15 Best American Horror Story Cast Members
The best of the ensemble.
American Horror Story started airing in 2011, and has since produced nine seasons and over 100 episodes. Creator and showrunner Ryan Murphy has proven more than once to be a very gifted storyteller, but the show's biggest strength lies with its always-brilliant cast.
There have been numerous impressive performers who have graced the series over the years, with the vast majority of them turning up more than once to play a radically different character.
Murphy's ploy of using the same actors for each season has yielded some staggering results, with many of the stars - from lesser known character actors to legendary Oscar winners - giving some of the best performances of their careers on the show.
With season ten somewhere on the horizon - and several all-time favourites returning to the series - now seems a perfect time to recall the greatest cast members in the show.
From those who work best as sinister antagonists to the more underappreciated folks to grace the screen, here are the 15 best American Horror Story cast members.
15. Adina Porter
Adina Porter is one of the most successful but underrated actresses working in TV today, having had major roles in such big hitters as The Newsroom, True Blood, The 100 and Ray Donovan.
She made her American Horror Story debut in the show's first season, Murder House, where she turned up for one short but sweet turn as Sally Freeman, the therapist of Ben Harmon (Dylan McDermott). Five seasons later, she took the role of Lee Harris in Roanoke, a season which was a bit of a misfire but in which Porter cemented herself as the story's MVP.
With roles in Cult and Apocalypse following her Roanoke nightmare, Porter has become one of the most consistent figures on the show, playing each of her thrilling characters with both sympathy and intensity.
For someone who started out as a mere guest star in the show's debut season and then went missing for several years, that's not bad going at all. She's currently set to return in the upcoming tenth season.
14. Naomi Grossman
Despite having a brief role in Apocalypse, Naomi Grossman makes it onto this list for one role and one role only: Pepper.
The single most tragic and sympathetic character on the show, Pepper turned up in the show's second season, Asylum, as an inmate of Briarcliff Manor. She used to be a part of Elsa Mars' (Jessica Lange) freak show, but after losing her husband was sent to live with her sister, and ended up admitted to Briarcliff after being blamed for her nephew's murder.
Pepper went through the wringer on the show, and Naomi Grossman was the first actor to reprise a role in two separate seasons.
This ended up being a great plan, since Grossman's performance remains a startling achievement, balancing Pepper's tragedy with her genuine lovability and sweetness. It was not an easy arc to watch, but Grossman made Pepper's journey one of the most compelling in the series.
13. Emma Roberts
Emma Roberts first appeared in the show's third season, Coven, as Madison Montgomery, a spoilt and arrogant movie star who also happened to be a witch. Though generally unlikable for much of the season's run, it became clear - thanks to the sublime writing and Roberts' pitch perfect performance - that she was more than met the eye.
As Madison, Roberts crafted one of Coven's most compelling characters, and was brought back in Freak Show for another full-season stint as complex con artist Maggie Esmerelda.
She later reprised her role as Madison in the messy and ambitious Apocalypse, and played the lead role in the latest season, 1984.
Roberts' ability to play morally questionable and emotionally confused antagonists is remarkable - even by American Horror Story standards - and it's fair to say she's one of the most accomplished mainstays of the series.
She's reportedly not going to make it for season ten, but it wouldn't be too far to assume we'll see her again shortly.
12. John Carroll Lynch
Turning up as Twisty the Clown in Freak Show, formidable character actor John Carroll Lynch had perhaps the most terrifying American Horror Story debut out of every other actor on the show.
Yes, he may have been slightly shortchanged in the end, but Lynch's portrayal of Twisty remains one of the show's most iconic and unsettling performances. The mask, the mannerisms, the murder and the bizarre tragedy all make him a vision of incomparable terror and disturbing unpredictability.
Throughout his stint on the show, Lynch has made a name for himself by playing serial killers. Twisty was first, followed by real-life murderer John Wayne Gacy in Hotel and the main antagonist of 1984, Mr Jingles.
No one is better than Lynch at playing these kinds of characters. He's able to be scary, violent and darkly humorous, but also tragic and sympathetic (look no further than Twisty's backstory). Here's to hoping we get more of him before the show reaches its end in the next few years.
11. Lady Gaga
When the news broke that Lady Gaga would be taking a lead role in Hotel, there was an air of skepticism and worry amongst the fandom, amplified by the fact that iconic mainstay Jessica Lange wouldn't be returning.
Any worries that people had were quickly tossed out the window, though, once Lady Gaga turned up as The Countess, the owner of the titular hotel and an age-old, enigmatic vampire.
Gaga was fantastic in the role, and stole the show from nearly every other cast member in the season with her terrifying persona and elegant but powerful presence.
Winning a Golden Globe for her performance, Gaga had a brief little role in the following year's Roanoke, and though she hasn't appeared on the show since, her brief time as The Countess was more than enough time for her to earn her place on this list.
10. Angela Bassett
During her stay on the show, Oscar nominee Angela Bassett has played some of American Horror Story's toughest characters.
Her first major role came in Coven, where she played voodoo priestess Marie Laveau. The arch nemesis of Supreme witch Fiona Goode (Jessica Lange) and evil socialite Delphine LaLaurie (Kathy Bates), Marie was incredibly powerful and played a leading role in that season's key events.
Bassett briefly reprised her role as Marie in Apocalypse, and turned up in Freak Show as the spirited and tragic Desiree Dupree.
Aside from a small, underused role in Roanoke, Bassett was missing from 1984 and won't be returning to season ten, but given how amazing she's been thus far, it wouldn't be a stretch to say she'll be back soon enough to give more top-draw, Emmy-nominated performances. The show's a better place with her around.
9. Kathy Bates
Academy Award winner Kathy Bates made her American Horror Story debut in Coven as the wicked, racist murderer and socialite Delphine LaLaurie.
Watching her interact with Jessica Lange through the season proved to be a match made in heaven, and despite her genuine off-screen likability, Bates proved to be just as unhinged and terrifying as she was in Misery.
It was a pleasant surprise when she not only returned in Freak Show, but took on a much more endearing role as Ethel Darling, the matriarchal "freak" of Elsa Mars' camp. Bates would also go on to play lead roles in Hotel, Roanoke (as the Butcher, she froze blood), and Apocalypse.
On the show, actors usually fit into one category - they play good guys, bad guys, or someone in-between. But not Bates, an actress never intent on playing the same role twice. She's been evil, loving, human and irredeemable, and makes it look fun as hell every time.
8. Taissa Farmiga
Taissa Farmiga deserves just as much credit as Ryan Murphy and mainstays Evan Peters, Jessica Lange and Sarah Paulson for American Horror Story's success.
In Murder House, she plays Violet Harmon, the troubled daughter of Ben and Vivien (Connie Britton), and the glue holding the season's characters together. As Violet, Farmiga was relatable, naive, moral, flawed and disastrous.
Farmiga was a revelation in the role given how young she was, and though she was noticeably missing from Asylum, her big return in Coven made it clear that she was a star in the making - and one of the show's most compelling players.
In Coven, she played Zoe Benson, a witch who finds herself stuck between a rock and a hard place but still manages to push through her adversity.
Other than a fleeting role in Roanoke and an all-too-brief role reprisal in Apocalypse, Farmiga hasn't had a lead role on the show since her days with Cordelia Goode (Sarah Paulson) and the coven, and her absence has been a tough one to shake over the years.
7. Finn Wittrock
Finn Wittrock's debut role as vile, spoilt brat and future mass murderer Dandy Mott in Freak Show made it clear he was an actor destined to stick around for more than one season.
Wittrock's searing, darkly comical and frequently petrifying antagonist was an absolute blast to watch, and the strongest aspect of Freak Show's otherwise lacklustre narrative. He was pathetic, selfish, psychopathic and cruel, and honestly it worked wonders.
In Hotel, Wittrock returned in a dual role - first as model Tristan Duffy, and then as Hollywood icon Rudolph Valentino - and played them both to perfection despite his limited screen time.
He had some criminally short-lived roles in both Roanoke and 1984, but given how great he's been in the past and that Ryan Murphy has confirmed his involvement in season ten, it won't be long until Wittrock comes back to the fold and sinks his teeth into another instantly iconic role.
6. Lily Rabe
Believe it or not, but Lily Rabe has appeared in eight seasons of American Horror Story, only missing out on a role in Cult, tying her with Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters for most appearances on the show.
In Murder House, she turned up as Nora, the wife of murderous doctor Charles Montgomery (Matt Ross), for a short spell, and then appeared in Asylum as the brilliant and possessed nun Sister Mary Eunice. In Coven (and later Apocalypse), she played Misty Day, a witch and hippie with an intense love for Stevie Nicks.
She's played serial killers, witches, murder victims, the Devil and ghosts over the course of the show, and is nothing short of a scene stealer in every role.
Rabe has been confirmed for a lead role in season ten, promising some more greatness from one of the show's most recognisable mainstays.
5. Frances Conroy
Appearing in seven seasons, the phenomenal Frances Conroy is one of the show's most prolific mainstays, and also one of its most noticeably talented.
She first appeared in Murder House as housekeeper Moira O'Hara (a role she shared with the also-brilliant Alexandra Breckenridge), who had a dark past with Constance Langdon (Jessica Lange) and two distinct looks depending on who was looking at her.
She had a brief role as the Angel of Death in Asylum, and played the powerful Witches Councilmember Myrtle Snow in Coven. With key roles in Freak Show, Roanoke, Cult and Apocalypse, Conroy proved time and time again to be one of the most gifted actors on the show.
Even if she was occasionally underused, she made it a joy to spend time with her characters, most of whom are innocent women pushed into morally ambiguity because of their tragic lives.
Conroy is set to return in season ten, promising some more striking characters in her future.
4. Denis O'Hare
In Murder House, Denis O'Hare played one of the season's most mysterious characters, Larry Harvey. Snivelling and conniving, he was an intriguing, unforgettable presence lurking in an equally striking season of TV.
As the show went on, it became clear that Larry was just the beginning of what O'Hare is capable of. In Coven, he played the titular coven's mute butler, Spalding, and without lines managed to craft a character who was as bizarre and he was troubling.
In Freak Show, he had a brief role as a con man (working with Emma Roberts' Maggie Esmerelda), but as it stands O'Hare's finest achievement remains his turn as Hotel's best character, Liz Taylor.
A transgender bartender who seemed to everything that was going on in the show and was maddeningly ambiguous in terms of her morals and motives, Liz is one of the best characters in the show's history without question, and Denis O'Hare's sensitive performance remains one for the ages.
3. Jessica Lange
During her stint on American Horror Story, two-time Oscar winner Jessica Lange won a Golden Globe, two Emmys, and endless praise from critics and fans alike. Without her, perhaps Murder House wouldn't have birthed such a daring and beloved show.
As Constance Langdon, Lange was the mysterious, seemingly cruel and heartbroken mother of Tate (Evan Peters) and Adelaide (Jamie Brewer). This role began Lange's trend of portraying tough, flawed and generally good women tainted by the horrific world around them.
In Asylum, she played the vicious Sister Jude with coldness and complexity, and despite being seen as the season's main antagonist used her superior acting chops to make her entirely sympathetic by season's end. In Coven, she played witch Fiona Goode as a powerful sorcerer unable to come to terms with her waning powers.
And as Elsa Mars, well, she was one hell of a singer.
Jessica Lange is massively responsible for the show's popularity, and looking at the wide range of complex characters she's had to play, it's easy to see why we miss her in the later seasons so much.
2. Evan Peters
Evan Peters has appeared as a main character in more seasons of American Horror Story than any other actor, only missing out on 1984.
An incredibly gifted actor, Peters' biggest talent lies in his uncanny ability to portray even the most awful and flawed characters with a level of humanity and understanding.
In Murder House, for example, he played Tate Langdon, a high schooler who seemed nice enough, falling for Zoe and attending therapy to help with his mental health, but underneath all his endearing appearance he was revealed to be a rapist, school shooter and murderous psychopath.
A hard role to play for sure, but one Peters could pull off with no issues. In Freak Show, Hotel, Roanoke and Cult he continued this trend, playing a series of terrible and just plain evil figures and finding a way to tap into their sympathetic side.
Slated to return in the upcoming season ten, Peters is iconic, passionate, terrifying and likeable despite his often cruel characters, and he'd be at the top of this list if it wasn't for one other actor...
1. Sarah Paulson
Between Evan Peters and Sarah Paulson, I'll admit, it's a near impossible fight to the top. But over the course of the show, Paulson has played more iconic and compelling characters than her cast mate.
Though barely around in Murder House, Paulson's turn as investigative journalist Lana Winters in Asylum remains the best of the show - a character who is as complex, strong and entertaining as Ryan Murphy's ever created.
She continued this winning streak with her role as the compassionate and selfless witch Cordelia Goode and later gave a staggering dual performance in Freak Show.
Most of Paulson's characters are inherently likable, typical heroes who always push back against the evil around them, but even when she goes evil, like in Hotel, Paulson still completely owns the role and steals the show.
The most iconic and memorable mainstay of the show, Sarah Paulson is American Horror Story's greatest cast member. Season ten can't come soon enough.