who is the mystery woman portraying Pete€™s wife? None other than Matthew Weiner€™s mother.

8. Changing Rooms

Again stemming from the changing nature of TV shows when they move past the pilot stage, the offices of Sterling Cooper seem to undergo a bit of a change-around. In the pilot most of the office doors do not yet have names on them, something rectified once the show established all of its players, and office doors and various locations change as well. It€™s a minor issue, but one, like the appearance of Mrs Weiner, that highlights how a show changes and expands from its pilot once it€™s picked up for a full season.

7. Hold The Phone

Communication is a key part of Mad Men, thus it makes sense for the telephone to feature fairly prominently - be it to deal with ad-clients, or calls of a personal nature. Several episodes show telephones with RJ (registered jack) modular connectors. These wires were not introduced until the 1970s, and as we know, Mad Men takes place in the decade before. Similarly, early seasons of the show use telephones with a clear plastic finger wheel. These episodes were set between 1960-63, while said wheel did not come into use until 1964. Before then they would€™ve been black and white. This may be nitpicking slightly, but then again those are the ridiculously high standards Weiner holds himself and his crew to.

6. The Window

No, this one has nothing to do with an episode of How I Met Your Mother. Instead, it refers to a rather controversial line of dialogue from Don back in season 3: €œThe window for this apology is closing.€ Hardly seems like a line to raise eyebrows, but that€™s exactly what it did in linguistic circles. It has been noted that using the term €˜window€™ in a metaphorical sense did not actually start until the 1970s. Further proof that Don truly is a visionary.

5. Same Page

In the same ballpark as Don€™s window line is one Roger delivers over the phone to Betty: €œI know you have to be on the same page as him€€ Again it seems rather innocuous, but then consider that Roger is delivering the line in 1963, and the phrase doesn€™t actually seem to have been first used until the mid-70s. Obviously the writers weren€™t all on the same page when it came to fact-checking that one. Other phrases that have been called into question include Peggy€™s use of €œI€™m in a very good place right now€ and Sal Romano€™s €œawwa!€

4. Le Cirque

A rare example of an historical inaccuracy from a later Mad Men episode (not that there€™s many anyway, but the majority occur in seasons 1-3), this one comes from the season six episode €˜To Have And To Hold€™, set in 1968. Joan and her friend have a conversation about making reservations at the restaurant Le Cirque. They€™d have had a very long wait for a table, as it didn€™t open until 1974. Weiner initially joked that Christina Hendricks had ad-libbed the line, before admitting that it was a €œterrible error.€ Le Cirque€™s publicist, meanwhile, commented that €œSirio would have been open if he knew that Joan wanted a reservation in 1968.€

3. The Sterling Cooper Sign

Mad Men is a show know for its style, so you€™d imagine a fair amount of thought went into creating the branding for Sterling Cooper. Well not quite enough, it would appear. Font designer Mark Simonson wrote a blog recording all the various typeface issues within the show, referencing a number of fonts used that didn€™t actually exist back in the 1960s. Once of the more notable errors, it turns out, was with the Sterling Cooper sign. The font used is Gil Sans, and Simonson points out that while this did exist, it wasn€™t widely-available nor popular in America until the 1970s.

2. Swiss Bank Tower

Following the formation of Sterling Cooper Draper Pryce, many shots throughout the series show the new office looking out onto a similarly large building. That just so happens to be the Swiss Bank Tower, which is indeed across from the Time Life building (which serves as the offices of SCDP). That wasn€™t the case in the 60s, however, as the Tower wasn€™t actually built until 1990. Whoops.

1. Lane€™s Dictionary

Arriving in season 3 to oversee the finances of Sterling Cooper, Lane Pryce brought a few things from Britain over to the States with him. One of those was a futuristic dictionary. In one of the most infamous anachronisms of the show€™s run, the bookshelf in Lane€™s office displays the three-volume Compact Edition of the Oxford English Dictionary. This edition wasn€™t published until 1987, meaning it appeared on Lane€™s shelves 24-years too early. How did this come to be? The Twitter account of Lane Pryce may give us some answers€

Regarding my office library, I was asked to hold onto those books by a nervous young man named McFly. http://bit.ly/WiTRG #madprops

€” Lane Pryce (@lanepryce) August 25, 2009
Which other mistakes and historical inaccuracies did you notice in Mad Men? Share your finds below in the comments thread below.

In this post: 
Mad Men
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.